AI-Generated Books Confront Publishing Industry With Big Questions (theguardian.com) 100
Romance novelist Coral Hart publishes her own romance novels for the Kindle, and found a kind of superpowere when she realized "the algorithm favours those who can produce a new book at least once a month," reports The Guardian:
Hart says she knows of authors who hire more than a dozen ghostwriters to keep pace. By herself, Hart can write 10,000 words a day, but AI could help her produce many more. Since 2025 she has written 370 novels under 21 pen names using AI, earning herself "high six figures". Like any Kindle Unlimited author, she is only paid per pages read: it would make no business sense for her to churn out books that readers quickly abandon... "So, it's not taking the human out of the equation. It's taking the friction and the time and the business blocks out of the way."
One study (awaiting peer review), led by Tuhin Chakrabarty of Stony Brook University, estimates that around one fifth of recently self-published books contain at least 25% AI-generated text. Hart now teaches courses on how to use AI to produce books. Unless disclosing the use of AI becomes a legal requirement, she advises other authors not to do so because of the public response. "The minute someone discloses [AI use] they get death threats, they get called names, they're ousted," she says.... In the literary world, many people fear the tech will undercut and replace them. "I think people are very afraid of AI, and people in publishing are delusional in thinking that it's not going to overtake our industry, that their screaming on social media is going to stop it."
But the anger comes from another place, too. If large language models can spit out books that people want to read, or produce a convincing pastiche of your favourite writer, that's almost certainly because they were trained on established writers' stolen work.... Many writers oppose AI for both moral and aesthetic reasons. One group of 70 prominent authors wrote an open letter calling on the big five publishers — Penguin Random House, Hachette, HarperCollins, Simon & Schuster and Macmillan — to promise that they will "never release books that were created by a machine". The publishers did not promise. [Tess Callero, a literary agent with Europa Content, says] "...you have to wonder the reason they aren't. Is it because they see a future in which potentially these books could be monetised?"]
So where do we go from here? Will big name writers win the argument for keeping AI out of literature, or will our bookshelves and e-readers soon be crammed full of AI-generated stories? And if a reader can't distinguish human from machine writing, does it still matter?
The Guardian's author notes this new technology brings new challenges to the book publishing world:
One study (awaiting peer review), led by Tuhin Chakrabarty of Stony Brook University, estimates that around one fifth of recently self-published books contain at least 25% AI-generated text. Hart now teaches courses on how to use AI to produce books. Unless disclosing the use of AI becomes a legal requirement, she advises other authors not to do so because of the public response. "The minute someone discloses [AI use] they get death threats, they get called names, they're ousted," she says.... In the literary world, many people fear the tech will undercut and replace them. "I think people are very afraid of AI, and people in publishing are delusional in thinking that it's not going to overtake our industry, that their screaming on social media is going to stop it."
But the anger comes from another place, too. If large language models can spit out books that people want to read, or produce a convincing pastiche of your favourite writer, that's almost certainly because they were trained on established writers' stolen work.... Many writers oppose AI for both moral and aesthetic reasons. One group of 70 prominent authors wrote an open letter calling on the big five publishers — Penguin Random House, Hachette, HarperCollins, Simon & Schuster and Macmillan — to promise that they will "never release books that were created by a machine". The publishers did not promise. [Tess Callero, a literary agent with Europa Content, says] "...you have to wonder the reason they aren't. Is it because they see a future in which potentially these books could be monetised?"]
So where do we go from here? Will big name writers win the argument for keeping AI out of literature, or will our bookshelves and e-readers soon be crammed full of AI-generated stories? And if a reader can't distinguish human from machine writing, does it still matter?
The Guardian's author notes this new technology brings new challenges to the book publishing world:
- Publishers have concerns about US copyright law, "which specifies that a book must be 'human authored' and considers AI-generated text public domain. "
- The article notes high-profile books being canceled after accusations their writers used AI. But even in those cases, "Another unresolved question is if and when publishers should withdraw books," since if publishers liked it enough to make the deal, shouldn't they stand behind that judgment?
- And should there be a way for authors who want to experiment with AI to work with top book publishers? (One theory is publishing houses are afraid of alienating a handful of top writers who almost universally oppose AI.)
"Right now, to write without the aid of a machine is to swim against a strong cultural tide," concludes the article's author, noting a recurring reaction from friends who "have looked at me with something close to pity when I tell them I would never use AI to write."
Copyright says no (Score:3, Insightful)
These are commercial works derived from copyright works without the author's permission.
Better living through AI ! /S (Score:3)
Re:Copyright says no (Score:5, Insightful)
It's clever banditry, but banditry all the same. The ultimate (for now) example of our drive to use the shield of corporations to avoid the cost that our choices, and the greed that towers over our society, have come to.
If I could pay someone else - who is themselves immune from rule of law - to steal stuff, disassemble and reassemble it in such a manner that it was difficult to prove whose stuff it originally was, and then resell it myself at a enough of a mark-up to make a comfortable living, I would not feel right doing so. I suppose might feel different if I was starving otherwise... but the banditry means that someone else is starving instead.
The summary says it all: "The minute someone discloses [AI use] they get death threats, they get called names, they're ousted". Everyone knows its wrong, but they do it anyway, because it's easy. If all it took to rob billionaires of their wealth was prompting an LLM, they'd be illegal tomorrow.
Question for the Authors (Score:4, Interesting)
Here is one question which could help.
Question for the romance author: "What did you read as a teen or in your 20s?"
Follow-up question when warranted: "How did fan-fiction reading and writing influence your writing today?"
Re: (Score:2)
read? i mean even the name is stolen so i wouldnt expect much.
Re: (Score:2, Flamebait)
> The summary says it all: "The minute someone discloses [AI use] they get death threats, they get called names, they're ousted". Everyone knows its wrong, but they do it anyway,
Yup, death threats and calling names is wrong, yet they do it anyway.
Authors "stealing" is nothing new (Score:2)
These are commercial works derived from copyright works without the author's permission.
Many books use, borrow,, steal, [insert characterization here], things from previous books without permission.
"5 Great Writers Who Stole The Idea You Know Them For"
https://www.cracked.com/articl... [cracked.com]
Re: (Score:3)
Just look at the issue on Steam with legit games being drowned in a cesspit of AI slop.
Re: Authors "stealing" is nothing new (Score:2)
They could and did do that before too, only they had to pay ghostwriters/writing assistants to do it. How much there was of it depended (and will depend) on how voracious their audience is, and how tolerant they are of slop. For romance, the answer is: very.
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:1)
If it takes an author 10 years to write a book, they can write maybe 10 in a lifetime. Now they can, as said, pump out more clones in a week than there are people to read the things. The stores become overrun with AI and it becomes impossible to find the ones written by actual humans.
Anyway, reading something written by an actual human is the whole point (at least for me). Seeing someone else's ideas and how they express them. If I w
Enabling large scale theft (Score:1)
We probably shouldn't enable that further by dismissing that AI is facilitating this on a mass scale.
They go after the people facilitating mass piracy, not the individual.
Re: (Score:2)
That's a baseless argument. It's technically correct as long as an AI has been trained on copyrighted works without appropriate permission(s). It is certainly feasible to train an AI with only works that are no longer copyrighted and/or copyrighted works with permission.
Personally, I see no issues deriving "commercial works" from such sources, and it wouldn't surprise me the quality of those works was greater, subjectively, than those trained on more modern works. Given that the cost of publishing has ge
Porn (Score:4, Insightful)
So yeah I'm hardly surprised she can churn out porn for girls using AI. It's no different than AI girlfriends except men's loneliness and horniness it's exploited in a different way.
We probably need to do something about the loneliness epidemic going around but it makes people feel icky to talk about government action on that front. The right wing's only solution is to turn women back into property by taking away their right to have bank accounts and vote (especially voting since fascists don't get along with uppity women folk). The left wing for their part just pretends the problem doesn't even exist and if you bring it up they yell at you about not being owed sex or something or they go on about patriarchy... Neither side has real solutions because neither side is honestly engaging with the problem.
Re: Porn (Score:2)
And this is how we get two Trump terms. The world would have been a better place with a President Clinton or a President Harris in charge.
Re: (Score:3)
Yes, it's called not vaccinating your kids and letting them die without any repercussions.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
It's not the Republicans pushing for everyone to have a vote. That's the Democrats.
Me personally, Id' be fine with gatekeeping voting behind maybe at least an associates but a BA/BS would be better. That'd actually exclude me from voting as I only have an AS.
I definitely think it would change who and how we vote though. Probably be a net gain for society.
Alternatively, I'd be fine with a voter test before you can vote. Something simple, like who's the current president. Name one of your state's Senators. Na
Re: (Score:2, Interesting)
Because it has historically been mostly the men fucking around. To be fair to them, the worst are weak and following a primitive design reinforced by culture, born to fuck and fight, we're not born wrong, we're taught it.
And the women that do, I'd bet they are often some version of a she-male, i.e. higher level of testosterone, higher libido; doing it because they are just plain horny or some other advantage, sleeping their way to the top of some hierarchy.
The paradox is some men love the idea of a high l
Re: (Score:2)
it has historically been mostly the men fucking around. To be fair to them, the worst are weak and following a primitive design reinforced by culture
wow.
And the women that do, I'd bet they are often some version of a she-male
wow again.
First of all, point #1 is false. Infidelity is roughly a 50/50 male/female activity.
Second, you're asserting that women who want to have sex are actually men. That's super stupid besides all the other shitty things that it is. Women used to be seen as the sex with the greater sexual appetite. This whole "women are sluts" thing is a creation of religious patriarchy which you have internalized.
Re: (Score:2)
Glad I wowed you, most excitement you have had all day darling.
50/50 meh, you sure? I'll take the bet it isn't.
Guess I am considering nature, how we compare to our primate cousins. Their impetus appears to be mate as often as possible. For the girls mating is a far riskier business, they literally have to live with the consequences for the rest of their lives. The men can just go onto the next.
That said in the Jewish tradition, lineage is traced through the female, because they can tell porkies about who th
Re:Porn (Score:4, Funny)
It's mostly women complaining about the Nvidia guy cheating, but why not the woman?
Well in that case everybody assumes that she was just doing her job as a Chinese spy.
Re: (Score:2)
That Jensen guy is basically holding up the entire market through a complicated back end financing trick where he passes money between multiple companies.
The problem wasn't the affairs the problem was he was giving secrets to the Chinese government. That could not be let slide. But because he is the linchpin in a nasty financing scheme and because we refuse to regulate companies anymore so that financing
Re: (Score:2)
You should be too, when the stock market inevitably comes back down to earth they're going to take all our jobs with it.
There's less chance of taking jobs with it when the stock market no longer reflects reality in any way. The dotcom bubble burst was signified by huge amounts in investment in firms that had no path to making money drying up, taking those companies and their jobs, and other firms that supported them, with it. The difference now is that it's all smoke and mirrors - circular financing in a game of pass-the-parcel between the few huge multinationals and their shell proxies that most other companies aren't invol
Re: (Score:2)
He wasn't even doing that. He was selling to a company not on the ban list to end run around the silly export ban on nvidia chips, which is of itself shortsighted and dumb to begin with.
Mainstream publishers sell porn to women (Score:4, Informative)
https://www.theguardian.com/bo... [theguardian.com]
and
The "Absolute Degeneracy of Modern Writing" https://www.youtube.com/watch?... [youtube.com]
Funny, how there is no media push, no advocacy nonprofits, government funded programs and the usual activism to prevent ever younger teen/child readers from encountering romance books containing explicit scenes / porn.
Re: (Score:2)
Wait, a fucking VIDEO about the degeneracy of writing?!
To rabble-rouse illiterates to rise up against romance novels?
LOL I guess I should buy stock in smutty publishers, that's free advertising.
Because porn is harmless (Score:2)
Also banning books sucks. Anytime anyone shows up trying to ban books it's never for good reasons. We used porn to create an internet surveillance Network that we all just kind of don't talk about for example. Many states require you give up your ID to access parts of the internet now so that you can be tracked. They will pinky swear they won't track you but we know t
Re: (Score:2)
That's literally the hobby as you just described. Shitposting online to get likes for the dopamine hit. When you get that +5, you know you did good. When you hit -1, you also probably did good. The worse is when you get no responses and no votes at all.
Re: (Score:2)
We probably need to do something about the loneliness epidemic going around
You can't. This result was engineered. You would have to tear down society in its entirety to fix this situation.
Re: Porn (Score:2)
Something tells me you have no fucking idea what âoegirlsâ like or want.
Re: (Score:2)
According to the BBC News, apparently Romantasy is a huge market these days. They kind of sound appealing. My impression is Lord of the Rings with sex scenes. So we get hot elf fucking action but of course all from a female perspective.
It's trashy romance novels meets Tolkien.
Expressionless (Score:5, Insightful)
When I read a book, there is an implied contract between the author and myself. I believe that the author is writing something with intention: carefully expressing some thought or feeling, trying to broadcast some meaning... or at least trying to make me laugh. When you use AI to "help," it becomes a deception. You're hoping the reader won't notice that you didn't actually write that sentence, that paragraph, that chapter. Maybe a human tweaked it, but maybe a human didn't even read it. The concern is that this exchange now just becomes entertainment, devoid of intent. As long as the output appears meaningful, it may be good enough... but it becomes a sad, hollow affair. I'm deeply afraid for the future of expression.
Wait until you read an AI-assisted technical book (Score:5, Interesting)
Picked up an O'Reilly book on a technology recently and 8 chapters in, each chapter had the same generic introduction and conclusion for each chapter and nearly all sections in each chapter.
I quit reading 40% of the way through the book since each chapter was 75% added filler material and 25% content.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
Re: Wait until you read an AI-assisted technical b (Score:2)
For instruction manual type non fiction, like O'Reilly's, that's reasonable. Really, to learn anything you have to ask questions. You can ask a competent and pedagogically wise human (terrific if you have one), you can ask an AI, or you can "ask" a reference text of some kind which hopefully has the answer to your question if it fits a very specific schema and/or they anticipated you'd ask that. 2 is genuinely better than 3 here.
Re: (Score:3)
On the other hand, human editors have always changed the author's work and sometimes hugely improved it.
So for me it really depends how the AI is used. Editing and helping improve work is fine, writing the book for you is not.
Re: (Score:2)
Editing of that sort seems to be a thing of the past now as far as I can tell. I find books have more structural issues and fractures where a rewrite occurred but the author didn't quite catch all the gaps properly leading to oddities. Editing used to catch these more but it's expensive and slow and I guess publishers figure it's less profitable than churning quantity of books.
Re: (Score:2)
I mostly don't bother with books written after around 2000, except for novels that were well reviewed. The quality just isn't there for non-fiction books, I find.
Re: (Score:1)
I believe that the author is writing something with intention: carefully expressing some thought or feeling, trying to broadcast some meaning...
You don't know many humans, do you?
Re: Expressionless (Score:2)
I am slowly writing a novel using ChatGPT as the editor and fact-checker. Because even if it hallucinates occasionally, that is nevertheless useful by pointing towards the right direction. It is still me writing that book, though. And this is why it will take years to finish it - if ever.
Re: (Score:2)
Fortunately, there are a lot of books that were written prior to AI slop appearing. I've been reading the Dune series and it's pretty awesome actually. On book 4 now.
I imagine there have already been enough books written that if no more were produced, I'd find enough content to keep me busy until I die and I'm only 42.
false choices given these articles (Score:3, Insightful)
Most articles like this are providing a false choice. We don't as a culture have to either accept AI or be left behind. We don't have to worry about other countries getting ahead of use in the economy either. It is all a bunch of false premises used for pushing people to pay for something.
If you outlaw AI generated IP, you can prevent the import from other countries. You can make laws to keep things fair. As this is, it is a race to the bottom in the name of the stock market.
Re: (Score:2)
I don't disagree but how will you ever put the genie back in the bottle. Soon it will be next to impossible to tell Ai from AI-assisted from a terrible human author. I read Kindle+ as it is now called a lot, 600 or so this year, and the place is drowning is AI slop from Eastern Europe.
Re: (Score:2)
that would do away with almost the entire pulp fiction genre. Hell is there a Harlequin romance novel that isn't formulaic ? I'm not sure one would sell if it didn't hit all the right points.
Re: (Score:1)
but how will you ever put the genie back in the bottle
Nuke them. Problem solved.
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
I agree, the AI boom has been entirely subsidized and very few places have actually turned any profit from its' use.
Re: (Score:2)
Just for comparison, what's your per year page count? I manage in the 250 to 350 range most years - in the 250 pages per book range. 600 books is impressive. Of course with a uid of 6757 you probably have a lot more time available than I do...
Re: (Score:2)
retirement has been good to me.
If people knew where their meat came from... (Score:4, Interesting)
Re:If people knew where their meat came from... (Score:4, Interesting)
Amazon is turning a blind eye (Score:5, Interesting)
2. Check out the 1000 five-star reviews (sure, they're not paid for by the author.)
3. Note the handful of genuine 1- and 2- star reviews complaining the thing is nothing but AI slop.
4. Check amazon's AI 'summary' of the for- and against- reviews.
5. Note this summary NEVER mentions people complaining about the AI slop.
Re: (Score:2)
I haven't checked to see if most of the slop is in KU. Maybe those readers are just happy if the book has words in the right sort of order, and occasional punctuation marks.
Re: (Score:2)
Most of what I pick gets a 4 or 5 star review. That doesn't necessarily mean it's a great work of fiction that will still be read hundreds of years from now. It just means that if you like that sort of genre, it was a decent job. Something will occasionally get a 3 if there are lots of typos or formatting issues or really plot dead. If it is really bad, I stop reading, and thus it doesn't get any stars at all. If Amazon had a don't waste your electrons 0 star, I'd skip to the end and give something a 0 star
Re: (Score:2)
Some of those warning reviews have dozens of 'helpful' ratings, so I'm far from the only one. If Amazon won't tell us it's AI garbage, we'll just warn each other.
Just put out whatever sells (Score:2)
Genuinely creative works have always been rare (Score:2)
Thrillers follow a formula. Murder mysteries follow a formula. Romances follow a formula.
We could ask: Does it matter if it's a human who internalises the formula and then regurgitates a minor variation on it, or a machine? Twinkies aren't hand made. Why should the book equivalent be hand made? I do wonder how different AI fiction from the work of, say, a Lionel Fanthorpe. He dictated his books in one pass. About one a week. They were typed up and published. No revision, no going back. He was a meat LLM. I
Weekly Dime Novels (Score:3)
The UK and US had a 70 year run of weekly story page magazines churning out an adventure or other story every week from 1850 to 1920.
See Dime Novel - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/... [wikipedia.org]
One example is the hundreds of issues of the Nick Carter dime novels.
This is 100+ years before AI.
Re: Weekly Dime Novels (Score:1)
Soon, weâ(TM)ll rediscover the six types of conflict in a story and note that everything is derivative.
Legal requirement (Score:2)
It's certainly a legal requirement to disclose LLM usage in the UK, because if you just use a human-sounding pen name, you're making a false implied representation that you're selling a human-written book with intent to gain (profit) from it, which is fraud by false representation. The police may not want to prosecute anyone for doing anything which corporations do because they exist to serve the rich, but the law as written seems very clear.
It may also be a legal requirement to have permission from the aut
Re: (Score:2)
You're putting a lot of weight on the shoulders of "human-sounding." I suspect it can't hold it up.
Retro content only (Score:3)
At some point people will start refusing to engage with any content created past a certain date. I've started doing it already myself. Unless something is exceptionally highly rated and I hear about it in multiple sources and personal recommendations, I usually won't watch or read anything released after 2015.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
I just bought Preacher book two from 1997.
Foreshadowed by 1980 book (Score:5, Informative)
Anyone who is fainting with shock has never read science fiction since this was foreshadowed by one of the masters of its golden age. In Number of the Beast (Robert A Heinlein, 1980) Jubal Harshaw, who first appeared I think in Stranger in a Strange Land, is a hack writer for mass market publications and dictates his stories from a lounge chair to his 3 human secretaries. A sentient AI named Minerva takes her turn. She starts out taking dictation, ends up writing different versions of the stories for different markets faster than him, and becomes a writer herself in later stories. There is no jealousy, they respect each other, work together harmoniously. Jubal does not have an artist ego instead is just writing to entertain readers. In another book, Mycroft (Mike) Holmes the sentient AI that runs the Moon, is interested in comedy while also writing political speeches for the rebellion. In none of these stories are AIs presented as stealing work from humans. If a romance pulp market is being fulfilled by terrible (or even talented) prose that is the business of the readers I'd say. But churning out endless stories with minimal human intervention to the point that human writers cannot afford to pursue a career or their art, may be a problem. We currently do not have AI authors that can write literature or even a passable manual that you don't want to stab yourself after reading a chapter, but this may change. I expect we'll need human editors a lot.
AI takes the fun out of writing (Score:4, Interesting)
I am a book author. Occasionally, I'll ask an AI for inspiration to provide a synonym or a turn of phrase when I feel stuck. It's like using a thesaurus. But I never ask it to generate substantial text. Why? Because writing is a fun, creative activity, and I am not going to hand away my enjoyment to a machine.
I also think it's important to suffer a bit while you write, trying to find the perfect phrase and place it in the perfect spot. It helps me grow as a writer.
Re:AI takes the fun out of writing (Score:4, Insightful)
AI takes the fun out of everything. I am a software developer; been writing software as a student since 1982 and professionally since 1990. I retired in 2023, just in time to avoid the soul-sucking advent of AI.
Re: (Score:2)
Deal with the devil (Score:2)
But it's a deal with the devil. And soon enough the humans won't be needed at all. Readers will just type what they want into Amazon's AI machine, it will "write" a book for them based on the prompt. No human needed. No author royalties.
Be careful what you wish for, authors....
80% slop (Score:2)
It still matters. (Score:1)
"if a reader can't distinguish human from machine writing, does it still matter?"
Yes. It still matters.
There is a relationship between an author, their work, and a reader. That relationship goes out the door when the author doesn't actually write. We need human relationships, even those as distant as author and reader, in order to function as humans. Authors change every time they write. Either because they start to see new mistakes, or learn new techniques, maybe learn new information. Every time authors h
So she's producing a book a month? (Score:2)
Using AI? In other words, she's print AI slop, that's carbon (or should that be silicon?) copies of every other one.
An algorithm that prioritizes that is one designed by a marketdroid, who wants to pump it out like laundry detergent.
I just did an actual novel in seven weeks. 76k words. And that was with a) I didn't want to write it, and b) no deadline, but a muse with steel toed boots. Then I waited, and then tood a week to edit it. Then it goes to beta readers. Then, eventually, it gets queried to publishe
Re: (Score:2)
Using AI to help is not it doing all the work (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
When you use tools such as a drill or a calculator, you know what the tool is doing. Those tools are deterministic. They're not a substitute for thinking, they just make something faster that you could do anyway with your brain and simpler tools. AI, as I understand it, is basically a black box. It doesn't always return the same results from the same input, and you don't have access to its internal logic. I don't want AI in my house any more than I want a random person, even if they are capable of doing so
Re: (Score:2)
Written by AI, huh? (Score:2)
People are really bad at detecting AI, especially normal people who don't sit with these machines every day.
I've seen them flag all kinds of ridiculous things as AI, descriptive verbs, em dashes, short paragraph breaks, commas as punctuation, lists of things mentioning other things, various types indentation, and more!
None of these things represent AI use by themselves, or together.
And nearly all of the outrage is manufactured and orchestrated by Russian disinformation bots.
There is no there there, in terms
Re: (Score:2)
It's pretty easy to figure out AI slop books. Important details change from paragraph to paragraph. Things like character names, locations, state of the world (is there a mountain in the background or an ocean), what people are wearing, what they have, etc... One book had a character fighting a snake, then it was a worm, then a snake again and back and forth even in the same sentence. At first I just through the author was trying to insult the snake by calling it a worm. A chapter later when the sunset
A good writer writes one good page a day (Score:2)