Linux-Based Phone Lasts 200 Hours on Standby 187
An anonymous reader writes "Motorola is showing off a Linux/Java phone with a claimed battery life of 200 hours on standby, or 200-250 minutes when talking. If those figures prove true, Linux sure is improving quickly on the power management front. That kind of battery life also suggests that the E895 might be the first single-chipset phone ever to run a complex OS, whether Symbian, Windows Mobile, or Linux. Other features are user-upgradable memory, 1.3MP camera, video capture, multimedia slideshows, and more. Hopefully a more U.S.-friendly version will follow, as happened when Mot's Linux-based quad-band A780 came out a year or so after it's tri-band forebear, the A768, shipped in China."
No cynicism (Score:2, Funny)
A great phone by itself, with the addition of lotsa power, i'm liking it
Re:No cynicism (Score:1, Interesting)
BOFH moment... (Score:2)
Re:No cynicism (Score:2, Interesting)
Impressive? (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Impressive? (Score:5, Insightful)
Iff you checked the capacity of your battery and decided that your phone indeed must have lower consumption then the new phone then you have to check whether your phone runs an OS that's in the same category as Linux and _only then_ can you claim it's not impressive.
(I'm not saying you must be wrong. I'm just saying that you may be comparing apples to PCs, ooops, sorry apples to oranges)
Re:Impressive? (Score:4, Insightful)
Like the greatparent said: the phone is absolutly NOTHING to write about (except LINUX LINUX LINUX LINUX... its slashdot, alright...)
Re:Impressive? (Score:2, Insightful)
That's the whole point you get a more flexible OS, not so huge phone and a still a decent battery life.
Yes, I still get nearly a w
Ogg? (Score:2)
Don't think you will be able to get a BASH prompt on this phone. It's a closed phone; customization will be in Java; and yeah there may be a Java ogg player but thats little advantage over most other devices.
Linux is "interesting" here, but not "friendly".
Also, note that the phone is upgradable to 10MB -ooohh! Woww!!! 10MB!!; I wonder why they bother to release such a device, some of their early models had 96MB which is something but low for a multimedia device.
Sam
Re:Ogg? (Score:5, Interesting)
I actually think that having a 'real' OS on the phone is a big step. If you could see the code for the current OS used on most Motorola phones today, you would appreciate what a step forward going to Linux really is.
Re:Ogg? (Score:2)
I was a software engineer at Orange, mostly doing MS Smartphone customisations, and swiftly got depressed when I learned it was a closed Java phone.
The 10MB is a poor limit though? However getting a bash prompt is what I want, and maybe installing squeak (scheme) or ficl (forth).
Is thay any way at all any poor sucker is going to get a bash prompt and install stuff on one of your 96MB phones?
Sam
Re:Ogg? (Score:2)
there is no 10MB limit since you can upgrade the flash RAM, but that's largely irrelevant unless you feel like paying twice as much for a phone. it's just another java phone, this time on top of linux. big deal.
Re:Ogg? (Score:2)
Thats because its not true, I do know this, I just typed in the wrong word. If my P900 hadn't broke I could have stopped the car and quickly amended my post.
"it's just another java phone, this time on top of linux. big deal"
I know "big deal", thats what my post was all about, linux-nothing its just a stupid stinkin java-only phone with nothing to recommend it to the discerning hacker.
How Moto can get so close and blow it is depressing, perhaps related to the "all o
Re:Ogg? (Score:2)
Moto didn't choose to run Linux on this phone so that it could be hacked, but because it lets them make a higher quality product at lower cost than the alternatives. And that's a good thing for Linux.
Actually, if I have to guess, Moto might think it's cool for a phone to be hackable (in the constructive sense of "hack", like the way TiVo supports the hacker community), but I'm certain that Moto's actual custom
Re:10MB ?? Actually 524 MB (Score:2)
Thanks
Sam
Re:Ogg? (Score:2)
Do they 'discourage' it? If I try to ssh into the phone , will I find some propietary lock that was put there specifically to stop me from doing it? and if I actually do it, will they come after me with some lawsuit?
or is it just the regular 'warranty void' disclaimer? (I don't mind that)
Re:Impressive? (Score:2)
Look at the phone and read the article. It's Linux-based, yes, but you're not going to be running SUSE 9.3 on that thing. It's
Re:Impressive? (Score:2)
Yeah, right. Next you'll be saying that Michael Moore quotes people he doesn't like selectively to make them look bad.
OSE for ever BTW.
Re:Impressive? (Score:1)
Re:Impressive? (Score:2)
One thing is, the Nokia has a monochrome screen and a lot less features. So you would naturally expect the Motorolla to use more Juice anyway.
I think the point of the post was to say "hey, a linux phone that doesnt suck"
I may get one of these if they come out in Oz...my Nokia is getting a little old.
Re:Impressive? (Score:2)
Your statement about Linux is irrelevant, about as irrelevant as saying Tivo has Linux whereas competitors might not. For most people, if it works well, it doesn't matter what is inside or how simple or complex, how well-fit or ill-fit those internals are.
Re:Impressive? (Score:2)
I'm sure you have a good phone and if the PDA functionality includes the above, then let me know, I'm looking for such a phone. Cheers.
Re:Impressive? (Score:2)
Re:Impressive? (Score:1)
Re:Impressive? (Score:2)
Now I set the phone to shut off at midnight and turn on at 8AM, so from my calculations thats 225 hours from a 1500Ah battery. It could have easily gone longer and probably break 400-500 hours on standby, and this is from a phone that is about three generations behin
Re:Impressive? (Score:2)
In other news, car drives 500 miles on a tank of gas, and plane 20 hours!
Agreed. Although impressive, not unheard of.
I dunno... (Score:3, Informative)
Re:I dunno... (Score:2)
Nothing special and this only made it on to
Linux Improving Battery Life? (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Linux Improving Battery Life? (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Linux Improving Battery Life? (Score:2)
Re:Linux Improving Battery Life? (Score:3, Informative)
It does....See this from TFA.
If true, these figures suggest Linux has made great progress in consumer electronics power management, possibly through the efforts of MontaVista, which has supplied the Linux used in all of Motorola's previous Linux phones.
Read this [linuxdevices.com] too.
Re:Linux Improving Battery Life? (Score:3, Interesting)
And the battery life is still not impressive, which makes the one sentence irrelevant.
Re:Linux Improving Battery Life? (Score:3, Funny)
Meh.
Again, it's only in Asia (Score:4, Insightful)
Again, TFA says:
Does anyone know why Motorola keeps doing this? Isn't there a viable market for linux-based mobile phone in Europe or the US for example?
Re:Again, it's only in Asia (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Again, it's only in Asia (Score:2)
Bullshit is right, but on your part.
A market test is done for 2 reasons.
Electronics are normally introduced into selected markets to test what type of ppl will buy a product. Historically, Electronics have been tested in America (dominately in NYC|LA|Chicago|Dallas, Clevand|Cinninati, somewhere in midwest (like lincoln NE), and somewhere like Pheonix|Seattle|Denver). Tha
Nothing to do with Linux (Score:2)
AsiaPac simply has a bigger more dynamic mobile market than the USA.
Re:Again, it's only in Asia (Score:2)
Re:Again, it's only in Asia (Score:2)
Re:Again, it's only in Asia (Score:2)
Re:Again, it's only in Asia (Score:2)
Bye egghat.
Re:Again, it's only in Asia (Score:2)
Its simply that new phones are better received in Asia, and Europe, then the US. Americans are more reluctant to adopt the new technologies, and more likely to stick with an existing phone.
In the past Motorola has had trouble shifting phones when the took new tech to the state. Having learnt the lesson they now sell them first in more responsive markets like the other phone companies.
Re:Again, it's only in Asia (Score:2, Insightful)
200-250 hours is not impressive (Score:3, Interesting)
Nokia 5140i [nokia.co.uk]
Re:200-250 hours is not impressive (Score:1)
200 hours is not impressive.
Sure, it lasts 200 hours on standby, but (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Sure, it lasts 200 hours on standby, but (Score:2)
Re:try debian (Score:1)
that's nothing (Score:3, Interesting)
Granted, I don't phone that much, but it's nice to have a device that doesn't need be be recharged every other day/week.
linux, linux, linux (Score:5, Insightful)
Does it really matter what OS your phone is running? It's a closed system; you can't get at the internals.
Re:linux, linux, linux (Score:2)
I've always wondered, does this mean we can expect to see some source code from Motorola? (It may already be published, if so forgive me).
That question is more rhetorical, but the real question I have is: Isn't that binary distribution? If device makers start using GPL code for their devices, and ship them, doesn't that make them subject to making their work public again? It would seem so, but my knowledge of this frontier is limited to say the least..
Re:linux, linux, linux (Score:2)
Want that code?
Just because you use GPL code doesn't mean your use of it falls under GPL.
Tom
Re:linux, linux, linux (Score:2, Informative)
Re:linux, linux, linux (Score:2)
I'm just saying that even though they can block me from loading new code, do they have a responsibility to make their changes public? Assuming there are changes...
Does shipping a consumer device with a modified kernel fall under binary distribution?
Re:linux, linux, linux (Score:1, Interesting)
They aren't obliged to make it any easier for you to put your own hacked Linux on the phone than it was for them to put their version on it, e.g. you may need to open up the phone and use custom I/O connectors to flash it. But most likely
Are you new? (Score:1)
Re:linux, linux, linux (Score:5, Funny)
Hand back your /. userid immediately, loser!
J.
what it gets you (Score:2)
Why does that matter? Because it makes development and porting to it a lot easier than to PalmOS, PPC, WinCE, or Symbian.
Re:what it gets you (Score:2)
There is nothing to "port", the stuff just compiles and works. And, it turns out, X11 is a great window system for handhelds. This isn't theory--Linux-based handhelds have been out for a while, and they are a joy to develop for and with.
and my point is... *anything* can be made portab
So, it's Linux? (Score:2, Interesting)
Java? No Thanks... (Score:1)
How easy is it to use... (Score:1, Funny)
to send message:
$ message --body Hi, how are you doing? --recipient 0415898537
bash: message: command not found
Re:How easy is it to use... (Score:5, Funny)
if [ $caller==BOSS ] /dev/null
then
$call >>
fi
Re:How easy is it to use... (Score:1)
bash: answer: command not found
user:~# pick-it-up
bash: pick-it-up: command not found
user:~# goddamitstupidlinuxphone
THE SYSTEM IS GOING DOWN FOR A REBOOT!
Motorola development (Score:4, Interesting)
They have
1. Multiband Phones running Linux (A780, this one, etc)
2. UMTS phones running Symbian UIQ (A1000, E1000, etc)
3. Clamshell-Phones running Windows Mobile (MPx220...)
4. and finally the ultra slim phones running Motorola's own OS (RAZR V3...)
Wow. Compare this to Nokia, they have about 3 basic setups with 50 different designs.
Re:Motorola development (Score:2)
Re:Motorola development (Score:2)
Wow, UNIX phone. (Score:3, Funny)
cp
Linux-based phones, laptops, convergence question (Score:2)
Part of me wants a cell phone that simply has ten numbers, a call button, and a call log, and for the other stuff I'll use a laptop
Re:Linux-based phones, laptops, convergence questi (Score:2)
Texting with this phone is fine because of the qwerty keyboard. However you still find yourself using text shorthand to cram as much as possible into a message. Y pay 4 2 msg whn 1 cn do.
Cool, but... (Score:3, Funny)
Something doesn't add up here (Score:3)
...is this sort of power management a feature of typical Linux kernels? Who wrote it? Has LT reviewed it?
...are we really talking about an advanced low power processor which happens to run Linux?
...what is it about Linux that facilitates this low power consumption? Is it that the OS is free, so the development was cheap?
Re:Something doesn't add up here (Score:1)
Argh! (Score:2, Insightful)
Linux has nothing to do with the power consumption. Good hardware design along with good software (regardless of OS) to switch the device off when not in use is the key to long battery design.
Enough with the
Is that a penguin in your pocket or... (Score:1)
Long battery life (Score:2)
RTFA (Score:2)
Measures 2 x 3.7 x 0.9 inches (51 x 93 x 23 mm)
Displaces 88.4 cc
Weighs 4.5 ounces (127 grams)
Can I Install Asterisk On It? (Score:2)
Re:Can I Install Asterisk On It? (Score:2)
I work with a company that's just rolling out that service. VOIP over wireless when it's there, GSM when it isn't. Same phone number.
Can't impress her like you used to? (Score:2)
Try this special product, Linux. We have millions
of happy customers all around the world. You will get the perfect feeling of being a man again!
Linux is the impotence treatment operating system that everyone is talking about. Linux acts up to 200 hours battery life, compare this to only two or three hours of Viagra action! The active ingredient is GNU, same as in brand Linux.
Simply dissolve half a pill under your tongue, 10 min before intercourse for the best erections you've ever had! Linux als
manpages (Score:3, Funny)
Battery life depends on signal strength (Score:3, Informative)
Cellphones with better battery life than Motorola's existed even four years ago. For instance, the Sony Ericsson T65i [virtualibrary.it] was the market leader in 2002 having a standby time of 300 hours and a talk time of 11 hours. In practice, I found that phone never lasted more than 200 hours standby and 6.5 hours talk time even with a brand new battery in an area with good reception close to a basestation. In areas with poor signal strength, standby was ~80 hours and talk time was ~3 hours. I expect Motorola's battery life figures fall off similarly quickly with signal strength.
Learn to spell "its", for frigging sake. (Score:2, Informative)
200 hours on standby? (Score:2)
Such inflated specs are about as misleading as hard disk MTBF ratings.
Linux phones and the GPL (Score:2, Interesting)
The GPL does offer the right to anyone using the software (on the phone) to read the code. The distribution and apps from Trolltech (and others) may not be licensed so. Either way there's got to be enough GNU tools used, so the non-average user can try and tweak it the way they like it (voiding warranty of course.)
If there are such possibilities than calling out "linux
Fucking nonsese (Score:3, Interesting)
What a bunch of fucking bullshit!
>If those figures prove true, Linux sure is improving quickly on the power management front.
It means Motorola's drivers and other code have improved.
And so fucking what anyway? Am I supposed to ditch my current phone just because this piece of shit can standby 200 hours?
Play On Words (Score:3, Interesting)
"Such stellar battery life suggests the E895 might be based on a single-chipset architecture, "
If I read that correctly it sounds like they don't know if was built on the single chipset or not.
I appears that the "author" does not have access to anything more than publicity manual. I would think that they could claim that this thing cures cancer, stops wars and ends world hunger...and no one would really know.
That being said, I would love to see this thing reviewd by someone who has kicked one of these things around for a couple of months. Which brings on my second gripe --
"Availability
The E895 is expected to be initially introduced in the Asia-Pacific region in Q4 of 2005."
I guess it does not really matter, because it will never make it to our shores -- and if it does, it won't be until we have flying cars and they find some way to increase the price and reduce the features. This is about the 10th cool gadget I have seen this month that I will never get to purchase in person, or as the case with cellphones, even if I could purchase -- I would never get to use without moving to Tokyo.
cool! (Score:2)
Nothing to do with power management (Score:2)
Wait ... what? (Score:2)
Re:By definition... (Score:3, Insightful)
Something smaller, more efficient; yes. but... (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Something smaller, more efficient; yes. but... (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Something smaller, more efficient; yes. but... (Score:2)
Re:By definition... (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Too less of user memory? (Score:4, Informative)
The OP says user-upgradable memory, which is quite not correct - the memory card is in addition to the 10MB but it's not a on-board upgrade. It's just an expansion - like in any other current smartphone or even featured phone in the market.
Re:Sweet! (Score:2)
I did that with my treo 650. I have one without the camera. it was as simple as looking for one online, and discovered several resellers. No you dont get to finance your phone in your plan for te next 3 years but that only stops those that really can not afford that phone.
Re:Sweet! (Score:2)
Not being a slave to a contract for 2+ years is worth quite a few $$$ to me. I get to change plans to take advantage of the newest rates instead of bei
Re:Qtopia? (Score:2, Informative)