Waymo Robotaxis Pulled From Freeways Indefinitely (arstechnica.com) 49
Waymo has temporarily suspended freeway operations across all its robotaxi markets after California regulators ordered the company off the state's highways over repeated incidents involving construction zones. The restriction follows a June recall (PDF) of nearly 3,800 vehicles and subsequent software updates (PDF) that failed to prevent further incidents, including a robotaxi driving past a California Highway Patrol rolling roadblock. Ars Technica reports: "Safety is at the foundation of everything we do," Waymo told Ars. "Following recent freeway construction zone encounters on U.S. 101 in California that did not involve any injuries or collisions, the California DMV has implemented an operating restriction on freeway operations in the state. In alignment with our safety-first principles, we have also temporarily restricted freeway operations across our other operating markets to evaluate our performance. Our ride-hailing service continues to operate safely on surface streets, serving over half a million trips each week. We are working with the California DMV and other state officials diligently and responsibly to resume freeway operations."
Waymo also told Ars it was continuing to work with the various California agencies that regulate transport. Until the suspension, Waymo was only conducting highway operations in Los Angeles and the Bay Area in California, as well as in Arizona.
Waymo also told Ars it was continuing to work with the various California agencies that regulate transport. Until the suspension, Waymo was only conducting highway operations in Los Angeles and the Bay Area in California, as well as in Arizona.
Speeding past police roadblock (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Speeding past police roadblock (Score:5, Interesting)
Fuck Waymo, but I can't bring myself to blame them for something humans could also be confused by.
/ Yeah, go ahead and insult me - Then feel free to visit my home state to see what sort of crazy BS passes as "traffic control" here and see if you get 100% of it on first sight.
Re: (Score:3)
NGL, the first time I encountered a rolling roadblock I had zero clue what was going on. Even took video of it assuming the cop was drunk or crazy - Though fortunately I didn't try to pass for the same reason (safer to have the crazies comfortably far in front of you than behind you, particularly crazies with a gun). They seriously need to tow a sign or something indicating intent beyond treating the I-5 as a slalom course.
Same. I don't blame the Waymo for trying to pass. I've never seen police do anything like this anywhere but California. Normally, you'd have a highway truck for this sort of thing, or you'd send two police cars to temporarily block the road for two minutes for a two truck to hook up or whatever after an accident. Seeing police cars weaving back and forth across the road like they're drunk is enough to seriously weird out anyone.
Negligent for S/W to be ignorant of driver's HB (Score:2)
It is completely negligent for self driving software to be unaware of something described in the drivers handbook
Re: (Score:2)
I saw one my first year in California. Cop car only a few cars ahead of me starts zig zagging. And I'm like "oh, that's weird, I better slow down and watch." Eventually it stopped, so most of us also stopped. And then I saw it was stopped in front of a huge piece of a car's plastic quarter panel that landed in the road. As the cop is dragging it to the side of the road, someone drives pass between the cop on foot and his car. And he screamed at them, then started talking on his radio. I hope the impatient i
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Yep. I've seen that exact scenario. Also some idiot thinking he could ride the shoulder to get to his offramp faster. That got him yelled at over the loud speaker and probably worse. Impatient driver for sure. Personally, I was rather grateful for the police office doing what he did because it's pretty lame having to dodge road obstructions and extremely dangerous at times as well.
Re: (Score:1)
Most humans would stay the fuck back from a cop car, because they could just open fire on you if they wanted to. Nothing but future paperwork prevents them from punching holes through you. Robotaxis lack the context support for the decisions they have to make. Maybe if the cops could tell them to back the fuck off, don't pass, and the LLM on the server could interpret that and put the taxi in some kind of back off/don't pass mode. Well the cops don't have a protocol for talking to robotaxis or a way to comm
Re:Speeding past police roadblock (Score:4, Funny)
stay the fuck back from a cop car, because they could just open fire on you if they wanted to. Nothing but future paperwork prevents them from punching holes through you.
Thats the most American post I've read all week :-)
Re: (Score:2)
Yeah, in a lot of countries they wouldn't even have paperwork.
Helicopter medical evacuation (Score:2)
I was immediately behind one once. He stopped us a few hundred yards from an accident. A helicopter landed on the freeway in front of us to evacuate the injured. That removed the feeling of annoyance.
Re:Helicopter medical evacuation (Score:5, Informative)
If a state wants to do something completely insane by national standards - Well, first of all, don't. But if they absolutely must, at least in this case all it would take is a sign or two to make the situation clear.
Re: (Score:2)
You confuse different with insane, and frankly the California technique is the better as described above. Easier to implement. The intention of the vehicle actually intuitive to someone with a clue.
Re: (Score:2)
I live in California and I was unaware of what a "rolling roadblock" is (but then, I don't drive). Yet it seems to me that if a highway patrol car just put on its red and blue flashers, that would indicate to most rational drivers that this was a police car not to be fucked with ... and you certainly wouldn't speed past it. (For those who don't know, the California Highway Patrol, affectionately known as CHiPs, is what we call our state police... if they're after you, you're in bigger trouble than with your
Re: (Score:2)
For those who don't know, the California Highway Patrol, affectionately known as CHiPs, is what we call our state police... if they're after you, you're in bigger trouble than with your local cops.
For those of you who are going to a University of California campus, the University of California Campus Police are also real honest-to-god state police. When a bank next to campus had an armed robbery they were first on scene. When a shooter fled into a nearby industrial park, their K-9 team led the search. Every fall there is a story in the campus newspaper where they gave instructions to a student, the student responded with something like "your just rent-a-cops, I don't have to listen to you", and then
Re: (Score:1)
It's 2026. Self driving cars have been a thing for almost 10 years, and have been anticipated for decades prior. It's time that NHTSA type regulators step up with some tangible standards & procedures for self driving vehicles, particularly when interfacing with construction work, emergency response, tow trucks, and all other manner of authorized roadway use.
This is your basic IETF RFC situation. Get the first responder set (ambulance, highway patrol, etc) in a room with the self driving folks, hamm
Re: (Score:2)
All 50 states have policies for police to perform traffic breaks on highways. California (CHP specifically) use a zig-zag maneuver because people are such terrible drivers in America that they often try to pass the patrol car when they simply drive in one or two lanes. I say we're bad drives because the UK performs traffic breaks on their road system, and basically the police vehicle simply drives down the middle of the highway with lights on and rarely have an issue with people trying to pass.
Re: (Score:2)
Traffic break, not roadblock. Traffic breaks are when the cops drive slowly weaving back and forth across the road with their lights flashing. Roadblocks are when they stop and block off the road.
Lots of people are confused by traffic breaks: "WTF is this cop doing? Swerving back and forth going real slow on the freeway?" I have seen people try to drive past the cop when they pull to one side, only to have the cop cut back in front of them and use the PA to tell them to "Stay behind me!"
It is not somethin
Re: (Score:3)
It is not something that is taught in drivers training, or in the drivers handbook, nor is it on the written test. You just learn about it when it happens to you. Most people figure it out quickly enough.
It is absolutely in the Driver's Handbook. See the last section on this page: Section 8: Safe Driving [ca.gov].
Re: (Score:2)
Excellent!
I don't recall seeing it in the printed versions they used to hand out, but it is good to know it is there in the online version.
Re: (Score:3)
Whenever you're driving at lower than normal speeds you're supposed to turn them on, to warn fast-moving vehicles approaching from behind.
I'm guessing you learn traffic "laws" from word of mouth, rather than the publication from the DVM.
Re: (Score:3)
If a cop is erratically driving back and forth across a four lane highway, you'd be a fucking tool to try to pass. I don't recall ever seeing it in the handbook, but seems pretty fucking obviously you shouldn't try to pass. Some people are just dim or impatient.
Sure, you may not understand WHY they are doing that, but why would anyone think it would be a wise choice to speed past, especially when pretty much everyone else around you is slowing down. Some people are just special stupid.
Re: (Score:2)
Indeed the first time I ever encountered one of these, I had no idea what was going on. If I had been alone I might have tried to pass, too. However I observed that other drivers were refusing to pass the zig-zagging cop so I did the same. I suspect the Waymo had never learned to observe what other drivers are doing.
Re: (Score:2)
If I sped past a police roadblock I'd be arrested on the spot.
Why? I mean if you're able to speed past a roadblock it's not much of a roadblock was it? I've actually done this (to be fair, not in America, your police are probably different from the rest of the world) and when I had a police car come after me and pull me over I explained I had no idea what they were doing, no I didn't see the police officer wave me over, and if they wanted to actually stop all cars they should do a better job. He gave me a breath test and then sent me on my way without any punishment.
W
Re: (Score:2)
They don't want to immediately stop all cars. They are trying to slow all cars, and may not even be trying to stop them at all, if there is something ahead going on which can be expected to resolve. In California we have highways with view-obscuring curves which nonetheless allow you to drive 65 MPH legally, and people often drive up to 80 MPH. If you just stop everyone, that's dangerous in a lot of places.
That was close (Score:3)
Well done. (Score:5, Insightful)
"You can't do that in California anymore."
Response: "You have a good point. Not only will we comply, we are going to extend the restriction to the rest of the market and figure it out."
No matter the underlying motive, that's a good response. We all know companies that would fight it and deny everything until the bitter end.
Re: (Score:1)
The regulatory environment is going to start changing some more drastically.
Re: (Score:2)
I think the political change in the last election has more to do with that than any good intentions.
The constant series of self-driving failures have far more to do with it and in any case your account is the farthest thing from legit so go fuck yourself.
ban them from crossing any railroad track as well (Score:4, Interesting)
https://www.msn.com/en-us/tech... [msn.com]
Re: (Score:1)
Did a remote-control human trigger this behavior or did the Waymo do it completely on its own? I would guess a remote-control human triggered the action. Pity news reports are so worthless and only care about click-bait.
Re: (Score:2)
Errr why? Your example shows that the Waymo is acting more sensibly than literally every other idiot driver who gets stuck on a rail road crossing. The car seems to have avoided a major catastrophe. Maybe ban humans instead. They are the ones that historically derail trains.
How much (Score:5, Interesting)
How many miles of supervised freeway driving are actually needed for adequate training. In 50 years and a couple of hundred thousand miles of freeway driving, I've only come across a traffic break like that about 2-3 times. The first time, I had no idea what they were doing, but I was not stupid enough to try to go past them.
The thing is there are situations that happen all the time, but that a single driver sees only rarely or never. All the other waymo cars did not end up behind a traffic break. It's different for a fleet of thousands than for a single guy. Exactly how much supervised training is needed? Waymo needs to estimate the frequency of these kinds of events. Unfortunately, for them, humnans can figure out something they've never seen before. Not so for Waymo. in fact, it's likely that Waymo systems can't even figure out that they are seeing something they've never seen before, because everything just drops out of a statistical soup.
Re: (Score:1)
The 0.01% of exceptions Waymo has not hit yet (Score:3)
Re: (Score:3)
"I don't need to outrun the bear; I just need to outrun you!"
Human drivers are so incredibly terrible and deal with those driving exceptions so badly that by comparison, Waymo ain't so bad. And lawyers can already sue Google/Waymo. But a driver ignoring whatever the police were doing would not be sued; they would at worst be fined. Which is the case for most of the shenanigans which Waymo cars pull, and (surprising nobody) is the case for the similar-but-more-dangerous shenanigans which human pull every
Re: (Score:2)
"I don't need to outrun the bear; I just need to outrun you!"
Human drivers are so incredibly terrible and deal with those driving exceptions so badly that by comparison, Waymo ain't so bad.
So why are humans still allowed on freeways? Seems like making perfect the enemy of good. Waymos are safer, so they shouldn't be the only ones left on the freeways. That is logic 101. Waymo safe, humans unsafe. Simple.
In related news ... (Score:5, Funny)
Waymo Robotaxis Pulled From Freeways Indefinitely
Waymo rebrands itself as "Wayless".
Self driving is AI hard (Score:2)
Autonomous self driving is AI hard. Urban driving allows you to get away from that, because a conservative constraint system combined with AI recognition of unrecognized/ambiguous cases can allow the car to simply stop and call for human remote help. Highway driving does not allow that, autonomy is required,
Until AI Jesus can and is allowed to take the wheel, completely free from any artificial and fragile constraint system for which you can always find some corner case where it has to be ignored, there is
HOld on (Score:2)
Good Riddence (Score:1)
Remember, DARPA wanted driverless cars--to comb the deserts and kill people.
It's a bummer (Score:4, Interesting)
It's a setback for Waymo, because a lot of people here in San Francisco use Waymo. But one of their main requests was to let them use it to get them to SFO (the airport), which is not in the city nor county of San Francisco. And getting there via side roads, crossing multiple cities, is not the way to do it.
What about other self driving cars? (Score:2)
Like KITT, KARR, Tesla's FSDs, etc. :P
Capitalism (Score:2)