France's Heat This Week Was Worse Than a Dire Scenario Imagined For 2050 (msn.com) 154
There's a deadly, record-breaking heat wave spreading east across Europe, reports the Washington Post — and it's even worse than a dire earlier forecast:
The forecast was recorded in 2014 as part of a campaign coordinated by the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) that invited about 60 presenters worldwide to imagine a weather report from the year 2050. In one clip, Ãvelyne Dhéliat from French television network TF1 presented a hypothetical scenario of high temperatures 36 years into the future — during a heat wave in a warmer climate in 2050... One of the maps that Dhéliat shared was lit up in shades of orange, filled with temperature predictions of 40 degrees Celsius (104 degrees Fahrenheit), reaching as high as 43 degrees Celsius (109.4 degrees Fahrenheit).
But it turns out, it didn't take 36 years for those imagined temperatures to be reached — and even exceeded. The heat on Wednesday alone, when the temperature soared as high as 112.3 degrees Fahrenheit (44.3 degrees Celsius), exceeded the 2050 projections in 19 out of 34 locations across mainland France — far sooner than some may have expected. Some places surpassed those hypothetical future temperatures by more than 20 degrees Fahrenheit. It's part of a dramatic shift in heat wave frequency across the country. Half of the heat waves observed since 1947 have occurred since 2010. "By 2100, heat waves could last up to two months continuously," the country's weather agency, Météo-France, said this week.
It was hotter in France on Wednesday than in Las Vegas and Phoenix and just two degrees Fahrenheit shy of what was observed in Death Valley, California. An estimated less than one percent of the planet was hotter than France's hottest place... [T]he heat dome, which will linger into early next week, is only part of the story. This type of extreme heat is becoming more common as the planet warms, especially in Europe.
Climate scientist Robert Rohde said in a post explaining the heat wave's causes that France and Western Europe should expect many more heat waves like this over the coming decades. "This isn't a fluke, but simply part of the new normal," he said.
Thanks to Slashdot reader fjo3 for sharing the news.
But it turns out, it didn't take 36 years for those imagined temperatures to be reached — and even exceeded. The heat on Wednesday alone, when the temperature soared as high as 112.3 degrees Fahrenheit (44.3 degrees Celsius), exceeded the 2050 projections in 19 out of 34 locations across mainland France — far sooner than some may have expected. Some places surpassed those hypothetical future temperatures by more than 20 degrees Fahrenheit. It's part of a dramatic shift in heat wave frequency across the country. Half of the heat waves observed since 1947 have occurred since 2010. "By 2100, heat waves could last up to two months continuously," the country's weather agency, Météo-France, said this week.
It was hotter in France on Wednesday than in Las Vegas and Phoenix and just two degrees Fahrenheit shy of what was observed in Death Valley, California. An estimated less than one percent of the planet was hotter than France's hottest place... [T]he heat dome, which will linger into early next week, is only part of the story. This type of extreme heat is becoming more common as the planet warms, especially in Europe.
Climate scientist Robert Rohde said in a post explaining the heat wave's causes that France and Western Europe should expect many more heat waves like this over the coming decades. "This isn't a fluke, but simply part of the new normal," he said.
Thanks to Slashdot reader fjo3 for sharing the news.
Mon Dieu (Score:4, Interesting)
The heat was so bad in France that they banned drinking alcohol [theguardian.com] in Paris.
Imagine telling a Parisian that they cannot drink wine.
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Mon Dieu (Score:4, Insightful)
Dehydration and general low availability of ambulances probably.
Re: (Score:2)
Yes, the reason is: lack of common sense.
Re:Mon Dieu (Score:5, Informative)
What is the reason for this?
There are many reasons for this. This may have just been in Paris, but banning alcohol consumption during heatwaves at specific events isn't that uncommon. Here's some of the reasons:
- Alcohol is massively dehydrating, it's a diuretic making you pee far more than normal. Yes it's still a net positive if you drink beer. It's not a net positive if you drink a spirit. But it is far from as hydrating as drinking water or even softdrink.
- Alcohol drops blood pressure. Heat drops blood pressure. Combining the two puts you at a much higher risk of heatstroke than you would be otherwise. If you have a heart condition you're also at a much higher risk of heart attacks. (Recorded cardiac events typically double in a mild heatwave).
- Many alcohols do not have electrolytes, beer does, but consuming just wine for example can put you in an electrolyte deficient state when you sweat a lot which can make heatstroke's worse (actually it'll move some heatstroke symptoms to just normal heat exhaustion stage, such as dizziness and loss of attentiveness and that's before you consider the last point).
- Alcohol impairs judgement. You're less likely to make good decisions, less likely to notice effects of heat stress, less likely to drink when needed, seek shade when needed, etc.
Actually one of the things which are really good for you in a heatwave is an alcohol free beer. It's hydrating, and heavy in electrolytes (important in heatwave) and many are isotonic. Alcohol free weizen beer is usually served at marathons at the finish line as a recovery drink in Germany.
Re: (Score:2)
Their emergency rooms were filling up with young people that don't know their limit.
Re: Mon Dieu (Score:5, Informative)
"they say". Of course alcohol dehydrated you. It is as much of a fact as you can get. Clearly evidenced, mechanism understood, and a shared personal experience of billions.
Re: (Score:3)
Just one of many. Alcohol also drops blood pressure (like a heatwave does) exacerbating the already far higher rate of cardiac events during a heatwave. Alcohol also impairs judgement - which is one of the key causes of death in a heatwave, not identifying you are heat stressed leading to a full on life threatening heatstroke.
Re: (Score:2)
And in Paris, that would result in a large number of people just going in Seine.
Re:Mon Dieu (Score:5, Informative)
In restaurants or at home, you obviously still can drink wine:
The alcohol ban is intended to stop people buying beer, wine and spirits from shops and drinking them in the street and beside the cityâ(TM)s canals and the Seine.
Re: (Score:2)
Banned drinking alcohol in public.
Re:Mon Dieu (Score:5, Informative)
Muslims don't consume alcohol.
Good joke, but that begs for the actual numbers: in 2020, 53% of french people claim to have no religion [wikipedia.org]. 34% are Christians, 11% are Muslims
Re: (Score:2)
It's not even a good joke, it's a Gutfeld-grade groaner.
Re: (Score:2)
I know you are, but what am I? :P
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Mon Dieu (Score:4, Insightful)
Such claims are stupid.
a) most Muslims do actually consume alcohol
b) Paris has not many Muslims - or France in general, perhaps 10% if at all.
Re: Mon Dieu (Score:2)
They have the wrong race or religion :)
Re: (Score:2)
Or both!!
Re: (Score:3)
As you become more ensconced in propaganda, you're more likely to make such ridiculous statements.
In reality, the religious group seizing control of the government in the US are the Christians. In my state, they have already banned alcohol on Sundays (and elsewhere).
Re: (Score:3)
To quantify, Texas bans alcohol 52 days a year, France bans it 1 day.
Re: (Score:2)
"More areas"- oh, no! Not even more no-bacon-eating zones in Europe, additionally to all the existing places where eating bacon already is banned. The horror. Already you can hardly find a place where you could peacefully eat your hard earned bacon without getting hanged by the Iranian Revolutionary Guards and Ghadda... no, wait Khomei... no, wait Bin Lad... uh, some islamic fanatic's terror commando.
The worst is that you can't even eat bacon in a Christian church! They'll throw you out and tell you never t
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
When did the current weather equal "climate"?
This is nonsense, a single hot day doesn't prove anything meaningful about climate change.
You have GOT TO BE KIDDING, right? Please tell me you don't believe the convoluted nonsense you just spewed; that you're actually trolling everyone.
Cuz... a never-before-seen hypothetical future weather report representing a third-of-a-century-from-now heat wave recurrence...really shouldn't be the current-day weather report that's baking parts of the world woefully unprepared even by their own fear-mongered worst-case-scenario hysterics for global policy changes vis-a-vis impacts of climate change.
In
Re: (Score:2)
When did the current weather equal "climate"?
When you came up with an idea to make it suit a narrative you're pushing that isn't related to what is being discussed.
a single hot day
Correct. Fortunately we have more data than that.
and lots of people didnt believe it in 2014 (Score:3, Interesting)
I remember there was lots of doubt when it was released at the time. And we are far from ready nowadays. it was extremely hot for almost everyone with lots of infrastructure failures. rails, transports, electricity, even air conditioning when it exist
The video undercuts itsself (Score:4, Interesting)
Actually, the video literally contains these captions:
"Besides, we have already experienced these temperatures. Remember the 2003 heatwave in France. Here are some of the temperatures recorded then: up to 42 degrees in Gourdon and Carpentras, even 44 degrees in Gard, and this was an all-time record."
Which makes this line from TFS sound stupid: "But it turns out, it didn't take 36 years for those imagined temperatures to be reached"
Don't get me wrong: I'm not a climate-denier. I'm just saying that this video doesn't support the story very well and pretending it does is bad journalism. I would argue that actual climate-deniers would rather see it as proof that this heat is nothing special, because it was similar in 2003. In that sense, this kind of reporting is probably achieving the opposite of what it intended to do.
Re:The video undercuts itsself (Score:5, Informative)
proof that this heat is nothing special, because it was similar in 2003.
Not sure what the reading comprehension problem of some people is about: up to 42 degrees in Gourdon and Carpentras, even 44 degrees in Gard, and this was an all-time record."
This are three cities with exceptional heat in 2003.
Now it is all of France and all of Germany it is not isolated heat islands in a random unlucky city: it is everywhere. I hope I am back in Thailand before August, if the same weather phenomena that is causing the current heat is happening again: it can only be worse.
Re: (Score:2)
No need to get snarky. My point was and is that TFA/TFS implies that the video was some apocalyptic prediction of 2050 that nobody thought would come true before then, but that the prediction is actually quite close to a situation that occurred 23 years ago as presented in the video, thereby counterproductively sensationalizing reality.
Ignoring the negative effects of bad journalism like this is almost as stupid as ignoring the negative effects of climate change.
Look at the video, TFA/TFS, and my point agai
Re: (Score:2)
I did not look at any video.
Actually, I did not notice a video.
I am reader, not a TV junky.
A sentence like: look at the video - makes me scroll on.
Re: (Score:2)
Then also do not respond to a comment that explicitly makes a point about a video, you dumb fuck.
Re: (Score:2)
"the prediction is actually quite close to a situation that occurred 23 years ago"
If by "quite close" you mean significantly different, which you don't and why the snark was justified.
Re: (Score:2)
Which makes this line from TFS sound stupid
Someone here sounds stupid, but it's not TFS. This European heatwave is a European heatwave. It's not single datapoints in small isolated locations. Gard may not be the hottest it's been (that record was set in 2019, higher than 2003), but FRANCE has just set a temperature record. Like ALL OF IT. Far higher than the previous 2019 record, and the previous 2003 record. And that's despite Gard missing the record by 4 degrees.
Also the 2003 record was far more localised, but there's more: It was not only on ave
Re: (Score:2)
You're attacking a straw man, a belief I explicitly said I do not hold. My point is about the crappy level of journalism, not that this heatwave is the same as the one in 2003.
Set aside your tribalism and blind rage and engage with my point.
Re: (Score:2)
I wasn't attacking any belief you had, I was attacking your stupid take claiming an article talking about France is wrong because Gare was a bit chiller than expected. The problem isn't the journalism, it's the reader, that is my point. There's no tribalism or rage here, just your dumb take.
Re: (Score:2)
Thanks for repeating your fallacies. I never said what you claim I said. Quote me, bitch.
Re: (Score:2)
Why is this stupid. It did last winter! When will this metereomarxist culture war ever stop?
Re: (Score:3)
"Doubting" things is easy. And dumb fuck can do it. Verifying them or proving them wrong is hard. Especially when you do not even try ...
Re:and lots of people didnt believe it in 2014 (Score:5, Funny)
Europe simply hasn't sacrificed enough virgins to the Climate Gods. It must round up a lot more and throw them into the nearest volcano.
... so they've come to Slashdot to recruit volunteers; very resourceful of them. :)
Re: (Score:3)
I don't remember the Global Warming Gang predicting that.
The Global Warming Gang is not in the business of predicting anything, they try hard to make it happen.
But if you mean scientists, just wait till you hear about AMOC collapse. No serious models anymore say it won't happen. And then, you'll have the heat that you wish for.
Re: (Score:2)
Meanwhile, here in Canada I've had the furnace on more than the AC all through June.
The temperatures in your home town this month are weather, not climate. I suspect you really do understand the difference, and are just pretending not to.
Re: (Score:2)
Well I can tell you're not in the GTA where it's been in the 20s for a while, and last year most of the summer felt like one big heat wave, where it was technically 6 back-to-back. [watchers.news]
Re: (Score:2)
that amount of warming will not happen by those dates, not even by end of century but it doesn't have to be anywhere close to that to be catastrophic
Ministry for the Future comes to life (Score:2)
That book still stays with me and haunts me. I still think it’s the best description of what an actually serious set of responses to climate change would look like that I’ve seen thus far
Re: (Score:2)
For everybody else's reference, here's the Amazon link, https://www.amazon.com/Ministr... [amazon.com]
Re: (Score:2)
It's excellent, truly
My car registered 125F briefly in Las Vegas (Score:5, Interesting)
Last week-end. It was a temporary sensor error, though. It was closer to 105F. I see 115F at home in the hills in San Jose a few days each year, and that is legit. But both the car and home have very efficient heat pump A/C, so that is not really an issue. The new Carrier heat pump A/C at home, combined with zoning, really sips energy. Just 158 kWh used on cooling since Feb 20. And 194 kWh used on heating, according to the smart stats. The 3 zones that are turned on (though not 24 hours) represent about 2000 sq ft. This includes a large dining room with south facing bay floor to ceiling windows. It's incredibly quiet too. Completely inaudible indoors. Even outdoors, due to it being variable speed, you can easily sit right next to it without being bothered.
In France, where I grew up, almost no one has A/C at home. And it is impossible to retrofit in most residences. Apartments don't use forced air for heating. They typically use radiators. My mother has floor heating at her apartment i Paris. The only options are window A/Cs. Those are very inefficient and very loud. They are not allowed on balconies in apartment buildings. A few have installed them illegally. But if there were hundreds of window A/Cs per apartment building, they would crack down due to noise. Not sure if the old buildings electric infrastructure could handle it, also.
In single family homes or townhomes, installing A/C is possible, but very expensive. That's not where most French people live, though. I feel for family members.
Re: (Score:2)
In Germany "Balcony Power Plants" are a thing.
Solar plants with or without a small battery, that can be directly plugged into the grid in the house.
It is limited to 800W plugin, but if you have a battery, it often has an extra plug to directly connect some equipment. In this case an AC would make sense.
Re: My car registered 125F briefly in Las Vegas (Score:2)
That would address the grid problem if your balcony has sun. But not the noise problem.
Re: (Score:2)
There are plenty of simple units that do not make noise. And perhaps it makes a small effect if they are in the shadow of the solar panel.
Or you use one of the modern inhouse ACs, small boxes that have a water tank, de-humify the air, and have a cold stream of air with tiny water droplets in them. I have no real experience with them indoors.
However tiny water spray air streams have an astonishing strong cooling effect.
Re: My car registered 125F briefly in Las Vegas (Score:2)
Which ones don't make noise ? How do they move the air
My bedroom was the attic growing up. It got painfully hot in the summer. Insulation was very poor. My father bought one of those AC units with a water tank just for my room. It was effective, but very noisy. You had to refill the tank every day. I'm sure it consumed a lot of electricity
Re: (Score:2)
Modern ones?
Sorry, I do not look at the brand of an AC in a beer garden admiring: oh, it does not make noise, I should make a photo to post it on grimdur.org to link it on /.
Perhaps do a google search: low noise AC or silent AC?
Re: (Score:2)
There are plenty of simple units that do not make noise.
Noise complaints due to installation of AC units is a major problem in Germany along with the rest of Europe.
Or you use one of the modern inhouse ACs, small boxes that have a water tank, de-humify the air, and have a cold stream of air with tiny water droplets in them. I have no real experience with them indoors.
The technical term for these is "fucking useless ACs", very good at emptying your bank account and little more.
Re: (Score:2)
Point is: there are plenty of units that do not make noise.
So pointing to some that do, for an argument, makes no sense.
The technical term for these is "fucking useless ACs", very good at emptying your bank account and little more.
Well, as I said. I have no clue about the,. But tech sites like heise.de recommend them highly.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Yeah, the interesting thing is:
there are some that dehumidify the room air, but still add "mist" to the exhaust.
I saw a cheap one, lol. I am tempted to buy one jus to test if it even works!
Re: (Score:2)
Houses in Europe were built for a different climate. Changing them now is going to be tricky, but we will have to find ways of doing it. For apartments that probably means lots of AC boxes on the roof and additional pipework on the outside.
Re: (Score:2)
One needs to remember France is very close to the US-Canada border in terms of latitude - and in general it's very temperate with temperatures exceeding 30C on the rare side. It's probably closer to Vancouver, Canada as climate. The only difference was, AC was controversial in Vancouver 30 years ago. Sure, you could expect commercial buildings to have AC purely because of the flexibility it enables for design, but older heritage buildings it was iffier.
Home AC was around - we had it installed in the 80s, bu
Re: (Score:2)
The only options are window A/Cs.
That's not so true anymore. There's plenty of cooling options coming to the market to retrofit in European style homes. Firstly heatpumps are typically retrofitted for central heating, and critically they can provide cooling. However the limiting factor is condensation on radiator lines. But a 2 friends and a work colleague have ones capable of cooling:
- Underfloor heating combined with insulation of the lines. It only sets the floor to 19C to avoid condensation but it's amazing how much having a physical s
Which Model? (Score:2)
The new Carrier heat pump A/C at home, combined with zoning, really sips energy.
Which model are you referring to?
Just 158 kWh used on cooling since Feb 20.
My heat pump used that much between Feb 20 and Feb 24.
And it is impossible to retrofit in most residences.
If you can drill a hole through the wall you can retrofit with a minisplit. There's also window shakers and floor standing portables. Though I don't recommend the latter.
Re: (Score:2)
It's a Carrier 27VNA348A0003 .
It used 32 kWh between Feb 20 - 24 . A lot of that was the very first day. The gas furnace had died in January. We used a space heater for about a month, which consumed 680 kWh (measured by monitoring smartplug). It only heated the 6000 cu ft master bedroom, so the cats wouldn't be cold. All the other areas were quite cold, which is why the heat pump worked hard the first day. We were on vacation abroad during the furnace outage so having most rooms cold wasn't that big of a de
Re: (Score:2)
Thanks for the info. I'll definitely be looking at that model.
98F
90% humidity
And a few more sq ft.
But it still snows in France (Score:2, Funny)
Re: (Score:2)
Yeah about that https://www.theguardian.com/tr... [theguardian.com]
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Far from ideal (Score:4, Interesting)
On second thought maybe that is the plan, lex luther style. The ultra wealthy will move up/down to the Artic/antartic, the rest of us will cook, and they will deploy robot staff in their fortresses.
Re: (Score:2)
Not sure if gasoline or liq nat gas is more carbon dense though.
Taking gasoline as pure octane, C8H18, i.e. ignoring all the additives that are generally added, and nat gas as pure methane, CH4, then:
By weight (1 kg):
gasoline contains ~0.84 kg of carbon
liq nat gas contains ~0.75 kg of carbon
By volume (1 L):
gasoline contains ~0.64 kg/L of carbon
liq nat gas contains ~0.35 kg/L of carbon
Remade in 2022, still got beat (Score:2)
They redid the exercise in 2022, adjusted with newest knowledge. The forecast got considerably hotter. Still got beat yesterday.
https://x.com/TF1Info/status/1... [x.com]
That 2014 forecast had already been beat in 2022.
#fasterthanexpected
so maybe 5% of GDP to climate? (Score:2)
Air Conditioning (Score:2)
Learn it, know it, live it.
I think I know why... (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
That's an absurd statement. If you live in an area where this does not happen, it doesn't make any sense to have your house set up as a refrigeration unit. This is hotter than it's ever been there; why would it be the norm in a place where this doesn't happen to built refrigeration into every dwelling?
Re: (Score:2)
Better call before you'll visit Europe next time. So we have time to install AC to cool your important, fat American ass properly. Why didn't you just complain loudly on the streets about how stupid Europe is, so we could become as smart as you? All the other American tourists are doing that, all the fucking time.
Re: (Score:2)
People really shouldn't live in places where they die if modern technology gives out for a day or two.
In a cold climate you can revert to burning things, but if it's too hot and the power goes out, it's a much bigger issue. Worse if there is too much demand on local water sources or importing food from far away because it can't grow in the local climate.
Re: (Score:2)
Yeah, climate change is a bitch when it happens on human timescales. "You shouldn't live where it's too hot" isn't really that fair to say when the place starts changing during your own lifetime.
Re:This is what you get (Score:5, Informative)
That's kind of the point about climate change: the climate is changing. Infrastructure built for the old climate isn't sufficient anymore. 30 years ago no one had AC in Paris because you didn't need it. Today it's becoming hard to survive without it.
Europe is the fastest warming continent on Earth [copernicus.eu]. That's why they're hitting this sooner than some other places. You'll see the same thing in Arizona soon enough. Think of blackouts during heat waves because there isn't enough power to run the air conditioners. Or people getting heat stroke even with AC, because it couldn't bring the temperature down enough. Either you'll spend a lot of money to update your infrastructure, or really bad things will happen.
Re: (Score:2)
How do you install air conditioning in a 400 year old building?
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
The same way you do it in a 20 year old building.
Only difference: the 400 year old building might have half or even a full yard thick walls made from rock.
Instead of AC, you first teach people: not to open the windows during day time, and not let in all the hot air from outside during daytime.
Then: a 400 year old building made from rock, does not need AC. Not even if it gets significantly warmer.
Just visit a castle or cathedral to confirm it.
Then, if you want to rebuild: most of such buildings have cellars
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
In "theory".
In practice it cools down enough that this does not happen.
The main problem is letting hot air inside, especially by people who think around noon, it is good to have a hot wind blowing through the house/apartment.
Of course you are right with your general assessment.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Well, it does not happen in my house.
Which is real rock. Sandstone.
And it indeed has a 60cm - 80cm outside wall.
Re: (Score:2)
How do you install air conditioning in a 400 year old building?
Through surprisingly small holes, same as every other building. You use split systems where the bulk (literally) is outside.
Re: (Score:2)
Window units or more likely split-unit ACs. If you ask the question, your knowledge of AC is decades out of date. Split-duct ACs are perfect for the job and France has the money.
I keep on reading Slashdot for that very reason; to maintain my knowledge of ACs up to date.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: This is what you get (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
And Europe is way behind on this metric, for a variety of reasons.
Consider this. I just looked the numbers up. Heat deaths in Europe are around 50,000 per year. Gun deaths in the US are around, wait for it, 50,000 per year. Europeans that shake their heads at America’s fetish with gun violence are killing just as many peop
Re: (Score:2)
We are not resistant to AC.
Are you fucking stupid?
We just do not have them: for historical reasons!
Moron.
Everyone who can installs them now ... craftmen doing the installations: are booked out, for months!
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
While the US is the uncontested master of climate-change denial, some of it is also going on in Europe. Stupid people enjoy a global distribution.
Re:This is what you get (Score:5, Insightful)
Incorporated AC when Paris was built?
Re:This is what you get (Score:4, Informative)
Fun fact: Paris was founded around 225 BC.
Re: (Score:2)
So they had 2250 years time to install proper American AC. But they didn't! Basically the whole climate mess is France's fault.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)