Chinese Professor Sues Google, Yahoo Over Search Exclusion 147
Techdirt points out that while there have been many lawsuits over someone's Google-rank, a Chinese professor is suing Google and Yahoo for removing all mention of him in China. "Google and Yahoo, of course, have agreed to play by local rules in China, upsetting many. Legally, it would seem like this suit has little chance of success — but I doubt that he cares about the legal result. What this actually does is to call attention to his plight — and on that front, it's clearly a successful strategy."
Gee.. (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:The summary is basically the article...it's so. (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:He will be excluded (not virtually) (Score:2, Interesting)
skills put to good use... (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Incorrect (Score:5, Interesting)
American society is so self-centered: we spend so much effort on looking out for ourselves, both at the level of the individual and at the level of the corporation, and not enough on making sure that we're looking out for our friends, family, neighbors, and country. Google's not perfect, and I'm not sure I like their approach to dealing with China, but I think that their "don't be evil" philosophy is a refreshing change from the downright predatory practices of many companies. At least they're making an effort.
The Fine Line Search Engines Walk (Score:2, Interesting)
1) Show everything--this implies crap sites (*coughs* boingboing), great sites (*coughs*
2) Do as you are told--obviously not as fun and cries of shenanigans and submissions are there, but then you get to show more results to people around the world who otherwise would just be filled with pure propaganda.
3) Do your own thing--"hitting the corner of the ping-pong table", barely get by with regulations without getting punished.
Guess what? None of those are illegal to do under any international law at this point in time (although I recall some events within the US on trying to sue sites that just link to other pages, but nothing for the international arena) and certainly nothing illegal to show or not show within the US for political sites.
Remember, this is a corporation, not a government, so there is no "right" that you have for them to "display" your site in "their" index.
At least all algorithmically anyway.
Wow-- very orwellian erasing his existence (Score:3, Interesting)
I *TRUSTED* them to give me impartial and accurate information (vs MSN which was hilariously slanted for microsoft some times).
I am going to look for another search engine.
I find this behavior to be extremely repugnant.
I'm not sure I can forgive them. They will join Sony on my entire list of companies that I won't buy products from.
Full disclosure- I do still play everquest which sony bought... but other than that no purchases of any of their products for close to 6 or 7 years now as well as directing company purchases I advise on against sony every time.
Sad that a company sworn to be ethical would fall to this kind of evil behavior.
Re:Just write a check (Score:3, Interesting)