BMW Starts Selling Heated Seat Subscriptions for $18 a Month (theverge.com) 374
BMW is now selling subscriptions for heated seats in a number of countries -- the latest example of the company's adoption of microtransactions for high-end car features. From a report: A monthly subscription to heat your BMW's front seats costs roughly $18, with options to subscribe for a year ($180), three years ($300), or pay for "unlimited" access for $415. It's not clear exactly when BMW started offering this feature as a subscription, or in which countries, but a number of outlets this week reported spotted its launch in South Korea. BMW has slowly been putting features behind subscriptions since 2020, and heated seats subs are now available in BMW's digital stores in countries including the UK, Germany, New Zealand, and South Africa. It doesn't, however, seem to be an option in the US -- yet.
Screw you BMW (Score:5, Insightful)
I wasn't in the market for a BMW, and now I know to avoid them. If I buy the hardware of heated seats, I want to run them any damn time I want.
Re:Screw you BMW (Score:5, Insightful)
Yet another reason to never buy a BMW. This is such bullshit.
Re:Screw you BMW (Score:5, Interesting)
Yup. Came here to say the same thing. At this point the people I generally see driving BMWs are either some young person who thinks it's a status symbol, or a drug dealer with their tinted windows.
I do remember BMWs back in the day when the 3 series was the shits (and the M3 of course), but like Mercedes, BMW has gone a path no one knows where. There isn't much to like about them any more since at this point everything is controlled by software. The amount of driver interaction is now limited to turning the wheel. Big fucking deal.
Remember when BMW used to claim they were the ultimate driving machine [youtube.com]? Pepperidge Farm remembers. Even their top end cars had manual transmissions so the driver could enjoy the drive and have complete control over their vehicle. Not any longer. Now everything is dictated in typical Germanic fashion. "You vill do vhat ve tell you. And you vill like it!"
Re: (Score:2)
To be fair, even formula 1 cars use paddle shifters, nowadays
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3, Funny)
Re: (Score:3)
You should switch out the fuel injection so you can have the fun of managing the choke and fuel mixture too! And get rid of the starter. There's nothing more thrilling than the chance of being maimed whenever you start your car!
Don't forget the manual ignition timing adjustment on the steering wheel.
Re: (Score:3)
Adjustment? Smells like an automatic system to me. Clearly you should have a set of buttons to trigger the spark on each cylinder yourself. Now that's control!
Re:Screw you BMW (Score:5, Interesting)
No, these days, you're not really buying the manual transmission (stick) for ultimate performance.
You're buying it for the visceral experience.
I've never owned a car that wasn't a 2-seater, stick shift manual transmission car in my life.
Ok, "technically" the '86 911 Turbo (930) was a 4 seater, but you couldn't fit more than a bag of groceries back there, so I don't count them as real seats.
I don't want a family car, a sedan...I want to own and drive cars that are fun, sporty and look interesting.
And, if you're driving and shifting, you are likely NOT staring at your phone while driving and trying to text....you have to pay attention to what you're doing.
As a side benefit, you're LESS likely to get carjacked as that those fucking idiot thieves generally don't know how to drive a manual transmission.
Paddle shifters just aren't the same...I've tried and the experience isn't there.
I find it extremely difficult to up or down shift with paddle shifters while also turning the steering wheel...you're hands just get caught up in all that mess...
I'm guessing my first non-manual transmission car will be an EV.
I just hope by then, they have a "reasonably" priced 2-seater offering, in the price range of a Vette maybe....
Re: (Score:2)
BMW is still making some vehicles with a stick. Last I looked they even had at least one model that was only available with a stick in the USA. Although ISTR hearing that there was enough outcry in Europe that they brought it back there, too. Last year BMW still had four models offered with a manual transmission. I believe this is more than any other manufacturer.
If you want a car that just does what you tell it, then it doesn't matter what brand you want, you still have to go back to the nineties or beyond
Re:Screw you BMW (Score:4, Informative)
The problem with a manual transmission is well, you only get 5 or 6 gears, and reverse. That's not efficient for an ICE vehicle - but it's impractical to have the 8-10 gears a modern automatic or autostick can provide - there's just too much H pattern to go through.
Even semi-trucks have automatic transmissions and they're a very popular option. And these had often 10 to 18 gears, but required special training to operate - and despite this, there are 3 or 4 different transmissions with different ways to shift, and learning one doesn't help you with the other transmissions. You often have to specify the transmission when you buy a new tractor because of this.
And because automatics have so many more gear ratios, they're even beating manuals in fuel economy - the lack of ratios in a manual means the engine is operating outside of the optimum efficiency regime more often.
Re: (Score:2)
"You vill do vhat ve tell you. And you vill like it!"
Sounds a lot like Python.
Re: (Score:2)
Imagine no possessions
I wonder if you can
Only corporate greed and penury
Man preying on man
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
"You vill do vhat ve tell you. And you vill like it!"
Any similarity between this attitude and and the systemd team is purely coincidental...
Re: (Score:2)
Stop with the stupid as fuck âoePepperidge Farm remembersâ crap. Its not clever or cute, its just lame
It was cleverer before Pepperidge Farms went to absolute shit. They cheaped the fuck out and now they're made with palm oil, the absolute crappiest oil possible. The mouth feel of their cookies is now best described as "cheap", which is unfortunate because the price is not. They're literally not worth eating.
Re:Screw you BMW (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Screw you BMW (Score:4, Funny)
Re: Screw you BMW (Score:3)
Capitalism means having the option to buy a car from another manufacturer. Socialism is having whatever you are allocated. Perhaps even heated seats if you report a relative for expressing counter revolutionary views.
Re:Screw you BMW (Score:5, Informative)
Yet another reason to never buy a BMW. This is such bullshit.
How is it bullshit? They are giving you the option of buying a feature at a reduced cost. Go to any car manufacturer and see if you can add heated seats as an optional extra for under $415.
You're literally getting angry because they are offering something in a limited fashion for less money while still giving you exactly the same option you had prior to buy it outright.
Ah. but you're missing the implication here. They didn't say you could buy it. They said you could get an "unlimited" license. That almost certainly means that when you trade in your car after three years, they will expect the new owner to spend $415 again.
Besides, if they're charging a fee for it, that means the hardware ships as part of the car, which means you're paying for the cost of the hardware in the purchase price of the car already. You're just not getting to use it.
Re: (Score:3)
No - if the hardware is there you've payed for it already. They're just requiring you to pay a monthly fee to enable a piece of hardware that is already sitting in the fucking car.
Re:Screw you BMW (Score:5, Interesting)
I wonder how much DRM is built in so people can't hotwire them.
("hotwire" - geddit?)
Re: (Score:3)
It won't be a relay, it'll be a CANBUS module with solid state control, and knowing BMW the car won't start unless it's plugged in, working properly, and registered to the ECU.
People regularly flash their ECUs anyway.
https://bmwtuning.co/ecu-flash... [bmwtuning.co]
Re: (Score:2)
You can buy heated seats in your new BMW, they're $415. If that's too expensive you can pay for a subscription and let the sucker that buys a used BMW deal with it down the road. If you like neither option you can not have heated seats or not have a BMW.
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Screw you BMW (Score:5, Insightful)
So are they setting the map for subscription everything for those who can't afford the full upfront price? This sounds like the rent to own furniture/appliance model that just takes advantage of low income people who end up paying 2 or 3 times what the item actually cost in the beginning. Can't afford the heated seats? We have an option for you! Just $18/month we'll help you drain your savings so you can keep a car you can't really afford with options you can't afford, but you can keep your butt warm. I wonder if their marketing will have a cheesy used car sales guy in a cheap suit selling these subscriptions.
Re: (Score:3)
Easy to see you know nothing about the realities of manufacturing. A heating element costs what, maybe $50. The costs saved by making all the cars the same can easily exceed that.
Re: (Score:2)
I have to guess if you buy one of the subscriptions models...but don't activate the subscription, that it would be fairly trivial to find the wires/switch that turn them on/off, and disconnect from the computer and reroute to a connection to a manual switch
Re: (Score:3)
Germans, man.
Re: (Score:2)
Guess you won't be buying a Tesla, either
Re: (Score:2)
Tesla extra buy features? (Score:2)
What feature of Tesla is quite as bad as this?
I know of two "add-ons" that only activate parts of the car if you buy them:
1. Unmetered access to the supercharger network - understandable, Tesla does have to buy them and pay for the power.
2. Autopilot - which is an incredibly complex and constantly updated software package, so it's like buying, say, licenses for Oracle after you buy a server to run it.
This isn't like heated seats at all, which shouldn't have any "active" development for the heating you're
Re:Tesla extra buy features? (Score:5, Funny)
A bit of searching says that you can play a $10/moth fee
I found a bug in your post, just FYI
Re: (Score:3)
Thing with Tesla's including larger batteries is that Tesla offered pre-sales where they ANTICIPATED more demand for the shorter ranged batteries than they got, to the point that building all long range batteries was more cost effective than having two production lines and inventory streams and such.
IE the customer had agreed to buy the smaller battery BEFORE the car was produced. So they software limited them, much like what Intel has done on occasion - too many chips binning higher, artificially cripple
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Like Mercedesâ(TM) has always had a subscription. Yes, it does unlock, literally in some cases, features that are in the car. But you also get always on connectivity. And you lose little if you donâ(TM)t pay for it.
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:3)
Re: Screw you BMW (Score:3)
To be fair, we do this in software all the time. It is far cheaper and more efficient to have a single deliverable, one that the user installs exactly once, with the feature set controlled by a software key. It also makes the upgrade process painless for all concerned.
Apparently, it is the same even when hardware is involved. Sure, you get people annoyed that some of their hardware is currently disabled. OTOH, they can upgrade their car instantly, without taking it to a dealership for extensive gutting.
Good news! (Score:2)
The lube is free*. Every BMW comes with a 5 gallon bucket of lube so you can take it easier.
*Free only until 2024. Additional lube will require a $10/month subscription.
Re: (Score:2)
Theft (Score:5, Insightful)
While I can understand that you need to pay a subscription to get 4G connectivity for the car, this one is clearly theft. But BMW is not the only one doing this, Tesla paved the way for this kind of theft.
Re: Theft (Score:2)
Interesting, which Tesla features are paywalled?
And don't say self driving because what you're actually paying for is a one time cost that guarantees future updates, including hardware updates as needed at no cost, which IIRC they've done twice now. Furthermore there's no monthly fee for it.
Re: (Score:3)
Battery capacity. Tesla puts the same battery packs in their cars regardless of which model you buy. The "capacity" is enforced through software. This is why they dropped the P100 and P75 branding... since they both have the same battery. I remember a few years ago during a hurricane in the US southeast, Tesla temporarily turned on the 100kwh capacity for all vehicles to help people get out of harms way.
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
A simple example would be to enable the full use of the batteries that are already installed in the car. And, like autopilot which would be deactivated if you sell the car. It's indeed not exactly the same, but you bought the car with the batteries, so why would you need to pay more to use them at 100% and worse, why would it be deactivated when the car is sold, which means you lose the prime you paid because the new owner won't pay for something he can't use. But it's stated that with BMW, you can also pay
Re: (Score:2)
Interesting, which Tesla features are paywalled?
And don't say self driving because what you're actually paying for is a one time cost that guarantees future updates, including hardware updates as needed at no cost, which IIRC they've done twice now. Furthermore there's no monthly fee for it.
For example, heated seats and steering wheel 'upgrades' for your Tesla: https://www.tesla.com/support/... [tesla.com] ... apparently: "Over-the-air upgrades are an essential part of the Tesla ownership experience and enable your car to improve with the touch of a button" (ugh, that's a level of marketing schmalz that would make a used car salesman gag). It's kind of like buying a phone and having to purchase an Over-the-air upgrade to be able to receive phone calls. Yet another 'innovative business model' you'd have t
Re: (Score:2)
Huh (Score:5, Funny)
Ubik (Score:5, Interesting)
Reminds me of the novel "Ubik" where the protagonist pays a subscription for the door to his apartment and has to scrounge spare change off people so he can get in/out. It's probably not far away now.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... [wikipedia.org]
Quite a visionary idea for 1969...
(I definitely recommend the book...)
Re: (Score:2)
Reminds me of the novel "Ubik" where the protagonist pays a subscription for the door to his apartment and has to scrounge spare change off people so he can get in/out. It's probably not far away now.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... [wikipedia.org]
Quite a visionary idea for 1969...
(I definitely recommend the book...)
I went to a bathroom at a Swiss gas station some years ago. You had to pay for the soap, the paper towels and the water you also had to pay to get into the toilet booth. I was amazed that they missed a chance to make you pay for lifting the lid on the toilet seat, charge you by the weight your turd and the volume of your piss and then made you pay again to get out of the damn booth. I don't mind paying for a clean bathroom but that was ridiculous. In Germany they just charged you whatever it cost to keep th
Charge for the electricity (Score:2)
You have to pay for the power that drives the device, so you should be able to charge BMW for providing electricity to their unit.
Free market (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
It's certainly doable, of course. It will realistically cost you more than $18 because you have to be able to do current control to get different heat settings. Odds are good that you will have to dig pretty deep into the interior to implement it as well, although it's possible everything you need is inside of the seat.
Re: (Score:2)
It's certainly doable, of course. It will realistically cost you more than $18 because you have to be able to do current control to get different heat settings. Odds are good that you will have to dig pretty deep into the interior to implement it as well, although it's possible everything you need is inside of the seat.
It may be doable with some wire, terminals, a switch, and a pot, which would quite cheap. Or you may want a PWM type controller which would be a bit more expensive, but the key is that it costs you whatever that is once per seat, probably for the life of the vehicle. Rather than paying monthly.
Re: (Score:2)
And probably less than $415 for the permanent upgrade as well.
Re: (Score:2)
Should be better alternatives than BMW (Score:2)
I'm sure most of the people that buy them won't care, BMW is pricey. Still there will be many that will avoid a purchase to avoid subscriptions. I could see charging for services that actually matter, like a communications, but charging for services that were previously free is a good way to piss people off and reduce sales.
But you have options, you could just add the heated seats for the full 415, which would pay for ~8 years of heated seats, so I bet most people opt for that.
Re: (Score:3)
Yeah I don't get it, just increase the cost of heated seats by $415. I guess they have their business metrics but is there really a buyer out there who is in the budget and market for a brand new BMW but would like to scrimp $415 by activating his heated seats only during the winter (the only selling point I can see to this?) Does that buyer exist?
I suppose the cynical view is this is just a simple test case to move more and more features to this model, to the very car itself.
Re:Should be better alternatives than BMW (Score:5, Interesting)
There may not be (many) people who would only activate them part of the time, but there are probably plenty of people who don't want them (and don't want to pay for them) at all, and plenty of people who do want them and will pay for them. This lets BMW build them all the same, which lowers costs for both groups. Manufacturing efficiencies are something that a lot of people on here can not understand.
Re: (Score:2)
Yeah, but normally when that happens it just becomes a "Standard feature" and is built into the price of the car, used as a selling point to go "see, our base model is better than their base model".
Same deal with eventually including radios in cars, then FM radios, CD Players, MP3, bluetooth, android/apple auto apps, etc....
Re: (Score:3)
You can do that, then your competitor can come along and say 'or you can buy our car for $x less, and not pay for things you don't want, like seat heaters in Florida'.
The reason the things you mentioned became 'standard' wasn't for bragging rights, it was because it became too expensive to offer options (too many possibilities). For instance, when I bought my first used car in the 70s, it came with the original sticker. The 'base model' had a 'standard' (manual) transmission, and an AM radio. The origina
Re:Should be better alternatives than BMW (Score:5, Insightful)
Nope, sorry. If they're including a hardware device in the car I Just bought, I reserve the right to use it as I see fit. If they want to charge for it, that's fine, but they only get to do that at hardware-purchase time. This whole "oh well that's a SOFTWARE feature, that's different" mentality is toxic.
Subscriptions are fine for things that need ongoing effort. Onboard data connectivity, or map updates, controls that have to go through an outside server, or the like. Not "the privilege of sending power to a resistive heating loop that's already built into the seat cushion".
And no, I don't agree with Tesla selling partial software-locked battery capacity either. Install the full battery, I expect to be able to use the full battery (minus whatever part is known by all parties up front to be reserved for wear leveling). If they want to sell a partial sized battery, then install a smaller one - maybe I wanted the weight reduction of carrying around fewer cells for some reason.
Re: (Score:2)
Sure I get the efficiency of building one seat for a model line but that doesn't explain the subscription model.
If you put heated seats in every car and just sell the activation at the time of purchase nothing really changes from how they sell it now. It's still just a feature you buy while purchasing the car.
I'm just still curious of the person buying a $40k+ vehicle and choosing to pay $18 a month versus just buying the heated seats feature for $415. I could be off base and there are plenty of BMW buyer
Re: (Score:2)
I have a car with heated seats, and i can already activate them during the winter - it has a switch for just that purpose.
I could have bought the car without heated seats, it would have been cheaper and very slightly lighter as a result.
The idea that you can pay extra to get some extra hardware to implement additional functionality is fine, you can make that choice.
The idea that you've already paid for the hardware, but don't get to use it without paying again is insulting.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
#DashboardBurritos
Just wait ... (Score:2)
Soon, they'll require a subscription just to be able to get these other subscriptions ...
Re: (Score:2)
Soon, they'll require a subscription just to be able to get these other subscriptions ...
You mean like connectivity in the car? I'll bet you that you already need to pay for that.
Subscribe for what needs maintence. (Score:5, Insightful)
Heated Seats, are already built into the Car, a subscription is a stupid model for this, because say unlike Tesla Subscriptions to Unlimited Cell Service, or even for a software controlled feature (Like the Auto Pilot or FSD, that is constantly being updated. (And I am not trying excuse Tesla, as I think for the Price of their cars these should be included) Heated seats as a monthly or annual fee is just idiotic.
I can get the idea that you may have to pay a one time fee of say $1000 to enable heated seats on your car, but a monthly fee is kinda stupid.
We really need to start Voting for Right to Repair laws, in which we can have access to the products we buy.
A lot of our wealth is from the physical stuff that we own. Renting/Leasing your car (with no buy back options), subscription for premium features, Tying a product or device to an account.... Vastly diminishes our actual wealth, at the trade off of spending less money.
If you remembered Garage sales of the 1980's vs Garage sales of today. You use to be able to buy records, tapes, of music they may no longer listen to. Books that no longer want to read, VHS Videos of shows the kids outgrew. Today it is mostly outdated clothing, and if you are lucky some power tools.
Re:Subscribe for what needs maintence. (Score:5, Insightful)
Presumably they have done the math, and it's cheaper to not have to stock different options, have different wiring harnesses etc., because enough people will pay for this. At a guess, they probably have it worked out so that every single subscription is gravy — the cost of putting the feature in all vehicles is almost certainly covered by the number of people they anticipate will pay for it outright.
Re: (Score:2)
If it costs them more to maintain it during the warranty period when used at the higher performance level, then that's reasonable. Otherwise, they can screw off, too.
Re: (Score:2)
Right, or even the lifetime unlock fee, especially if they are buying the car from a dealer who will certainly try to upsell them on it. This is a way of securing additional future revenues for dealers, who are puckering at the concept of selling EVs. BMWs in particular have traditionally produced extremely high service revenues in the engine bay, but it's generally true of all German vehicles. It's pathetically common for them to require multi-thousand-dollar engine or transmission services to stay on the
Re: (Score:2)
This is the trend. When you "buy" something, companies are increasingly trying to maintain control of the hardware through software.
Started with music, then videos, books... and on to hardware... computers (Microsoft and Apple were pioneers here) and now everything that has software and connectivity (which is just about everything these days) prohibits you from access to repair or upgrade or even just use "features" without paying the man.
Good argument for FOSS in everything but we are a long way from that.
Re: (Score:2)
Wait until they find out how cheap it is to just jumper a hardware switch directly to the heater itself! They'll be prepared to sue under the DMCA. They might even put the DRM inside the same chip as the thermostat to force the issue.
Re: (Score:3)
This isn't an issue with capitalism directly. However a case where there is a drastic drop in consumer protection, and lack of acceptable alternatives.
Capitalism: if you don't like it. Don't buy it, go to someone else.
The problem is that world governments, both Liberal and Conservative have been making sure that Companies have increasing freedoms to do what they want, while the consumers get more restrictions, and tougher enforcement for those who break the laws.
The inequality is due to how most elections
Turn signals still optional? (Score:2)
When will they add a subscription for enabling turn signals on BMWs? Or is that not available due to hardware limitations?
Re: (Score:2)
and as an plus they can lock out non dealer repair (Score:2)
and as an plus they can lock out non dealer repair on any thing in the car and use the DMCA to shutdown 3rd party
parts sales
repair guilds
repair tools
repair software
etc.
Automatic Humor Here (Score:2)
As reprehensible as this is, it does at least bring some dark humor into play...
Now you can LITERALLY hotwire your own seat to steal heat!
Yet another reason... (Score:2)
Yet another reason NOT to buy a BMW.
Spending money stupidly is the point (Score:2)
You can't blame BMW for fleecing high-end consumers who are buying a vehicle as a status symbol - it's their whole business model. With the luxury market, the entire point is that you pay a stupid amount of money for trivialities, so you can fit in with your friends that are doing the same thing. Being pointlessly expensive is a *feature* in this market. If you buy a BMW, you know what you're doing, you're paying too much for something to try to impress people, so don't be surprised when they continually in
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
External validation.
For some folks, it's all they have.
Way more to come but you can save on indicators (Score:2)
Microtransactions have been known to be a BMW plan for the past 2 years, since they anounced "going all-in on in-car microtransactions" in July 2020. On the plus side, owners can probably save on buying a subscription for indicators since BMW drivers usually don't them anyway.
Re: (Score:2)
[golf clap]
Including repair? (Score:2)
Not just heated seats (Score:5, Interesting)
I really hope this doesn't catch on. People need to raise hell over it. It's one thing to offer stuff that either requires data (wifi hotspot for instance) or requires on-going development costs (map updates, self driving). But a subscription for stuff already installed and you are basically flipping a bit to enable it in a control module? Fuck that.
Link for anyone interested: https://www.bmw.co.uk/en/shop/... [bmw.co.uk]
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
Went to the UK store and holy shit, they are nickle-and-diming you for a ton of features
This is standard practice for most luxury brands. Porsche is even worse - it's not a new thing.
what a (Score:2)
Simple work-around (Score:2)
Savings (Score:2)
Configuring an i430 on the BMW USA site shows that heated seats is a $500 option, so if an "unlimited" subscription is $450, then that's a discount.
A Piece Of The Action (Score:3)
Nice warm seats ya gots here.
Be a shame is something– happened to 'em.
No thanks (Score:3)
I owned a BMW x5 for 5 years, I was unlikely to buy another to be honest.
But now for SURE I won't. Fuck BMW.
I Predict That In The Future... (Score:4, Insightful)
Toyota is doing it too (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
I wouldn't count on one big auto corporation being much better than another. They already have you tied into giving them money for "routine maintenance"... you can expect them to invent more ways to get continuing revenue from something you thought you bought and owned.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Anticipated lifetime repairs is part of BMW's profit statement.