The Search For the Face Behind Mavis Beacon Teaches Typing (wired.com) 56
An anonymous reader quotes a report from Wired: Jazmin Jones knowswhat she did. "If you're online, there's this idea of trolling," Jones, the director behindSeeking Mavis Beacon, said during a recent panel for her new documentary. "For this project, some things we're taking incredibly seriously ... and other things we're trolling. We're trolling this idea of a detective because we're also, like,ACAB." Her trolling, though, was for a good reason. Jones and fellow filmmaker Olivia Mckayla Ross did it in hopes of finding the woman behind Mavis Beacon Teaches Typing. The popular teaching tool was released in 1987 by The Software Toolworks, a video game and software company based in California that produced educational chess, reading, and math games. Mavis, essentially the "mascot" of the game, is a Black woman donned in professional clothes and a slicked-back bun. Though Mavis Beacon was not an actual person, Jones and Ross say that she is one of the first examples of Black representation they witnessed in tech. Seeking Mavis Beacon, which opened in New York City on August 30 and is rolling out to other cities in September, is their attempt to uncover the story behind the face, which appeared on the tool's packaging and later as part of its interface.
The film shows the duo setting up a detective room, conversing over FaceTime, running up to people on the street, and even tracking down a relative connected to the ever-elusive Mavis. But the journey of their search turned up a different question they didn't initially expect: What are the impacts of sexism, racism, privacy, and exploitation in a world where you can present yourself any way you want to? Using shots from computer screens, deep dives through archival footage, and sit-down interviews, the noir-style documentary reveals that Mavis Beacon is actually Renee L'Esperance, a Black model from Haiti who was paid $500 for her likeness with no royalties, despite the program selling millions of copies. [...]
In a world where anyone can create images of folks of any race, gender, or sexual orientation without having to fully compensate the real people who inspired them, Jones and Ross are working to preserve not only the data behind Mavis Beacon but also the humanity behind the software. On the panel, hosted by Black Girls in Media, Ross stated that the film's social media has a form where users of Mavis Beacon can share what the game has meant to them, for archival purposes. "On some level, Olivia and I are trolling ideas of worlds that we never felt safe in or protected by," Jones said during the panel. "And in other ways, we are honoring this legacy of cyber feminism, historians, and care workers that we are very seriously indebted to." You can watch the trailer for "Seeking Mavis Beacon" on YouTube.
The film shows the duo setting up a detective room, conversing over FaceTime, running up to people on the street, and even tracking down a relative connected to the ever-elusive Mavis. But the journey of their search turned up a different question they didn't initially expect: What are the impacts of sexism, racism, privacy, and exploitation in a world where you can present yourself any way you want to? Using shots from computer screens, deep dives through archival footage, and sit-down interviews, the noir-style documentary reveals that Mavis Beacon is actually Renee L'Esperance, a Black model from Haiti who was paid $500 for her likeness with no royalties, despite the program selling millions of copies. [...]
In a world where anyone can create images of folks of any race, gender, or sexual orientation without having to fully compensate the real people who inspired them, Jones and Ross are working to preserve not only the data behind Mavis Beacon but also the humanity behind the software. On the panel, hosted by Black Girls in Media, Ross stated that the film's social media has a form where users of Mavis Beacon can share what the game has meant to them, for archival purposes. "On some level, Olivia and I are trolling ideas of worlds that we never felt safe in or protected by," Jones said during the panel. "And in other ways, we are honoring this legacy of cyber feminism, historians, and care workers that we are very seriously indebted to." You can watch the trailer for "Seeking Mavis Beacon" on YouTube.
Interesting documentary premise .... (Score:5, Insightful)
But honestly, I find it difficult to be too indignant about them using a likeness of some Haitian woman for the sake of only having to pay her $500 compensation.
I mean, when that software package was first released, do you really think anyone involved had much certainty it would be a big financial success? That was written back when a lot of software was developed by a single individual or a team of a couple of people. It wasn't the world of Triple A game releases made by big studios like we have today.
How much was it really worth to them to invest in a face to be the "mascot" for the program? If someone demanded much more compensation than what they paid, I'm sure they would have just elected to use an animated character that didn't exist as a physical person at all. It wouldn't have really changed anything as far as the program's success.
Re: Interesting documentary premise .... (Score:5, Interesting)
Re: (Score:3)
Re: Interesting documentary premise .... (Score:2)
You think you can produce a new computer hardware company in your garage today? The early Apples were made of wood. The barrier to entering into the PC market are higher today than they've been since the 60s.
Re: (Score:2)
Current value. (Score:2)
Re: (Score:1)
"Wizard of Id's Wiztype" was the best anyhow. I don't remember anyone liking Mavis Beacon.
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Interesting documentary premise .... (Score:5, Insightful)
But honestly, I find it difficult to be too indignant about them using a likeness of some Haitian woman for the sake of only having to pay her $500 compensation.
I mean, when that software package was first released, do you really think anyone involved had much certainty it would be a big financial success? That was written back when a lot of software was developed by a single individual or a team of a couple of people. It wasn't the world of Triple A game releases made by big studios like we have today.
How much was it really worth to them to invest in a face to be the "mascot" for the program? If someone demanded much more compensation than what they paid, I'm sure they would have just elected to use an animated character that didn't exist as a physical person at all. It wouldn't have really changed anything as far as the program's success.
So now we are supposed to pay models in perpetuity because they were on the cover of a software?
Her being paid 500 dollars for one image is pretty standard. Turning it into "cyber feminism" is a stretch bordering on psychotic.
And it will definitely not have the effect the cyber feminists demand, that of if you are a model, you are critical to the project.
This is easily fixed by AI generated images, and the destruction of a market segment for people. then people like Renee L'Esperance won't get even 500 dollars. NO actual human images will be used. Good work.
Re: (Score:2)
Wired is so desperately biased. (Score:5, Insightful)
How many stories go like this where the software sells a couple of dozen copies then disappears off the face of the Earth, and the few hundred dollars the model gets is the best deal, and the developer is stuck with debt and loss? What's the ratio of failed business to success?
Someone took a risk on developing software, made it big, and somehow this is twisted into racism and sexism. I'm sick of it.
Agree - Re:Wired is so desperately biased. (Score:4, Insightful)
Only in Wired because of the demographics of the picture on the software box. And, consider that the entire article is one extended advertisement for a film and to promote the careers of the filmmakers.
Re: Wired is so desperately biased. (Score:1)
And wrong too. First depiction of a black person in tech?
Nintendo Punch-Out 1984?
Heavyweight Champ 1976?
You want black female:
Outrun: 1986 has a black female at the lineup and I canâ(TM)t be bothered to look up old arcade cases, but I remember many games depicting both white and black people, especially race when you could pick a driver or most sports game.
I had this software (Score:3)
Re:I had this software (Score:4, Interesting)
Yup, a teacher at my high school said the same thing (I hadn't seen your comment before thinking this). I was in CS in the computer lab right after the typing class (in my Freshman year they had a typewriter room).
Although maybe we'll get Mandela Effect'ed on this one.
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
I don't care (Score:1)
Re: (Score:3)
It's as good a reason as any. Why does anyone get royalties at all?
Re: I don't care (Score:2)
Actors play an integral role in the success of the product. Their performance will be played again and again in subsequent viewings of the film/show.
The model who posted for a headshot for a box had nothing to do with the functionality of the software inside.
Re: (Score:1)
Actors play an integral role in the success of the product. [...] The model who posted for a headshot for a box had nothing to do with the functionality of the software inside.
The woman whose face was on the box helped sell the product. As such, she deserves some of the rewards. You might well say yes, and she got her five hundred bucks. But is that really fair compensation for helping sell many copies of something? Why shouldn't everyone whose likeness is used so prominently get points, or at least an inflation-adjusted per-use fee? This isn't just one of a bunch of people in a manual or something, this is the face of the product.
Re: (Score:2)
Ah. So in your opinion, the Gerber baby's family should still be raking it in?
Re: (Score:2)
Ah. So in your opinion, the Gerber baby's family should still be raking it in?
In short, yes.
If that baby isn't important they can take it off of their products.
Re: (Score:2)
I would agree if they were still getting money (no idea if that's the case or not) but were I the owners of Gerber I'd be ending that agreement and letting AI put some kind of vaguely similar (possibly mutated) image of a baby (or Winston Churchill) on my baby food jar.
Re: (Score:2)
but were I the owners of Gerber I'd be ending that agreement and letting AI put some kind of vaguely similar (possibly mutated) image of a baby (or Winston Churchill) on my baby food jar.
Same thing, innit?
But yes, that would be a legitimate workaround. You could trademark it, too.
Re: (Score:2)
Yes, it is. It's more than fair.
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
Because the programmers who spent days and weeks writing the code get - oh, wait, nevermind.
BuT tHe RoYaLtIeS (Score:2, Insightful)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: BuT tHe RoYaLtIeS (Score:2)
Is this not fraud? (Score:1)
Stating the obvious here (Score:2)
Re: Stating the obvious here (Score:2)
They've known who she was for years. Possibly since before that sort of thing was common. The story is they made a documentary.
Suggestion for next investigation (Score:2)
Wow...the Y2K for a face.... (Score:5, Informative)
Wow....the Y2K for a face...well here's the 1998 New York Times article that gives some more insight...
https://archive.is/SZWHd [archive.is]
Key paragraph...
''One day he walked into Saks Fifth Avenue in Beverly Hills to buy some cologne, and there behind the cosmetics counter was a beautiful black woman named Renee L'Esperance,'' said Mr. Bilofsky, reading from a file that was put together to celebrate the 15th anniversary of Software Toolworks. ''Born into a well-to-do Haitian family, she fled the Duvalier regime and wound up at Saks. She had never modeled, and her extremely long fingernails made her an unlikely typist, but when Les looked at her, he saw Mavis.''
Cue the music and theme song from "In Search Of..." (with Leonard Nimoy, logically) https://www.youtube.com/watch?... [youtube.com]
JoshK.
They needed a face conveying anyone could learn. (Score:1)
-reality sucks.
So ... (Score:3)
... if she were white (or Chinese, or ... ) it would have been just fine?
If not ... why?
Re: So ... (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
... if she were white (or Chinese, or ... ) it would have been just fine?
If not ... why?
There will always be fringers with axes to grind.
The concept that a person who is paid well for a few images is now entitled to perpetual renumeration for that is based on a couple aspects that some fringers have that everything is racist and sexist. And it is true that being "black" and being a birthing person will have some of the fringers looking hard for a reason that racism and sexism is involved.
What isn't as obvious at least for people looking for reasons to go goofy over what is a standard pra
Re: So ... (Score:2)
If it's AI generated then you can't have a copyright. So your competition might start using your mascot in ways you really don't like and there's nothing you can do about it.
ACAB? Ugh. (Score:2)
As soon as they mentioned ACAB in the very first quote, I knew exactly what the agenda of the film producers is. It is embarrassing that things have come to such a state of disunity and political polarization that one acronym basically tells you everything about a person's identity, and even gives some clues as to what they might look like.
"In a world where anyone can create images of folks of any race, gender, or sexual orientation without having to fully compensate the real people who inspired them"
This m
Re: ACAB? Ugh. (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
So it has nothing to do with the horrible Genesis song? Wait. Thats ABACAB. Sorry.
Thank you sir or madam, I will never get those 4 minutes of my life back after looking and listening to the 1981 performance on YouTube, though I do desperately desire that time returned to me.
Ugh.
Re: ACAB? Ugh. (Score:2)
WTF is ACAB?
Re: (Score:2)
she is hanging out with (Score:2)
Interesting spin (Score:2)
Interesting spin on the company asking themselves what a secretary should look like and deciding a black woman best represents the role of someone whose job it is to type a white man's words.
My thoughts (Score:2)
Hmm, that sounds interesting!
"
I'm out.