Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
The Courts The Internet AT&T Advertising

Comcast's 'Fiber-Powered Wi-Fi' Is Just Cable, AT&T Says In False Advertising Case (arstechnica.com) 40

AT&T is suing (PDF) Comcast over its "fiber-powered" advertising, arguing that the term misleads consumers into believing Xfinity offers fiber-to-the-home service when most customers actually receive their Internet through coaxial cable. "Comcast should be required to restore to AT&T any and all profits earned as a result of its false and misleading advertising or provide AT&T with any other restitutionary relief the Court deems appropriate," the lawsuit said. The lawsuit asked for a permanent injunction "requiring Comcast to cease describing its hybrid fiber-coaxial service as 'Fiber-Powered.'" Ars Technica reports: While Comcast has deployed plenty of fiber throughout the US, its cable Internet service makes the final connection to homes with coaxial cable. This results in upload speeds being far slower than download speeds. In contrast, fiber-to-the-home service can provide symmetrical upload and download speeds. Comcast has deployed fiber-to-the-home in only small portions of its cable territory while advertising its service as fiber-powered in the majority of areas where cable makes the final connection. AT&T's lawsuit said that in describing its cable broadband as fiber-powered, Comcast "conveys to reasonable consumers the misleading impression that Xfinity Internet is a fiber-to-the-home service comparable to AT&T Fiber. In fact, the vast majority of Xfinity Internet runs over a hybrid fiber-coaxial ('HFC') network, where the critical 'last mile' connection to the customer's home uses copper coaxial cable, not fiber."

[...] AT&T previously challenged Comcast's fiber-powered claims through the advertising industry's self-regulatory system operated by BBB National Programs' National Advertising Division (NAD). The NAD determined in June that Comcast accurately described its mix of cable and fiber technology in a disclosure, but that Comcast didn't make the disclosure prominently enough. [...] The NAD recommended that Comcast make the disclosure "more prominent and more proximate to the 'fiber-powered' Wi-Fi claim as necessary to ensure that the disclosure is clear and conspicuous." Comcast said it would comply with the decision, but AT&T's lawsuit makes it clear that it isn't satisfied with the current state of Comcast's advertising. We contacted Comcast and will update this article if it provides a response.

Comcast's 'Fiber-Powered Wi-Fi' Is Just Cable, AT&T Says In False Advertising Case

Comments Filter:
  • by Anonymous Coward
    There must be copper paired with the fiber, I assume? Never heard of this.
    • Re: (Score:2, Funny)

      by Anonymous Coward

      This is two racoons fighting over trash. Nothing to see here, move on. Maybe squirt them with the hose if they are bothering you.

    • by Xenx ( 2211586 )
      I don't know if this is oversimplification as a joke, or honestly not understanding. Comcast uses HFC, which from what I can tell is an industry term for fiber to the node. However, FTTN is broad and HFC specifically terminates closer to the house. Fiber to the home would be able to perform better than HFC/FTTN in most cases. AT&T, I assume, is doing fiber to the home and their complaint is that customers will confuse Comcast's implementation as FTTH.
    • You think your wifi router gets its electrical power from the ISP? :D
      This isn't a princess phone connected to a land line!

      Fiber to the home (FTTH) is an optical fiber that ends in a "fiber jack" inside your home. This conveys the laser beam signal into TCP/IP over an Ethernet jack, sure, but at all possible speed. It's the most reliable, best-performing, and potentially upgradeable digital connection we have for business and residential customers.

      If the ISP runs the "last mile" through coax or phone cables,

  • by drinkypoo ( 153816 ) <drink@hyperlogos.org> on Monday November 16, 2026 @06:18PM (#66427870) Homepage Journal

    HEY EVERYONE COMCAST'S FIBER POWERED WIFI IS JUST CABLE!

    See? Nobody cares.

    Anyway pretty much all the cable is Hybrid Fiber Coax (HFC) now. They run fiber to the head end and then run coax from there. You get all the benefits of fiber to the neighborhood without the high cost of fiber to the premises. Most people will never notice the slightest difference because they won't buy the most expensive fiber plan anyway.

    • Old man shouts at sky, tells himself the world agrees with him. Nobody cares.

    • by dfghjk ( 711126 )

      "You get all the benefits of fiber to the neighborhood without the high cost of fiber to the premises."

      Not according to AT&T, they claim upload speeds suffer.

      "See? Nobody cares."

      No, you don't care. And lawsuits aren't directed to you...or the public generally. This is about money, not the customer.

      "Most people will never notice the slightest difference because they won't buy the most expensive fiber plan anyway."

      That is probably true but it doesn't justify false advertising. The lawsuit is not about

      • It's not false advertising. There's fiber involved, and Wi-Fi is faster than cable. So if the download speeds suffer, it's not the cable's fault. It's a failure somewhere else that would happen whether they used fiber or not.

        The only advertising that matters is the speed. Either they deliver it or they don't.

      • by Guspaz ( 556486 )

        It's a fairly minor difference. My understanding is that AT&T is using a mix of XG-PON (10/2.5) and XGS-PON (10/10), while on coax, DOCSIS 4.0 (which Comcast uses) gets you up to 10/6. At that point it's just about the oversubscription ratios, and not really the speeds on offer.

    • >"Anyway pretty much all the cable is Hybrid Fiber Coax (HFC) now. They run fiber to the head end and then run coax from there."

      Yep, that is very true. And Cox has ads all over also saying "fiber powered" for years. All AT&T and others have to keep advertising is "fiber to your home" and the others, like Cox/Spectrum/Comcast/etc can't make that claim.

      >"You get all the benefits of fiber to the neighborhood without the high cost of fiber to the premises. Most people will never notice the slightest

      • Well, that makes sense, and I hear that people have those problems, but I never do. My problems are all with my bill continually increasing. My provider is Optimum.

        • >"My problems are all with my bill continually increasing."

          Oh, I have that issue too. And most of it is due to lack of competition. Little incentive to innovate, be customer-service focused, or be efficient. For decades, here (and in many places), Cox has been a government-endorsed monopoly for land-based CATV and ISP.

          A few other players here have entered now, but it is going to take a while for the trend to flip around. Metrolink (now T-Mobile) is starting to heat up. Their fiber is finally on the

          • In the county seat they are getting Vero fiber. But I live in a faraway land (30 minutes away, anyway) and I am glad to have cable.

            Not all that long ago I had to be on a local WISP, and I got maybe 6Mbps for $100/mo. So I'm not ecstatic about paying over $100 now, but at least I'm getting real-world 400+ Mbps despite living in the sticks. And my PC is on a WiFi link from there and I can only get about 120Mbps real-world anyway. But I'd sure like to be able to get FTTH just because my ISP sucks and we're suc

            • by ukoda ( 537183 )
              I'm rural and I get 1GBs fibre with a static IPv4 address for $65/mo, but then again I'm not in the USA. Here AT&T would never had to go to court as Comcast would have been forced to pull their misleading advertising pretty quickly.

              Many countries have consumer protection laws to protect the public from corporations. It looks like there are places where it take a rival corporation to bring a corporation inline, maybe.
    • In most cases it goes even farther than the head end, a lot of modern cable systems are fiber to the neighborhood node. Your internet is only traveling over coax for maybe the last few hundred yards, probably no more than a mile.
    • by Guspaz ( 556486 )

      In theory, HFC can meet or exceed fiber speeds in both directions anyway. DOCSIS 4.0 supports up to 10 gigs down and 6 gigs up over a single copper coax cable. That's faster than the 10 down 2.5 up you get with 10G-PON/XG-PON, but less than the symmetrical 10 you get out of XGS-PON. Yes, that would typically be shared, but so is fiber to the home, which is always some sort of PON-based solution. So ultimately the last mile doesn't matter, what you're pushing over the last mile does.

    • by Archfeld ( 6757 )

      they are adverting fiber speeds while supplying coax/copper connection. That is bullshit and false adverting. I realize AT&T only cares because it cost them some profit, but we have to draw the line somewhere. I want my "UNLIMITED" service to be on fiber...lmao

      Warning : You have been warned!!!

      note extreme use of sarcasm in some of this post

  • Will this end up being a "farm fresh" Vs "free-range" type thing, where the latter has a very strict legal definition, but people might expect the same from the former?

    "fiber-powered" isn't necessarily wrong because the Comcast main network runs on fiber -- the network is (em?)powered by fiber, as such.

    If they aren't actually saying "fiber to the home", then they don't have provide fiber actually "to the home".

    Fucking marketing terms that are, at some level, "technically" correct, but are intentional
    • The difference is that "fresh" doesn't have a clear technical meaning, but "fiber-optic" and in context, "fiber" does.

      The average person thinks that word games win in court, because the average person has a poor vocabulary and can't tell when a word is subjective and when it isn't. But most judges can tell the difference. Quite easily.

      AT&T will be about to win the case, and then they'll settle and sign an NDA, because the actual damages will be tiny, since AT&T doesn't offer effective competing prod

  • Two companies I'm glad I don't have to deal with any longer.

  • and with ATT just having one fiber hookup in a city = that city has fiber to the home.

    • by TypoNAM ( 695420 )

      In my case AT&T still claims to have FTTH service in neighborhoods like mine, about 3 square miles, consisting ~240 houses in the FCC broadband availability database. However, they only ran fiber down one half a street of maybe 30 homes and the rest had only the option of Xfinity coax service until GFiber became available almost two years ago. Only a few homes show up in the FCC database for my neighborhood for not having AT&T FTTH available, such as mine, because we've tried signing up for said ser

      • When is AT&T going to be finally fined and forced to correct their lies in the FCC broadband availability database?

        About the same time they're held accountable for not spending our tax money on building out last mile internet

  • I'll likely switch to FTTH when the only local provider can figure out IPv6. I have a spare 10GBIC port in the firewall for when they're ready.

    I lost the closest switch to the cable modem and a port on the next switch during a recent lightning strike.

    I have various ethernet and coax arresters installed now but those are only so good, even if the fuse/tube blows.

    A glass pair would eliminate that headache.

    FWIW Comcast seems to have no liability for Acts of God they didn't defend against.

    A real fiber company

  • I've seen this a lot here in Finland over the years. The ISP advertises "fiber" service, but the fiber only reaches the basement, and it's anyone's guess how they make the final links to individual apartments. Could be VDSL2, cable or various forms of Ethernet. Nobody ever knows what kind of a modem you need until you check for yourself. The customer service keeps babbling about "fiber" and I've even heard them talk about "fiber modems" for consumers. It's like "fiber" is the magic word that makes everythi

  • is probably fiber, but then again anyone could make this case. But really they've done their homework on misleading consumers. Consumers see the word fiber and make assumptions, so way to take advantage of human stupidity

  • "Fiber Powered Internet". HFC (Hybrid fiber–coaxial) has been used since the early 1990's.
  • by abulafia ( 7826 ) on Monday November 16, 2026 @06:56PM (#66427954)
    And the lawyers, too. Just smack them all on their respective noses and direct all money spent on the case to customers.
  • This results in upload speeds being far slower than download speeds. In contrast, fiber-to-the-home service can provide symmetrical upload and download speeds.

    No, just no.

    In fact, providing asymmetric speeds can be a feature.

    If I can get fiber for $X/month that offers 5 Gb/s in each direction, or cable for the same $X/month that offers 9 Gb/s down and 1 Gb/s up, I may prefer the latter.

    For almost all customers though, fiber vs. copper won't matter. What matters is capacity, reliability, price, customer service, etc. not how the signal actually travels. There are some specific use cases where the physical properties of copper or the physical properties of fiber

  • When you expect people to behave reasonably, there's always someone to look for loopholes in the commonly accepted practices to exploit to deceive people for profit.

    That's why you need lawyers and laws creep into every aspect of your life - that percentage of people always looking to take advantage of others in some way.

    Maybe instead of new laws, we just start putting advertising people in public stocks next to a display of their deceptive ads, and hand out rotten fruit to anyone who wants it.

  • I'm sure that AT&T took advantage of the lack of legal definitions and lack of industry standards and lack of truth-in-advertising laws affecting communications hardware, whenever they could: It's difficult to sympathsize. But a line has to be drawn somewhere and AT&T is making that happen.
  • In our area, wireless providers claim "fiber speed" or "fiber quality"

  • I don't understand why AT&T thinks they are entitled to whatever money Comcast is making from this. They are no more entitled to it than me, or the King of Siam. If they can show a specific injury, then maybe they have a case. Otherwise, the money should go back to the customers who were actually "harmed" by the fraudulent claim.
  • Some cable companies even go so far as to falsely say "powered by fiber coaxial cable" in their commercials.

    Of course, there's no such thing as "fiber coaxial cable." It's the same old system.

    They are, however, upgrading the older copper coaxial cable plant for higher frequencies since DOCSIS 3.1 now calls for 1.8 GHz instead of 1.2 GHz. The old RG-59 can't carry 1.8 GHz and can barely carry 1.2 GHz for that matter. They're replacing the old cable with RG-6 and RG-11 which both handle above 2 GHz.

Imitation is the sincerest form of plagarism.

Working...