Satya Nadella Says He's AGI-Pilled Now (theverge.com) 56
An anonymous reader quotes a report from The Verge: Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella says he's AGI-pilled, at least when it comes to how AI might make startling changes to the structure of the economy and how politics might change because of it. "I am AGI-pilled in the sense that at an economy level, what is the political economy's organization around AGI?" he asked at a roundtable discussion following his Microsoft Ignite keynote at the Chase Center in San Francisco. But Nadella doesn't think frontier models like Claude are conscious. "I don't think so," he said, adding that he follows Microsoft AI CEO Mustafa Suleyman's view that companies should not give rights to models and treat them like they might have a moral status, which companies like Anthropic do as a matter of principle. Suleyman has told me he thinks Anthropic's team has "wireheaded" themselves, and that this approach is dangerous. Nadella wasn't quite as firm about it. "It's a good debate," he said. "I'm not sort of dogmatic about it. What I'm saying is the most important social technical issue we have to deal with is how do you ensure that an economy can diffuse this technology broadly?"
I asked Nadella how he was thinking about AI after hearing his response to another reporter's questions about Anthropic releasing more products in its office suite. Nadella talked at length about the potential collapse of the economy and the end of democracy if one AI model were allowed to achieve monopoly status. "If the Marxist sort of view is that there's only one firm, then it's over, right? For all of us." "Most people think about this as a competition between tech firms, which of course it will be," he said. "But remember, the model has no limits. It'll be a healthcare company. It can be a financial services company. It can be anything if it wants to be. It can take over the government. Thinking of this as some narrow competition between tech firms, of who is going to get to the next trillion dollars of market cap, is one of the strangest, narrowest ways to think about it."
Nadella went on to say that the very nature of companies stood to be disrupted in the future. "If intelligence has network effects, what is the future of a firm?" he asked. "If the model sees anything and learns it, and essentially all of human capital collapses into token capital, what is the role of a firm and the human capital in a firm? That's the debate." "I think the political economy is going to get more and more interesting in that context. No one -- at least in a democracy -- can even win an election if this just goes that way, if there's only capital and there's no labor. I mean, I don't know, that's not an economy." "If the Marxist sort of view is that there's only one firm, then it's over, right? For all of us. Not just for me. You are also going to somehow be some affiliate of Anthropic."
I asked Nadella how he was thinking about AI after hearing his response to another reporter's questions about Anthropic releasing more products in its office suite. Nadella talked at length about the potential collapse of the economy and the end of democracy if one AI model were allowed to achieve monopoly status. "If the Marxist sort of view is that there's only one firm, then it's over, right? For all of us." "Most people think about this as a competition between tech firms, which of course it will be," he said. "But remember, the model has no limits. It'll be a healthcare company. It can be a financial services company. It can be anything if it wants to be. It can take over the government. Thinking of this as some narrow competition between tech firms, of who is going to get to the next trillion dollars of market cap, is one of the strangest, narrowest ways to think about it."
Nadella went on to say that the very nature of companies stood to be disrupted in the future. "If intelligence has network effects, what is the future of a firm?" he asked. "If the model sees anything and learns it, and essentially all of human capital collapses into token capital, what is the role of a firm and the human capital in a firm? That's the debate." "I think the political economy is going to get more and more interesting in that context. No one -- at least in a democracy -- can even win an election if this just goes that way, if there's only capital and there's no labor. I mean, I don't know, that's not an economy." "If the Marxist sort of view is that there's only one firm, then it's over, right? For all of us. Not just for me. You are also going to somehow be some affiliate of Anthropic."
I ran that summary through Google translate (Score:2, Insightful)
It still made no sense..
Re: I ran that summary through Google translate (Score:5, Insightful)
Satya-bot (Score:2)
I didn't understand a word of that article. I thought it was just me. What a relief to see your comment and then many below.
Try again running it through Google translate, but this time make the input language Goggledygook.
Maybe the reporter was mislead, not talking to the real Satya, but a Satya bot spewing an AI generated rant.
If that incoherent drivel was the best that the MS CEO can muster, maybe they really do need AI. AI vs BS (Bullshitter Satya).
Re: (Score:2)
It says Satya Nadella is a pill.
What can I say (Score:2)
The guy can really read the room.
+wx (Score:3)
Re: +wx (Score:1)
Re: (Score:3)
It's from The Matrix, where the protagonist is given a choice between a red pill and a blue pill. The red pill allows him to wake up and see the truth, the blue pill makes him forget and go back to his mundane life.
Ironically the far right adopted "red-pilled" to mean becoming an embarrassed Nazi.
Anyway, in this context it means he believes AGI is close and it's going to make things much worse for everyone who isn't already a billionaire.
Re: (Score:2)
What's far more hilarious is the far right used the word "Woke" as an "insult" to left views, despite it meaning EXACTLY THE SAME THING as "red pilled". They must have been embarrassed that the left came up with a much better and term that did not require careful observation of The Matrix to know which direction it meant.
WAT? (Score:5, Insightful)
I have not idea what he is even say.
Sure if there is only capital and no labor you don't have an economy. I guess that much is true capital lacks agency it just sits there unless labor, even if the laborer is its owner decides to make it do something. - fine
But all that stuff about the model can be anything ... sounds like he is on cocaine, every bit as wireheaded as anyone at anthropic.
Re: (Score:3)
But all that stuff about the model can be anything ... sounds like he is on cocaine, every bit as wireheaded as anyone at anthropic.
If/when AGI arrives, it probably will be able to be anything. He doesn't think it has arrived. Therefore he is arguably sane. Mostly. But this kind of thing is nutty in general:
The firm? The human capital? Just say "humans" or "people", Satya, if you are one. They are the concern, not the firm. Without the humans,
Re: (Score:3)
If/when AGI arrives, it probably will be able to be anything.
I think he's experiencing some kind of worship complex and wants to suck the mighty AI's dick.
Its going take a long time and be really expensive, like fusion power. We'll just keep throwing the poor into the firebox since its not meant for them anyway.
Re: (Score:1)
I have not idea what he is even say.
Don't overthink it. Me, I'm faster-than-light and huge-tits pilled.
The only thing a CEO can do that AI can't.. (Score:2)
Okay, Coppertop (Score:2)
Is this a Matrix reference? Because we all know how that turned out...
Re: (Score:3)
That still leaves the small issue in that the "???" that traditionally lies between there and "Profit" is "Where do we find any paying customers now?"
Who better to know? (Score:5, Interesting)
Nadella talked at length about the potential collapse of the economy and the end of democracy if one AI model were allowed to achieve monopoly status.
Well, Windows came pretty close to monopoly status; and Europe seems clear that failure to decouple would threaten its economy and therefore, by extension at least, its democracy as well.
Given that Nadella is one of the architects of Microsoft's full-on "all your data and compute are belong to us" strategy, he probably has some insight into the dangers he's warning us about. Authors do have insight into their own works. I wonder, though, if he realizes even on a merely intellectual level that he IS the danger, or at any rate a significant part of it.
... how do you ensure that an economy can diffuse this technology broadly?
"The economy" doesn't have to "diffuse" shit, dear Satya. The fact that you're talking that way is yet another indication that you're dodging any personal responsibility for the way things are now. "Diffusing" is simple: open all the models, give everybody access to all of them, and let the great levelling begin. But will you and your kind do that? Of course not.
The delusions of grandeur that you fuckers repeatedly double down on are getting really, really tiresome. Stuff your pseudo-profundity, save your erotic power fantasies for your oligarch circle-jerks, and spare us all your bullshit.
Re: (Score:3)
He means, how do I make my product, everyday and everywhere and hopefully, the preferred purchase?
A technology is ubiquitous because it is cheaper, more reliable and more powerful than its predecessor. They've already got "power" and pretend they have "cheaper" which is doubly plagued, because it's also destroyed by the absence of "reliable". He's assuming the current technology can achieve this.
I think he is examining scarcity: As intellectual property, the law can enforce artificial scarcity. But
Re: (Score:2)
He means, how do I make my product, everyday and everywhere and hopefully, the preferred purchase?
Thanks for pointing that out. Even in the midst of my cynical criticism, I had subconsciously assumed that Nadella wanted to make society better. Talk about a blind spot!
I guess I'm not as cynical as I thought. Now I'm torn as to whether to change that or leave it alone.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Where is the Butlerian jihad when you need it?
On the other side of a planet-wide economic depression of heretofore unseen scope and scale.
Microsoft gets serious ... (Score:2)
AGI is just (Score:5, Insightful)
Another Gullible Idiot.
Re: (Score:2)
These companies are now facing MASSIVE losses if LLM's fail due to the limited (at best) utility of the models.
Re: (Score:1)
"LLMs" disregard physics so they will never scale. Then they try to make up for it by spending billions of infrastructure instead of millions on a better approach. It's like negative IQ has veto and decision power now.
WTF is he even saying?? (Score:3)
I've read his statement 3 times, and I still can't tell you what he said.
Marxism misunderstanding (Score:5, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
I never understood how to give points to a post, so I don't know why this reply is at -1. It should be at least a 3.
BTW, the way to "diffuse" the economy is simple. In communism, you tax labor to maintain the government because capital is owned by the state. In capitalism, you should tax capital (not income or profit) to force it to move and create more goods and services. Ideally, you should tax land. That is the capitalist way to diffuse wealth.
Milton Friedman (the most capitalist economist ever) puts it
Re: (Score:2)
https://www.noemamag.com/build... [noemamag.com]
Closely related article. I don't necessarily agree with everything but it makes some good points.
Answered and asked. (Score:3)
Thinking of this as some narrow competition between tech firms, of who is going to get to the next trillion dollars of market cap, is one of the strangest, narrowest ways to think about it.
We don't think of it as a narrow competition for market cap. That's your own Wall Street induced brain damage talking. We think of it as:
the potential collapse of the economy and the end of democracy if one AI model were allowed to achieve monopoly status.
And that's bad, just to be clear.
The question is: Can LLMs get to AGI ? (Score:3)
The crucial question is: Can LLMs get to AGI ?
i.e. Can throwing ever-more data in the form of human-generated texts into an LLM system with ever-more parameters give it enough general intelligence to exceed humans ?
I hope it cannot. And I do not think it can. More data in the same LLM systems will not get them to AGI. A different AI approach is needed.
And Anthropic IPO-ing now is a sign that they know that.
If I am wrong, I truly believe humanity is doomed. We will not be able to control AGI AIs.
Re: (Score:3, Interesting)
We're way passed LLMs. All most all models today are multi-modal, being trained on audio, visual (pictures and video), language, data (ledgers, spreadsheets, CAD drawing, etc).
This whole "Can LLMs reach AGI?" is a dead question.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
That's like saying a Tesla is built on model-T technology. Sure it is... but its a silly argument.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
That's like saying a Tesla is built on model-T technology.
Now I'm wondering how you DRM a Babbitt mold.
Re: (Score:3)
No, it's like calling your nazi car a car.
Re: (Score:1)
This whole "Can LLMs reach AGI?" is a dead question.
Yeah, the answer is NO. Anyone who thinks they can, or will get to AGI, is delusional.
Re: (Score:2)
Yeah, the answer is NO. Anyone who thinks they can, or will get to AGI, is delusional.
Tell me you don't know much about AI, but think you do. Wait! You just did.
Re: (Score:1)
will not get them to AGI. A different AI approach is needed.
It is very clear based on this comment and all that follow in this thread that you do not have even the slightest clue how AI works. You are quite confidently wrong. You sound like a MAGAt.
Re: (Score:2)
They do not.
They just show you to be a stupid cunt.
Mistakes lucky, over-educated fools make. (Score:2)
LLM (not AI, not SI, not AGI) exist.
They learn from human beings. This means:
1) They cannot teach themselves things people do not teach them.
2) They cannot DISCOVER new things by themselves. They do not know how to do it.
3) All they can do is contain the sum total of human knowledge.
In addition:
They cost more in water and electricity to answer a question than a human trained in that area does. (The trick is they are trained in more things than any human is trained in).
Yes it is true that the wealthy peo
Satya Nadella: "I'm AGI-pilled now." (Score:2)
"You have no idea what I mean by that, but it sounds hip and cool. And that's the way I want it."
Re: (Score:2)
It all makes sense to me, but I survived the dot-com era.
He's a fucking idiot, though. He's pondering unknowns that he could learn about in a 100-level Sociology class.
Micro$oft Nonsense Machine (MNM) (Score:2)
Nonsense Man CEO.
Diffuse into the economy, aka spread the product as widely as possible and pay the gate keepers a fee for access.
Micro$oft is on the choad towards another IBM to HCL nonsense path.
Every Artificial Idiocy company wants dominance and full exclusive control of access to their product and right now they are the crack dealers giving out free samples to the idiot masses to make them smoke the magic smoke and make dependant and addicted to the product that will ruin their lives and everyone's arou
What the (Score:2)