SpaceX Catches Starship On the First Try (theregister.com) 68
Over the weekend, SpaceX successfully caught a Starship upper stage returning from orbit for the first time, demonstrating a key piece of its plan for a fully and rapidly reusable launch system. The achievement means SpaceX has now demonstrated tower catches of both Starship stages, though not yet on the same flight. "Many small fixes are needed to achieve immediate reusability (like an airplane)," noted SpaceX's Elon Musk. The Register reports: Flight 15 began well, with the 33 Raptor engines of the Super Heavy booster launching the stack from Pad 2 at Starbase, Texas. Hot staging followed, and the booster performed its directional flip maneuver. Thirty-two Raptor engines relit for the boostback burn, intended to return Super Heavy to the tower for another catch. The booster had managed the maneuver on flight tests 5, 7, and 8, but this time something went wrong. "The boostback burn ended early due to low fuel mass," SpaceX said.
The booster automatically aborted its return to the tower and diverted offshore. It completed a landing burn, briefly hovering above the Gulf before its engines shut down and the flight termination system delivered an explosive finale. Starship reached orbit under the power of its six Raptor engines and deployed 26 Starlink V3 satellites. Unlike the previous flight's brief orbital stint, this mission lasted almost a day. Following a deorbit burn, Starship returned to the launch site 22 and a half hours after it left.
The booster automatically aborted its return to the tower and diverted offshore. It completed a landing burn, briefly hovering above the Gulf before its engines shut down and the flight termination system delivered an explosive finale. Starship reached orbit under the power of its six Raptor engines and deployed 26 Starlink V3 satellites. Unlike the previous flight's brief orbital stint, this mission lasted almost a day. Following a deorbit burn, Starship returned to the launch site 22 and a half hours after it left.
Re: (Score:2, Troll)
Yeah, he's an ass. (An immigrant ass, to conservatives.) But he and his company are not the same things. They are not disconnected, of course, but they are not the same things.
SpaceX has done some good stuff. The guy who owns SpaceX is a pathetic ass. We should be impressed with SpaceX, because this "catch" is just the latest in a long string of impressive accomplishments. We should treat Musk with all the respect he deserves, which is the same as the respect he gives others, which is pretty much zero
Re: Nice! (Score:1)
In other words, art and artist are not one in the same.
But like many before him, there are multiple sides. One of them does a damn good job at...all sorts of things, and continues to do so. Reminds me of something Adam Savage of mythbusters said when a fanboy asked him if he heard of Nikola Tesla: "Nikola Tesla the genius, or Nikola Tesla the nutjob?"
People who want to toss him in jail or take over his companies simply because they don't like him would be cutting off the nose to spite the face. Besides, tha
Re: (Score:2)
Ship flight nominal (Score:5, Insightful)
The booster had low fuel on return and declined the catch attempt. Did the approved alternate gulf splashdown. Overall a good show. With both stages proven catchable the road to full and rapid reuse is proven open. Spaceflight will see a significant cost reduction.
Re:Ship flight nominal (Score:5, Interesting)
One second less on the ascent is 15 seconds more time at the catch. They'll nail both catches next time.
Way to go SpaceX!
I think this amazing... (Score:3, Insightful)
Re: (Score:2, Troll)
They find out a little bit about a subject, hear about well know problems with it, and think of easy fixes for those problems, assuming their genius was what was needed to find those fixes.
Only later, do people who actually know about the subject in depth quietly point out why their insights and quick fixes are actually worthless.
Talk for a while to any grad from a "good" college or a startup founder or someone who was a young prodigy. They are all li
Re: (Score:2)
How did Musk fix AI again? I missed that part. If you mean it went full Nazi in less than 3.2 nanoseconds, yes, Grok won that contest.
Founders are a real pain in the ass. After their first few years of easy success or sometimes struggling through what should have been easy, but thinking they learned a lot, all they have is inflated egos, bad ideas, hand-waving and bullshit. The problem is they also hold political power in organizations, or just so much equity that everyone has to put up with them.
Musk pushe
Re: (Score:2)
Catching Starship is an engineering triumph. Thrusters on a car is a pretty straightforward PR stunt that's wildly impractical and isn't that impressive from an engineering perspective since we've got cheap computers that make the hardest part buying the thrusters.
Re: I think this amazing... (Score:1)
Only later, do people who actually know about the subject in depth quietly point out why their insights and quick fixes are actually worthless.
They said the same thing about sub $1,000 phased array antennas and reusable rockets. NASA even has a published document explaining in detail why it would never make economic sense. Arianne literally bet against it, while publicly mocking it, and now they're trying to make a subpar and costlier copy of it. Actually I'm personally aware of many things SpaceX has done that industry experts say it either can't be done or won't ever be practical.
Re: (Score:2)
This is the NASA that built reusable rockets right? And when were they saying what about cheap phased array antennas? The things have been around for more than a century, they've been sticking them on cars like candy for a couple decades and both your phone and your wifi router have probably have one or more, the latter for going on 20 years.
Re: I think this amazing... (Score:1)
https://www.businessinsider.co... [businessinsider.com]
https://www.forbes.com/sites/q... [forbes.com]
If I put any actual effort into it, I could likely find half a dozen more examples. But honestly? This is kind of tiring. You guys always think you're experts on this crap, and then when it comes to hindsight, you weasel word your way into pretending you were right all along when you obviously had no fucking idea. A lot of the most prominent critics of reusable rockets have since deleted everything they've said about it from the Internet inst
Re: (Score:2)
Did he fix electric cars or get lucky and decide to get into the field around the same point that energy density in batteries finally made them reasonably economical?
Re: (Score:2)
"He"* "fixed" electric cars in the commercial sense by going for the roadster which made them sexy and fast rather than starting from the Sinclair CV5 / EV1 / Chevrolet Spark
* When I say he, here, we should really name Martin Eberhard (and possibly include Marc Tarpenning) who actually started Tesla with the idea. It's worth noting that Musk moved Eberhard to the side and effectively silenced him with NDAs, likely in order to be able to claim Eberhard's credit.
Operations (Score:2)
Even worse, Boeing has been building space ships and rockets for fifty years at this point. It's not like they are amateurs. It isn't a money or expertise problem. It's a management probl
Re:I think this amazing... (Score:4, Interesting)
That sort of tracks. Both men started successful companies that were innovative in a wide range of industries. Both had some good ideas (Rotary drill bits for Hughes, Starlink for Musk) but also stubbornly held onto bad ones that turned into financial albatrosses (Spruce Goose for Hughes, Cybertruck for Musk). Both are/were womanizers. Musk has followed Hughes into fascist politics. But Musk hasn't quite gotten to the crippling mental illness stage yet. There's time left for that I suppose.
Economics of Starlink (Score:4, Insightful)
IMO Starlink has an economics problem. Twice the number of satellites != twice the revenue. Diminishing-returns limit the profitable size of a constellation. So IMO Starship will need to get serious soon about being able to handle something more than pez-dispensers launches. It wonâ(TM)t be sat-datacenters. Starship needs to be able to accommodate more customers than just SpaceXâ(TM)s own Starlink.
Re:Economics of Starlink (Score:5, Informative)
EBITDA margins on Starlink are 63% already. Huge moneymaker, which is becoming a problem for NASA since the revenues already exceed NASA's entire budget and escalating exponentially. NASA is becoming small potatoes to their only functional launch provider. The 26 satellites launched this time each carry 10x the bandwidth of previous versions so equivalent to 260 of the old birds and 10 Falcon 9 launches. The new bigger sats weigh 1/2 ton and required the bigger rocket. A fully recovered Starship launch costs about $4M for fuel, an indeterminate amount for refurbishment but nowhere near 10x the internal cost of Falcon 9 launches of $15M. The satellites themselves are mass produced by SpaceX in a factory and all-in only about $500K. The economics of Starlink are sound.
Re: (Score:2)
This was always snake oil. You're not going to get orbital power stations for anything but orbital power use.
Re: Economics of Starlink (Score:1)
60 tons of payload is 10 MW so at 80% loss you get 2 MW that works always. Several NASA studies exist on this.
Power beaming [Re: Economics of Starlink] (Score:5, Informative)
You're not going to get orbital power stations for anything but orbital power use.
60 tons of payload is 10 MW so at 80% loss you get 2 MW that works always. Several NASA studies exist on this.
Zero NASA studies have shown this. You can't do classic microwave power beaming at a 2 MW power level: the rectenna receivers are nonlinear devices, and you won't get enough power density to turn them on. Microwave power beaming from GEO really needs GW or higher power levels to make sense.
You could switch to laser power beaming (my speciality) to get a smaller spot size, but now you don't get power "always," you get power as long as it's not cloudy.
Re: Power beaming [Re: Economics of Starlink] (Score:1)
You can just research things.
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/cita... [nasa.gov] FINAL.pdf
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citation... [nasa.gov]
Laser Power beaming [Re: Economics of Starlink] (Score:5, Funny)
You could switch to laser power beaming (my speciality) to get a smaller spot size,
You can just research things.
Yes, that's what I do for a living.
...
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citation... [nasa.gov]
Did you scroll down on that far enough to read the author's name?
Re: (Score:2)
...
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citation... [nasa.gov]
Did you scroll down on that far enough to read the author's name?
Oh SNAP!
Re: (Score:3)
Not even Michael Jordan could have dunked on someone this hard. :)
Re: (Score:2)
Am I the only one who doesn't trust SpaceX not to design them such that it's possible to focus the beam?
Re: (Score:2)
Re: Economics of Starlink (Score:2)
The correct design is without the ability to focus. If they can be focused, they can be used as a weapon.
Re: Economics of Starlink (Score:2)
I think you havenâ(TM)t addressed the main question though: 5x the number of satellites != 5x the revenue. Costs go up linearly with the number of sats, but revenue does not. There is some constellation size where profit stops being attractive.
At that point, you only need Starship to replenesh old sats, not to increase the constellation size. Thatâ(TM)s true for launching competitor sats too. I conjecture those constellation sizes arenâ(TM)t that far away given Starshipâ(TM)s massive cap
Re: Economics of Starlink (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
NASA has an ace up its sleeve. If Starlink wants to keep launching from the US, they can be forced to provide x amount of launches per year and cost plus some percent.
You know it's funny you quote it EBITDA (Score:2)
And NASA isn't a business it's a government agency. I don't know what makes you think they care about profitability one way or another.
The economics of starlink are not sound. Yes the company can make money. But the problem is they can't make enough money to justify the absurd valuation of SpaceX and that's before we start talking about th
Re: (Score:2)
Yeah, when Musk talks about "Thousands of launches per year!", I have to wonder - do we even have enough stuff to haul to orbit to utilize all that?
I'm most excited about what this means for the future ISS replacement. Starship can haul some seriously large and heavy components to orbit. Considerably more than the Space Shuttle could. This completely changes what we can build in orbit.
Re: Economics of Starlink (Score:3)
Yes, exactly 100%. Thereâ(TM)s only so much demand for comms satellites and the occasional space telescope. Nobody is going to be building space factories or space hotels as anything other than prototypes for many, many years. Iâ(TM)m not seeing the demand.
Re: (Score:3)
Starship is launching larger satellites that can each provide more customers with greater bandwidth so (potentially) more revenue with the same number of satellites. It's pretty certain they'll also start deploying other types of satellites too. This was a test launch that would normally have been done with a chunk of concrete as payload.
Starlink does have an economic problem. It's hilariously uncompetitive when wired alternatives exist so most of the market is out of reach.
Re: (Score:2)
The cost per bandwidth for satellite is declining exponentially. Fiber optic deployments cost real money and take real time, the costs not improving. At the moment satellites are outpacing fiber, cable and wifi deployments by a radical amount - the entire planet was covered with no dead zones in just a few years. At some point the cost of providing satellite Internet is less than the cost of maintaining the wires in the ground. Along the way bandwidth increases everywhere, consumer costs go down.
Re: (Score:2)
Bullshit. Fibre optic technology has been improving for decades both in capacity on existing lines and capacity requiring new fibre. Meanwhile radio (i.e. satellites) are already pretty hard up against bandwidth limits and capacity is mostly being increased through beam steering, which is physically limited by the antennas. That's why Starship can launch the high capacity Starlinks and Falcon can't. AND you have the replace the whole shebang, from power station on down, every five years.
Starlink is a dead end (Score:2)
The problem with starlink is that it's always going to cost more than terrestrial services so the only market for it is places that don't have access to terrestrial services. In other words land lines and cell phone towers.
Anytime starlink starts to build up a sizable market share in an area the terrestrial services or just going to move in and price them out and that's that.
They could have had a nice thing going with military contra
Elon is a contributing factor (Score:2)
Let’s take this gentleman’s argument at face value that anyone can throw money at rockets and get something like Starship, Falcon or Dragon.
Perhaps he can explain to everyone how SpaceX is able to catch giant starships from orbit with chopsticks and deliver 85% of all Earth payload to orbit with Falcon, while Blue Origin, which started before SpaceX and was funded by the immensely wealthy Jeff Bezos, is not yet able to launch reliably?
Also, why is it that Boeing and Lockheed received several times what SpaceX did from the government for development of their rockets and spacecraft, but the Boeing capsule is still not operational and ULA delivers less than 5% of SpaceX payload to orbit?
I am genuinely curious about these questions.
Re: (Score:2)
Presumably, SpaceX got the best share of former NASA's contractors reusable rocket initiative engineers (like Tom Mueller who came from TRW) and importantly machinists. I think Blue Origin was already formed and hired up when SLI was cancelled. Blue Origin also had the bad strategy of aiming for human spaceflight first rather than commercial satellite launch. Without a revenue stream from commercial launch the amount of experience they get launching was reduced.
Re: (Score:3)
He is also the best engineering manager in the world.
Boeing was ruined by its addiction to the government teat, just like printer ink made HP rubbish, and easy credit destroyed Lehman.
Bezos runs BO like a Boeing that withdrew from the government teat, not as treacle slow as cost-plus Old Space, but not as risk-taking to be as fast as New Space.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
The booster when caught is much heavier than the starship when caught.
What is impressive about catching starship is not its mass but the fact that it descended from orbital height, and slowed down from orbital speeds while undergoing reentry and still being reusable soon after the catch.
Re:Elon is a contributing factor (Score:4, Insightful)
Spacex is doing well with engineering because it doesn't have the huge weight of Boeing and Lockheed legacy engineering processes weighing it down, for one thing. I don't think anyone can throw money at a problem and get results, I think it needs people who have the right knowledge and experience when the money is available, and the freedom to prioritize reusability over concerns like safety. Boeing and Lockheed haven't been able to retool their processes using Silicon Valley VC mentality of move fast, break things. Plus I think there's a mix of passion, youth and cult behavior at SpaceX that is working well for it. I don't think it's a good thing for the world, because Musk is a fanatic who has tied his fortunes to the worst people in the world right now, but for purely engineering purposes some good things are coming out of it. It's a shame that Musk will probably hold all those engineering patents himself, just like Jeff Bezos does.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Patents only last 20 years and often take half that time to realize their value. That means that even if the patent is the only way to accomplish something, it may be a decade or less before its use is open to the world.
Boeing's engineering process is just fine (Score:2)
Re: Actually the mission was a failure (Score:2)
I agree with the troll. Recovering the booster is far more important than the space ship, at this time.
Although WOW
Re: (Score:3)
To determine whether a mission was a success, you look at the checklist of objectives and see how may were fulfilled. Some were, some weren't. You could still call the mission a success even with some failures.
Maybe booster recovery is more important right now (to save on launch costs, like Falcon?) because it costs about $63 million to manufacture, as opposed to $27 million for Starship. But that definitely changes when you have human crew on Starship. Then you'd much rather lose the booster and recover th
Hot fucking damn (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
At the risk of feeding the troll, no they won't. Galloway's criticisms of Musk were about restricting Starlink. He wasn't resentful of the spaceflight success, he was upset that the success wasn't being used to support American allies. Crockett's feud with Musk was about Doge- again, nothing to do with spaceflight. Neither of these people currently hold elected office.
Re:democrats are going to REALLY want to end Musk (Score:5, Interesting)
This is a common difference between liberals and conservatives, in my experience. Conservatives tend to trust people. So once they put someone in the "good guy" catagory, they respect anything he does. And once someone is a "bad guy", then anything he does is awful. Liberals are usually more "trust this result" oriented. So liberals like that Musk took SpaceX and Tesla from tiny to very successful companies. They like Starlink. But they hate when Musk has manipulated Starlink to hurt Ukraine (and thus Ukraine's allies like the EU and the USA). (Yeah, Not All Conservatives, blah blah blah.)
Ten years ago, if you had asked conservatives if they would support a force of federal agents on the street, disappearing people, entering homes without a warrant, and killing citizens who threatened them with a deadly camera-phone, they would give a wildly different answer than they gave 18 months ago. Because their ideology changes with the wind, but their trust in Big Strong Man (haha) is quite sturdy.
Re:democrats are going to REALLY want to end Musk (Score:5, Insightful)
I don't know if trust/mistrust is they right term so much as in-group/out-group. They want a leader who will strongly police in-group/out-group dichotomies and that takes precedence over the details of what the in-group does or how it does it. They are ok with state power when they believe it is about policing the in-group out-group dichotomy (i.e. arresting immigrants) but not when it is breaking down that dichotomy (supporting minority rights).