Drive a Greasecar - DIY Biodiesel 387
TinyTim writes "Sure, you could buy expensive biodiesel for you car - or you can hack your diesel to run on filtered vegetable oil. Kits take a few hours to install and cost about $800, but you can get your fuel free from restaurant deep-fryers (the filters are ~$10/2000mi). Supposedly no loss of performance or mileage, and you can change between diesel and veggie oil with the flick of a switch. A previous article mentioned the theoretical possibility, but it looks like kits are now available from greasecar.com."
So.... (Score:2, Funny)
Re:So.... (Score:2, Funny)
Many Users (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Many Users (Score:2)
You stated: ".... a short term solution to a long term problem."
Now to me, vegetable oil is a re-newable resource... I guess there are worse things in this world then an influx of veggie growers?
Re:Many Users (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Many Users (Score:2)
Using Canola is really only a positive thing if you presume that the used fryer fat would have been dumped in a landfill instead of being otherwise recycled. Once demand exceeds used-oil supply, canola based engines becomes a losing proposition.
Re:Many Users (Score:2)
Vegetable oil would likely be the same though I'm sure some restaurants would increase their push on fatty fried foods in order to maximize revenues. B)
Re:Many Users (Score:2)
Re:Many Users (Score:2)
Re:Many Users (Score:2)
Spot on the Driveway.. (Score:4, Funny)
I suppose you could try tasting it..you might get to know your fuel by taste! Bob's Burger Stand and his unmistakable motor fuel..er, deep fat frier grease!
I can see it now: You drive into your local Drive-Thru and order a burger, fries, shake and 5 gallons of their day-old fryer grease!
Re:Spot on the Driveway.. (Score:2, Informative)
Great.. (Score:2)
Smells like...? (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Smells like...? (Score:4, Funny)
I recall working at Wendy's and taking out the fryer grease...
Pouring it into a dumpster that had 400 gallons of what smelled like rancid shit. It had a four-inch-thick congealed craptastic skin on it that belched farty gasses when breached.
I don't care if it smells like french fries, as long as it doesn't belch rancid fart stink.
Re:Smells like...? (Score:2)
I used to do the same stuff at McDonald's. When you consider what ends up in the grease traps (not just cooked-off fat, but also water, grill-cleaning chemicals, food of all types that didn't cook right (any combination of bacon, sausage, beef patties, eggs, etc.), and other such stuff, is it any wonder that the grease dumpster smells like ass?
I was told pretty much the same thing...every once in a while, a tanker truck would stop by the store to suck the grease out of the dumpster. You have to wonder how many women would keep using their lipstick and other cosmetics if they knew what went into making that stuff.
Re:Smells like...? (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Smells like...? (Score:2)
Re:Smells like...? (Score:2)
How far can this go? (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:How far can this go? (Score:2)
I wouldn't want to speculate exactly how much. I would feel okay guessing it's not enough to completely replace fossil fuels in vehicles, but then again we probably need to drive less anyway.
Re:How far can this go? (Score:2)
C//
Re:How far can this go? (Score:2)
Though my point was that we're making all this food -anyway-, so it's kinda moot.
Re:How far can this go? (Score:3, Insightful)
Anyway, these carbons in the fuel are the good carbons. They are the ones that were floating around the atmosphere just last year. The bad carbons are the ones that were floating around 50 million years ago.
We can burn all the fuel we want if we burn the kind that is made from carbons that were floating around last year.
SOAP! (Score:2)
It's waste, not a profit stream (Score:2)
Re:How far can this go? (Score:2)
When these guys get their grease for free its just because the resturants don't get paid for it, probably they have to pay to have it removed, and its pretty high in the novelty factor.
Gold! (Score:2, Funny)
(I'm thinking of the deep fryers used to cook the french fries.)
And imagine the revenue Krispy Kreme donuts stores could get out of this! "Coffee, donut and fillup for only $2.99!"
Your car already has to be diesel-based (Score:2)
Bah, I knew I should have bought a German car!
As an experienced trucker, I know. (Score:5, Funny)
Re:As an experienced trucker, I know. (Score:4, Funny)
Folks, just remember this quote the next time you're trying to decide between speeding up to get in FRONT of the trucker, or slowing down to pull in BEHIND him.
Or my new favorite third option, get off the interstate as quickly as possible.
This isn't new.. (Score:4, Informative)
Re:This isn't new.. (Score:2)
Obligatory Simpson's quote... (Score:5, Funny)
Homer: Oh, I'll say. Look at that red-headed kid. There must be twenty dollars worth of grease on his forehead alone.
Bart: I was thinking more of the deep-fryer.
Homer: All right, we'll try it your way.
J
Re:Obligatory Simpson's quote... (Score:2)
Groundskeeper Willie: STOP, thats me retirement grease!
No free fry oil in Dubya's America! (Score:5, Informative)
Most restaurants with friers, dump the old oil into a large bin out back. Every few months a tanker truck comes and picks up the oil. Then they make crayons and other shit out of it. Point is, restaurants get money for their old oil. Why would they give it away?
Re:No free fry oil in Dubya's America! (Score:2, Informative)
Unless it's a VERY large quantity, (and even then) nearly all resturants actually pay a fair fee to have the grease "disposed" of.
That's the reason they're more than happy to give it away free, if you talk to the right people.
Re:No free fry oil in Dubya's America! (Score:2)
Just because Joe-Bob's grease company is getting paid by the restaurant to pick the stuff up doesn't mean that he doesn't make even more money reselling the grease. There are lots of cases of service providers getting greased on both palms (if you'd excuse the pun).
make sure to ask (Score:3, Informative)
there was an article about such a thing at Salon, but it no longer available i guess, though you can read it with google cache...
Grease Rustlers [216.239.39.100]
Companies like Griffin have contracts with restaurants to come around regularly and pick up their grease. From Griffin's point of view, the grease is theirs the minute it enters the container.
So i'd definitely think it would be wise to at least ask the restaraunt you wanna fill up at before doing so.
Re:make sure to ask (Score:2)
Re:make sure to ask (Score:2)
as to why i choose that particular page, it was just the portion that applied most directly to my point really.
Re:No free fry oil in Dubya's America! (Score:3, Informative)
Re:No free fry oil in Dubya's America! (Score:2)
Re:No free fry oil in Dubya's America! (Score:2)
>Why would they give it away?
No, not quite. They pay to have the grease hauled away, along with their other food waste, which is often separate from the usual garbage.
Storing it indefinitely is a nuisance (and is regulated by law in many places), and so it is of value to the restaurant to have it hauled away, just as it is with, say, the butcher's carcassess, which don't just get thrown out with the municipal garbage.
Now, the recycler gets a fee for collecting this stuff, and he also gets to collect for whatever he can convert it into.
None of this means that the grease itself is a directly profitable commodity, just that it is enough of a nuisance that the collection of it is a viable service business, and that part of the disposal process includes a certain amount of recycling.
When you are no longer the only person in your whole state with a frygrease conversion vehicle, you won't be able to simply ask the restaurant if you can have their fat for free. (And taking it without asking is tresspassing.)
Re:No free fry oil in Dubya's America! (Score:2, Informative)
Resturants pay to get rid of their waste oil. There are a few companies that take it to extract the glycerine (for soap and the like), but that is it.
At the Midwest Renewable Energy Fair [mrea.org] I saw the system mentioned, went to a session on it, and talked to a man with a grease powered VW truck. He gets all of his grease for free, and one other person that had a converted vehicle mentioned that he gets paid to take the grease.
-Jim
Re:No free fry oil in Dubya's America! (Score:2)
At one time they were paid for the pick up. This used greese, while useless to them does have value. Fitler it good, get rid of the broken down oils, and it would be worth what they paid for it. However it is broken down and no longer cooks correctly. However those who don't need it as pure enjoy the lower price.
At one time restaruants were paid, but with the rise of fast food there is now a glut in the used greese market, and they pay to get rid of it.
Re: (Score:2)
There is BioBus project in Montreal. (Score:2, Informative)
The site and the explanation is here: BioBus [stcum.qc.ca]
Must start on diesel (Score:3, Interesting)
Now, I wonder if it's just at the beginning of the day, or if he has to be on diesel every time he turns the key. If the latter, and you're mostly driving around town, then you'll never get the chance to use the oil part of it. (Not to detract from its usefulness on long journeys, of course.)
I had a quick look at the greasecar site, but couldn't find the answer to this question. Anyone know the deal?
Re:Must start on diesel (Score:2)
Re:Must start on diesel (Score:2)
Melt grease? Heck, if you park a car in the sun, your engine (and seatbelt buckle) will be carrying enough heat to start a small foundry.
Vegitable Oil? (Score:2)
What's the point? (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:What's the point? (Score:4, Insightful)
You're wrong.
This is slowly driving me crazy. This is an alternative idea, and one that is WORKING on a small scale. There are people right now who are recycling fryer grease into car fuel.
- Is it emission free? Of course not!
- Are the emissions better than gas/diesel emissions? Maybe. Maybe not.
- Is this going to make it all OK for all of us to drive big cars as much as possible? Of course not!!!
- Is it at least going to replace fossil fuels? Don't be absurd!
This is not a solution. Electric cars or hybrids are not a solution. H2, solar, or compressed air powered cars are not the solution! No piece of technology stuck onto a car is going to solve the socioeconomic nightmare of our dependency on vehicles!
BUT...
That doesn't mean we shouldn't use this. In fact, we should be VIGOROUSLY studying these alternatives. The bottom line is that if we wait for a solution, it'll never happen and we'll eventually be buried up to our asses in rusted carparts and used car oil. WHILE we pursue a solution, we MUST be using this thing, the electric cars available, Hybrids, diesel, and whatever else is out there. Same for engines--let's look at the Wankel again, now that Mazda has (sadly) dropped it. If they get used, they get researched. If they don't get used, we'll end up stuck with inefficient, archaic, dinosaur-burning tanks until the end of time; and that will come a lot quicker as a result.
So quit throwing away all of the little steps forward--they're the only way we advance.
Re:What's the point? (Score:2)
The bottom line is that if we wait for a solution, it'll never happen and we'll eventually be buried up to our asses in rusted carparts and used car oil.
I don't buy it. We're using energy faster than the sun can provide us with more of it. There isn't a solution, short of clean fusion/fission. Until then, the only "solution" is to stop using energy so quickly.
Re:What's the point? (Score:2)
That's a news to me--I thought the vast majority of the sun's energy that hit the planet went unused.
Do you have a source for that? If it's true, we should consider using some of the rest of the sun's output...
--
Benjamin Coates
Can we make purpose-made biodiesel? (Score:2)
Re:What's the point? (Score:2)
Sorry, the vast majority of people (myself included) don't care enough to make lifestyle changes.
Technical solutions are the only thing that even stand a chance. In the absence of a technical solution, the problem will continue to go unsolved.
--
Benjamin Coates
Re:What's the point? (Score:2)
Technical solutions are the only thing that even stand a chance. In the absence of a technical solution, the problem will continue to go unsolved.
That's fine. I'm just saying the problem is going to continue to go unsolved.
Re:What's the point? (Score:2)
Re:What's the point? (Score:2)
It Gets _Cold_ Up Here (Score:2)
I don't think that is going to work too well in Northern Wisconsin in the winter.
Berkeley is the leader in this ... (Score:3, Informative)
There is a place in SF where you can buy it for your car. $3 or something a gallon (bit pricey, even for our ridiculous $1.75 87).
-Sean
Oops! (Score:2)
-Sean
What is the total emissions picture? (Score:2, Insightful)
Seen 'em on the road. (Score:2, Informative)
Alternative Fuel Vehicle Tax Break? (Score:2)
Oil-pressing (Score:2, Informative)
you don't need a conversion kit (Score:2, Interesting)
As to the exhaust odor, I can personally attest that it is a lot more pleasant smelling that petro-diesel. Also, the noisy, sooty emissions that people associate with diesel is really just the result of badly designed engines. Get a recent TDI engine from volkswagon (an auto company whose engineers actually went to college!) and you'll have a much cleaner burning engine.
Lastly, to respond to the inevitable comments about the economy of growing fuel crops (poor energy balance, not enough arable land, etc) - you are missing the point! Biodiesel is being made from a waste product. Clearly, it isn't the answer to all our energy needs, but it's a piece of the puzzle.
VW (Score:2, Informative)
I just went 601.4 miles on my last tank, which used 13.3 gallons. That's around 45 miles per gallon.
The car is awesome. Same mileage as a silly little econobox such as a Metro, but with the power of an ordinary car. In fact it's probably got MORE torque than an ordinary car. I can pass gasoline cars easily in 5th gear on a hill, and I can let out the clutch from a stop without even touching the throttle!
And yes, I guess I can run it on grease!
I scoff at all you gasoline slaves.
Carl
Re:VW (Score:2)
A chipped Euro TDI would be nose to nose to a chipped North America 1.8T (2002 or not) - and the TDI can run twice the distance on the same amount of fuel.
I'm a 1.8T owner and proud of it (it responds better with intake and exhaust upgrade, for example), but the TDI is not bad at all - if I lived in Europe I might have got the diesel though.
Even a North America TDI would be enough for city driving tho. As you only make use of the torque most of the time. It's only when you go onto Interstates (or tracks) then horsepower becomes important.
Speaking of Diesel Fuel (Score:2)
For those who don't want to read the article, it describes VW's latest test/concept car. Two person, 600 lbs car. It has a tank for 1.7 gallons and gets better than 260 MPG(though only rated for 235. ONLY.). And no, it's not slow. They rated the top speed as over 70 MPH. Which is plenty fast, even for highway travel.
Ontopic: it runs on diesel fuel. Who wants to mod this car and make it even more environmentally friendly? "It barely even burns Vegetable Oil!"
I don't, however, know what's involved in applying the mod. Or if VW could even fit it in this car. But it would still be cool. I actually want one of these cars. Errr... this car. That would be sweet. *sigh* Time to go buy a lottery ticket.
Re:Speaking of Diesel Fuel (Score:2)
I used to own a vintage Aircooled VW (Karmann Ghia), and with the stock engine and transmission, it's top speed was 86 mph. However, power near the top end is pretty weak, especially up hills. Let me tell you, if you don't have a lot of power up above 50 mph or so, you WILL get jacked around on the freeway. Period.
(which is why I yanked the stock engine out of there and replaced it with a Porsche engine - NO problem attaining 86 mph - NO problem attaining 110+ - NO more getting jacked around on the freeway, trying to merge on enterance ramps, etc.)
I would never take a 70 MPH top-speed vehicle on ANY freeway. Speed Limit 55? What a joke. Wake up and smell the violators.
Not so simple (Score:5, Informative)
The most critical part of the diesel is the fuel pump and injectors. They run at 3000-5000 psi with very low volume per stroke, so leakage cannot be tolerated. The fuel has to be filtered extremely well (sub micron). My worry with biodiesel is that it might plug filters due to microbial growth [always a problem in diesel], or the vegatable oil hydrolyze into organic acid plus glycerol. The organic acids will cause corrosion of the injector pump plungers and injector tips. Not good at all. The fuel will also have different rubber swell characteristics, so you may get fuel leaks. I'd try this first on a imetal-to-metal Mercedes with simple to replace rubber rather than a Peugeot or VW with a fuel-lubricated pump and that main O ring soaking in fuel.
I expect vegatable oil could be made to work with additives: a biostat, acid neutralizer plus seal swell control. But it would have to remain a separate product becauase petroleum oil and vegatable oils aren't miscible. If you wanted a blend, you'd need an emulsifier, and the results might be too viscous.
Re:Not so simple (Score:2)
Actually, it's amazingly simple. (Score:5, Informative)
Rudolf Diesel designed his engine to run on vegetable oil. That's how it was originally supposed to work, and it was originally demonstrated at the World's Fair running peanut oil.
Modern diesel engines are slightly modified to optimally burn the refinery waste products we call "diesel fuel". But only slightly...
If you want to efficiently burn vegetable oil in an unmodified modern diesel, you should use biodiesel (easily home-made, see Tickell's site [veggievan.org] for details).
If you want to run straight veggie oil, you need to preheat the oil (no problem when the engine is running, plenty of heat easily available, but you will need a preheater or a small tank of "starter fuel" at startup time). You also need to make sure that your filters are very efficient, and that you have bacteria/fungi controls, and that you have a water trap. These are the same considerations with regular "diesel fuel", but since the latter is nasty hostile petrowaste and the former is edible bio-friendly fryer grease you will have to be much more careful and vigilant.
Most people running straight vegetable oil are uber-geeks. They like to tinker and they aren't afraid of breaking things, because they know they will be able to get something to work if they need to. If you don't feel like that is a description of you, try biodiesel instead, and you won't have to make any modifications to your vehicle at all. You can even mix biodiesel and petrodiesel with no problem.
Re: (Score:2, Funny)
It's not environmental, it's political (Score:2)
What you get is a renewable resource that may not be better for the environment, but is better for geopolitical reasons. That's not so bad in my book.
-jon
Smelly Mercedes with a tank full of vegetable oil (Score:2)
"I'd like to by a Greasecar" (Score:2)
Perfect... (Score:2)
Free Advertising! (Score:2)
Sorry, won't work... (Score:5, Informative)
To begin with, some links for self study:
- Dieselnet.com [dieselnet.com] has a great glossary [dieselnet.com] and provides some excellent links [dieselnet.com]
- Delphi [delphi.com] has some nice PDF's on Unit Injectors [delphi.com] and Common Rail [delphi.com]
- Here some information from Bosch [boschservice.com] - Siemens [siemensauto.com] has some nice pictures [siemensauto.com] of injection systems, mainly common rail
Due to the very high pressures (up to 2100 bars) and therefore high temperatures with modern fuel injection systems, you really go to the limit of what diesel fuel can do: You use it simultaneously as fuel, coolant and oil and it takes a good blend to fulfill all these requirements! The chemical formula is important as well as the physical properties. The DOE [doe.gov] has a webpage about diesel fuels [doe.gov]. Have a look at their online diesel fuel property database [doe.gov] and see which properties are essential for characterizing fuel. Other important factors are
- durability
- particles/filtration
- compressability/resistance against cavitation
Not to forget resistance of all sealings etc against the fuel. Think RME and you know why almost everybody in the industry (e.g. SCANIA [scania.com]) only approves blends with max 5% alternative fuels...
Don't get me wrong, but if those fuels are ruining the car, we really can't talk about environmental advantages then, now can we? On the other hand, serious life cycle analysis like this one [doe.gov] and field studies [deep.org] will hopefully help to develop cleaner cars. If those are then driven by gas engines, diesel engines or fuel cells... who knows?
Hardware trolls AWOL? (Score:2, Funny)
and yet...
There is no "Imagine a Beowulf Cluster of these!" post.
"Greased Lightning" (Score:2)
In 10 seconds flat I was thinking about the car "Greased Lightning" from "Grease"
Anyone else think of Groundskeeper Willy? (Score:2, Funny)
"Yes, yes we do..."
"Well then grease me up woman!"
"Okie dokie."
Favourite Simpsons quote, ever.
Stay away from this crap! (Score:2, Interesting)
"Ach! That's my Retirement Grease!" (Score:3, Funny)
-Donut
There goes that insult.... (Score:4, Funny)
better for the environment????? (Score:2)
The biggest reduction is in CO2 which is not eliminated from the exhaust emissions but the oil plant absorbs as much CO2 in its growing cylce as the oil puts out when it is burned. This creates a balance
Ummmm, excuse me, but where did all the CO2 from burned gasoline originate? In the dinosaurs and the plants that died and became oil. hmmmm....sounds like a balance to me
Re:better for the environment????? (Score:2)
from plants -> animals that lived dozens of millions of years ago. Earth's ecosystem has long-since balanced itself to run witnout that carbon in the system. pumping it all back in in what, geologically and ecologically speaking is an instant of time can cause what D&Ders used to refer to as 'system shock'.
When the polar ice caps finish melting (the north pole is probably going to be gone by mid century), then the planet's temperatures are really going to spike, and we'll be facing some serious drought and heat-wave problems.
Dunno if this is a ridiculous question or not, (Score:2)
Has anyone considered the possibility of building a fuel cell along those lines as well? One that you could, say, start with a small fireplace in order to heat the vegetable oil/grease to a vapor state sufficient to combust?
While vehicles aren't the most efficient energy consumers, most homes are considerably worse...
And then there's possibilities for developing nations, to both do away with a large amount of pollution, where even small villages could have electricity with waste products as the fuel (some do this already with methane producing cesspits)... Just retrofitting old diesel generator rigs with a system like this could move a lot of areas into at least the 20th century...
Re:Simpsons (Score:2, Funny)
Man #1: It's our grease now. [he takes Homer's shovel and hits him over the head with it]
Homer: Daahhh!!
Man #2: We run the grease racket in this town. [they start to leave]
Homer: Hey, that's my shovel!
Man #1: We also run the shovel racket.
[the two men drive away in their truck labeled "Acne Grease and Shovel"]
Re:WOOHOO! (Score:2, Funny)
Re:It is illegal to drive with home-made fuel (Score:2)
Re:It is illegal to drive with home-made fuel (Score:2)
I know that it's illegal to put aviation gasoline in your car because no road tax was paid on it. I suspect there could be some variation of that problem in this case as well.
Re:Cheap only if the grease is free... (Score:2)
Re:Back to the Future (Score:2)
Re:Producing vegetable oil (Score:2)
Boy, sounds like an impressive comment, but I'll be damned if I see much useful info in it. Sorry:)
Re:THIS IS NOT FOR ALL DIESELS!! (Score:3, Informative)
2 : to reduce to minute particles or to a fine spray
Ever seen a perfume atomizer? It just makes a really fine spray.. doesn't break any chemical bonds. (: