Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Data Storage Google

Can You Recycle a Hard Drive? Google is Quietly Trying To Find Out (grist.org) 47

Rare earth magnet recycling is about so much more than sustainable data centers. From a report: The U.S. alone generates nearly 17 percent of all used hard disk drives -- the largest share globally -- and researchers have estimated that if all of these data storage devices were recycled, they could supply more than 5 percent of all rare earth magnet demand outside of China, potentially helping meet the demand of the information technology sector as well as clean energy companies. A consortium of U.S. researchers, tech companies, hardware manufacturers, and electronic waste recyclers has recently begun exploring exactly how those rare earths can be re-harvested and given a second life.

In 2019, these stakeholders published a report identifying a host of potential strategies, including wiping and re-using entire hard disk drives, removing and reusing the magnet assemblies, grinding up old hard drive magnets and using the powder to manufacture new ones, and extracting purified rare earth elements from shredded drives. Each of these strategies has its own challenges -- removing magnet assemblies by hand is labor intensive; extracting rare earths from technology can be chemical or energy intensive and produce significant waste -- and for any of them to be scaled up, there needs to be buy-in from numerous actors across global supply chains.

Making even the relatively minor supply chain adjustments needed to place used or recycled rare earth magnets inside new drives "is difficult," said Hongyue Jin, a scientist at the University of Arizona who studies rare earth recycling. "And especially when you've got to start from some small amount with a new technology." Still, some companies have begun taking the first steps. In 2018, Google, hard disk drive manufacturer Seagate, and electronics refurbisher Recontext (formerly Teleplan) conducted a small demonstration project that involved removing the magnet assemblies from six hard disk drives and placing them in new Seagate drives. This demonstration, said Kali Frost, a doctoral student in industrial sustainability at Purdue University, was the "catalyst" for the larger 2019 study in which 6,100 magnet assemblies were extracted from Seagate hard drives in a Google data center before being inserted into new hard drives in a Seagate manufacturing facility. Frost, who led the 2019 study, believes it is the largest demonstration of its kind ever done.

The results, which will be published in a forthcoming edition of the journal Resources, Conservation, and Recycling, not only showed that rare earth magnets could be harvested and reused at larger scale, but that there were significant environmental benefits to doing so: Overall, re-used magnet assemblies had a carbon footprint 86 percent lower than new ones, according to the study. Frost says that this estimate conservatively took into account the energy mix of the local power grid where the data center operated. Considering Google's near round-the-clock renewable energy usage at this particular data center, the carbon footprint of the reused magnets was even lower.

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Can You Recycle a Hard Drive? Google is Quietly Trying To Find Out

Comments Filter:
  • yes, if you pay (Score:2, Insightful)

    by sdinfoserv ( 1793266 )
    You can recycle anything. It's just more expensive then pulling the element out of the dirt. Since it costs less to just throw it away, and since the US is a Capitalist based society, our pocketbooks dictate we just toss it.
    • Re:yes, if you pay (Score:5, Interesting)

      by mrclevesque ( 1413593 ) on Friday August 06, 2021 @04:35PM (#61665155)

      "It's just more expensive then pulling the element out of the dirt. Since it costs less to just throw it away"

      I'm guessing this is the case if a lot of the environmental costs are not accounted for, or wages are keep unreasonably low through market segmentation (open movement of wealth, and closed movement of labor, across borders).

      "since the US is a Capitalist based society, our pocketbooks dictate we just toss it"

      Capitalist, in the sense that those with more capital have more power to control the market and what gets commoditized and what does not?

      • by rtb61 ( 674572 )

        See that is the rub, it requires economies of scale to recycle properly. All the waste, you consider dirt, not pieces to be recycled, just dirt to be mined and you treat it as such. Grind all that shite up to a fine power and feed it to a process line, where it goes through a series of refinement processes to extract desired molecules and break down undesired molecules into more desired molecules. Nothing left over but fertiliser, safe fertiliser, even heavy metals have worth, but it requires economy of sca

    • by tlhIngan ( 30335 )

      Except I don't think hard drives are something that are uneconomical to recycle. The cases are typically steel which is remarkably recyclable, so much so that scrap steel is recycled as well as it has value.

      The platters are typically aluminum coated with some form of iron oxide. The magnets contain rare earths so they're extremely valuable.

      The problem isn't recycling hard drives, it's the data contained on the drives. Destroying that data usually degrades the value of the recycling - if you shoot it up, the

      • by Anonymous Coward

        What kind of mish-mash of 40 year old obsolete information and urban legends is this?

        Who let Granddaddy use the AOL again?

        The cases are typically steel

        Um, no?

        The platters are typically aluminum coated with some form of iron oxide.

        Uh, no? Not since the early 1990s?

        The magnets contain rare earths so they're extremely valuable.

        Uh, no? They're called "rare", but they aren't that rare. The platinum in catalytic converters is far more valuable, yet platinum isn't a rare Earth.

        Destroying that data usually degrades the value of the recycling - if you shoot it up, the lead gets everywhere

        What kind of psycho redneck nonsense is this? You think people drag their steel hard disks out behind the iron-oxide-red barn to shoot the drive like Old Yeller?

        You can't be for real. As a comedian, g

    • by stikves ( 127823 )

      Not only our pocketbooks, but also convenience.

      Here, in my city, we cannot use the city services for recycling 90% of otherwise perfectly recyclable content. No packing foam (okay, they make a mess), no plastic toys, no glass (except containers), no metals (except cans), no electronics, and definitely no plastics bags. And it does not matter whether these have the "recycle" symbols on them (most of them do), they will just not pick those up.

      So, you have an old server? They will not pick it up. You'll have t

    • You can recycle anything. It's just more expensive then pulling the element out of the dirt. Since it costs less to just throw it away, and since the US is a Capitalist based society, our pocketbooks dictate we just toss it.

      Throwing stuff away costs less than recycling, when someone else pays for cleaning up the waste. One of the problems of capitalism is that cost/benefit optimisation tends to be localised to individual corporations, whereas many actual costs and benefits have society-wide scale. For example, we know that plastic waste is a severe environmental problem, that could be very costly to fix, but the plastic producers and users do not incur these costs. Because of that, it currently does not pay to recycle plastic

      • The problem is when government influence becomes a commodity.

        At that point you get to hijack the economic process itself and it becomes politics.

        It's like winning a boxing match by taking the referee hostage.

        • The problem is when government influence becomes a commodity.

          That is indeed a problem where politicians are just guns for hire to corporate sponsors, which seems to be a common model in the USA. Not all democracies are run like that, though. In some places, politicians gain their positions and retain them, because they act to represent the majority of voters. In the UK, there is a concern about sleaze in politics, where chums of politicians get favoured treatment in terms of lucrative government contracts, and certain corporations get favoured lobbying access to min

    • by Kisai ( 213879 )

      It's often not worth recycling "finished" products, because of the energy intensity required to break it down. Never mind the labor.

      We should be aiming to reuse first. And with magnets that's probably a bad idea since magnets lose their magnetism from being handled poorly, and the smaller ones break pretty easily (like those in 2.5" and 3.5" drives.)

      Still, recovering the materials used to make them is probably pretty straight forward, remove the head assembly, place it in a vice, twist, and you either break

  • by cecil36 ( 104730 ) on Friday August 06, 2021 @03:59PM (#61665047) Homepage

    I frequently scrap hard drives for metal recovery. The controller boards have a lot of precious metal on them, so I sell them to a company called Boardsort (http://www.boardsort.com). The rest of the drive is mostly aluminum, so that ends up going to the scrap yard. The outer shell is cast aluminum. The platters are either aluminum or glass with the chrome plating with trace amounts of precious metals. The read/write head has a copper or copper plated winding on it, so I toss it with my electric motors along with the drive spindle. The magnets inside I may keep or give to someone who I know collects them.

    • by Anonymous Coward

      Sounds like bullshit, the amount of material is so small for a modern drive, and older drives are worth far more selling to vintage enthusiasts on eBay.

      How much "lot of precious metals" can you find on a PCB about 4 inches square? Bullshit.

      How much copper can you find on a magnetoresistive head with a write winding that may contain micrograms of copper?

      Complete nonsense, Cecil.

      • by Mspangler ( 770054 ) on Friday August 06, 2021 @07:47PM (#61665695)

        I used to work at a gold mine with a heap leach. Anything over 0.04 Troy oz/ton was profitable. At the time gold was going for $400 an ounce. It doesn't take much.

        The rare earth magnets can be dissolved in acid, then the elements separated by solvent extraction. The problem is one of scale, do you have a hundred tons a day to feed a recycling plant? I suspect not. Those economics are more dubious.

        • I used to work at a gold mine with a heap leach. Anything over 0.04 Troy oz/ton was profitable.

          I recall reading about a massive pollution incident when cyanide was used to leach gold from mine tailings in Romania. The lagoon wall broke, and the cyanide sludge went into the nearest river, which ended up in the Danube, killing all the fish, and a lot of other wildlife. Luckily, cyanide is not a cumulative poison, so the rivers recovered fairly quickly.

          I am not sure of the chemistry needed to extract rare earth metals from waste, compared to the chemistry needed to extract from ores. As I understand it,

  • When I get a new computer first thing I do is make a folder "old machine", then copy the entire old computer's hard drive to it. Then if I'm going to toss the computer remove the hard drive and stick it in a closet. When I give a shit I delete the Windows OS stuff from the saved stuff,, but with disk capacities being what they are I usually don't bother. I've got stuff from the 90's several layers deep in "old machine", that I never look at and don't care.

    I reckon some day I'll remove every screw I ca
    • Wowsers, I can't even begin to imagine all the porn you've collected over the years.
    • "badblocks" in Linux does a nice multiple pass write / read that is very easy for the CPU to do while it does things I want in the foreground. I do this after the first couple of the backups of the, as you put it, "old drive" directory tree. I was hoping to find a good link in this discussion, since I have 30+ plus drives: 44-pin and 40-pin IDE, SCSI of various flavors, and SATA of various performance specs.

  • by Joe_Dragon ( 2206452 ) on Friday August 06, 2021 @04:06PM (#61665075)

    SSD's don't have the magnets that HDD's have.

  • ...thinking about the choice of the word 'quietly'

    is this only because they didn't put out a press release? or maybe they're trying to pull a fast one and wanna keep it on dl

    remove the word on of its two occurences and does the meaning/info change?

    and yes, I am trying to look busy right now

    • ...thinking about the choice of the word 'quietly'

      is this only because they didn't put out a press release? or maybe they're trying to pull a fast one and wanna keep it on dl

      remove the word on of its two occurences and does the meaning/info change?

      and yes, I am trying to look busy right now

      It's just lazy headline writing.

  • Perhaps a better idea would be to throw that funding into finding better ways of manufacturing solid state drives that may be much easier to recycle at end of life. I have not purchased a mechanical hard drive in over 5 years now for personal systems of my own and friends. I understand mechanical is still much more economical for data centers, but solid state would be a much better option in the long run, in my opinion.
  • A hard drive at a google data center is going to cause X amount of fuel to burnt if it was recycled or not.
    It doesn't matter where it was taken from or where it goes to, there will be a hard drive there and it will be using power.

    A more important question is what's the MTBF of a recycled assembly as opposed to a new one.

    • A more important question is what's the MTBF of a recycled assembly as opposed to a new one.

      In that case, we are talking about refurbished rather than recycled drives. To me, recycling means rendering waste down to raw materials, which can be used to build new stuff. Machines can have a very long service life, if worn out parts are replaced. What I would be concerned about is that hard drives are not designed for such maintenance and refurbishment, so maybe it is not feasible. The same tends to apply to a great deal of electronic kit these days.

  • Collecting all IT waste and munching it up gives a mixture better than high grade metal ores
    which can then be processed by the same technologies used to extract metals from ores.

  • I take apart my dead hard drives. Doesn't take very long with power tools and a few torx bits. I have a large collection of rare earth magnets from those drives, and they are very useful for many things, even as refrigerator magnets. Just don't bring two of them together with bare hands.

Is knowledge knowable? If not, how do we know that?

Working...