Bill Gates Has Earned Billions Investing in Climate-Polluting Landfills, Reports ProPublica (propublica.org) 83
Environmental activist Bill Gates has "quietly accumulated a $29 billion stake in America's No. 2 landfill operator, Republic Services," reports ProPublica, in a new 5,000-word investigation. But inspectors from America's Environmental Protection Agency "have repeatedly found methane — a highly potent greenhouse gas — escaping from Republic landfills at levels above federal limits. Republic has lobbied against regulations that could make the waste industry cleaner, including by keeping organic garbage out of landfills in the first place."
While Gates has invested at least $2 billion in green companies, he's "put more than double that amount into a very dirty, old-school industry," their article argues. And Gates has increased his stake in Republic "to 38% of the company, a position worth $29 billion." While fossil fuels get most of the attention, scientists increasingly see landfills as a crucial climate issue. They're responsible for as much as a fifth of the country's emissions of methane, a highly potent greenhouse gas, studies show. Republic alone generates as much climate pollution as 3 million gasoline-burning cars each year, according to its own reports....
[Gates] has failed to make Republic live up to his own climate principles, a ProPublica investigation has found. Federal inspectors have repeatedly found methane escaping from Republic landfills at levels above federal limits. The company has refrained from adopting the ambitious emissions-reduction goal embraced by its main competitor... "It seems very likely that Bill Gates has the power to influence Republic's behavior to make it more climate-friendly, even if that costs the company profits," said Ann Lipton, a legal scholar who studies corporate governance at the University of Colorado, Boulder... Gates didn't respond to repeated requests to discuss his landfill investments, and ProPublica couldn't find any public comments he's made about them.
But the bet has proven wildly lucrative. Since November 1999, when he emerged as the owner of 5% of Republic's shares — "It's 'Garbage In' for Gates," the New York Post headline read — the company's stock price has soared thirtyfold. And Gates has personally received $2.6 billion in dividends, a ProPublica analysis of securities filings shows... A rare clue to why Gates made his foray into landfills can be found in an interview he gave to Fortune [in 1999]... To fund his plan to give away virtually his entire fortune, he said he'd given his personal money manager, Michael Larson, a simple remit: Sell Microsoft shares, buy safe, boring assets... After that initial investment, Larson progressively increased Gates' stake in Republic over the years that followed. [On behalf of the Gates Foundation] Larson would also acquire a small chunk of Republic's main competitor, Waste Management.
Methane emissions weren't a major focus of climate activism until years later The gas can trap 80 times more heat than carbon dioxide in the near term, and it's responsible for one-third of the global warming we experience today, according to the United Nations Environment Programme. But it also breaks down much more quickly, turning into CO2 and water vapor in about a decade — which means that cutting methane emissions now would reduce that warming within our lifetimes. This is especially urgent, scientists say, as the climate approaches tipping points that could doom rainforests, coral reefs and ice sheets.
While Gates has invested at least $2 billion in green companies, he's "put more than double that amount into a very dirty, old-school industry," their article argues. And Gates has increased his stake in Republic "to 38% of the company, a position worth $29 billion." While fossil fuels get most of the attention, scientists increasingly see landfills as a crucial climate issue. They're responsible for as much as a fifth of the country's emissions of methane, a highly potent greenhouse gas, studies show. Republic alone generates as much climate pollution as 3 million gasoline-burning cars each year, according to its own reports....
[Gates] has failed to make Republic live up to his own climate principles, a ProPublica investigation has found. Federal inspectors have repeatedly found methane escaping from Republic landfills at levels above federal limits. The company has refrained from adopting the ambitious emissions-reduction goal embraced by its main competitor... "It seems very likely that Bill Gates has the power to influence Republic's behavior to make it more climate-friendly, even if that costs the company profits," said Ann Lipton, a legal scholar who studies corporate governance at the University of Colorado, Boulder... Gates didn't respond to repeated requests to discuss his landfill investments, and ProPublica couldn't find any public comments he's made about them.
But the bet has proven wildly lucrative. Since November 1999, when he emerged as the owner of 5% of Republic's shares — "It's 'Garbage In' for Gates," the New York Post headline read — the company's stock price has soared thirtyfold. And Gates has personally received $2.6 billion in dividends, a ProPublica analysis of securities filings shows... A rare clue to why Gates made his foray into landfills can be found in an interview he gave to Fortune [in 1999]... To fund his plan to give away virtually his entire fortune, he said he'd given his personal money manager, Michael Larson, a simple remit: Sell Microsoft shares, buy safe, boring assets... After that initial investment, Larson progressively increased Gates' stake in Republic over the years that followed. [On behalf of the Gates Foundation] Larson would also acquire a small chunk of Republic's main competitor, Waste Management.
Methane emissions weren't a major focus of climate activism until years later The gas can trap 80 times more heat than carbon dioxide in the near term, and it's responsible for one-third of the global warming we experience today, according to the United Nations Environment Programme. But it also breaks down much more quickly, turning into CO2 and water vapor in about a decade — which means that cutting methane emissions now would reduce that warming within our lifetimes. This is especially urgent, scientists say, as the climate approaches tipping points that could doom rainforests, coral reefs and ice sheets.
Re: (Score:3)
Why, I can feed my food leftovers to my pigs and then eat the pigs. Circular economy in the EU or, as known elsewhere, ATM.
Re: (Score:2)
You can also make babies and eat them.
Re: (Score:2)
Is that what you do? An interesting approach, but I hear it is very risky. You have to roast them thoroughly.
Re: (Score:2)
With beef prices what they are I love slow cooking a pork shoulder on weekends.
Re: (Score:2)
Yes, and besides, if you own pigs, you can always feed them a corpse you don't want decomposing around.
They will go through bone like butter.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: Suggestion (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Are you a Robert Pickton follower?
Re: (Score:2)
If you want me to do any of that, you'll have to pay me to do it. Sorry, that's just how it works in late-stage capitalism. Open up your wallet and I'll put my food waste anywhere you want and switch my diet over to avocado toast.
Re: (Score:2)
If you want me to do any of that, you'll have to pay me to do it. Sorry, that's just how it works in late-stage capitalism. Open up your wallet and I'll put my food waste anywhere you want and switch my diet over to avocado toast.
If you think via your wallet, then how about "sort your garbage and your taxes will go down, or at least not go up as much?"
Re: (Score:1)
If you think via your wallet, then how about "sort your garbage and your taxes will go down, or at least not go up as much?"
Why would that happen? Landfill is landfill, no one is picking recyclables out of landfill manually. If anything taxes would go down by not recycling at all and tossing everything in the trash.
*Note: not advocating for this, just questioning why you think your taxes would go down if you (and everyone) sorted their waste. In fact they'd probably go up, most recycling activities actively cost money.
Re: (Score:2)
Why would that happen? Landfill is landfill, no one is picking recyclables out of landfill manually. If anything taxes would go down by not recycling at all and tossing everything in the trash.
Landfill is meant for stuff that belongs in landfill. It's expensive. It requires ... well, land, and needs to be managed in a very-long-term way.
Diverting recoverable trash away from landfill to recycling or composting makes economic and environmental sense.
Re:Suggestion (Score:4, Insightful)
If landfills were more expensive than composting and recycling, they would already be cutting costs by paying me to sort garbage for them because it would make them more money.
Re: (Score:3)
You have to pay somebody to haul your shit away. That somebody could be government (via taxes) or a private enterprise. And that somebody could charge you less if you separate your shit in the first place.
In the context of government, separating garbage would reduce the cost of waste management, and thus reduce the burden on the government's budget. That would translate into a better use of tax-money.
Sorry, you're not going to get a check for separating your garbage, but that doesn't mean you don't benefit
Re: (Score:2)
Unfortunately, the guy I pay today charges MORE if I sort my garbage because its not even worth it for them to send a 2nd truck or dump the 2nd bin by hand into another hopper on the same truck.
Re: (Score:2)
The companies that collect your garbage tend to have regional monopolies. They are NEVER going to charge you less. They are a business and that business is making money collecting your trash. Since the alternative is taking your own trash to the dump, most will just pay the ransom.
Re: (Score:2)
It's expensive.
It's not. Throwing something into a ditch is orders of magnitude cheaper than recycling it. That is one of the problems we have with recycling and why it's so hard to scale it up.
Diverting something away from landfill makes environmental sense, but short of subsidies or other government regulation it absolutely does not make economic sense.
Re: (Score:2)
You can't just throw garbage into a ditch. Landfills need to be zoned, financed, logistically supported, and carefully maintained in an environmentally responsible manner. Even after they're closed, for up to 30 years. That takes money. And that's why landfill owners charge for the privilege of dumping in their dojo.
The main problem with recycling is fluctuation in the market for recyclables. Sometimes you can't make a profit for awhile. Nevertheless, there are good environmental reasons to maintain a recyc
Re: (Score:2)
Until the world's economies are forced to stop treating the environment as an externalities, nothing is going to get better.
Re: (Score:2)
Landfill is landfill, no one is picking recyclables out of landfill manually.
Boy, you really don't get out much, do you?
Re: (Score:2)
This is Slashdot. None of us get out much. Having a 4-digit UID, you should know that. ;-P
Re: (Score:2)
I don't own the landfill or whatever is getting polluted by it. I don't own anything. My government doesn't own it either. Its not my responsibility to do anything about it. Try this logic again once we get to socialism. Until we do, landowners can pay me help them stop polluting each other if they want it to happen.
Re: (Score:3)
I don't own the landfill or whatever is getting polluted by it. I don't own anything. My government doesn't own it either. Its not my responsibility to do anything about it.
Your government has to pay the owners of the landfill to dump your shit there. And then you have to pay your government via taxes for the privilege. Still think it's not your responsibility?
Try this logic again once we get to socialism. Until we do, landowners can pay me help them stop polluting each other if they want it to happen.
If you think separating garbage is socialism, then you don't know what socialism is.
Good luck setting up your own waste-management arragement where a landowner pays you to take your shit away.
Re: (Score:2)
Sweet summer child, trash hauling is privatized where I live.
Me sorting trash so the trash hauler can save a buck is the same kind of corporate cuckoldry as when somebody commits fraud against a bank and I'm on the hook for it because somebody "stole my identity"
Re: (Score:2)
"Trash hauling" a.k.a rubbish collection is privatised were I live. As a commercial customer they charge less for a bin of DMR than general waste so you pay less if you sort. As a private individual, well, that's organised by the council and paid for by my taxes. They only collect general waste once every two weeks, so I have an incentive to sort. Which is good because I'd rather not waste tax money treating recycling as valueless general waste.
Re: (Score:3)
In the interest of balancing the conversation, I must concede that in some areas, the economies of recycling just don't work. It can happen due to fluctuations in the market for recycled goods, to the point that it actually costs more to recycle than to just dump into landfill. Even so, I think it's good to recycle for the sake of the environment.
Re: (Score:2)
I suppose it depends on how much the landfill charges. To avoid externalities, you need to charge enough to keep maintainance for many decades after it closes, particularly pumping and decontaminating seepage.
It also depends on what you're recycling. Aluminium fetches about $1500 per ton, for example.
But the thing is usually someone pays, the question is who and when.
Re: (Score:1)
You can always spot the boomer.
Re: (Score:2)
Because taxes NEVER go down. Ever. Government just finds new ways and trickier, convoluted ways to raise taxes. I can't wait for California to start charging us per mile but not taking vehicle weight into account. I mention this because vehicle weight is the biggest factor in damage to the roads. Your ICE and EV tanks are so much worse on the roads then a sedan. The real damage comes from the delivery trucks but since those are "business" they some how escape paying for all the damage they do.
So good luck w
Re: (Score:2)
Let's review what I wrote, with emphasis added.
If you think via your wallet, then how about "sort your garbage and your taxes will go down, or at least not go up as much?"
Nevertheless, taxes have gone down on occasion. It's just not a typical occurrence.
Re: Suggestion (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2, Informative)
Since then, his net worth has more than tripled and his foundation, the largest philanthropic organization in the world, has invested Billions $$ in companies whose practices are the exact opposite of the foundation’s supposed charitable goals and social mission.
The Gates Foundation has investments in the worst polluting companies in the US and Can
Re: (Score:2)
Exactly! Fuck Bill Gates.
Re: (Score:2)
City folks don't have gardens. I'm eating meat until I can't afford it, though given the cost of beef, that's getting closer every year.
Re: (Score:2)
Compost your food waste and put it back into your own garden.
I tried that but the neighbours complained about the smell. I've gone back to just using the toilet again.
Re: (Score:2)
I too flush my food scraps down the toilet
Re: (Score:3)
Compost your food waste and put it back into your own garden.
Composting releases the exact same amount of the exact same gasses from food waste that is released when they break down in the landfill.
The thing that is good about composting instead of putting food waste in the landfill is about land management and habitat destruction, not needing as many new landfills. It doesn't really impact the gasses.
Except where the landfill is capturing some of the methane and using it to make biofuel. Then of course your garden compost releases a lot more... temporarily, until
Re: (Score:2)
I'd suggest researching the difference between anaerobic and aerobic composting, especially the waste products such as gases.
The local landfill down the road has a huge composting complex, turning compost into soil in about 10 days. Shred it (including green waste up to trees), mix in some chicken shit for nitrogen, stick it in huge tubes (perhaps about 100'x8') with huge fans forcing air through the mix, mix in some sand and beautiful soil to sell. No methane and more carbon locked up in the soil.
Dropping
Re: (Score:2)
Forgot to add, individuals can do similar with their compost heaps, mix it right, regularly turn it over to supply oxygen and it composts fast and methane free.
Re: (Score:1)
Methane from US garbage has approximately zero influence on the weather.
You meant climate. It makes no sense to talk about its effect on the weather.
Methane emissions from US-based garbage comprises about 14% to 15% of the world's methane emissions. That does not have an "approximately zero" influence on climate.
Forced sorting of garbage into compostables is fascism, and here in Californitopia, where it is legally required, no one does it anyway.
I also live in California. I'm not being "forced" to sort my garbage, I'm just given the opportunity to do so. Which I happily do, because it's good for the environment and it helps to reduce municipal taxes when garbage is handled more effectively.
Learn to help your ne
Re: (Score:2)
No, 15% of US methane emissions; the US accounts for about 10% of world anthropogenic methane emissions.
Re: (Score:2)
"California requires all residents and businesses to sort and compost organic waste under Senate Bill (SB) 1383, which took effect on January 1, 2022.
What the Law Requires
Residents: Single-family households and multi-family complexes (5+ units) must separate food scraps, yard trimmings, and food-soiled paper from regular trash and place them into designated organic/green waste containers"
Re: (Score:2)
Forced sorting of garbage into compostables is fascism,
Fascism is forcing you to sort my garbage.
Sorting your own garbage for recycling is showing personal responsibility.
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
Sorting your own garbage for recycling is showing personal responsibility.
I see where you went wrong there. MAGAs and similar assholes do not do "personal responsibility".
Re: (Score:2)
Yeah, but they keep talking about it, so it is always tempting to nudge them and see them squirm.
Re: (Score:1)
MAGA loves "personal responsibility" as long as it's not them being "held responsible."
Re: (Score:2)
Sure. The "other" side needs to have all of it and never do anything bad. They themselves are obviously excluded from all that because they are the chosen ones or something like that. Total failure at being people with any kind of positive worth to society...
Re: (Score:2)
Agreed. At least the few ones smart enough to understand basic things.
Money Problems (Score:3)
Once you hit about a $100 million dollars it is a LOT harder to be ethical. This is not a joke, it is a fact of life.
You have so much money it is practically impossible to only use it responsibly. Pretty much the only way to do it is to pay a money manager to specifically only invest responsibly. And they each have to trust other people. But people lie.
Forget about the money and just think about dogs instead. If you own one dog or even 10 dogs you can give them a good life. If you own even a thousand dogs, I guarantee you some of them will be mistreated. It is just too much for a single mind to track, you have to assign other people to deal with it and each of them can not track more than 50 or so without hiring minions. So with a thousand dogs you probably have 20 or more people. 5 percent of people are criminals, so one of these is likely to be an a-hole mistreating 50 dogs.
This does not give the rich an excuse. Just because something is hard does not give you a pass for not being ethical. You got the money, either give it all away or take responsibility for what you do with it.
Part of being rich is making sure that the people you hire do what you want them to do, not just what they think you want them to do.
More money than you can spend is savings (Score:5, Insightful)
More money than you can invest is power.
The problem here is that once you get above 100 million you're not talking about money in any real sense anymore. It's now just raw unfettered power.
That means that the only person who would bother pursuing money past that is a psychopath that wants power without having to get it through consensus and democracy.
This is why you need wealth caps. It's what wealth taxes are meant to do. It's why we used to have a 90% tax bracket at the top. We recognized that if you let somebody have that much power they're going to use it against you because they have to. Because once you have that kind of money and power you're going to be constantly afraid of losing it to somebody else.
What's worse is people with that kind of money and power will actively sabotage the country because they need the country to be poor and weak otherwise the can't use all that money and power as leverage.
If everybody in the country had what they wanted and needed being that wealthy wouldn't amount to much. They need a large group of people who are perpetually on the verge of homelessness and starvation for that kind of money to mean something.
This is why having billionaires is so much more expensive than you realize. A lot of folks will say well if you took all their money away you couldn't even pay off the national debt.
If we took their money away we could easily pay off the national debt. That's because they keep us in debt specifically so we are in a constant state of fear and confusion that they can use to their advantage. If they can't control your access to food and shelter and the good stuff in life why would you do what they have to say?
If they were legitimate experts but Elon Musk is an investor not an inventor. Bill Gates never wrote a piece of software in his life he stole what little he had from MIT trash bins.
So it's not just that these psychopaths take all the money, they do, but they hold you back. They make your life worse so they can boss you around and tell you what to do and you'll have to do it.
Re: (Score:3)
Stupid headlines - Asleep Readers (Score:2)
Quoting the parent and agree with it "Once you hit about a $100 million dollars it is a LOT harder to be ethical. "
Once you have hundreds of millions or billions to invest, there are simply not enough companies to invest that money into.
Billionaires and billionaire funded nonprofits will own dozens of stocks, hundreds of municipal bonds, private equity, farmland and what not investments.
These "Rich person X crusader for social cause Z invested in this company which works against social cause Z" news article
He also had the patents (Score:3, Insightful)
He is not nor has he ever been a good person let alone a philanthropist. There is no such thing as a philanthropist. It's a trick the Epstein class came up with so long ago they weren't called the Epstein class...
You don't have to make the world a better place because there's all these rich men and women doing it for you so it's okay you don't have to worry about it. And if you fall on hard times you don't have to be afraid of the lack of a safety net because again there's all these wealthy people who frequent certain Islands that have your back.
And you certainly do not have to question their character or decency or ask yourself how they made their fortunes because they're doing all these wonderful things with that money.
Re: (Score:2)
Have you ever heard of Andrew Carnegie [wikipedia.org], or the thousands of public libraries [wikipedia.org] he founded and built out of his own funds around the world? There are literally thousands of small cities and towns that wouldn't have a library if it weren't for his generosity. I know; the only library in the small city I live in is one of them.
Yeah I got that propaganda in grade school too (Score:2)
Carnegie devoured the country for decades and built a few libraries and we pretend he's this great man when he was a psychopathic piece of shit.
We could have just built the libraries and told him to go fuck himself and we wouldn't have had to have decades of elevated prices from monopolies.
Stop worshiping heroes. If you want heroes go watch professional wrestling and remember what k
Re: (Score:3)
I don't think that 2,509 Carnegie libraries built literally all around the world can properly be called "a few."
We could have just built the libraries and told him to go fuck himself...
Yes, we could have, in some of the larger cities, but the smaller cities and towns couldn't have afforded to build one. His Carnegie Formula [wikipedia.org] however, saw to it that there was
Re: (Score:2)
Yea, often towards end of life, these people suddenly worry about their legacy or the God they fear. Doesn't change the shitty things they did acquiring the money.
Courting Redemption From Republicans (Score:2, Funny)
Re: (Score:2)
It must be time for my booster, I've been getting terrible reception lately.
Re: (Score:2)
All he has to do is buy their elections for them
Waste to energy (Score:2)
Surprised more landfill operators don't have waste to energy operations (downstream of recycling). It isn't perfect, but it does a lot to reduce the operating costs of the landfill.
Cleanliness (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
False, these are profitable businesses, and gas separation is not difficult.
Note the link to Republic's document, it takes you to a table that shows their landfill emissions going down substantially every year. That's because they're making money off reclamation. It just takes time to expand it.
Re: (Score:2)
Waste to energy burns the trash in a steam boiler and generates electricity from that. It reduces waste volume and mass by 70-80% so you just have to landfill the ash. It eliminates the methane problem, but of course it generates CO2.
Re: (Score:3)
They do, and the linked document (the link right before the lies about "Republic alone generates as much climate pollution as 3 million gasoline-burning cars each year, according to its own reports") shows their CO2-equivalent emissions going down consistently each year because they're increasing their reclamation investments.
I have strong environmentalist views, but I don't think the lies and exaggerations in stories like this do anything to help those causes. It's almost like a hit-piece on their own ca
Do you expect something different? (Score:2)
Even if he was entirely above board in trying to tackle environmental issues, would his actions be any different here? I am not trying to give him more credit than he is due, but getting regulations passed at the federal level to fix this isn't going to happen. Owning a controlling stake is about the only thing that reasonably could. The question is whether he has the will or the ability to lead that change.
Climate polluting landfills? (Score:2)
What, pray tell, should we do with our trash? Genuine question.
And "make less of it" is a religious statement, not an answer.
Thanks.
Re: (Score:1)
Talk to you supermarket, Amazon, and every other company you buy things from. *Tell* them to sell you stuff with a lot less packaging. Let them swap plastic for cardboard where they absolutely have to keep the packaging, otherwise stop sending it out. If they won't - STOP buying their stuff.
Oddly, I don't think you'll bother. You'll just keep consuming, and keep throwing away a large percentage of the stuff you consume. You probably won't even bother to freecycle the old stuff - you'll just throw it away.
It
I wish this was a Green/Methane power play (Score:2)
Slashdot obsessive pro-Elon site (Score:3)
Yet, there are tons of posts catering towards Muskâ(TM)s perspective in the desperate hope heâ(TM)ll retweet and drive traffic to Slashdot.
This morning, for example, there is this slam on Bill Gates and another on Amazons rocket / satellite competitor to Space X having a problem. Yet, a search of ALL Slashdot posts [slashdot.org] yields zero articles about Musk building factories to rapidly produce jet turbine power plants to generate data center electricity via the most directly CO2-emitting means possible⦠exclusively reading Slashdot for news, a nerd would believe Space X has never had a launch failure. Twitter never laid off most of itâ(TM)s staff. AIDS deaths in Africa wonâ(TM)t skyrocket because USAID was fed into a wood chipper by a gleeful trillionaire.