Forgot your password?
typodupeerror

+ - Is organic farming the future Hummer of the eco movement?-> 5

Submitted by
onyxruby
onyxruby writes "Organic farming has caught on as a popular means of claiming to be eco friendly. With a relatively low personal cost (just pay twice as much at the checkout) and claimed health benefits it has become a popular option for those who can afford it. However is this simple green washing?

Researchers at Stanford University reviewed 200 studies and found health benefits to largely be anecdotal. Chensheng Lu with Standford University was asked to pick if one was healthier than the other, "Right now I think it's all based on anecdotal evidence".

With a world population that has already hit 7 billion people, finding cropland to feed the worlds masses is no small matter. Organic yields are substantially lower than conventional yields and the only way to obtain additional farmland it to take wildlands. According to Dr. Steve Savage who did the first comprehensive study of organic farming for the USDA in 2008 simply converting the United States alone to organic standards would require substantial additional cropland.

a switch to organic agriculture would require a 43 percent increase over current U.S. cropland, according to Savage. As he puts it, "On a land-area basis, this additional area would be 97% the physical size of Spain or 71% the size of Texas

The first comprehensive studies of organic farming coming back saying that the health benefits are anecdotal and the loss of yield substantial. I'm inclined to call organic farming the Hummer of the Eco movement, to be held in contempt as exposed as simple green washing. I think in years to come it will be looked at no differently than ethanol from corn. Can anyone make a good argument against this?"
Link to Original Source

This discussion was created for logged-in users only, but now has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Is organic farming the future Hummer of the eco movement?

Comments Filter:
  • I am very familiar with farming, and I know what kind of feedstock they use to feed the farm animals in farm factories

    For example:

    Do you know anything about Bone and Meat Meal?

    Google it if you don't

    They feed farm animals - from chickens to sheep to cows - all kinds of "proteins", even that from ground up animal carcasses - to fatten the animals for slaughter

    Have you heard of "Mad Cow Disease"?

    Google it if you don't

    Do you know how "Mad Cow Disease" spread?

    You guess it, the Bone and Meat Meals that they feed

    • by onyxruby (118189)

      I actually know very little about farming and nothing about Bone and Meat meal. I can't say that I'm a fan of the practice you describe, or that I know better one way or another. I'm on only my second year ever of planting gardens, and both years I made my gardens 'organic' to avoid my own use of pesticides.

      I have been following organic foods more this year after watching with interest how some things did well in my 'organic' garden and some things were completely killed by bugs. In order to bring context t

  • While Taco Cowboy's arguments about the horrible stuff they feed animals are important to note, it's also important to note that non-organic agriculture involves using fertilizers and pesticides that pollute the environment, killing the organisms that naturally regenerate the fertility of the soil, as well as processes that lead to desertification, algal bloom and other disruptions to natural ecosystems.

    So in fact many well-informed people who eat organic food, do so to preserve the environment, and co
    • Isn't that just the flip-side of the claim that due to the low-density of organic agriculture, it requries much more deforestation (aka destruction of the environment) in order to produce equal amounts of food? Seems like a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation.

      I recall reading how universities in brazil are genetically engineering plants from africa in to grow on land that is otherwise inhospitable because they've run out of farmland - its either cut down the amazon or grow gm-crops on "bandlan

    • by onyxruby (118189)

      I believe these people to be well intentioned, however I believe their efforts and money are being misplaced and would be better spent in other directions. I am making the argument that organic foods produced at scale are not sustainable. I think the loss of bio-diversity from additional land loss is enough to counter the damage from pesticides - it's a lesser of two evils situation.

      Organic farming isn't really green because it significantly more land for the same yield. I have already provide my citation f

Living on Earth may be expensive, but it includes an annual free trip around the Sun.

Working...