Become a fan of Slashdot on Facebook

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
The Almighty Buck United States

US Treasury Unveils Plan To Kill the Penny (cnn.com) 204

An anonymous reader writes: The US Treasury is phasing out production of the penny and will stop putting new one-cent coins into circulation. The US Treasury has made its final order of penny blanks this month, and the mint will continue to manufacture pennies as long as its supply of penny blanks exist.

President Donald Trump stated that production of pennies are wasteful, as the coins cost more to produce than their one-cent value.

US Treasury Unveils Plan To Kill the Penny

Comments Filter:
  • by alvinrod ( 889928 ) on Thursday May 22, 2025 @01:52PM (#65396291)
    Save us the trouble of repeating this entire drama in another few decades and kill off the Nickel alongside the Penny. It'll be far easier than to stop the government from overspending and stopping the value from being eroded through inflation, but even when I'm paying in cash at the sort of places or events (e.g. outdoor concerts) where it is cash only, no one is transacting in anything less than dollars. Anyone alive when five cents could actually buy something soon won't be.
    • can't do it (Score:5, Insightful)

      by jizmonkey ( 594430 ) on Thursday May 22, 2025 @02:17PM (#65396401)

      We have a non-truncatable currency system. An ideal coin system will have the following characteristics - that it is "countable" for any number, and that eliminating the smallest coin will always leave the remaining coin system countable. "Countable" means that that cashier's algorithm of pulling the largest coin less than the amount needed and then repeating with the next largest coin will produce the optimum number of coins. For example, with our current system, if you need to make 42 cents, you do a quarter (leaving 17 cents), then a dime, (leaving 7 cents), then a nickel and then two pennies. Our current system is only truncatable for the penny. If you only consider coin amounts which are multiples of 5 (since other ones become impossible after getting rid of the penny), our system minus the penny is clearly countable.

      The problem is, consider getting rid of the nickel. Now try to make 30 cents. You pull a quarter, leaving 5 cents, oh shit you made a mistake. Back up, you should have done three dimes.

      • Easy solve: get rid of the dime too

      • How many cashiers deal with actual currency anymore? Most customers, including elderly ones, use a card. Even I cases where hard currency is used, how many have a cash register that automatically dispenses the change instead of requiring the operator to manually count it? The education system is so abysmal that the people expected to work tills may not be able to calculate change anyway.

        Your post is more of an endorsement of killing the Dime than it is saving the Nickel. I've not used anything less than
        • by larwe ( 858929 )

          Autodispense change-making cash registers are not rare, but they are also far from universal. They're expensive. Your corner bodega won't have one usually. As far as "going card only" there are social objections to this, ranging from personal privacy to "many of the poorer people in the USA are bankless", which is why some jurisdictions have explicitly banned cashless stores.

          I agree with you on not using anything smaller than a quarter recently, but I have an alternative suggestion for you - stop minting co

        • How many cashiers deal with actual currency anymore? Most customers, including elderly ones, use a card.

          Wow...where do you live where they no longer use cash and only use credit cards?

          I tend to still carry and use cash whenever I can....and I see it being used quite often when out, especially the grocery store, or gas/convenience store....

          Also, I like to tip in cash when dining out....in the past that was a way to keep the server from having to pay so much tax on it....but looks like new legislation is a

          • I haven't needed cash in a very long time. Here in Australia even someone like our LEGO club has a card reader for purchases at our meetings (e.g. raffle tickets and drinks) abd I can't remember the last time I saw an actual business (retail store, food outlet, etc) that didn't take card.

            Of course I also have a bank account with a Visa Debit card that has no minimum balance and basically no fees.

      • by flink ( 18449 )

        Get rid of the quarter. Bring back the 50 piece and keep the dime.

      • Re: (Score:3, Informative)

        if you need to make 42 cents, you do a quarter (leaving 17 cents), then a dime, (leaving 7 cents), then a nickel and then two pennies.

        That's 5 coins. In Europe, it's only 3 coins: 20c + 20c + 2c.

        The problem is, consider getting rid of the nickel. Now try to make 30 cents. You pull a quarter, leaving 5 cents, oh shit you made a mistake. Back up, you should have done three dimes.

        In Europe, it's 2 coins: 20c + 10c.

      • The 10% of society left who transacts in cash, can have their share of a few billion pennies in current circulation. Enough to dismiss any argument or concern about our system being minus the penny anytime soon. I even expect a ton more coming into circulation as more piggy banks get broken in a belt-tightening era.

        Transactional charges and fees do far more to erode the value of the new-era digital dollar than the nuking of pocket change ever will.

      • >Can't do it

        Funny, Canada did. They're handling it just fine.

    • by thegarbz ( 1787294 ) on Thursday May 22, 2025 @03:04PM (#65396551)

      That would drive mass inflation as companies stop nickel and diming customers, and move to dime and dollaring them instead.

      • That would drive mass inflation as companies stop nickel and diming customers, and move to dime and dollaring them instead.

        People pretty much only nit-pick over the digits past the decimal point when it comes to gas prices.

        $3.02/gal "Oh, that's not too bad."
        $3.23/gal "Hmm, better fill up now before it goes up any higher."
        $3.59/gal "Did a refinery blow up or something?!"
        $3.89/gal "Fuck these fucking gas prices in their fucking ass! I'm voting for the other political party now! Fuck!"

        Meanwhile, a pack of prepared chicken strips can jump up by a whole dollar and people are like:
        "I can't remember what that cost the last time I bo

        • Well, when you're filling the 50-gallon fuel tank in your 7 mpg truck, those per-gallon prices all get whacked with a nasty multiplier. That 20-cent difference costs you an additional $10.

          But, all the more reason I love paying $0.05 per kWh for my "fuel".

      • That would drive mass inflation as companies stop nickel and diming customers, and move to dime and dollaring them instead.

        You mean diming and quartering them, there is still hope... ;-)

        • Yeah, that. Can you tell I don't live in America :-) To be brutally honest I'm not sure what a nickel is. Without looking it up, 2c or 5c is my guess. A dime is 10c right?

    • by buss_error ( 142273 ) on Thursday May 22, 2025 @03:36PM (#65396715) Homepage Journal

      From the Fine Article:

      President Donald Trump stated that production of pennies are wasteful, as the coins cost more to produce than their one-cent value.

      If it costs thirty five cents to make a one cent piece, but the cost of the metal is a fraction of one cent, then no one gets one cent pieces to melt down into base metal.

      If a dollar coin has five dollars worth of metal in it, only the very stupid wouldn't go get all the dollar coins they could and melt them down for the base metal.

      The cost of the base metal should be less than the face value of the coin. The cost to produce the coin is largely irrelevant. The cost to make a bill of any denomination is the same for each bill (leaving out the minor variations for printing millions of them) but only last a limited time compared to a coin. For a dollar bill about 18 months, a bit longer as the denomination goes up. But every coin wears for 20 to 30 years. Arguably if saving money is the imperative we should stop printing paper money.

      Your words:

      Save us the trouble of repeating this entire drama in another few decades and kill off the Nickel alongside the Penny.

      If the standard is that the coin is too low in value to bother with, I agree. The issue is that the one cent coin's value is too low for people to care if they lose one, or even a 100. Same with nickles, dimes, but quarters... now people pay a tiny bit of attention. But not for much longer, really, and the purchase power of a quarter drops ever lower. This is why we see more and more credit card vending machines. Inflation proof, and when we get to the point of needing a wheelbarrow to haul cash around the credit card makes it a simple transaction.

      Back in the Day I had a job where we had to settle with the state tax authority each and every day we operated. The joke was as the tax percentage was not an integer, (EG: a fractional number) so we kept a one cent piece we'd cut in half. We'd trade it back and forth with the state guy depending on the balance due. It was always funny when we got a substitute state guy in during illness or vacation.

      • by gtall ( 79522 )

        Is this the same la Presidenta that wants to add another several Trillion to the national debt? Or that wants to accept a "gift" (read: bribe) from UAE of a gold plated plane, stick the American taxpayers for the bill of upgrading it so that it can fly as Air Force One, and then make off with it to Mar-A-Lardo?

  • This time for sure!

  • Energy (Score:2, Funny)

    by backslashdot ( 95548 )

    We really should be using energy as in watt-hours as currency. Energy is work, and universally convertible to quality of life improvements. Plus, trading energy is easy. Say you want to buy a car or something .. instead of handing over a bag of cash you hand over a bunch of oil barrels. For most things it wont be inconvenient to make purchases if you carry around a gallon or two of gasoline in your backpack.

    • by larwe ( 858929 )
      This reminds me very much of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... [wikipedia.org]
    • by DarkOx ( 621550 )

      Exactly and we should really PEG the money supply to installed generating capacity as well. That way it can easily expand (or shrink) with the economy and not be so easily tampered with.

      • I'm interested in your tagline

        Repeal the 17th Amendment TODAY!

        Personally, I'd be in favor of ending the Senate's representation of each state, two senators. It makes no sense for Wyoming, with half a million people, to have two votes, while California, with forty million people, has two votes.

    • We really should be using energy as in watt-hours as currency.

      The cost of producing energy varies quite a bit. I can go to Harbor Freight right now and buy a solar panel that'll produce electricity for free, but somehow the power company still insists on billing me about $0.14 per kWh for the electricity I use at home.

      Of course, the idealistic response would be that I should just get a whole bunch of those solar panel thingies, but immediate budgetary and practical constraints make that idea infeasible. Economics is hard, and apparently, so is getting away from payi

    • What if all I have is a wheelbarrow full of assorted batteries? Batteries store electricity
      • That's legal tender right there. And the wheelbarrow is too, if it's at the top of a hill. You probably shouldn't have flaunted your wealth on a public site though.

    • by Kaenneth ( 82978 )

      That's called Bitcoin.

  • CGP Grey (Score:4, Informative)

    by Himmy32 ( 650060 ) on Thursday May 22, 2025 @02:02PM (#65396337)
    CGP Grey has had some interesting videos on the getting rid of the penny [youtube.com] and the nickel [youtube.com].
  • Cool. (Score:5, Funny)

    by NMBob ( 772954 ) on Thursday May 22, 2025 @02:03PM (#65396343) Homepage
    So the price of everything that is like $4.99 is going to be rolled back to $4.95? Nice. Ha!
    • So the price of everything that is like $4.99 is going to be rolled back to $4.95? Nice. Ha!

      You forgot about the tax. Practically, everything will probably just get 1-4 cents more expensive. It'll be interesting to see how and where things get rounded.

      I imagine this is part of a push to a cashless society, where all purchases can be tracked -- unless you're using crypto (wonder why this President would back that? /s) in which case, we all will have to wait in line while people's transactions clear... fun.

      • Gotta tell you, it's reasonable to accuse me of TDS -- I think that dude is the worst, and a wannabe genocidal fascist who seeks to end Democracy -- but even I'm sitting here going "yeah, that's actually a reasonable call, to eliminate the penny."
        • Gotta tell you, it's reasonable to accuse me of TDS -- I think that dude is the worst, and a wannabe genocidal fascist who seeks to end Democracy -- but even I'm sitting here going "yeah, that's actually a reasonable call, to eliminate the penny."

          Not disagreeing -- on any part of that :-) -- just thinking about the consequences. Most place will probably NOT round down. Even if the government provides rounding guidelines, or laws, if anything, they'll adjust prices so things get rounded up. Also, pricing and rounding will have to include the effects of the sales tax. Paying with non-cash will be simple either way.

    • No. No one knows what's going to happen. That's exactly the problem. Sales taxes, where they exist, inevitably cause prices to be off the 5 cent mark. With no national legislation planned at all and state legislation likely to be slow to have any influence, the effect will be chaos as different vendors, different local jurisdictions, and different states struggle to find an equitable balance.

      The best part is that, because nickels cost the US government even more in overhead than pennies do, the whole th

    • That already happened in United Kingdom, Australia, New Zealand and most of the western world like three decades ago.
  • If the government required shops to round down and account for the difference in quarterly checks to the Treasury Dept, the 70 billion cash transactions a year could translate to ~$1 billion in revenues for the U.S. government and we wouldn't notice at all.
    • by PPH ( 736903 )

      and account for the difference in quarterly checks to the Treasury Dept

      Checks? Pay them with pennies.

    • Why should the government get the money? They are neither the buyer nor the seller in the transaction.
      Yet another sneak tax is a brilliant idea. /s

  • I'm not joking. Kill the penny. I was usaf and did overseas for a bit, 3 years in England and a combined year in Italy and France, and AAFES (our store/supermarket/consessionaires) dealt in 0 or 5, no pennies. Too much $ to ship 'em over there.

    And for me, on a personal level, the penny hasn't felt right or sounded right since 1982. That was the last year of the copper penny. Ever after you get a zinc slug with the thinnest veneer of copper. Sounds and feels like Monopoly money.

    Kill it already. Serves

    • And what do you do about sales tax? If the answer is "round up", who gets the rounded up money: the retailer or the government? I guess states could just increase sales tax to 10% so that the total is always a multiple of .05 (since we know that they won't lower sales tax to 5%).
      • by isj ( 453011 )

        Sales tax has nothing to do with the cash payment. The sensible thing to do is to round towards nearest divisible-by-5-cent number. That's what other countries do.
        So if you buy an apple and with sales tax it's $1.02 you pay $1.00 in cash. If it's $1.08 then you'll pay $1.10 in cash.
        Or you can pay exact value with debit/credit card.

        • Given that this is being done without any legislative guidance, it's completely up to the retailer on how they'll charge customers. However, thinking that they'll do what other countries do or will do something sensible is a bit naive. In the U.S., companies do whatever maximizes their profits, regardless of what's sensible or decent.
  • People speculating about how we're going to round up or round down without pennies are missing the point. Since COVID, I rarely carry cash, nor do the people I know and work with. It doesn't matter if pennies aren't minted anymore, because hardly anyone is carrying or using them. Practically everything is cashless.

    The one-cent denomination will survive just fine. If I buy something that costs $21.62, then that's what I'll be charged on my credit card. The round up / round down issue only matters if I p

    • People care because it'll be a great excuse for retailers to increase prices even more, regardless of how you choose to pay. The sensible thing to do would be to round the total iff you're using cash, but what will likely happen is that retailers will round the retail price on every individual item. And many fees are percentage based, including sales tax, so fees could end up being raised to become an even multiple of 5%. Companies are already acting incredibly scummy and things like this give them the l
    • Since COVID, I rarely carry cash, nor do the people I know and work with. It doesn't matter if pennies aren't minted anymore, because hardly anyone is carrying or using them. Practically everything is cashless.

      Not where I live and travel or from what I see.

      Hell, I love to carry and use cash for most everything I can that isn't online....I use cash in meatspace.

  • by schwit1 ( 797399 ) on Thursday May 22, 2025 @02:34PM (#65396439)

    Does the President have the authority? Congress doesn't have to approve?
    Will an Illinois(Land of Lincoln) resident get a judge to stop this action?
    Should the government mandate all prices to the nickel, including gasoline prices?

    Now do daylight saving time.

    • On how the law that created the treasury was written. In some cases it spells out exactly what the treasury does, IE make so much currency. Usually it says something equivalent to "Maintain the currency supply as necessary" so the executive branch has some leeway. It's pretty much how it's supposed to work. If there is a sudden spike in the need for $20 bills, you don't want to wait for an act of congress for permission to print more, and generally congress doesn't care, anyways.
    • Does the President have the authority? Congress doesn't have to approve?
      Will an Illinois(Land of Lincoln) resident get a judge to stop this action?
      Should the government mandate all prices to the nickel, including gasoline prices?

      Now do daylight saving time.

      I am not USoA'n but if I recall correctly:
      - Either congress or the president of the US mint can eliminate a coin.
      - Past presidents of the US Mint wanted to eliminate the coin, but feared "political backlash"
      - even if courts told trump that the executive order is invalid, the very existance of the executive order has shown the current president of the US Mint that there will be no political backslash, so s/he will eliminate the penny on his/her own volition.

      And even if the president can not eliminate a coin

    • Does the President have the authority?

      That question stopped mattering on the 20th January.

  • > as the coins cost more to produce than their one-cent value

    I'm sure this will fix the 2 trillion annual deficit. Now we can afford those tax cuts for rich people!

    • by rskbrkr ( 824653 )

      Now we can afford those tax cuts for rich people!

      You must be extremely happy then that the current administration is on the verge of passing a tax cut that provide exactly $0 benefit to rich people, unless some millionaire/billionaire decides to pick up a side gig as a waiter/bartender.

  • Is there anything else at all? Even just one other thing?

  • Way back in the 1960s, the penny was going to be discontinued until the John Birchers made a stink that it was somehow part of a communist conspiracy, and that was the end of it. My, how times have changed.

  • by smooth wombat ( 796938 ) on Thursday May 22, 2025 @03:22PM (#65396649) Journal

    Since prices will now have to be rounded to the nearest five cents, which way do you think businesses will go? Will they round down to .00 or will they round up to .05 (or even the next .00)?

    Taking bets.

    • Prices don't change, it's the final bill. So if you buy 11 items in your cart, they only round up once.

      In Australia at least, if you're buying fresh produce by weight.

      Besides, don't most Americans throw their small change in the tip jar rather than saving 2 cents?

    • Re:More inflation (Score:4, Informative)

      by taustin ( 171655 ) on Thursday May 22, 2025 @04:38PM (#65396907) Homepage Journal

      This only affects people using cash. People using credit or debit cards - and that's the majority of retail already, and the percentage keeps going up - won't be affected in any way. And outside of retail transactions, almost nobody uses cash, and that's been the case for decades.

      The effect will be minimal, and reduced further as time goes by.

  • We got rid of the penny here in Canada in 2012. There hasn't really been any issue since getting rid of it. The majority of people pay with debit/credit cards. For those who pay cash, the price is rounded up or down to the nearest nickel, which at the end of the day balances itself so there's no real loss. Financial institutions and retail establishments prefer it this way too, as there's significant handling costs compared to the value.

  • Canada stopped producing the penny over a decade ago and life went on. By ditching the penny, it saved the government millions of dollars a year. If something is $3.99 and you pay via debit, you pay $3.99. If you pay with cash the price is rounded up to the nearest .05, so $4.00. If that price variation is rage inducing, you have bigger problems, for everybody else it was a non-event.
  • They should phase out nickels and dimes while they’re at it. I can’t remember the last time I used a coin smaller than a quarter.

    • They should phase out nickels and dimes while they’re at it. I can’t remember the last time I used a coin smaller than a quarter.

      Nickel, yes. The dime still costs less to mint than its 10 cent value, it can live a while longer...

      The dollar bill, on the other hand, should be substituted by the dollar coin...

      Oh, and re-start the production of 50 cents coins, mostly for coin operated stuff. Sometimes, something costs way too many quarters...

  • by zephvark ( 1812804 ) on Thursday May 22, 2025 @04:20PM (#65396859)

    Pennies are British. America's never had any. I get that some of you are still wistful about leaving the former British Empire but, hey! Wake up and smell the coffee, and don't call it "tea", 'cause it isn't.

  • I agree with the people pointing out how Canada eliminated the penny and it's worked fine to round up or down to the nearest 5 cents.

    But it seems to me the value of the penny in U.S. currency has more to do with enabling the psychological "mind games"? EG. Promising people can get an item or service for only a penny, because people equate that with "pretty much no cost". While sheer volume of customers accepting the deal means it adds up to at least a sum that's worth collecting vs. just giving the same th

  • I think the hole point in removing the penny: demoralize Americans, further. Putin is getting his money's worth. Crashing economy, alienated allies, breakup of NATO, and even shut off the NOAA, because it would have been the last chance to see the Russian bombers.

Can anything be sadder than work left unfinished? Yes, work never begun.

Working...