Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
United States News

US Could Ask Foreign Tourists For Five-Year Social Media History Before Entry (bbc.com) 270

Tourists from dozens of countries including the UK could be asked to provide a five-year social media history as a condition of entry to the United States, under a new proposal unveiled by American officials. From a report: The new condition would affect people from dozens of countries who are eligible to visit the US for 90 days without a visa, as long as they have filled out an Electronic System for Travel Authorization (ESTA) form. Since returning to the White House in January, President Donald Trump has moved to toughen US borders more generally - citing national security as a reason.

Analysts say the new plan could pose an obstacle to potential visitors, or harm their digital rights. Asked whether the proposal could lead to a steep drop-off in tourism to the US, Trump said he was not concerned. "No. We're doing so well," the president said on Wednesday. "We just want people to come over here, and safe. We want safety. We want security. We want to make sure we're not letting the wrong people come enter our country."

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

US Could Ask Foreign Tourists For Five-Year Social Media History Before Entry

Comments Filter:
  • Ihre Papiere (Score:5, Insightful)

    by Inglix the Mad ( 576601 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:09AM (#65850697)
    I mean, let's just drop all pretense. The entirety of the Republican Party at this point is gleefully walking to that statement.
    • Re:Ihre Papiere (Score:5, Insightful)

      by Valgrus Thunderaxe ( 8769977 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:11AM (#65850705)
      Shithole country.
      • Re:Ihre Papiere (Score:5, Insightful)

        by Mr. Dollar Ton ( 5495648 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @12:24PM (#65851057)

        There's been no reason to visit the trumpistan or even board a trumpistani airline for 20 years now, ever since they instituted that ass-fingering service, TSA, and the Homelander Department that runs it.

    • Re: (Score:3, Informative)

      * Only applicable to people darker than a latte or from one of those gay woke countries.

    • by BeerCat ( 685972 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:46AM (#65850799) Homepage

      I mean, let's just drop all pretense. The entirety of the Republican Party at this point is gleefully walking to that statement.

      Uh, "walking". Ok.

      Damn, I misread that word, and reckoned that, indeed, the Republican Party was gleefully rubbing one out to that statement.

  • “Country” (Score:2, Flamebait)

    by Sebby ( 238625 )

    "We want to make sure we're not letting the wrong people come enter our country."

    We want to make sure we're not letting the wrong people come enter our shithole country.

    There FTFY.

    • Re:“Country” (Score:5, Informative)

      by Inglix the Mad ( 576601 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:44AM (#65850795)

      Asked whether the proposal could lead to a steep drop-off in tourism to the US, Trump said he was not concerned. "No. We're doing so well," the president said on Wednesday.

      Keep in mind that statement is complete and utter crap. That's for the Fox News / Breitbart / Newsmax crowd who earnestly believe that (insert_EU_city) is a burning sharia law hellscape filled with "no-go zones" that police are terrified to enter.

      Tourism is doing pretty darn terrible according to those sinister libs at, checks source, Fortune

      Exclusive: U.S. businesses are getting throttled by the drop in tourism from Canada: ‘I can count the number of Canadian visitors on one hand’ [fortune.com]

      Or those dirty commies at, checks source, Forbes

      U.S. Tourism Will Lose Up To $29 Billion As Visitors Plummet Amid Trump Policies [forbes.com]

      Not that it isn't intentional in some ways.

      • Re:“Country” (Score:5, Informative)

        by ClickOnThis ( 137803 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:20AM (#65850881) Journal

        This. Trump has his head up his ass regarding many things, but regarding this statement about tourism in particular.

        Tourism has in fact dropped off significantly from the rest of the world since he took office, especially from Canada. And it's not the tariffs or the currency exchange-rate, or even the unwelcome (and unwelcoming) fees and secondary-inspections at the border for some visitors. It's the "51st-state" rhetoric and the disrespect for Canada's sovereignty.

        And it's not just tourism. There are widespread boycotts in Canada against goods made in the USA. Some clever US companies have, with limited success, engaged in "maple-washing" -- labeling their products to make them appear to be sourced in Canada. US liquor is absent form stores in many provinces, and sells poorly where it is available.

        Trump is reaping what he has sown, but as usual, he's engaging in denial.

        • Re: (Score:3, Informative)

          by swillden ( 191260 )

          Americans are reaping what Trump has sown, but as usual, he's engaging in denial.

          FTFY

          This is a gaslighting that he'll probably largely get away with, since most Americans -- especially his voter base -- have little contact with tourism or people from other countries.

          His ongoing attempts to gaslight them over grocery prices, though, that one's going to be tougher. I'm surprised he's trying that. I mean, he's dumb, sure, and insulated from truth, but surely someone around him is smart enough and clueful enough to tell him that it would be better to sell it as a period of unfortunate

      • Re:“Country” (Score:5, Insightful)

        by dargaud ( 518470 ) <slashdot2@NOSpAM.gdargaud.net> on Thursday December 11, 2025 @12:55PM (#65851183) Homepage
        I lived in the US in the past, and I still come for vacation and to climb in Yosemite and Utah every once in a while, but you can bet your ass I won't show up if I have to give my passwords and prove I did not disparage 'Dear Leader'. Indeed, I'll even say it here for the record: Trump is a piece of shit, a pedo, a conman, a rapist, a felon; and his entire administration is corrupt to the bone. Here.
    • We want to make sure we're not letting the wrong people come enter our shithole country.

      If it's such a shithole country, why do so many people want to come here that we have to build walls to keep people out?

      • by Puls4r ( 724907 )
        Because our is temporarily better. But with Trump's race to the bottom, we're quickly becoming Russia. So.... yeah.
      • Re: (Score:3, Insightful)

        Your shithole country has kept most of Latin and South America abjectly poor through your treating them like colonies, meddling in their internal affairs, supporting not only the most corrupt governments there, but also the perpetrators of many disgusting crimes against humanity, all while funding their drug cartels.

        What did you expect would be the result?

      • by Sebby ( 238625 )

        that we have to build walls to keep people out?

        Uh, you mean like the one Trumptard promised Mexico would pay for?

        (hint: that never happened, like just his healthcare plan "in a couple of weeks", or "infrastructure week" that everyone is still waiting for 10 years on)

  • Of course (Score:4, Insightful)

    by ArchieBunker ( 132337 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:17AM (#65850721)

    The stasi would be proud of this. Perhaps they would be a bit more discrete on the reasoning.

    Can't wait for the people who call everyone else snowflakes denying others entry because they called Dear Leader an orange turd a decade ago.

  • by lazlo ( 15906 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:22AM (#65850735) Homepage

    So... now no one from Australia under the age of 21 is allowed in the US?

    But, that aside, what does this even mean? Like, putting aside that it's a terrible idea, functionally, how would you do this? The *idea* of the law (so much as there is one) seems to assume that the number of social media accounts per platform that a person has is exactly one. Not zero, and not several. This is false. And how do they want it delivered? Just a link to your public profile? A download of all of your activity for five years? Your username and password? The first seems pointless, the rest seem terrible.

    • by Anonymous Coward on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:25AM (#65850743)

      You already put more thought into this asinine proposal than anyone in this administration.

    • by tlhIngan ( 30335 )

      Also makes the assumption that people are on social media. I mean, I have a Facebook account, and the past 5 years I posted 0 times on it. I have a Twitter account, and the past 5 years all I have are tweets like "Enter now for your change to win a free iPad from MacRumors!"

      That's really the only reason I have any social media accounts - if I want more entries in some draw I have to post a message on my Twitter feed. Last I checked, I was followed by a couple of bots and my total follower count are those bo

    • Like, putting aside that it's a terrible idea, functionally, how would you do this? The *idea* of the law (so much as there is one) seems to assume that the number of social media accounts per platform that a person has is exactly one. Not zero, and not several. This is false. And how do they want it delivered? Just a link to your public profile? A download of all of your activity for five years? Your username and password? The first seems pointless, the rest seem terrible.

      If you get diverted to secondary inspection at a US border crossing, USCIS can, and just might, scan your electronic devices. They may demand to know your passwords -- to your devices and your online accounts. If you refuse to give them, then they may refuse you entry, or confiscate the device for more detailed inspection, and (eventually) return it to you.

      This can even happen to citizens, except that they cannot be denied entry. Green-card holders cannot be denied entry either, unless they have committed a

      • by djgl ( 6202552 )

        Last time I entered the US, I carried a blank phone.

        Luckily I've seen enough of the US and have no intention to visit again.

      • by Sique ( 173459 )
        How do you prove a negative? If you have no Instagram account, how do you prove it? By not knowing your Instagram password?
  • Proving a Nagative (Score:5, Insightful)

    by El Fantasmo ( 1057616 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:24AM (#65850739)

    Entrant: I don't have any "social media".
    Boarder Guard: Prove it.

    Good luck explaining to some MAGA loyalist at the border check how difficult it is to prove a negative.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... [wikipedia.org]

    • by TwistedGreen ( 80055 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:55AM (#65850825)

      Heaven forbid, you might have to show them your Slashdot account!

      • Heaven forbid, you might have to show them your Slashdot account!

        That would be fun, actually. I'd have to give them slashdot and substack. They'd have no idea what either of them are.

        Well, it would be fun until they denied me entry.

    • I think you disproved a negative just now. I didn't think anyone that wasn't MAGA would spell it boarder. I get it that autocorrect is a thing but I haven't seen it until now.

    • by vbdasc ( 146051 )

      Border guard: You seem like an anti-social type. We don't want the likes of you in our country. Go away.

    • Entrant: I don't have any "social media", but it doesn't matter because I applied for a regular visa like most of the world instead of using the ESTA program.

      Border Guard: Enjoy your visit.

      Look past the headline. Headlines lie.

      • by bungo ( 50628 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @01:15PM (#65851287)

        I applied for a regular visa like most of the world instead of using the ESTA program

        My guess is that you're American, and you've never had to apply for a US visa?

        The process is very costly and takes a large amount of time. To even get an appointment to visit the embassy, you have to pay a fee in advance. If you have all of the paperwork, then you can pay more for a visa. If you don't have what they deem necessary, then you have to pay for another visit at the embassy. Sometimes, paperwork appears to be decided not sufficient for no apparent reason.

        After potentially multiple expensive embassy visits, over many weeks - since booking a visit is just saying you'll pop in next Tuesday - you can wait months to see if the visa is approved. This is why people prefer the cheaper, easier ESTA process.

        And you know, the ESTA program only exists for countries that have similar arrangements for the US.

  • by devslash0 ( 4203435 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:28AM (#65850747)

    They law needs to be precise what they mean by social media. We've got the big, obviously SM companies around like Twitter, Facebook, etc. but nearly all platforms these days contain a social element to them. Is Strava social media? Is slashdot? How about your comments on Google?

    We need a law that is precise so that the government doesn't stretch it to cover all our data, which they'd obviously love to do.

    • We've got the big, obviously SM companies around like Twitter, Facebook, etc

      Except they've all gotten into OAuth, so you could have an account that is just a single sign on identity with no post, view or comment history. Is that a social media account? If you hand it over it will be declared obviously fake.

  • They going to arrest some old people and put them on the first flight home because they've barely heard of twitter and tiktok never mind used them yet the guards don't believe them?

    Or will this be limited to certain age groups?

    What a cretinous BS idea.

  • that anyone still wants to visit that shit country.
    Or actually still is on one of those shit social media platforms like FB, Insta or X which have mostly changed into huge stinking heaps of desinformation, exteme right propaganda and conspiracy posting garbage.
    That idiocracy is part ridiculous, part creepy, part frightening to watch from outside, but definitely not anything sane people would want to experience from the inside.

  • I guess, given the recent social media ban for under-16-year-olds in Australia, these kids can't apply to enter the USA now... hahaha!

    • Tourists from dozens of countries including the UK could be asked to provide a five-year social media history as a condition of entry to the United States

      Is Australia one of the countries (and just for the sake of completeness, is Austria?).

  • I don't use Facebook so they have nothing on me, no TwitterX either, I have a BlueSky account but I use it only as a news reader and I never post any comments my bsky account is basically an empty shell, they can see my slashdot history, and if they can dig up my 4chan comments they would have a good laugh and think I was mentally ill
  • by rsilvergun ( 571051 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:37AM (#65850767)
    There is a government contract to go with this and it'll go to somebody well connected, probably Elon Musk. That was what Doge was all about. They caught a bunch of things and turned them into a juicy government contracts. The 250 million Elon spent on electing Trump was money well spent.

    Everything is a grift now. Capitalism is collapsing and the only thing left is crooks trying to get the last bit of what you have out of you before the collapse.

    We really need a third way. I get that nobody in this country is going to get behind socialism. Not after almost 100 years of propaganda.

    But it's pretty obvious capitalism is collapsing too.

    So we can't have capitalism and we can't have socialism so what's it going to be?

    And we better figure out something fast because the clock's ticking and right now the third option is a total economic collapse. They're already talking about using AI to deny people Medicare and let the AI companies keep the savings. So even if you are retired you better start thinking about it
    • by Sebby ( 238625 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:44AM (#65850793) Journal

      So we can't have capitalism and we can't have socialism so what's it going to be?

      Retardism. The US is already there. Been there for years.

    • Don't use antiquated terms like socialism. If you have to define it you've already lost. Instead say private sector and public sector. They don't have the baggage associated with capitalism, socialism, and communism. Those are from the 1800s have been reduced to name calling labels.
    • They're already talking about using AI to deny people Medicare and let the AI companies keep the savings

      Who needs AI? Just deny every claim and make it impossible, through a crooked appeals and court system, to appeal any denial decision. Done. (Grisham wrote a book about this many years ago, called the Rainmaker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... [wikipedia.org].

    • by vbdasc ( 146051 )

      Techno-feudalism might be the future.

  • scared of words (Score:4, Insightful)

    by awwshit ( 6214476 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:39AM (#65850779)

    Republicans are scared of educated people that use words, people that might speak the truth.

  • by jacks smirking reven ( 909048 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @10:40AM (#65850783)

    Stop bringing in your money and spending it on our local businesses and hospitality sector.

    • by OrangeTide ( 124937 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:26AM (#65850897) Homepage Journal

      And stop coming over to the headquarters of our multinational companies, making business deals and acquisitions that creates some of the largest corporations in the world.

      The US doesn't like money anymore, at least not as much as it likes xenophobia.

      • Don't pretend people landing on private airstrips are filling out ESTAs.

  • I won't see my parents for quite a while. The decision was taken before this news by the way. Getting through the border has been dangerous for a long time now and we told family not to come.

    Both wifey and i have US citizenship but we don't go through the border anyway. Especially since we are European born. It is nearly certain we will leave the country, sell the house and give our kids better French courses than what we can give them. They are not ready for a school in a French-speaking environment. We wi

    • Besides,

      Colleagues who work in academia in Europe tell me these are their instructions, since months:

      - Take a blank computer that is only used for this purpose.
      - Pass through customs with zero data.
      - Once you arrive, retrieve the data you sent yourself before leaving.
      - And above all, ask yourself if you really need this data and need to make the trip.

    • You can crash at your parent's place, but won't see them for quite a while.

      Did a human write this?

      • You idiot.

        I am explaining if i leave the US permanently, my family can spend a short time at my parent's place to give us some time to figure things out. But that won't happen very soon unless some kind of emergency happens.

  • that Donald Trump turn over his media posts when he visits. They will ban him for life.
    • that Donald Trump turn over his media posts when he visits. They will ban him for life.

      President Donald Trump has immunity from that kind of inspection.

      While he's in office.

  • by TuballoyThunder ( 534063 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:22AM (#65850889)
    Oh, crap
  • Theoretically, if I wanted to visit the USA, I would not be subject to this rule because it doesn't apply to Canadian citizens.

    But of course, I have no desire whatsoever to visit such a shithole country running headlong down the path to fascism. And pay 3x for the privilege of visiting a national park. I guess Trump just hates the tourism industry.

  • by joe_frisch ( 1366229 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @11:53AM (#65850955)

    Putting aside the privacy issues, its going to be difficult to comply with this. As others have said, there are many things that might be considered "social" media - Slashdot, discussions on news sites, specialty interests hobby groups. Do things like tripadvisor count? I have accounts that I've created, and never really used, long ago forgotten the usernames and passwords. I have email accounts set up to absorb spam and then abandoned, email accounts from former jobs where I no longer have passwords or even usernames.

    They are setting people up to be caught "lying" because they didn't disclose an account.

  • I posed publicly on my social media page that Charlie Kirk got what he deserved and that I was upset Thomas Crooks missed. Now I don't need to make up excuses for not wanting to go to the USA when my employer asks me to, I simply won't be let in.

    • by dskoll ( 99328 )

      It'd be hilarious if this caused an uptick in anti-Trump-regime postings on social media from people who don't want to be forced to travel to the USA for work.

  • There's a business opportunity for a company to create thousands of innocuous social media accounts and post photos of food and cats. Build up nice histories of blandness and then sell them to people who need innocuous history.

    Heck, someone could even create their own social media site and pre-populate it with 5 years of innocuousness and sell those account details. "Why yes, my only social media is FaceTok!"

  • by jenningsthecat ( 1525947 ) on Thursday December 11, 2025 @12:00PM (#65850977)

    Asked whether the proposal could lead to a steep drop-off in tourism to the US, Trump said he was not concerned.

    If I was being charitable, I'd say that Orangey McOrangeface is simply unaware of how his policies have drastically reduced the number of tourists from other countries, and how badly the US tourism industry is suffering as a result.

    But I'm disinclined to be charitable toward the clearly evil fucktard who lies only when his lips are moving. So I'll just say that Trump is entirely aware of the misery and damage that he's inflicting on his own citizens. I firmly believe that he relishes the misery he's causing, not just to the tourism sector, but to everyone below a certain income level. And that "certain income level" is getting higher every day...

    My wife just made the interesting point that the current US administration is well on its way to ushering in a revival of British Victorian-era workhouses. I wish I could come up with a counter-argument; but I'm afraid that she's probably correct. Virtually every move that Trump has made can easily and logically be interpreted as part of a plan to effectively enslave the majority of the US population.

    For example, the farming economy is being destroyed under Trump. When mega-corps take over farms, the farmers will either be wage slaves on what used to be their own land, or they'll be sleeping in boxes under bridges until the police take them to - that's right - the poor-house. Or the "poor-farm"...

    Technocratic hegemony is on its way, and if we don't stop it soon things are going to get really ugly. And I fear that it might be contagious. It may get to the point where there's no safe country to move to - at least not one that hasn't closed its borders.

  • by Voice of satan ( 1553177 ) on Friday December 12, 2025 @01:10PM (#65853755)

    Here is a more recent article:

    https://visasnews.com/en/us-so... [visasnews.com]

    And go to hell if you do not have a smartphone.

            Phone numbers used within the past five years;
            Email addresses used within the past ten years;
            IP addresses and metadata associated with submitted photos;
            Names, birth details, addresses, and contact information for immediate family members;
            Additional biometric data, including facial, fingerprint, and iris data, and, when applicable, DNA;
            Professional phone numbers and email addresses from the past five to ten years.

    Thank god they don't need to go trough the hassle of a visa application !

"An open mind has but one disadvantage: it collects dirt." -- a saying at RPI

Working...