Itch Is Being Flooded By AI-Generated Garbage (aftermath.site) 66
The number of game pages being created per-day on Itch has doubled, the indie games site announced Saturday on Bluesky. When asked why, they responded: "take a guess."
As the gaming news site Aftermath puts it, "the surge has been almost entirely down to AI-created garbage racing onto the platform as the popularity of vibe-coded theft, copycats and machine-built slop explodes." Back in 2024, when the spectre of AI-'created' video games was still in its infancy, indie platform itch.io decided that the best it could do to combat this growing threat was, like Valve has done with Steam, institute a voluntary 'AI' filter when adding new projects to the site. By November 2026, as itch buckles under the weight of new AI-generated 'games' pouring onto the site, that filter is proving about as robust as a wet paper bag.... Shopfronts are being deluged by this shit, and it's making it a terrible user experience for customers.
And while in Valve's case there's a compelling case for stronger human moderation of the store, I'm not sure that's a viable option for a relatively tiny, community-run platform like itch... [A]t time of writing I visited the latest releases section and there was still a huge number of clearly AI-generated titles (or titles making extensive use of AI in their visual assets) which made no use of itch's voluntary tag system.
The issue here isn't that these games are making money--itch themselves say in a reply that while the number of projects listed has doubled, "the number of downloads and purchases has not"--it's that an inability to combat this surge makes the site worse for every single person using it. It gets harder to find real games, for example, and it also makes the shopfront look like a clearance rack.
As the gaming news site Aftermath puts it, "the surge has been almost entirely down to AI-created garbage racing onto the platform as the popularity of vibe-coded theft, copycats and machine-built slop explodes." Back in 2024, when the spectre of AI-'created' video games was still in its infancy, indie platform itch.io decided that the best it could do to combat this growing threat was, like Valve has done with Steam, institute a voluntary 'AI' filter when adding new projects to the site. By November 2026, as itch buckles under the weight of new AI-generated 'games' pouring onto the site, that filter is proving about as robust as a wet paper bag.... Shopfronts are being deluged by this shit, and it's making it a terrible user experience for customers.
And while in Valve's case there's a compelling case for stronger human moderation of the store, I'm not sure that's a viable option for a relatively tiny, community-run platform like itch... [A]t time of writing I visited the latest releases section and there was still a huge number of clearly AI-generated titles (or titles making extensive use of AI in their visual assets) which made no use of itch's voluntary tag system.
The issue here isn't that these games are making money--itch themselves say in a reply that while the number of projects listed has doubled, "the number of downloads and purchases has not"--it's that an inability to combat this surge makes the site worse for every single person using it. It gets harder to find real games, for example, and it also makes the shopfront look like a clearance rack.
Everything is now (Score:3)
Re: (Score:3)
The internet is pretty much dead yeah. It's crazy how everything is dying so quickly now. All the quirky websites I used to visit regularly have gone under in the last 12 months. I guess AI megacorps just killed the golden egg goose. But luckily they have a copy of everything that is now disappearing, so that they can sell it again to us mediated by their LLMs.
Re: (Score:2)
"It has more actual users than ever," bots and refrigerators are not actual users... you know that right?
Re: (Score:1)
I think maybe their pointing out the paradox that usage has only ever gone up and more than ever people are spending more and more time online vs other things. Is it an endless scroll? Are they actually interacting or just viewing? So saying "the internet is dead" is odd because any walk around town will show that everyone is glued to their screen. If the internet is dead, what are they doing? I think the answer is they're contributions have increased, but bots have moved 10x so that volume is drowned
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
you maybe right, even on the intelligence scale.
Re: (Score:2)
as a parent of gen-alpha, this trend may have run its course.
Re: (Score:2)
Re:Everything is now (Score:5, Insightful)
Re: (Score:2)
The ironic thing is the most egregious use of AI image slop is consumed and created by the older "boomer" generations. Look on say Nextdoor and they use it for everything.
It's an ironic twist that today I would say we need restrictions on the internet to protect the generations that 20-30 years ago said we need restrictions to protect the children. Their minds have been crushed by Facebook and ChatGPT more than the zoomers have been.
Re: Everything is now (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
We're going to go back to a model where we only trust word of mouth, because any other way of discovering things is too fraught.
The clever way to technically enable this would be through a cryptographically backed web of trust layer which could be applied to the top of web browsers, news readers, and email clients to provide trust scores.
There seems to be little interest in providing this. There's no money in it since nobody will trust such a system if it's monetized. So the community will have to do it. I
Re: (Score:2)
Ummm, it will only be dead as a propaganda platform. I have numerous uses of the Internet that do not revolve around "the web" or gacha games.
I would go so far as to argue that your main premise is wrong. Most people use the Internet for communication purposes: their bank, placing orders, etc. This AI garbage may dance all around all of that and make some communication harder, but those base needs will still be fulfilled regardless of AI. Which means, that AI is not going to kill the Internet; at most, it w
Re:Everything is now [AI slop] (Score:2)
You say that like you think it's a bad thing. That has already happened.
How about? (Score:3)
But from the article I get an idea what it is about.
Why don't they insist a new game needs to be totally free for, say, the first month, once it has proven itself as bona fide the publisher can charge money of include advertising.
Re: (Score:3)
I believe AI sloppers use Itch as a referencing platform, they don't really care if the "game" is downloaded or not. They're on Itch so they can make their slop seem legit. Probably earning some money from clicks and exposure somehow, not sure how the "business model" works tbh
Gatekeeping (Score:5, Interesting)
The whole schtick of Itch.io was that it had less gatekeeping than Steam, so if Steam has an issue with the flood of AI slop, Itch has an even bigger issue.
Re:Gatekeeping (Score:4, Insightful)
It's more of a quality issue. An AI generated game could be good, it's just that because the barrier to entry is so low now, literally just type a prompt and then complain about the things that don't work right, that people with lame ideas and copycats are not dissuaded by the effort required.
I'm not so sure (Score:4, Interesting)
I don't think you can make a good game with AI. The guys who made super meat boy spent months manually tweaking the gameplay mechanics to make it feel good.
Human beings are just too analog and complex. You are not going to be able to tell a computer to make something fun and it's going to do it. Now what you can't do is point a computer at something that is already fun and it can copy it but that's just going to be a pale imitation.
It's like all this Sonic the hedgehog rip off games from the '90s. They were all pretty terrible. The best AI can do is make Bubsy.
Re:I'm not so sure (Score:5, Insightful)
Using AI is a wide spectrum.
You can easily use AI to make great video games, just like you can use AI to write any other software. Just like you can use intellisense for code completion and still make great video games.
The thing that determines if a product is great is the people involved in the process who understand the business case, the expected work product, and the spirit of the goal. So I'm 100% for a game company using AI to help it write code and create the building blocks of a game. Like any product code needs reviews, graphics need tweaked, the software needs to be tested and product tested.
So yes, if you one shot a game with AI and do no testing or tweaking it's going to be shit. If you use it appropriately like any other tool you can accelerate your deliverable and make fine products.
I think we will see some games crafted with love that leveraged AI for the parts that are less interesting. For example someone with talent in graphic design and writing who has a wonderful idea for a turn based RPG, but isn't sure how to make Unity work leverages AI to turn that story and art into something fun. It would be great if everyone could find people who believed in their ideas and worked with them, but often all you find are people who tell you nothing will work. Sometimes you have to go it alone and AI is making that easier.
Re: (Score:2)
Isn't having AI write a computer game a bit like teaching your sub-average IQ cousin to do everything FOR you instead of just doing it yourself? Only with more hallucinations and forgetting things...
Re: I'm not so sure (Score:2)
Yes, but the cousin also doesn't need sleep and can produce a lot of work
Re: (Score:2)
It makes you a bit more a manager. Just think about when you're building a computer game without AI. You probably look for someone doing the graphics for you, because most coders are not good at creating graphics (and freeware games often show that). Yeah, the person is doing everything FOR you when it comes to graphics. But does it make the game worse, because not every contributor has every skill that contributes to the game?
You could now argue about "is it your game?!?!?!" but in many cases I do not care
Re: (Score:2)
There isn't a single game publisher on the planet that is thinking about AI like that. They want AI to build the entire game so they can fire their staff.
Almost all of the cost of making these big AAA games is the staff that make the game because well of course it is it's art.
We all know the goal is to replace all the artists with bots that generate slop for us to pay for
Re: (Score:2)
We can move goal posts all we like. All modern companies writing software are using AI. My company is heavy in AI use and we are opening more positions not less. The problem is that these new roles are for much more senior engineers simply because the need for entry level engineers is being replaced by AI. The bigger question is how do you train new senior engineers.
Slop companies were making slop before AI, they are going to continue. There is a huge market for it. Just like spam, scammers, and all other s
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
"I don't think you can make a good game with AI."
That sentence is underspecific. If you mean "You cannot make a good game in one prompt" you're certainly right. Counter example for this overly broad sentence: I could instruct an LLM to write exactly the code I would type manually.
For real applications you of course do not use the LLM only as typing assistant, but as coding assistant. Here the things meet in the middle: The human knows the direction, the LLM writes the code. One prompt won't get you a good n
Re: Gatekeeping (Score:1)
Re: (Score:3)
I hear that some of the AI generated ports to retro machines are as good as the originals.
Re: (Score:2)
90% of game developers are using coding agents.
Cite examples? Any game that's been released since 2022 that you didn't think was shit. It used AI, almost without exception.
Re: (Score:1)
We don't know which ones they are and that's the point. If you're enjoying a game, do you care how it was coded? Its not like game code is known for being a paragon of elite coding methodologies. Corners are cut to ship, and hacks on hacks with dubious testing are frequent.
The odds of playing an AI coded game are going to go up close to 100% until at some point we have some "certified organic" label that needs to be applied so you can tell the difference. (Or worse you can tell because it has more bugs
Re: (Score:2)
If it were just about pearl-clutching standards that'd be one thing(roughly the same slop problem for both; but not easier or harder); but if you want to serve the "I did this game jam thing, pay what you want if you think it's neat" you've got a lot of your desired and legitimate activity that would be
Fraud (Score:2, Interesting)
Re: (Score:2)
pretty sure cmdr taco never said that
Ointment? (Score:2, Insightful)
Perhaps there is some ointment that they could use for this problem?
Twitch was bad enough. But Itch? What a fucking awful name for a platform that I never heard of.
But wait... (Score:3)
What if there is an innovative, engaging game - a nearly original premise, even - that is well executed but just happens to be created using AI tools? The answer? There's no value there because within 24 hours of any inkling of success, the AI clones will hit the market.
I think Indy game development is on life support and headed for the casket. The only real barrier to this new ecosystem is what can only be found in very deep pockets, and the companies who have that are already bleeding out from different but concurrent reasons,
Right when gaming hardware is vanishing over the pricing horizon, the game production industry is throwing up all over itself.
I'm pretty glad that at 56 I no longer care very much. I have my three games I play, and I hope some updates are made, but I'm off the treadmill.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
Given the way big publishers have already made games a cesspool of microtransactions, online-only operation even for single player experience.... Retro game interest is *long* overdue.
AI slop is merely the latest 'slop' in an industry long rotting.
Re: (Score:2)
I would agree with that. The last micro transaction I purchased was - I kid you not - the WoW celestial steed. I'm not proud of it, but in my defense I didn't know what that would mean.
I have never bought another skin, cosmetic, or piece of gear for real money since. I don't buy battle passes. I bought the base game for Diablo IV and play each season, but the "Shop" is ignored.
Re: (Score:2)
Right when gaming hardware is vanishing over the pricing horizon
Today's integrated graphics are insanely good and powerful. The trick is to play games from developers that care enough about supporting good performance on integrated graphics.
You can't put it back in a bottle. (Score:5, Insightful)
Software development as we know it is ending. AI tools are 'good enough' that any idea can be made fairly quickly with even limited knowledge. This opens up a lot of opportunities for creativity and itch scratching while at the same time impacting the commercial value of software. I'm shocked the open source community doesn't see this as a pivital moment for free software.
For example, recently I wanted to play nethack on my m1 mac. I also wanted to use a tileset. Finding no good OSX arm based clients, I spun one up in a week with a custom tileset that I tweaked to my likings and even added graphical features to represent the true 'size' of items and creatures in the game.
Now I'm fully capable of building that solution by hand, it would have taken a month or two, but I would have needed to find a like minded person who knows how to build graphics and shared the same visual inspirations and goals I had. That would have probably just caused me to end the idea. Instead I scratched that itch and have been playing nethack a ton more and I'm happy. I released the code as open source so anyone who cares to can play with it.
To me that is real value and not 'slop'.
Re: (Score:2)
To me that is real value and not 'slop'.
The question is, what happens when you try to maintain it? Is it even feasible or do you just have to do the job over again? And can the world sustain every job being done over and over again with AI?
Re: (Score:2)
Well I know how to design and write software. I have well written specs, requirements, and design documents. I have strong unit, functional, integration, and smoke tests. I have design documents and requirements for all my graphics. With that I can get modern AI tools to make the changes safely and reliably to my work.
I create a github issue, AI picks up issue. I get a PR. I review PR, as needed either comment for changes, fix it myself, add a new test for behavior I need to ensure, etc. I see AI no differ
Re: How about just ask to prove the work. (Score:2)
You might think AI is a good tool, but I would still want to ban it in creative spaces.
I was early in signing up for itch.io (Score:2)
My page is still up [quakeulf.itch.io], but in a decade it's not amounted for much except for a playground for my hobby-projects. Still, it's nice to have them available like this.
Double Sites (Score:2)
Time to create segregated New Submissions and Popular Posts main page, aka Firehose and Slashdot?
future of the programming industry in general? (Score:3)
I have to wonder if gaming AI slop is just the tip of the iceberg. As an Old Phart I have resisted using AI to do my programming assignments. I've seen other, less experience programmers rocket ahead with Copilot and similar tools, but it bothers me that many of them don't really understand the code they asked AI to generate. This appears to be more true of offshore programmers.
I have to wonder if at some point we'll realize that most of it is slop. By which time, the slop will be so ingrained that we never get rid of it.
Is this the real answer to the Fermi Paradox? A society progresses until AI starts writing code? I'm not saying AI will take over; I'm saying that we'll die through ineptness and lost technology.
Or maybe I'm just a luddite.
Re: (Score:2)
Is this the real answer to the Fermi Paradox? A society progresses until AI starts writing code?
"AI writing code" is too specific for becoming the "Fermi Filter", it will rather be "Humans outsourcing thinking to machines, losing the ability to think."
Re: (Score:2)
Is this the real answer to the Fermi Paradox? A society progresses until AI starts writing code?
"AI writing code" is too specific for becoming the "Fermi Filter", it will rather be "Humans outsourcing thinking to machines, losing the ability to think."
Yes, thank you! That's what I was trying to express.
Re: (Score:2)
Not all of the humans will lose the ability to think.
Some will, however, think of how to do evil.
Right now we are destroying the biosphere so some men can live lives in excess of kings.
AI is probably best seen as part of that trend, because it is magnifying it.
The humans who can think are oppressing the ones that don't, keeping them from learning to think and solving these problems.
Whether they do that with AI or not only changes how rapidly it happens, and how rapidly the climate runs away to the point tha
Re: (Score:2)
It is probably best to not ask AI to solve problems for you. Make it do drudge work, like setting up header files. Any logic that requires subtlety of thought is out of bounds for AI.
The incorrect use of AI allows lies to fly as Truth until they are challenged. With so many lies flying about, it is difficult to ascertain the Truth. There lies the real danger.
It looks like itch may need to create a process that causes enough friction to allow a human to review whatever makes it past the filter. Is it "unfair
An itchy probem indeed (Score:2)
How do you scratch it?
Gatekeep aggressively (Score:2)
Volume is not quality. Those who object can go elsewhere.
Windows Vista r3visited (Score:2)