Flock Reinstalled Its Cameras After Another City Canceled Its Contract (thedrive.com) 36
Earlier The Drive reported a police chief "had to direct his staff to disconnect the power cords from Flock cameras in Plymouth, Minnesota after Flock Safety ignored and failed to respond to the department's notice the city was canceling its service.
"But in other instances Flock's gone and reinstalled cameras without permission," The Drive reported this week: On September 29th the city of Dayton, Minnesota posted a community update on its Facebook page alerting residents that Flock had installed and put into service two cameras against the City's direction without authorization... "The City notified Flock on September 18, 2026, that the program was on hold, and no work orders were to be completed. Unfortunately, the City's direction was not followed, and the camera was placed back into service without authorization." The statement continued and noted, "Following the report, City staff reviewed locations throughout the community to determine whether any additional cameras had been reinstalled, and one additional location was identified. The Police Department has been notified, and both cameras will be removed promptly...."
The Minnesota cities of both St. Paul and Crystal told Kare 11 that they removed the Flock cameras themselves following their respective city council votes in August and September respectively. The cameras are stored and are still waiting to be picked up by Flock. Crystal Chief of Police Pete Underthun told Kare 11, "Once we made this decision, I personally went to the locations and removed the cameras and poles myself." Chief Underthun noted, "We are still working with the company to close out our contract and for them to pick the cameras up from our garage."
"But in other instances Flock's gone and reinstalled cameras without permission," The Drive reported this week: On September 29th the city of Dayton, Minnesota posted a community update on its Facebook page alerting residents that Flock had installed and put into service two cameras against the City's direction without authorization... "The City notified Flock on September 18, 2026, that the program was on hold, and no work orders were to be completed. Unfortunately, the City's direction was not followed, and the camera was placed back into service without authorization." The statement continued and noted, "Following the report, City staff reviewed locations throughout the community to determine whether any additional cameras had been reinstalled, and one additional location was identified. The Police Department has been notified, and both cameras will be removed promptly...."
The Minnesota cities of both St. Paul and Crystal told Kare 11 that they removed the Flock cameras themselves following their respective city council votes in August and September respectively. The cameras are stored and are still waiting to be picked up by Flock. Crystal Chief of Police Pete Underthun told Kare 11, "Once we made this decision, I personally went to the locations and removed the cameras and poles myself." Chief Underthun noted, "We are still working with the company to close out our contract and for them to pick the cameras up from our garage."
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: Grammar (Score:2)
Wow (Score:5, Insightful)
Police actually listening to what citizens want.
Re: (Score:1)
NACAB.
Re: (Score:1)
The National Association of Chinese American Bankers?
Re: (Score:1)
Police actually listening to what citizens want.
Yes. In one city.
One battle.
But I'll believe they're actually listening when they start treating repeat violations as they should. Arrests would be made if a private citizen was caught putting cameras back up over and over again. And I mean Flock executive arrests. To drive the point home.
Flock-a-mole games, is not how we win this war. Neither is Axon whack-a-name games.
Re: (Score:2)
"Flock Off!"
Apropo!
What a Cluster Flock.
This is proof of who the real customer is (Score:5, Insightful)
So, if they are putting up cameras without permission / without contracts then it shows clearly (as if we didn't already know) that even their supposed customers (the police depts) are just a means to an end - to get that data for the REAL customers - which I am sure are big gvt and data brokers
We live in the stupidest / shittiest timeline.
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
So, if they are putting up cameras without permission / without contracts then it shows clearly (as if we didn't already know) that even their supposed customers (the police depts) are just a means to an end - to get that data for the REAL customers - which I am sure are big gvt and data brokers
And if the request for data was via an NSL or FISA court order, Flock could be ordered to not even admit that they are doing it. Perhaps the local police departments should require Flock to issue an aggregate NSL report in the contract.
Re: (Score:1)
Your post is silly. The cameras were always a means to an end, to get money. That one city didn't want to participate is irrelevant in their cross country network. The value is in the coverage, not the locality. Saying "I have cameras in New York" is profitable when you are talking to police in Philadelphia as well.
No doubt they have other customers as well, but to split them into "real" and "non-real" is just silly.
That's bold. (Score:5, Interesting)
So are these cities going to cite them for a few hundred counts of trespass?
I'm pretty sure I can't just go climb up on traffic light support arms and install my own cameras without some kind of legal authority - why can these guys?
Re:That's bold. (Score:5, Insightful)
Flock cameras are often installed on dedicated poles.
I would keep the cameras until Flock identified, under oath, the customer that wanted the cameras reinstalled.
Re: (Score:2)
"Flock cameras are often installed on dedicated poles."
Who owns those poles and the land those poles are installed on? The cameras may be installed with flock-owned nuts and bolts, so what?
I would hold a company criminally liable, I would insist on knowing who in the company had jail coming.
Re: That's bold. (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Every time I see one of those poles I think of Cold Hand Luke.
Re: (Score:2)
"why can these guys?"
money and power, if you did the same there would be consequences.
Re: (Score:3)
Oh you and I would be sitting in jail if we installed something on city property after being told not to.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: That's bold. (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Because you didn't get the local police department to agree to ToS which one party can change on a whim to say whatever they want after you initially agreed. I have no idea what their ToS actually state and I'm not sure anyone in the police departments do either. Who wastes the time to read what I imagine is 20+ pages of legal documents written to be
New customers? (Score:2)
Could be that someone else has entered into a contractual agreement with Flock. And Flock might be covered by utility franchise agreements for access to the right-of-way. Now its an interstate commerce issue. Have fun messing with that (particularly with the current administration).
Network Value (Score:5, Insightful)
Flock knows that their value comes from a large network. This is why their public outreach on ALPRs being equivalent to someone just seeing you in public rings so hollow. Having an large searchable network of historic lets people know is different in knowing where someone is that just happening across them at the grocery store.
They are selling the value of the network, even if they try to convince people on the constitutionality on the individual sensors.
Re: (Score:1)
AI allows drawing conclusions from mass movement information, it is beyond just someone's location, it would allow predicting market moves based on movement of groups of people.
This is not just about following any one person, this is about information movement, following a group of people who work on the same project for example to understand when they are going towards the same site / goal. This is beyond dangerous.
3-letter agencies (Score:2)
Those locations were being actively used for surveillance, possibly even installed by them.
Give a deadline to pick up the abandoned cameras (Score:2)
Criminalize the conduct. (Score:3)
Have to be careful not the criminalize people legitimately using things like ring cameras (maybe), but companies have been writing off fines as a cost of doing business for too long. Start threatening to put CEOs in jail for the actions of their company. Have a list of alternative titles or role descriptions for companies that try to skirt the law by having a Chief of Hanging Loose Officer.
Time for some jail time yet? (Score:3)
Seems a pretty simple solution to this stupid seeming "issue".
And? And? And THEN what do you DO?!? (Score:2)
"But in other instances Flock's gone and reinstalled cameras without permission"..
If a private citizen just started slapping up cameras all over the place on property they do not own or control, they would be violating obvious laws and be facing fines at a minimum. Repeated offenses every day or week would be facing more than that.
That would be after the violating hardware is immediately removed by every means necessary by those enforcing the fucking law, at your expense.
Go ahead, law enforcers. Tell me WHY you are not doing that with this. You pretend to care about privacy, and yet yo