Instacart To Cut 1,900 Jobs (bloomberg.com) 39
Instacart plans to terminate about 1,900 employees' jobs, including the only unionized positions in the U.S., representing a fulsome embrace of the gig economy. From a report: The grocery delivery company already classifies most of its workers as independent contractors, whose ranks have ballooned to more than 500,000 during the coronavirus pandemic. But starting in 2015, the company hired a small subset of workers as employees, who under U.S. law are entitled to protections like minimum wage and can be subject to more direction and training by their boss. "What we found is that our shoppers require training and supervision, which is how you improve the quality of the picking," Instacart Chief Executive Officer Apoorva Mehta said at the time. "You can't do that when they are independent contractors."
Now, Instacart is moving in the other direction, eliminating 1,877 employees' positions, including those of 10 workers in Illinois who last year became the first in the country to vote to unionize at the company. The company said it's doing this as part of a shift toward new models, like providing its technology to retailers to have their own workers prepare customers' orders.
Now, Instacart is moving in the other direction, eliminating 1,877 employees' positions, including those of 10 workers in Illinois who last year became the first in the country to vote to unionize at the company. The company said it's doing this as part of a shift toward new models, like providing its technology to retailers to have their own workers prepare customers' orders.
Re: Biden/Harris (Score:4, Insightful)
The Democrats *TALK* about supporting the working class. But policy over their last few terms has been more along the lines of, "Don't outright swat the working class, but don't support them either."
Words are great for warm fuzzies. Let's see what they actually do before we start singing their praises.
Re: (Score:2)
Ah, full troll then. My mistake.
Re: Biden/Harris (Score:4, Informative)
Under Trump, the number of uninsured Americans has gone up by 7 million
https://www.vox.com/2019/1/23/... [vox.com]
Many are those are the working poor and self-employed.
Re: Biden/Harris (Score:5, Insightful)
The Democrats have abandoned working-class concerns and spend most of their time worrying about if the needs of LGBT or Immigrants are being fully met and abandoned the working stiff regardless of their identity. The problem with identity politics is that those who you don't identify or mention hear that clearly and loudly. This is part of the reason why DJT got elected and Hillary lost in 2016.
I hope the Democrats return to their roots of caring for working-class families which include all identities.
I know mod me down for saying the obvious.
Re: (Score:1, Troll)
The Democratic Party is also antiworker and corporatist. I'm going to be laughing at you Biden supporters when you finally realize ideologically he is essentially Republican/right as far as big corp support (and big military and big supporter of oppressive governments good for big corp interest) goes.
The wailing and whining of the progressives and far left is coming...
Fulsome? (Score:2)
"...including the only unionized positions in the U.S., representing a fulsome embrace of the gig economy."
I wonder if the article writer knows what the word "fulsome" means?
Re: (Score:3)
"...including the only unionized positions in the U.S., representing a fulsome embrace of the gig economy."
I wonder if the article writer knows what the word "fulsome" means?
https://www.merriam-webster.co... [merriam-webster.com]
generous in amount, extent, or spirit
a fulsome victory for the far left— Bruce Rothwell
Re:Fulsome? (Score:5, Insightful)
It seems Apt to me. embracing the gig economy isn't a great thing.
It really kicked off during the last financial crash, with some people calling it a new economy. While it was just a modern take on doing odd jobs to get money so you can live for the next week.
Uber was initially advertised towards people as a way to help with your office commute. You have to drive to work 20 miles away to the big city, Uber can help find someone else who you can carpool to the city with. Where you will get paid if you drive, and pay less than a cab if you didn't. It wasn't meant as a job or an income, just some extra spending cash for an activity that you probably would do anyways.
After the financial crash in 2008 a lot of out of work people, so they jumped onto these Gig Jobs, and worked to make it their own. As it was a way to get a job without trying to find a job.
It wasn't so much "without trying to find a job" (Score:5, Insightful)
Long term it'll bite us all in the ass. What company is going to hire somebody for anything when they can pay them piece meal. You'd think we'd have learned this ages ago [duckduckgo.com] but, well, here we are.
I give it 5-10 years before it's being applied outside driving & delivery. We'll start seeing piece work for IT before long.
Re: (Score:3)
Companies which can't pass the additional expenses on to their customers will go ou
Legalize Slavery (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
"fulsome"... (Score:1)
"a fulsome embrace of the gig economy"
fulsome foolsm
adj. Disgusting or offensive.
We see what you did there.
Re: (Score:2)
It's actually a little bit of both [merriam-webster.com].
Government late to the game (Score:2)
The current system is a mess of 100+ year old ideas, depression era regs, and tax code rules with unintended side effects.
There needs to be a way to offer some sort of safety net around healthcare, retirement savings, unemployment for roles that aren't the standard 40 hour job. Doesn't mean that someone working 4 hours a week gets the same benefits as a full-timer, but something.
I don't have all the answers but generally speaking I think benefits like healthcare and retirement should be separated from empl
Re: (Score:2)
More generally I'd just say to implement a UBI that gives people enough to survive on, but politicians will just fuck it all up because they'll see promising
A US based Union is a fast path to job cuts. (Score:2)
There is a problem with Unions in the United States. They do little to actually protect workers but create an environment that creates a bad working environment and possible job cuts.
A while ago, I use to work as an outside consultant. I would often have customers of Union shops. These customers, often had the most worn out employees, as their jobs were always hanging in by a thread. I have been brought in because the IT Staff had been fired from the place, the Union did this because IT workers were more
Re: (Score:3)
Companies, charitable organizations, religions, bureaucracies, unions, or anything else ultimately function in that manner unless very specifically designed to prevent it, and like any unchecked
They're on the right track here .... (Score:3)
Having done a bit of this kind of gig work for Postmates before? It's really not worth your time and effort for what you're paid when you have to handle the entire shopping process.
It's one thing to incur your time and expense to drive to the location, pick up the order, and then drive it to the customer. But you burn a lot of time walking the aisles to locate everything on a customer's list. And typically, at least one thing they request is out of stock. So then you're stuck contacting the customer directly to explain the situation, assess and offer suitable alternatives, and make those changes as requested.
If they just eliminated that whole mess and let store employees put the orders together for pickup, the job would make more economic sense to do.
This is probably a response to CA Prop 22 passing (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:3)
Considering how much of a margin it passed by (58% for, 42% against), I suspect it had a lot more to do with Californians who like their cheap taxi and delivery services and don't want to see the prices get jacked up.
A lot of Californians who were "independent contractors" were afraid of losing their job^H^H^H gig work because Uber, Lyft, and others threatened to exit the California market [salon.com] if they didn't get their way.
With the ongoing coronavirus pandemic and millions of people out of work, many turned to gig work for income, and many of these people also voted in favor of Prop. 22
Meanwhile, the companies that backed Prop 22 are now raising fees to cover the benefits they said they'd give to their independent contractor
Re: This is probably a response to CA Prop 22 pass (Score:2)
What did they even do??? (Score:3)
I'd already have been shocked that they had 1900 employees *TOTAL*. If the layoffs are not drivers, how the hell does Instacart have that many employees *TO* lay off?
I mean... it's not a bad app or anything. But it's not a particularly innovative one either. It's a combination of location services, a cart, shopping lists, billing, and dispatch. Those are all solved problems, most of which can be bought as a service or even as off-the-shelf code to be customized and used to your preferences. The biggest problem is operating at scale. But with a good DevOps/SRE team, putting together AWS infra that can handle millions of daily users is fairly straightforward these days.
I'd wager that, with the right people, it could be developed, maintained, and operated with 190. What the hell do the rest of their people even do, that they had ten times that number just to lay off?!?!?
Strike breaking (Score:2)
", including those of 10 workers in Illinois who last year became the first in the country to vote to unionize at the company."
Yes, bringing in goons to crack heads open is so 20th century. Now if they so much as think of unionizing, they are simply fired on the spot.
Re: Strike breaking (Score:2)
^more like passwords no longer work, and electronic keycards suddenly go invalid. The termination notice is in the e-mail.
Gone jobs or moved jobs? (Score:3)
It sounds like Instacart has simply reached the point where they have the bargaining power to get the stores to do some of the work they had to hire people for- meaning the stores need to hire people to do it.
Re: (Score:2)
Bingo.
Dealing with humans (even if they are "only" contractors) is a major pain. Grocery stores already have a structure setup to deal with humans. Much better for Instacart to focus on the technology end, which both saves the stores from having to do it and gives the customer a uniform experience across stores.
How ? (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:1)
we need to end employer-provided healthcare now! (Score:2)
we need to end employer-provided healthcare now!