XBMC 'Atlantis' Beta 1 Released, Now Cross-Platform 169
An anonymous reader writes with a welcome followup to last year's promise of XBMC being made available for Linux: "The first cross-platform Beta version[s] of XBMC Media Center for Linux, Mac OS X, Windows, and Xbox have now been released in preparation for an upcoming stable release, code named 'Atlantis.'" Now, though, there are binaries available for download through the XBMC Media Center site, though only for the non-Xbox versions.
Great! (Score:2)
I love xbmc. Anyone knows of a nice (and cheap) pc that could serve as a media center with xbmc, a la asus eee box, but with the ability to run hdtv content?
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Not the EEE laptop, the EEE Box [asus.com] It can do 720p, but not 1080p.
Re: (Score:2)
XBMCMC? (Score:2, Informative)
The first cross-platform Beta version[s] of XBMC Media Center for Linux, Mac OS X, Windows, and Xbox have now been released in preparation for an upcoming stable release, code named 'Atlantis
Xbox Media Center Media Center? I'm sorry, but when I see XMBC I think Xbox Media Center in my mind. Its use isn't ubiquitous enough that people have forgotten what it stands for.
Re: (Score:2, Informative)
See here: http://xbmc.org/about/ [xbmc.org]
xbmc rocks (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:xbmc rocks (Score:4, Informative)
I run this on my linux box that i use for my htpc. I like it because it can handle anything i throw at it even HD content (something the orginal xbox couldnt handle) Also i think it looks 1000000x beter then mythtv gui
Re: (Score:3, Informative)
That's presuming you can get MythTV to work properly, a dicey proposition at best.
I've had FAR more luck getting XBMC to talk correctly to pre-recorded media (of almost any format) from my NAS and winboxen.
As for the GUI... I love the XBMC GUI. I love the fact that the Xboxes I purchased at a flea market for comparative pennies make lovely network video boxes for the spare rooms in my house to pull just about everything I've recorded from NAS.
I'm looking forward to the "new" Windows-based XBMC so my home th
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
Re: (Score:2)
Agreed, it's the center of my media center at home. I just wish the Xbox could handle 720p, but not a big deal for me right now.
The interface is top notch, my wife can navigate with ease, of course, we have a remote to interact with it.
Re: (Score:2)
I upconvert, I'm talking about the 720p tv rips that are available from eztv, etc. Don't work for me.
Re: (Score:2)
Bill Gates was shown a demo of XMBC and asked how Microsoft could engage the community. Why don't they come out and support it on the 360? I might consider buying one if it did.
Re: (Score:3, Insightful)
Microsoft doesn't care about engaging the community as long as they can imprison the community.
It's a shame too, because there are lots of ways that they could embrace "freedom" that would win them lots of favor with the very customers they've spent all these years alienating. They could do lots of things like this, but they'd rather try to succeed with a stick than a carrot.
Maybe after the guy with too many Y-chromosomes steps down Microsoft can go back to being part of the community rather than trying to
Re: (Score:2)
You need +15 modding >:(
So so pissed off that Sony blocked XBMC on linux with the PS3 (they closed the GPU loophole)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
I haven't taken time to play with any of them yet. Anyone tried LinuxMCE?
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Reports on LinuxMCE are less than wonderful. But then I'm biased having been using XBMC on Linux for months now. Folsk i've spoken to who have tried LinuxMCEhad trouble getting it running much less doing what they wanted - it's much more involved I'm afraid.
The Killer App (Score:5, Insightful)
XBMC really was the killer app for a modded 1st gen XBOX. I dropped a 120GB hard drive in mine, had it auto-sync with my video torrent folder, and had a brilliant little movie/tv show playing setup going on. It makes an Xbox do what Microsoft should have done with its Media Center Extender initiative.
For something that was quasi-legal (if I remember you needed proprietary things from the Xbox developer's SDK to properly compile the source for the Xbox) it had a remarkably excellent UI. Things seemed to work quite well. It seems like a good thing to have some real competition in the media center market, particularly cross-platform open-source competition.
Re: (Score:3, Insightful)
I still watch nearly all my TV on my xbox. TVRSS with rtorrent, samba, and XBMC has made broadcast TV obsolete.
Re: (Score:2)
I still watch nearly all my TV on my xbox. TVRSS with rtorrent, samba, and XBMC has made broadcast TV obsolete.
A bit noisy, no? Or was the 1st gen Xbox quieter than today's? I achieve the same Az+RSS+Winshares+Samba coverage of old and new TV with a diskless NFS header running mythtv on a mini-ITX board. Didn't bother with broadcast TV but like you say, with BT coverage you don't miss out.
Re: (Score:2)
What do you use to get the feeds? I currently use pytvshows. It works great, but I wasn't sure if there were any others out there. (There is TVShows.app for OSX, but development has stalled).
Re: (Score:2)
Oh, I wrote my own using perl's XML::RSS. It was ridiculously easy.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Modding the Xbox wasn't the quasi-legal gray area, unless you consider modifying hardware you own illegal. It was that the compiled binaries for the Xbox had to be compiled from the developer SDK and that was only available to developers who were approved by Microsoft and paid for it.
Re: (Score:2)
I think I always used one of the "All in One" CD's that seem to float around the darker corners of the internets.
XBMC is spelled "XBMC", (not "XMBC") (Score:3, Informative)
Plex (Score:2, Informative)
Re: (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Plex (Score:4, Funny)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Depends. Strikes me that at least one of the core XBMC devs is going out of his way to deliberately trash the reputation of the Plex developer, up to and including deliberately misspelling the guy's name.
His fork may be better or worse technologically (that's something you can measure objectively,) but there's no need for name calling.
Re: (Score:2, Informative)
Re: (Score:2, Funny)
untrue, Linux source is available. Any proper /.'er should have no issues compiling themselves ;-) Binaries only for Ubuntu at the moment as that is the target/dev environment.
Re: (Score:2)
Actually it runs on several distros but Ubuntu is the one they are working towards supporting. Atlantis is being done as an ISO for a bootable CD anyway so really who cares what the underlying OS is exactly? If you're going to do a dedicated HTPC you might as well run the supported OS anyway IMO
Re: (Score:2)
He's waiting for you to give up your remotes and mouse first, Mr. Manly-man.
DVR? (Score:3, Interesting)
I used to use MythTV but hated the interface; that combined with the free TV guides going away made me try out MCE 2005, which I currently run.
MCE2005 works, the interface is great (for PVR stuff at least...I don't really like the music manager, though), but the management is crap compared to MythTV. I can't remote onto it easily because it's XP-based, and the web management is garbage, too. I've been thinking of trying out something else, or seeing how MythTV is now.
Basically my setup is this: I have a FreeNAS that I use for file sharing that I have my music and downloaded videos on. I have the MCE box in the living room doing DVR stuff, with connections to the file shares for music and the rest of the videos. And I an original Xbox sitting around doing nothing.
I'd love to be able to put the DVR somewhere out of the way, have it do it's thing, and pump everything to XBMC somewhere. But can you do the live-tv thing with XBMC? Maybe I'm missing some other package out there completely?
Re: (Score:2)
I used to use MythTV but hated the interface;
Can't blame you there, it is... rough. But it is immensely capable, so I've learned to live with it's rough edges in exchange for the incredible power it provides (and being a programmer, I can't help but love being able to write custom SQL recording rules :).
that combined with the free TV guides going away
You chose a closed solution with little flexibility over paying $20 *per year* for guide data [schedulesdirect.org]? Really? Meh, to each his/her own, I guess.
Fortunately, you ca
Re: (Score:2)
You chose a closed solution with little flexibility over paying $20 *per year* for guide data [schedulesdirect.org]? Really? Meh, to each his/her own, I guess.
Mostly it was I got it for free from work, and had grown frustrated with MythTV. I'm thinking of looking back into it, and granted the schedule thing isn't that big of a deal :-)
Fortunately, you can hook XBMC into MythTV. Wouldn't that be a solution for you?
I guess that's what I wasn't sure of. So XBMC can run on an xbox and hook into MythTV? Or does XBMC need to be running on an actual computer (possibly even the same MythTV box?) to actually be able to use the DVR things that MythTV does? Hmmmm...I'll have to look into this - thanks!
Re: (Score:2)
The model would be that XBMC would run on an Xbox, and it would connect to Myth over the network just like another frontend.
Incidentally, from what I can tell, XBMC now has a basic, native MythTV client built in. It can be used to watch and delete recordings, and watch and record live TV. However, it has no EPG support, no commercials skip, etc. See here:
http://www.gossamer-threads.com/lists/mythtv/users/326091 [gossamer-threads.com]
Looks like an interesting option.
Anything similar for Wii? (Score:2)
I want to stream music and video (but I'd settle for just music) to my Wii. I don't want to hack it, so my best bet is probably coming up with a web application to view with Opera on the Wii. I played with Jinzora for a while but never could the Wii part of it to work; I never could figure out how to start the Flash player that was supposed to handle everything.
So, dear Slashdotters, have any of you managed to play music or other media on a Wii from a Unix sever?
Re: (Score:2)
Someone has ported XBMC partially to the Wii. Problem is he won't release his code or his binaries. A very few people have them and say it works great (for alpha).
If you can code donate some time to the XBMC group and get it working.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
That's Windows-only, so I can't use it.
Re: (Score:2)
The idea is great, but that's only for Windows.
Re: (Score:2)
I found it about six months ago, which is why I mentioned it in my post. ;-)
On the PS3 (Score:2)
I've been really wanting to get XBMC on my PS3. I have it on my original XBox, but is struggled with HD at times depending on the codec because it lacked memory. The XBox also can't put out 1080p.
I'm wondering if I should attempt to install Linux on my PS3, and then compile XBMC on it. Will I have issues because of the non-x86 architecture?
If I have Linux on my PS3, will it still play PS3 games? I think I need to hit up Wikipedia and start reading.
Re: (Score:3, Informative)
Yes, you can do multiple partitions and keep the PS3 OS (and thusly play PS3 games) as well as a separate Linux partition.
Now I just need to know if I can compile XBMC on the Cell/PPC architecture.
Re: (Score:2)
However there's one little problem in the PS3 partitioning scheme. You can either devote 10GB to Linux and the rest to GameOS, or 10GB to GameOS and the rest to Linux. Neither is optimal, because 10GB is not really enough for Linux, or GameOS.
Re: (Score:2)
Dumb question, but:
Couldn't one (on a stock 40GB PS3) dedicate 30GB to GameOS, 10GB to Linux, and plug in an external USB drive to pick up the slack?
Seems reasonable to me. It's not as if Linux software is particularly huge; 10 gigs should be plenty for Linux program data. Local content can be stored on the external device, and with an appropriate filesystem, shared between Linux and GameOS.
Re: (Score:2)
Yes, you can, but the problem is you have to set it up to boot with USB storage in the kernel instead of a module. It's also much slower, supposedly the hypervisor makes USB storage access slower than it should be. There's another problem, GameOS can only read FAT drives, not ext3.
I've complained to Sony about the partitioning scheme, I want to be able to choose a 50%/50% split, or better yet any division of it I want.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
Sorry, no go. There's not good enough video support in the PS3 jail. There is a HUGE thread in the XBMC forum about this and the answer is no right now it's not running. They would be interested in someone doing a PPC port though.
XBMC vs AppleTV? (Score:2)
Anyone have any hands on experience with both or have a link to any information discussing the pros/cons of these two media centers?
I am about to invest a couple thousand into 3 MacMinis and 2 AppleTV units, which hooked up to a 3TB NAS device (drobo) can all share via Airport Extreme from my shared iTunes folder (which is already set up as a media share on the drobo). By attaching a secondary Airport Extreme in b/g compat mode, I hope to use my iPhone as a remote control -- mainly for the NiceCast iTunes r
Re: (Score:2)
On XP at least, support of remote controls is poor. I guess Microsoft want to sell you to a copy of Media Center Edition or the equivelent Vista version, so they withhold the drivers.
I assume it's better on Linux.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
I'm about to sink A$700 into a low end PC to do all that. Granted it I'll only have a DVD drive not a blu-ray drive (maybe when they come down in price). Except for the Itunes bit, I absolut
No Mac PPC executable (Score:2)
(as above)
Elisa (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
I ran XBMC on my gen 1 xbox many years ago. Recently I got a nice HTPC w/ elisa running - and elisa was nice. A few months ago I switched back to XBMC on my htpc, and it's well ahead of elisa. So many awesome things I don't have time to write here, but I'll name a few:
#1. 2 click IMDB scanning and automated from thereon
#2. When you "stop" something from playing, and come back to it later and press play it asks you if you want to start from the beginning or resume (This is a "little thing" but really shows h
xbmc is damn fine software (Score:2)
I have an xbox and use xbmc on it. it's quite good. this software is just something we all have wanted for so long. It plays anything in any format. It streams music and movies and rss feeds.
it's all function and feature sans vapor.
XBMC for Xbox (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re:XBMC ? (Score:4, Informative)
the source code is available to all platforms, including xbox.
Just the binaries that are not available to xbox, because the MS xbox sdk does not allows them to redistribute binaries.
Re:XBMC ? (Score:4, Informative)
To compile XBMC for the Xbox is illegal since it'll have to be compiled using the XDK (XBox Development Kit) which is not available to the average joe (as one may suspect).
That's the reason they don't distribute a compiled version. But if you google for XBMC and T3CH ... you might get something in return.
Oh... the wonders of googling...
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2, Informative)
Re:XBMC ? (Score:4, Interesting)
The developers haven't legally licensed the Xbox XDK, and so they can't legally distribute binaries. So you'll have to find them somewhere illegitimate.
Even if you own the SDK, which, I think, average joe CAN buy, distributing binaries is disallowed under SDK EULA without MS's blessing, which they will not give for XBMC. This is pretty much same problem as iPhone developers have, except unlike iPhone there are no alternative ways to compile code for XBOX - you HAVE to use the MS SDK and as such MS can sue for distribution of compiled binaries (which then have to be distributed along side of other illegal material like movies and music and thus looks just as illegal).
On the flip side, at least there is no Apple "Fight Club" rules for MS SDK - you ARE allowed to talk about it without getting sued.
-Em
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2, Troll)
it's not like the makers of any other tool get a say in how you use it or what you do with the product you produce with it.
Tell that to anybody producing a GPL-licensed library.
Re: (Score:2)
Its a moot point to prod MS with a stick or not. Truth of the matter is that XBox (remember this is XBox, not Xbox 360) is a dead platform and has been dead for a while.
That is why I am so excited that they took XBMC and opened it up to larger platforms. The nice thing about the Xbox was that you get a mini-pc in a tight, cheap package, but the power of it's been lacking these days (sub-Ghz celeron with next to no memory only goes so far) so with new platform support maybe we'll finally get HD, DVR and oth
Re: (Score:2)
That is why I am so excited that they took XBMC and opened it up to larger platforms. The nice thing about the Xbox was that you get a mini-pc in a tight, cheap package, but the power of it's been lacking these days (sub-Ghz celeron with next to no memory only goes so far) so with new platform support maybe we'll finally get HD, DVR and other extra hardware-based capabilities.
The holy grail of course would be being able to run it on the PS3 or the Xbox 360, either of which could handle HD content. The Xbox will actually do 720p or 1080i and XBMC will probably produce video at these resolutions but you can't feed it data fast enough (that is, the Xbox's 733MHz Coppermine Celeron can't process a HD stream) so it won't help you.
I don't really know the state of X360 hacking, but if it ever gets to where the state of Xbox hacking is today, it will be the ideal platform to run XBMC on
Re: (Score:2)
How long ago was this? Personally, I've been running XBMC on Ubuntu 7.10 since early this Spring, don't think I've had a single crash.
Re: (Score:2)
The holy grail of course would be being able to run it on the PS3 or the Xbox 360, either of which could handle HD content. The Xbox will actually do 720p or 1080i and XBMC will probably produce video at these resolutions but you can't feed it data fast enough (that is, the Xbox's 733MHz Coppermine Celeron can't process a HD stream) so it won't help you.
I am not sure if 360 or PS3 are really that attractive anymore. You could pick up a used modded Xbox for $100-$150 - now THAT was worthwhile, but at the cost of PS3 and X360, its actually cheaper to buy PC - and no hacking or mod-chipping required.
-Em
Re: (Score:2)
I'd assume it's a legal grey area - does anyone actually know whether the idea that the EULA of a compiler can limit the distribution of binaries that it outputs has ever been tested in court?
Uh, the compiler is Visual Studio. The XDK is a set of libraries, which are software. In order to distribute software built with these libraries you must follow the license. In order to get your code signed by Microsoft so it will run on an unhacked Xbox and in order to get their blessing for distribution you must submit the code to Microsoft.
In addition, the XDK is legally available only with an Xbox development kit. So if you don't have a dev kit, and you have the XDK, you broke the law.
Re: (Score:2)
Its not a legal grey area, distributing anything linked to the libraries in the XDK is a clear violation of copyright law.
Re: (Score:2)
I'd assume it's a legal grey area - does anyone actually know whether the idea that the EULA of a compiler can limit the distribution of binaries that it outputs has ever been tested in court?
The fact that the XBMC team don't want to prod MS with a stick and blindly hope that they aren't bankrupted by defensive legal costs, of course, is entirely understandable, but I'd still think that they've got something of a case; it's not like the makers of any other tool get a say in how you use it or what you do with the product you produce with it.
The issue is that compilers often add something to the compiled code: libraries, and so forth, but even headers and metadata might be an issue.
This isn't like a breadmaker machine telling you (well, the manufacturer telling you) you can't sell their bread under so-and-so conditions, this is like a breadmaker that makes bread that includes some 'secret sauce' of theirs telling you you can't redistribute their secret sauce without permission (but of course even this analogy is wrong, since 'redistributing'
Re: (Score:2)
Part of the problem is there's little or no motivation to release a free SDK (e.g. cleanroom reimplementation), because a modded Xbox is an "illegitimate" platform - you're already breaking some backwards law by modding it, you might as well break another backwards law by releasing unlicensed binaries.
I'm not fond of legally-encumbered distribution, because frankly it's none of Microsoft's business what Joe Random sticks on the internet. The SDK should be open in the first place. It's not like M$ is going
Re: (Score:2)
The average person can NOT purchase the XDK. It is available only from Microsoft and only with the signing of a development agreement. There is an OpenXDK in-progress. It does not yet do much. You can run Linux without hacking any code on the Xbox (100% legally) but nothing else...
Anyway, even if the developers had somehow legally licensed the XDK they wouldn't be allowed to distribute any resulting binaries themselves. They have to be submitted to Microsoft for signing to run on an unhacked box, and Micros
OSX Users (Score:5, Informative)
OS X Users might want to check out: http://plexapp.com/ [plexapp.com]
This group forked from XBMC a while ago. It was originally called OSXBMC but to differentiate from the 'official' OSX XBMC release they renamed to Plex.
I've played around with it for a while and it is absolutely gorgeous. Each release gets it more and more integrated with OSX. Apple remote, mouse, local file system, etc.
They've also teamed up with CenterStage [centerstageproject.com] to work towards a more OSX like GUI.
Currently my XBOX, bought for $75 used, is going strong. Served via the XBMC protocol running on a debian server with 2 TB of data. pytvshows and rtorrent are nearly as good as a DVR (considering I work second shift) and ... There just aren't more words to describe how awesome the XBMC project is and how far it has come in the last 3 years I've used it.
I'll have to check out the other release tonight to see how it compares.
Re: (Score:3, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
He also had binaries on my desktop months ago.
Best to market does not always beat first to market.
Re:OSX Users - Boxee (Score:2)
I am in the Boxee alpha, and it's like XBMC meets web 2.0. It's invite only for now, but you can request an invite at twitter.com/boxee (OSX and Linux only, Windows version coming soon)
Re: OS X Users (Score:4, Informative)
Hi Gamester! (Cyberace1?) Gamester (one of the project managers of XBMC) is hardly an impartial observer. There are a number of features that Plex has that XBMC does not, and many report it to be more stable on their Macs. Not to mention he keeps misspelling my last name, which is "Feingold".
Come to the Plex forums (forums.plexapp.com) or download Plex to compare for yourself, but take his statements (posted under a pseudonym) with a grain of salt.
Re: (Score:2)
Again. I haven't had a chance to check out the 'official' release. But the difference was Plex has had a release now for 4-5 months. This means that I could have actually run it prior to now.
Plex also incorporates Sparkle, which is the autoupdater framework for OS X. (Which would be ideal for a set top box).
CenterStage is also something that is likely to only be in Plex and not OSXBMC.
I downloaded it on my work laptop (XP) and the thing I didn't like is that it
1) changed my resolution
2) started up full scre
Re: (Score:2)
I downloaded it on my work laptop (XP) and the thing I didn't like is that it
1) changed my resolution
2) started up full screen immediately.
Well... it's a media center, not a media player. It's designed to be used as your shell, just as you would on the Xbox itself. Compare with MythTV and others like it.
Re: (Score:2)
I just downloaded it... The BIGGEST thing is that Plex acts like an OSX application. You download the DMG and you place it anywhere. OSXBMC comes with an installer, why in God's name does something like this need an installer? Everything should be self contained in the .app.
Second response seems to be quite a bit better with Plex vs OSXBMC.
Re: (Score:2)
How can Windows be available for anything but windows?
Just wait a minute! You'll get it! Or you'll be trying so hard to see what might be funny about it that I'll have time to make a clean getaway with your windows. You can keep the Windows, though.
more colossally bad moderation (Score:2)
Looks like somebody has too many moderator points today.
Re: (Score:2)
Deal with it.
Re: (Score:2)
It's just 4 meaningless letters now.
Does that mean that we can rearrange them any way we like? XBMC == XMBC == XCBM == XCMB == MBCX == CXMB == CMXB == BMXC ad naseum?
Re:Product name whack-a-mole (Score:4, Funny)
Does that mean that we can rearrange them any way we like? XBMC == XMBC == XCBM == XCMB == MBCX == CXMB == CMXB == BMXC ad naseum?
"Ad nauseum"? Remind me never to get on a Tilt-a-Whirl with you. There are only 24 permutations.
Re: (Score:2)
Where are my mod points when I need them ?
+2 funny!
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)