A 'Law Firm' of AI Generated Lawyers Is Sending Fake Threats As an SEO Scam (404media.co) 12
An anonymous reader quotes a report from 404 Media: Last week, Ernie Smith, the publisher of the website Tedium, got a "copyright infringement notice" from a law firm called Commonwealth Legal: "We're reaching out on behalf of the Intellectual Property division of a notable entity, in relation to an image connected to our client," it read. [...] In this case, though, the email didn't demand that the photo be taken down or specifically threaten a lawsuit. Instead, it demanded that Smith place a "visible and clickable link" beneath the photo in question to a website called "tech4gods" or the law firm would "take action." Smith began looking into the law firm. And he found that Commonwealth Legal is not real, and that the images of its "lawyers" are AI generated.
The threat to "activate the case No. 86342" is obviously nonsense. Beyond that, Commonwealth Legal's website looks generic and is full of stock photos, though I've seen a lot of generic template websites for real law firms. All of its lawyers have vacant, thousand-yard stares that are commonly generated by websites like This Person Does Not Exist, none of them come up in any attorney or LinkedIn searches, and the only reverse image search results for them are for a now-broken website called Generated.Photos, which offered a service to "use AI to generate people online that don't exist, change clothing and modify face and body traits. Download generated people in different postures." "All of the faces scanned were likely AI generated, most likely by a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) model," Ali Shahriyari, cofounder and CTO of the AI detection startup Reality Defender told 404 Media. Commonwealth Legal's listed address is the fourth floor of a one-story building that looks nothing like the image on its website, and both of its phone numbers are disconnected. No one responded to the contact form that I filled out. Smith realized that what's happening here isn't a copyright enforcement or copyright trolling attempt at all. Instead, it's a backlink SEO scam, where a website owner tries to improve their Google ranking by asking, paying, or threatening someone to link to their website.
Tech4Gods.com is a gadget review website run by a man named Daniel Barczak, whose content is "complemented by AI writing assistants." In this case, the photo that Smith had "infringed" was a photo downloaded from the royalty free, free-to-use website Unsplash, which 404 Media also sometimes uses. The image was not taken by Barczak, and has nothing to do with him, he told me in an email: "I certainly don't own any images on the web," he said. The original photographer did not respond to a request for comment sent through Unsplash. Barczak told me that he had been previously buying backlinks to his website for SEO, but said he wasn't aware of who was doing this or why. "I have no idea; it certainly has nothing to do with me," he said. "However, recently, someone has been building spammy links against my site that I have been dealing with." "I have mastered on-page SEO, but unfortunately, I buy links due to a lack of time," he added. "In the past, I had a bad link builder. I wonder if it's him going mad at me for letting him go It's hard to say the web is massive, and everyone can link whenever they want." Link building is an SEO strategy devised to get outside websites to link to your website. He added that "bad links may damage [the site's] profile in Google's eyes." In this case, however, the "lawyers" were threatening a well-established tech blogger, and a link from Tedium would likely be treated as a positive in the search algorithm's eyes.
The threat to "activate the case No. 86342" is obviously nonsense. Beyond that, Commonwealth Legal's website looks generic and is full of stock photos, though I've seen a lot of generic template websites for real law firms. All of its lawyers have vacant, thousand-yard stares that are commonly generated by websites like This Person Does Not Exist, none of them come up in any attorney or LinkedIn searches, and the only reverse image search results for them are for a now-broken website called Generated.Photos, which offered a service to "use AI to generate people online that don't exist, change clothing and modify face and body traits. Download generated people in different postures." "All of the faces scanned were likely AI generated, most likely by a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) model," Ali Shahriyari, cofounder and CTO of the AI detection startup Reality Defender told 404 Media. Commonwealth Legal's listed address is the fourth floor of a one-story building that looks nothing like the image on its website, and both of its phone numbers are disconnected. No one responded to the contact form that I filled out. Smith realized that what's happening here isn't a copyright enforcement or copyright trolling attempt at all. Instead, it's a backlink SEO scam, where a website owner tries to improve their Google ranking by asking, paying, or threatening someone to link to their website.
Tech4Gods.com is a gadget review website run by a man named Daniel Barczak, whose content is "complemented by AI writing assistants." In this case, the photo that Smith had "infringed" was a photo downloaded from the royalty free, free-to-use website Unsplash, which 404 Media also sometimes uses. The image was not taken by Barczak, and has nothing to do with him, he told me in an email: "I certainly don't own any images on the web," he said. The original photographer did not respond to a request for comment sent through Unsplash. Barczak told me that he had been previously buying backlinks to his website for SEO, but said he wasn't aware of who was doing this or why. "I have no idea; it certainly has nothing to do with me," he said. "However, recently, someone has been building spammy links against my site that I have been dealing with." "I have mastered on-page SEO, but unfortunately, I buy links due to a lack of time," he added. "In the past, I had a bad link builder. I wonder if it's him going mad at me for letting him go It's hard to say the web is massive, and everyone can link whenever they want." Link building is an SEO strategy devised to get outside websites to link to your website. He added that "bad links may damage [the site's] profile in Google's eyes." In this case, however, the "lawyers" were threatening a well-established tech blogger, and a link from Tedium would likely be treated as a positive in the search algorithm's eyes.
Forget Osama Bin Laden (Score:4, Insightful)
SEAL Team Six needs to track down SEOs, phishers, and spammers. Those guys are the real threat to our way of life.
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
SEAL Team Six needs to track down SEOs, phishers, and spammers. Those guys are the real threat to our way of life.
They will go away if enough people ignore them.
Scam infringement letters are nothing new. I got them (by paper mail) 30 years ago.
They shotgun them out and wait to see who is dumb enough to respond.
I file them in a folder so I have a paper trail, and otherwise ignore them.
99% of the time, I never hear from the same scammer again.
The biggest mistake you can make is to talk to a lawyer. The lawyer will recommend a robust response, resulting in plenty of fees.
Re: (Score:2)
They will go away if enough people ignore them.
I suspect we're close to a point in history where AI will let these guys impersonate your own mother just to get you to click on stuff. Carefully targeted phishing will soon be scalable thanks to cheap/free AI. By the time you realize that you're not really talking to an awkward techno-illiterate relative it's too late.
Scam infringement letters are nothing new. I got them (by paper mail) 30 years ago.
Agreed. A lot of the old cons are alive and well on the internet today. Oh, I need you to wire me some money so I can release the funds for your inheritance/lottery/settlement. Yeah, that one
Re: (Score:2)
Theres a slightly malicious part of me that kind of looks forward to the CEO bots destroying the internet, because honestly, its become a destructive shitshow.
The free and liberating internet of the late 90s and early 2000s died a long long time ago, and its now a hell dimension of corporate social media wrecking kids attention spans and bamboozling their elders with disinformation.
Meh (Score:2)
This is news? I guess throw in AI photos and this scam is somehow novel.
Yep, AI won't "take over the world" (Score:2)
but it will assist us in destroying ourselves.
That took longer than expected (Score:2)
But it is not a surprise at all. The legal system is so fundamentally broken that average people just try to have as much distance from it as possible.
disbar them! (Score:2)
disbar them!
"I buy links due to a lack of time" (Score:3)
Go die in a fire, fucking spammer. The nerve! Probably thinks he's the victim here.
I Can't Believe It's a Law Firm! (Score:2)
works on contingency?
no, money down!