NASA Seeks Proposals for Reboosting the Hubble Space Telescope (arstechnica.com) 24
The Hubble Space Telescope "will plunge back into the atmosphere in the early-to-mid-2030s," reports Ars Technica.
So now NASA has released a Request For Information (RFI) "asking commercial companies for ideas on how to reboost, service, or a controlled disposal of Hubble." Specifically, NASA is looking for information about companies' current and near-term capabilities for capturing Hubble and boosting it to an altitude of at least 373 miles (600 km), enhancing the telescope's performance, or guiding Hubble to a controlled reentry. "The requirement includes that the boost and/or servicing mission must not harm the HST and that this mission is expected to occur by 2032," NASA wrote in the RFI. The contractor would be responsible for providing the launch vehicle, servicing spacecraft, mission operations, and "crew if applicable."
NASA is not committing to buying a Hubble rescue mission, but officials want to know who might be interested in mounting such a mission, how much it would cost, and which companies would have a realistic shot at reaching Hubble before it falls out of orbit and burns up on reentry. Orbital dynamicists currently predict that it will likely happen in 2033 or 2034 without intervention, but reentry forecasts can change based on solar activity... A reboost to NASA's requirement of 373 miles (600 km) would likely keep Hubble in orbit for at least 25 more years.
"NASA last raised the orbit of Hubble in 2002," the article points out, "when the Space Shuttle Columbia visited the observatory for a servicing mission." The final shuttle servicing flight in 2009 did not reboost the telescope's orbit, and with the retirement of the shuttle fleet two years later, Hubble has steadily lost altitude with no way to stave off eventual destruction... NASA's newer flagship observatories, sometimes described as successors to Hubble, are not actually one-for-one replacements. Hubble is tuned to observe the Universe in visible and ultraviolet light, while the Webb and Roman telescopes peer deeper into the infrared Universe. Astronomers will likely have to wait for the launch of NASA's Habitable Worlds Observatory in the 2040s for an improvement on Hubble's visible and ultraviolet vision.
So now NASA has released a Request For Information (RFI) "asking commercial companies for ideas on how to reboost, service, or a controlled disposal of Hubble." Specifically, NASA is looking for information about companies' current and near-term capabilities for capturing Hubble and boosting it to an altitude of at least 373 miles (600 km), enhancing the telescope's performance, or guiding Hubble to a controlled reentry. "The requirement includes that the boost and/or servicing mission must not harm the HST and that this mission is expected to occur by 2032," NASA wrote in the RFI. The contractor would be responsible for providing the launch vehicle, servicing spacecraft, mission operations, and "crew if applicable."
NASA is not committing to buying a Hubble rescue mission, but officials want to know who might be interested in mounting such a mission, how much it would cost, and which companies would have a realistic shot at reaching Hubble before it falls out of orbit and burns up on reentry. Orbital dynamicists currently predict that it will likely happen in 2033 or 2034 without intervention, but reentry forecasts can change based on solar activity... A reboost to NASA's requirement of 373 miles (600 km) would likely keep Hubble in orbit for at least 25 more years.
"NASA last raised the orbit of Hubble in 2002," the article points out, "when the Space Shuttle Columbia visited the observatory for a servicing mission." The final shuttle servicing flight in 2009 did not reboost the telescope's orbit, and with the retirement of the shuttle fleet two years later, Hubble has steadily lost altitude with no way to stave off eventual destruction... NASA's newer flagship observatories, sometimes described as successors to Hubble, are not actually one-for-one replacements. Hubble is tuned to observe the Universe in visible and ultraviolet light, while the Webb and Roman telescopes peer deeper into the infrared Universe. Astronomers will likely have to wait for the launch of NASA's Habitable Worlds Observatory in the 2040s for an improvement on Hubble's visible and ultraviolet vision.
Exodus (Score:3)
It might be too soon but the Exodus Technologies third-order Coulomb devices (IIRC) are built for this kind of very low impulse long duration lifiting.
Getting a rig up there to clamp on to the Hubble is probably the hard part of the project.
High-impulse propulsion is more likely to damage it than low and slow.
Re: (Score:3)
While I'd love imaginary propulsion tech to be our saviour here, you know that Hubble exists outside a lab, right?
"Peer Review and Scrutiny: While showcased at venues like the Electrostatics Society of America, APEC, and technical discussions, the claims sit well outside conventional physics consensus, and full peer-reviewed validation is pending"
Re: (Score:3)
Yay another perpetual motion machine!
If you hand me a working reactionless thruster[*] I can hand you back a perpetual motion machine. If you don't believe in free energy then you cannot believe in reactionless drives either[+].
[*]more efficient than a photon rocket.
[+]Well for certain values of "you". There are some people here who will just screech invective when presented with basic physic, so it turns out a person can continue to believe hi angel'o'sphere
Surely Starship can launch something better ? (Score:1)
Re: (Score:3)
launch something better
What's better? We did launch something better, but it's worth noting that this better thing took us 30 years to build. Even the hubble mirror alone took 8 years to build... and they fucked that one up.
Re: (Score:1)
- Removing the need to optimise for weight makes it a lot easier.
- There is a mirror waiting:
https://www.spacegroup.no/we-thought-hubble-was-one-of-a-kind-with-its-2-4-meter-mirror-but-an-american-agency-kept-two-others-under-tarps-for-years/
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
NASA isn't allowed to "launch something better, cobbled together with modern tech", they can only do what the herd of technophobic lawyers in Congress allow them to do. Unfortunately they put a far, far higher priority on killing people around the world than advancing our species into the future.
2025 Pentagram budget - $750 billion
All NASA budgets since creation combined, including Apollo - $650 billion
2025 Space Farce budget - $32 billion
2025 NASA budget - $25 billion
This is why we can't have nice things.
Re: (Score:2, Interesting)
Unfortunately they put a far, far higher priority on killing people around the world than advancing our species into the future.
I so wish we lived in a perfect world where military spending wasn't necessary. But, sadly, we don't. Has the US military always been used in the best way? Of course not. But sadly it's been far better than the way near pier countries have done so. Or even the historic dominant militaries of the past.
This is why we can't have nice things.
It's ironic that you complain about the military while using the internet; which is based on the work done by the US military when it developed ARPANET sixty years ago. Or that you are complaining about NASA fu
Re: (Score:2)
It's ironic that you complain about the military while using the internet; which is based on the work done by the US military when it developed ARPANET sixty years ago.
And the web was invented by civilians working on basic science research.
Food preservation
People have been working on food preservation for millennia. Refrigeration via artificial means (i.e. not using natural ice) was invented by civilians (one cycle even invented by Einstein). Freeze drying apparently is very old, since you can do it in ve
Re: (Score:2)
lol oops trying to avoid the lameness filter which hates the Nahtzees. We all know who invented the modern highway!
Apparently slashdot doesn't like mention of the third empire, Nahtzees or Hartler.
Re: (Score:2)
Reagan and Stockman made much of the 'multiplier effect' to justify their bloated military spending, but actually NASA has the highest multiplier effect of anything the US gov't does, something like 7 to 1. This would indicate NASA's R&D generates enough in taxes that they actually **MAKE MONEY** off the organization. Gerard O'Neil's university class did a study in the late '70s and found, to everyone's astonishment, that just the taxes of the advances in telecommunications generated by the space prog
Re: (Score:2)
By all the gods, conservatives are the biggest frelling cowards on the planet. We spend more than the next ten countries COMBINED, eight of which are our frelling ALLIES, and it's still not enough to calm their fears of the boogieman under the bed.
The US military has two uses currently, as a protection racket for multinational corporations and dictatorships which reward our high officials sufficiently and as mercenaries against the powerless who attempt to resist them.
Slow tow to a lunar orbit on the far side (Score:2)
Surely Starship has the capacity to launch something better, cobbled together with modern tech without the need to optimise for weight ( Hubble weighs 10 tons, Starship can lift about 100 tons to LEO ) ?
Its still cheaper to use what is already up there.
Have a slow tow to a lunar orbit on the far side. That might be the cheapest way to get something there. Better than a deorbit if at all functional.
Re: Surely Starship can launch something better ? (Score:1)
Maybe we could ask China for help (Score:2)
It'd be a sneaky way to learn more about their grappler satellite too. https://www.twz.com/44054/a-ch... [twz.com]
Man, now I want to re-watch Outlaw Star...
Re: Maybe we could ask China for help (Score:1)
Swift orbit boost failed ... (Score:4, Informative)
Last August, NASA's contracted a company to boost the Swift space telescope.
But the rescue mission had control and positioning problems, and the whole thing was called off [slashdot.org].
I hope that another mission succeeds for Hubble (and perhaps Swift?)
Re: (Score:3)
The second try should have a better chance of success.
The other question is whether just boosting the altitude is enough. Does Hubble need a full service call? In other words do they need a manned mission to fully refurbish gyros and whatever else?
As long as we're boosting orbits... (Score:2)
Why not boost the ISS instead of de-orbiting it? Is it because it's just too old to keep safe for human habitation, regardless of what orbit it's in?
Re: As long as we're boosting orbits... (Score:3)
They boost the ISS every few months. It would come back by itself in a year or two if they stopped.
The reason to stop is that it is wearing out. Corrosion and cracks keep cropping up.
Re: (Score:2)
The ISS is old and worn out. It is getting to the point where it would take more to keep it going than to just let it crash at Point Nemo and consider rebuilding another one. The ideal would be to replace the modules with new ones, but nations are not cooperating with each other as they used to, so having a Russian module replaced isn't going to happen anytime soon.
Should we do another Shuttle program? (Score:2)
The Space Shuttle program had its limitations... pretty much a high Earth orbit (geosync), but it was able to do well enough to work with satellites, including grab one, and fix it. This won't replace the larger rockets, but it gives a reusable lander, and a way to pluck stuff from orbit and take it back to earth. For example, it may be a lot cleaner to have samples from an asteroid placed in an orbit and plucked out than it would be to have them survive re-entry.
I wonder if that program should be restart
Just make a call to Elon (Score:2)
He can fix this in the blink of an eye.
If we built a large wooden badger... (Score:2)