Purism Announces 'Librem 5 v2' Linux Phone with RISC-V SoC (omgubuntu.co.uk) 38
From the Linux-news blog OMG Ubuntu:
Purism is crowdfunding a new version of its Librem 5 Linux smartphone, this one powered by RISC-V rather than Arm.
Librem 5 v2 will use an octa-core SpacemiT K1 RISC-V SoC, replacing the quad-core Arm64 NXP CPU. This processor shift will provide better performance and longer battery life than the original Librem 5 and not run as hot in use. Memory is bumped to 8 GB RAM, up from 3 GB, and storage leaps to 128 GB from 32 GB. Librem 5 v2 will run PureOS, Purism's Debian-based operating system using Phosh as its UI. SD card read speeds are faster, which is handy since the device can boot a second OS from a memory card. On-board hardware encoding means the Librem 5 will be able to take 13 megapixel photos and shoot high-definition video for the first time....
"RISC-V is the future, and Librem 5 v2 is the perfect product to bring it to a mainstream audience", Jonathon Hall, CTO at Purism, says of the launch. "Freeing us from the control of Big Tech starts with the foundation, and RISC-V's foundation frees us from the oligarchy. The Librem 5 v2 puts you in control of your data, combining that with the ease of use we expect in the modern era".
Its specifications include a 5.7-inch 720 x 1440 display, hardware kill switches, and a removable 4500mAh battery, writes Slashdot reader BrianFagioli: The asking price is $1,599, with production delivery targeted for roughly May 2028.. Purism acknowledges remaining work on graphics, peripheral drivers, ARM64 app emulation, and power management. NERDS.xyz argues that the concept is appealing, but the price and wait are difficult to justify for an everyday phone. Android already uses the Linux kernel, so the appeal here is an alternative built around PureOS and the broader desktop Linux ecosystem. Is this a reasonable cost to help fund that alternative, or too much money for hardware and software that buyers cannot yet evaluate as a finished product?
Purism says they've already received 53 of their goal of 2,500 orders (2%) with 91 days still remaining. (The campaign runs through February 15 of 2027)
Librem 5 v2 will use an octa-core SpacemiT K1 RISC-V SoC, replacing the quad-core Arm64 NXP CPU. This processor shift will provide better performance and longer battery life than the original Librem 5 and not run as hot in use. Memory is bumped to 8 GB RAM, up from 3 GB, and storage leaps to 128 GB from 32 GB. Librem 5 v2 will run PureOS, Purism's Debian-based operating system using Phosh as its UI. SD card read speeds are faster, which is handy since the device can boot a second OS from a memory card. On-board hardware encoding means the Librem 5 will be able to take 13 megapixel photos and shoot high-definition video for the first time....
"RISC-V is the future, and Librem 5 v2 is the perfect product to bring it to a mainstream audience", Jonathon Hall, CTO at Purism, says of the launch. "Freeing us from the control of Big Tech starts with the foundation, and RISC-V's foundation frees us from the oligarchy. The Librem 5 v2 puts you in control of your data, combining that with the ease of use we expect in the modern era".
Its specifications include a 5.7-inch 720 x 1440 display, hardware kill switches, and a removable 4500mAh battery, writes Slashdot reader BrianFagioli: The asking price is $1,599, with production delivery targeted for roughly May 2028.. Purism acknowledges remaining work on graphics, peripheral drivers, ARM64 app emulation, and power management. NERDS.xyz argues that the concept is appealing, but the price and wait are difficult to justify for an everyday phone. Android already uses the Linux kernel, so the appeal here is an alternative built around PureOS and the broader desktop Linux ecosystem. Is this a reasonable cost to help fund that alternative, or too much money for hardware and software that buyers cannot yet evaluate as a finished product?
Purism says they've already received 53 of their goal of 2,500 orders (2%) with 91 days still remaining. (The campaign runs through February 15 of 2027)
Typical Slashdot editing (Score:3)
The price is off by a magnitude. It should be $159.90, right?
Re: (Score:1)
Only if your nick should be Anonymous Idiot.
Re: (Score:1)
Be interesting to know their cost of the bill of materials.
Re: (Score:2)
At that price, just buy them to harvest the RAM.
Re:Typical Slashdot editing (Score:5, Interesting)
Low volume product, years of development to pay off, RAMpocalypse... The price doesn't surprise me.
It's just a shame, because it will remain a niche product because of it. If you just want a decently repairable, reasonably open phone, then Fairphone is probably the way to go.
Re: (Score:2)
Triple that (at least!) for all the phone-y bits. Out of my budget but Purism keeping the lights on and paying developers to work on the software.
c.f. the PinePhone which aimed for a much cheaper price point but that company seem to be retreating with rising production costs?
The problem (Score:5, Insightful)
So the only people buying either have nothing to do with their money or are niche security devices buyers.
It's still a big market for a small team and I wish them the best of luck.
Re:The problem (Score:5, Interesting)
This is hard for a lot of people to understand, but if you're making something different than what other people are doing, and you're not a billionaire (for example, if you're taking pre-orders to fund production) then it has to be a premium niche product and will have a high price.
I've heard so many people say, "I want to start a company and make a Whatsit for the little guy!" And they don't realize, if you want to make a Whatsit for the little guy, first you have to build Whatsits for rich people so you that you can build your company up enough that you can afford to build a mega-factory with enough economy of scale that you can make low priced Whatsits. And then they call me a bootlicker, and I wish them luck on their idea.
The fact that this is a premium product at means it's vaguely possible that they'll have success and be able to make a cheap version in the future.
Re:The problem (Score:4, Funny)
This phone is exactly what all the crotchety old fucks at slashdot have been asking for.
Re:The problem (Score:4, Insightful)
This phone is exactly what all the crotchety old fucks at slashdot have been asking for.
Most of them are asking for a basic phone. This thing uses a recent octocore processor and has a high end camera. Sure some people are asking for a high end phone which is also Open, but most seem to just want a phone which does basic phone things and is also Open.
Re: (Score:2)
How much more basic do you want, a flip phone? With software bloat and a dozen abstraction layers between you and the silicon you're going to need those 8 cores.
Re: (Score:2)
Speaking only for myself, yes, I could happily use a flip phone. I would need a separate device to handle tablet type duties, but I wouldn't need to carry it at all times, and I could just use my existing phone for that. My favorite form factor was the classic RAZR.
Re: (Score:2)
Not gonna lie, I like a lot of what it offers
Re: (Score:2)
Did they ever get the Librem 5 v1 fully functional?
Re: The problem (Score:2)
This probably will be a good device for early RISC-V adopters who are interested in getting their software or the rest of software tool chain running smoothly on this architecture.
Good but a tad pricey. (Score:4, Insightful)
A FOSS RISC V device is what we need more of. This is expensive though and they don't say if they have a multi language version. What I want is a FOSS Blackberry Classic type phone for a 150 Euros. With some minimal custom Linux that I can tweak with some simple scripts. Smartphones are way to expensive anyway.
Re: (Score:2)
At that price point and low production volume, you're looking at a brick that would be a lot bigger than a Blackberry Classic.
Re: (Score:3)
The problem is what you want does not have mass market appeal which is in direct conflict with economies of scale and thus will *NEVER* be cheap.
Re: (Score:2)
Talk to some Chinese companies like Sipeed. Sipeed already makes RISC-V based KVMs that run Linux, and cost a fraction of what everyone else is charging for them. You can load your own OS on them too, no need to trust their software.
That's what you need. A company that has the connections and engineering talent and deals with niches.
Re: Good but a tad pricey. (Score:2)
Perhaps you should partner with a contract device developer in Asia, estimate the build cost, and crowd fund it? Sure, it requires effort and accountability on your part. But you can do it!
RISC-V (Score:2)
Re: (Score:1)
No, but it's ok if you're stupid and ignorant. Only firmware engineers need to know about instruction sets, and which chips have which.
Re: (Score:1)
It's getting better and so are the compilers. RISC-V is going to dominate the microcontroller market with their pricing and selection of features. As an individual I can buy CH32V chips for literal pennies. https://www.wch-ic.com/product... [wch-ic.com]
Re: (Score:3, Informative)
From a practical standpoint, while it's possible for an ARM license to be revoked, that doesn't affect the person buying/using chips. What hurts is having a access to the specific cores/implementations you are using restricted, which is far more likely on RISC-V as every vendor on tha
regression (Score:1)
Caveat Emptor (Score:3, Interesting)
I got burned by the OG Purism 5 crowd-fund. After years of waiting, and being told that they had changed their policy and wouldn't refund my money, I got an enormous brick of a phone with half-assed software. I've never been able to actually use it so it sits in a drawer.
My two cents to anyone interested in this phone is to wait until it's actually shipping before sending Purism your money.
Re: Caveat Emptor (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
How did you get burned? I'm genuinely curious if their initial marketing was deceptive.
You got your device, at least. Having to wait an exorbitant amount of time for what's basically a prototype seems to be par for the course for these things.
I wish them good luck (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
if i was sitting on a big pile of money i would buy one just for that reason
And that's the problem with this device. The target market isn't swimming in cash right now, they can't afford this. I guess it's not also a big problem that your bank app won't run on it, since after they buy it, the average person won't have anything left in the bank, but it's a lot to spend for a less compatible device.
If I'm trying to have a secure phone, I'm not going to do a lot of the stuff I do on other devices with it, so I don't need it to be very powerful. I can do that stuff with another device.
Why RISC-V? (Score:2)
The people that pay this (Score:3)
$1599 for a vaporware phone are probably the ones laughing at Apple Fan Bois for buying a $1999 Duo.
SIM (Score:2)
$1500 is not anywhere close to mass market: $500 tops.
These things don't make themselves! (Score:3)
Sure appreciate the various observations offered up that the price is high especially as compared to what the phone will deliver. Let's all just admit that while it's priced like an iPhone or Android it won't deliver a similar experience.
Given they are starting without using a major phone OS, and that from a hardware perspective doing this without blobs, I can appreciate that probably drove some design decisions and part costs.
This boils down to, are there approx 2500 people out there willing to put their money into an FOSS device to advance and make the idea real.
Re: (Score:2)
Let's all just admit that while it's priced like an iPhone or Android it won't deliver a similar experience.
What do you mean by similar experience? They certainly won't run the same software, but I know from experience that Linux in your pocket can be quite good. I used to have an iPaq H2215 which I ran Linux on and that was surprisingly decent in its day. There's no reason that this far more capable device cannot provide a worthy experience which would satisfy modern users.
This boils down to, are there approx 2500 people out there willing to put their money into an FOSS device to advance and make the idea real.
And to pay a lot! I'm in the market for a new phone, but not near that price point.