Tech Companies Draw on 'Wisdom of the Crowds' 131
An anonymous reader writes "News.com is carrying an article on a 'mini-conference' held at Yahoo's HQ this past Wednesday. The get-together put representatives from Google, Microsoft, Yahoo!, and HP together to talk about their experiments with predictive networks. The 'wisdom of the crowds' allows these companies to make use of the collective knowledge their employees hold to answer important questions for the company." From the article: "David Pennock, a principal research scientist at Yahoo Research, said the company has created a currency called a Yootle. It's described as a 'scorekeeping system for favors owed.' Pennock offered as an example a programmer offering to write a piece of code for a few Yootles. Or, when organizing a dinner outing, one employee could use an internal SMS tool to bid 2 Yootles for Italian and 4 Yootles for Mexican. 'If you don't get to go to the restaurant you want to, you get compensation' in Yootles, he said. Related to Yootles is Yahoo Research's experiment with a fantasy prediction market for technology called the Tech Buzz Game. It's a modified version of software licensed from NewsFutures in conjunction with O'Reilly Media and features topics like Atlantic hurricanes and portable media devices. Winners are those who predict how popular a topic will be on Yahoo Search. "
scorekeeping system for favors owed (Score:5, Insightful)
Gaming the system (Score:5, Insightful)
Anyway, my point is...this is great, except human nature will always win out. The system only works if people participate. To get maximum participation, you need some sort of incentive. As soon as there's incentive, people will figure out a way to game the system.
Wisdom of The Crowds (Score:4, Insightful)
The companies mentioned have some very smart people working for them. It's a shame the PHB's pretty much kill whatever innovation is happening in the belly of those beasts.
The wisdom of the crowds is frequently spoiled by individuals that game the system. Microsoft astroturfers on
The end result is the wisdom a crowd was supposed to provide essentially evaporates.
Re:scorekeeping system for favors owed (Score:2, Insightful)
Maybe your sisters problem was that she didnt trust she would be compensated when there perhaps was no basis for that lack of trust. However, there is nothing 'selfish' about expecting and/or demanding compensation.
Wisdom (Score:3, Insightful)
Beware: there's another phrase (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:I am surprised it took this long... (Score:4, Insightful)
I bid $10 for "eat out of a dumpster". (Score:4, Insightful)
Yes, it is an extreme example, but it shows how you can "game" that system. Not a good idea.
Re:scorekeeping system for favors owed (Score:2, Insightful)
I totally agree with you. This "yootles" idea is hyper-lame, and doomed from the start. Ohh - some idiot wants to eat supper at Denny's, but instead he has to go to Burger Basket, so he gets compensated 5 yootles? Christ. Get over it, man. Just go eat at Burger Basket already. Seriously, if I have to offer some guy "yootles" to get him to eat a meal with me, I don't want to hang out with that jackass in the first place.
The only people using this crap will be dorks with overdeveloped senses of entitlement. Eventually, they won't be able to stand each other, and they'll just stop doing things together.
Re:scorekeeping system for favors owed (Score:4, Insightful)