Three Months of Britain's e-Petition System 183
eldavojohn writes "The idea seems simple. Provide feedback for your government via the internet. If enough people sign a petition, address it. That was the idea when an e-Petition site was launched in Nov 06 for Prime Minister Tony Blair. The BBC is reporting on the million or so petitions that the PM has received since the site went live. While most petitions are rejected or ignored, they have a top ten with one petition having 600,000 signers. Is this a valid way to provide feedback to the government or merely an exercise in keeping the populace happy?"
2,400 Petitions, 1 Million SIGNATURES (Score:5, Informative)
-Ian
My experience (Score:5, Informative)
I signed a petition to add an exception to copyright law for personal use [pm.gov.uk] a month or two ago. A couple of weeks ago, I got an email from the system notifying me of the government's response [pm.gov.uk]:
Now obviously the petition didn't have a huge effect, but at least they are aware there is public demand for this, and it's helped me keep track of what they are actually doing about it.
Re:Sure (Score:5, Informative)
Interestingly enough, the same people [mysociety.org] who built this petition system for the government also created WriteToThem [writetothem.com] — write your message in a text box on the site, and they email/fax/post it to your MP. This has the advantage of them being able to spot when an MP is ignoring people and they've published league tables and other statistics [writetothem.com] about how responsive MPs are.
Dr Graffin's "Web-surdities" (Score:3, Informative)
Here is the link to the article: http://badreligion.com/news/essays.php?id=8 [badreligion.com]. He has since become a Ph.D and a biology instructor at UCLA.
To quote from the first two paragraphs:
Re:How about a breath of fresh air instead? (Score:5, Informative)
People who aren't from the UK often get confused by this. The Queen, for all practical purposes, has no political power. No monarch has entered the House of Commons in well over three centuries.
The last time they tried it was in 1642 — Charles I tried to arrest five MPs for treason, and the House of Commons told him to bugger off. Shortly afterwards he was defeated in civil war, and parliament created a court to put a monarch on trial for the first time in history — he ended up being executed.
These days, the monarch's representatives don't even enter the House of Commons unless they have permission from the Members of Parliament. They rarely even express any political opinions.
Lots of people read history books about how kings and queens used to be dictators, but that's exactly what it is — history. The monarchy is an anachronism; a leftover we use mainly as a tourist attraction. We don't "recall" them because there's no point, not because we can't.
Re:How about a breath of fresh air instead? (Score:3, Informative)
And I've no idea what you mean by "double dissolution" as a cause, perhaps you mean dissolution was the effect?
Re:My experience (Score:2, Informative)
The road pricing petition is doing suspiciously well with 30x the signatures of the next most popular. That's over 1% of the population. Either someone has been marketing it well or there may be invalid signatures. You have to submit your address, but that's not hard to fake.
Re:Validity? (Score:3, Informative)
Good analogy. If medical trials were undertaken for a new drug and it was found that the Drs couldn't administer it correctly, do you think the powers that be would :-
a) Issue a licence for the drug anyway, because the Drs will get the hang of it eventually
b) Send it back to the drug companies until they can provide a simpler administration system
My guess is they'd send it back to the drug company.
Sure, work to make the technology foolproof, but in the meantime don't foist a half-baked technical solution on the public just because it sounds like a good idea. The fact of the matter is that this kind of technology just isn't foolproof yet and there will be security leaks, and for that reason the tech is simply not ready to be rolled out yet!