Anti-Frostidigitation: Heatpipe Gloves 324
Hettinga writes "A little casemod couture this morning, courtesy of Hongbin Ma, a professor of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering at the University of Missouri. He has developed heatpipe-driven gloves which pump therms from your toasty upper arm down to those aforementioned frosty digits. 'Each glove contains five small heat pipes, one for each finger, that are about 14 inches long and 1 mm x 2 mm in the cross section. Each pipe consists of three sections: an evaporating section, which is attached to the upper arm area; an adiabatic section, which is between the finger area and the arm area; and the condensing section, which is attached to the finger area.' Coming soon to a half-pipe near you..."
Seriously? (Score:3, Funny)
Too bad... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Too bad... (Score:5, Insightful)
I can't imagine that little bit of lost heat was the difference between life and death for anyone. But, the fact that we have evolved the feature suggests it was.
--
In London? Need a Physics Tutor? [colingregorypalmer.net]
American Weblog in London [colingregorypalmer.net]
Re:Too bad... (Score:2, Insightful)
If our hands and feet remained nice and toasty, we would lose a little bit of heat, certainly. But, we'd also stay outside much longer than we would have otherwise, and that's the difference that could kill you. You'd slip into hypothermia muttering incoherently to yourself "at least my little piggies are nice and toasty."
Furthermore ... (Score:4, Insightful)
So, your body notices the core temperature dropping and says "Crikey! Better shut off those extremities even more."
So, aren't these gloves self defeating? And possibly dangerous because they will lower your core temp while simultaneously reducing the options your body has to naturally fight that drop.
Re:Furthermore ... (Score:3, Interesting)
I ask you.. why are your hands warming it mittens than in gloves? Are mittens self-defeating?
Re:Furthermore ... (Score:3, Informative)
The heatpipe gloves would reduce your core body temperature. Mittens would not.
Re:Furthermore ... (Score:5, Insightful)
Additionally this could be very handy for jobs that require people to be outdoors, yet use their hands. In the recent cold spell here in New England, I felt terrible for the toll collectors, construction workers, and police who could bundle up, but still couldn't wear heavy heavy gloves since they needed to use their hands. This technology would allow for a very light weight set of gloves that would allow mobility of the hands, while insulating the rest of the body as mush as needed.
Re:Furthermore ... (Score:5, Interesting)
Alcohol has the same effect. It dilates the blood vessels in your skin, making you feel warmer at the cost of increased heat loss. That, coupled with a general loss of sensibility and reasoning, causes many deaths in places where the temperature falls below freezing.
Re:Too bad... (Score:2)
Yup. It's about 15 below here right, now. Definitely makes a difference.
Re:Too bad... (Score:2)
Re:Too bad... (Score:5, Insightful)
Let's say you don't have the option of going somewhere warm (ie, inside to a nice toasty fire)... Which do you have a more critical (ie, life-preserving) need for - To keep using your large muscles (legs, upper arms), which serves both the purpose of generating heat and might eventually move you to somewhere warmer; or, manual dexterity, which would only really help if you needed to operate a book of matches (something that didn't exist for 99.99999% of human history)?
Our bodies decrease blood flow to the extremities for precisely that reason. Additionally, assuming the worst, we can live without a few fingers or toes or even an earlobe; Sacrificing them to keep our core body temperature high enough seems like a viable tradeoff under extreme circumstances. The fact that we now have thinsulate and heat-packs and almost always a warm place to go nearby, so having our fingers nice and toasty seems more useful than preventing the small heat loss from them, had no effect on how we evolved.
But, the fact that we have evolved the feature suggests it was.
Although this may seem in direct contradiction to my point above, I mention it only for clarity... Not all inherited traits "evolved" in the natural-selection sense. One of the fundamental ideas behind evolution says that mutations occur essentially at random, and those that increase our odds of reproducing (which dying young does not) get passed on. However, those traits that have no effect whatsoever on our chances of reproducing can also get passed on, just by blind chance. For a trivial example, Alzheimer's disease - It doesn't affect people until they've passed their reproductive prime, so as debilitating as it seems in later life, it doesn't reduce its own chances of remaining in the population.
Re:Too bad... (Score:2, Informative)
Not quite. Even considering a generous definition of "human history" spanning 1 million years, if matches weren't available for 99.99999% of "human history" then they weren't invented till a little more than a month ago. :-)
You probably mean "99.9823%" instead, as chemical friction matches were invented in 1827. Decimal points are powerful things
Re:Too bad... (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Too bad... (Score:4, Funny)
You'd think at least the temp-regulation system would be smart enough to shunt some of that extra heat off to your hands before busting out the sweat... But I guess the right hand doesn't know what the left lung is doing. =)
Re:Too bad... (Score:2)
Probably preserving core temperature is more important that protecting the fingers and toes--at least you then have a chance of keeping going long enough to find shelter. Birds have a more clever countercurrent heat exchanger solution. The arteries and veins run together, so that the venous return is warmed by the arteries, reducing loss of heat
Re:Too bad... (Score:2)
Well, if your fingers are too cold to light a match (which can happen)...
Re:Too bad... (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Too bad... (Score:5, Insightful)
There are those with poor circulation in the extremities whose bodies have some trouble warming hands and feet back up once they've gotten cold. Speaking as one of them, once my feet have gone cold, they stay that way for ages, even after getting into a warm (or even hot) envinronment, changing shoes/socks for warmer/dryer pairs, etc.
Re:Too bad... (Score:2)
I have no idea why this was modded flamebait, unless someone has a personal vendetta against those with poor circulation...
Anyway, many of those people are that way because they are (or recently were) smokers. My father has poor circulation in his legs because of weight. Some have it because of a weak heart, and some just "because." A suggestion is warm water. Submerse your cold extremities in warm (not hot) water, and they should warm up pr
Re:Too bad... (Score:4, Insightful)
What it really means is that the garment that this is in is less thermally efficient than the same garment without (you will lose heat faster). It maybe handy for delicate work were you need thin gloves and warm hands in a cold environment with the only other real option is an active heating system power by batteries.
Re:Too bad... (Score:2)
Maybe it's just me, but I tend to have plenty of extra body heat around my torso and limbs, but my feet and hands still get cold. I'd like gloves like this.
Re:Too bad... (Score:2)
That's why you can buy wind-proof mitts (treated leather) normally used for snowmobiling. Less surface area to lose heat from, the fingers can keep each other warm, etc. Also, if you have to do something by hand, you can pop your hand out of the mitt, do what you have to do, and put your hand back in real quick compared to a glove.
My dogs (St. Bernard and Newfie) would be happy to stay outside
tell that to raynaud's sufferers (Score:2)
Re:Too bad... (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Missouri is in the south (Score:2, Interesting)
Without gloves, biking for longer than 30 seconds is painful many winter months. My commute (in western Illinois, less than an hour from Missouri) is only 2 miles, and I wear Thinsulate gloves, and my hands are STILL cold when I get to work.
Personally, I'd like to see a heat pump that moved heat from the small of my back (well insulated by a pack full of books and student papers) to my hands, nose, and ears!
cbd.
Re:Missouri is in the south (Score:2)
Anyway, St. Louis can be known for some pretty nasty weather. The worst part is the weather changes. Right now it is 2PM and about 26F. In a few days, it will be in the mid-50's around this time of day. It is tough to get used to the cold when it goes from 70 to 30 to 55 to 20 to 60 to 0 in a given winter month.
Your comment really makes no sense.
Great... (Score:2, Funny)
That's "funny, hmmm..." (Score:2)
Which bring up the question: WHY do your hands get cold, when you have a perfectly good heat-transfer medium built in?
Answer: Evolutionarily, when your environment gets cold it's important to maintain the temperature of your brain and core body organs, to keep you alive. When those are in jepoardy, your body may sacrifice heating, first of your hands and feet, then of your arms and legs, and risk damaging them, as a better tradeoff than risking DYING, or brain or or
Re:That's "funny, hmmm..." (Score:3, Interesting)
How would moving heat that would go out into the atmosphere to your hands harm you in any way?
what about feet? (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:what about feet? (Score:2, Informative)
Ma, who also is developing the same device for shoes, is the founder of MU's Research Consortium for Innovative Thermal Management
Cool (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Cool (Score:2)
Holy Crap, that's funny. Thanks
Sounds good for low-circulation folks (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Sounds good for low-circulation folks (Score:2)
Re:Sounds good for low-circulation folks (Score:2)
Somewhat offtopic, but a lot of people who believe that they have Raynaud's have something else (like acrocyanosis [healthatoz.com]). Anyway, the result is the same: cold, blue hands. Worst part about having acrocyanosis is that it makes it really difficult to put the moves on the wife during the winter - she doesn't want my hands anywhere near her!
Re:Sounds good for low-circulation folks (Score:2)
Re:Sounds good for low-circulation folks (Score:2)
Re:Sounds good for low-circulation folks (Score:2)
What about hyperthermia? (Score:3, Informative)
Re:What about hyperthermia? (Score:2)
Ie you're not risking much to keep comfortable: if you end up needing that extra heat, you're likely in the fucked category.
That was not so back in the bad old days, when curling into a ball and huddling behind a tree was state-of-the-art thermal protection.
Re:What about hypothermia? (Score:3, Informative)
But if you're wearing these gloves, but aren't otherwise wearing clothes appropriate to -20, then yeah, you might get hypothermia.
On the other hand, hyperthermia is unlikely to be a problem caused by these gloves in -20C weather.
Inverse overclocking... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Inverse overclocking... (Score:2)
Makes the whole wireless keyboard a bit useless, but there you go.
I am concerned.... (Score:2, Funny)
No worries! (Score:2)
There's an easier way... (Score:4, Informative)
Damon,
Re:There's an easier way... (Score:4, Informative)
Re:There's an easier way... (Score:2)
Damon,
Re:There's an easier way... (Score:2)
Re:There's an easier way... (Score:2)
Actually you'd be surprised. I'm not advocating anyone tossing their coat aside and just wearing a hat all day but the effect is definetly there.. wearing something over your ears has a big impact on how warm you feel.
I suspect it's mostly psychological though, because despite how you feel your body would still be susceptible to hypothermia.
Growing up in alaska, I would often just put on a hat when going outside briefly
Re:There's an easier way... (Score:2)
Oops.
Re:There's an easier way... (Score:2)
Interesting about carpal tunnel and the like though. In most cases though, the way we dress here is enough to withstand -20F windchills (and I do have arthritis).
Really? (Score:5, Informative)
If he has 'developed' these gloves, I would like to see a picture of them. It looks like these are just as 'developed' as those night-vision contacts over at Popular Science.
Re:Really? (Score:2)
Anyway, the article clearly states that he is developing the gloves, not that he has developed them. Also, there is a picture of a supposed prototype on the page, but I can't tell what the hell it is.
Aerogel (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Aerogel (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Aerogel (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Aerogel (Score:2)
Re:Aerogel (Score:2)
-Tim
Dammit! (Score:2)
Raise your hands if you are sure (Score:2)
Keep those hands down (Score:5, Informative)
That said, it IS more efficient if the bottom end is the "hot" end, 'cause the rising warm fluid vapor and the down-flowing condensed fluid are both assisted by gravity. However, gravity is NOT an essential part of the process (some satellite instruments use heatpipes to keep-em cool in free-fall, for example).
A friend of mine does heat pipes as a business: koolpipes.com [koolpipes.com]
No, didn't RTFA (Score:5, Interesting)
When the guy who supervised the dexterity and mental acuity test took of his gloves, it took less than three minutes for his hands to be freezing cold, while the infrared camera clearly showed that the main characters fingers were still warm.
Seemed fairly conclusive to me, that the trick was keeping the torso heated, as that would prevent the problems, these gloves are supposed to fix.
Besides - if you can have warm dextorous fingers without wearing gloves, I'd go for that any day of the week, as long as I'm not working with objects, that can hurt my hands.
Re:No, didn't RTFA (Score:4, Informative)
Doing this helps prevent shivering, which saps EVEN MORE energy from you. It also helps protect from hypothermia by insulating the core, and not the extremities. Having your core temperature drop is WAY worse than having cold hands!
Re:No, didn't RTFA (Score:2)
ps. Yes I know the answer.
Shocking! (Score:2)
Re:No, didn't RTFA (Score:4, Informative)
Re:No, didn't RTFA (Score:2)
Expensive, but definitely on my wish list.
S
Hand warmers (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Hand warmers (Score:2)
We do have a pollution problem you know. And it's less of a paim in the ass than stocking up and hand warmers and inserting themm and trying to maintain a stable temperature.
it can help much more than sports! (Score:5, Interesting)
this would make life for a Raynaud's afflicted person much easier on day's like today when it's 6degF outside and expected to be -1 later tonight.
mars suits (Score:2)
Not quite complete spacesuits, but enough to keep you alive and working while on the surface of the red planet. They included a lattice of warming wires beneath a flexible exterior.
Next up: harvesting bodily fluids [redmeat.com] with a suit.
There is a reson that your body does this. (Score:3, Informative)
Don't be stupid... keep your body warm first.
Keep your torso warm (Score:5, Insightful)
The draining of blood and heat from your hands and feet happens when your core temperature starts dropping. This is done to protect the vital organs, heart, liver etc over the non-vital, hands, feet. If you can keep your core temperature normal you can actually work without gloves even below zero (celsius). This because the body is warm and needn't cut the heatloss from hands or feet.
There was a good documentary on the Discovery channel about the very subject not long ago.
So, while heatpumping gloves seem nice, I'd go with keeping my body warm and be rid of any gloves hindering my hands.
Yeah, bring on the puns..
Re:Keep your torso warm (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Keep your torso warm (Score:3, Interesting)
It really varies... (Score:3, Informative)
I think this likely varies in different people, temperature, wind, activity, etc.. There's lots of situations where I would have been happy to move heat from arm to hand, and when my co
Re:Keep your torso warm (Score:2)
Summer's right around the corner... (Score:2)
Warmest parts of the body (Score:3, Insightful)
this is *nuts*! (Score:3, Informative)
If you wear a heated vest (or even just keep a charcoal-burning hand warmer in a chest pocket (nice and low tech)) your hands don't get all cold and numb; they stay dexterous and warm. And without *any* gloves at all.
Ok so *serious* below zero temperatures will still result in skin loss if you *touch* something...
one that works from a motorcycle cylendar head (Score:2, Interesting)
neat idea, moving the heat that way. here's another application of the same notion. (which i haven't yet seen) they should make a jacket/gloves that warms from a motorcycle cylendar head.
if anyone's ridden a motorbike in cold weather, you know what i mean. something that took the heat from the cylendar head would be a gem.. at 70 mph wind chill in 20 degree weather, nothing from your armpit's gonna help those fingers. many's the day i've ridden one handed in that kind of weather, holding my left hand
Condutive textiles (Score:2, Interesting)
An interesting solution I heard about was conductive textiles - fabrics that act as heating elements (i.e. they're not simply a wire - wires break easily and consume a lot of current
Re: (Score:2)
What about mittens? (Score:3, Insightful)
These gloves should be made with gortex and should be marketed to people that work in the harsh cold and snow.
Unless you actually need all 5 fingers, gloves are really kind'a dumb. Mittens (and yes, people make cool mittens now), are much much warmer then gloves since your fingers are lumped together. Anyone that's lived in cold weather, or is an avid snow rider will tell you that.
These why spend money on expensive Nintendo Power Gloves when you could pick up a pair of trendy mittens for fraction of the price?
goretex+thinsulate (Score:2, Informative)
These gloves may be thinner lighter and warmer than gortex gloves, but goretex you can take off when you have to do delicate work (starting a fire) and you can put your hands in your armpits if they get too
It's a passive system (Score:5, Informative)
So yes, hand warmers are cheap and effective, but they'll die after a few hours once the reaction finishes.
Keeping your core temp high is a nice idea, but let's say you already have a nice coat and things - I think having some gloves that would passively heat my fingers would be nicely appreciated. Their was a post about how if it's a matter of life-or-death, you should maintain your core temp, but I think the more realistic application of these gloves would be to maintain comfort of your digits when you know you're going to be outside.
Again, the system is passive - no batteries, no chemical reactions, nothing at all. You'd put them on and forget about it.
Potentially negative side effect ... hypothermia! (Score:2, Interesting)
hottest part of hell (other use for the heat pump) (Score:2)
-- oldy but goody
Useful in Business (Score:2)
Cure for Programmer's Hands? (Score:2)
I'll never have to hear, "AAAAAAUUUUGHHH!!!! COLD HANDS!!!!!" again.
Opera gloves? (Score:2, Insightful)
A cure! (Score:2, Funny)
Cayenne Pepper (Score:4, Interesting)
Alaska Bugs Sweat Gold Nuggets [alaska-freegold.com]
Exhale Heating System (Score:2)
Hook them up to other warmth generators? (Score:2)
Now, we get those shoes with the crystalline soles that generate a little electricity every time you flex them and...
You know, I think writing this [blogspot.com] burned out more brain cells than I realized ;-)
Re:Hypothermia? (Score:4, Funny)
Solution to fend of heat-pipe-glove-induced hypothermia, buy a warm coat to go with it.
Re:Rats! (Score:2)