Exxon And Timex Release The Speedpass watch 362
introverted writes "Exxon and Timex have released a Speedpass-enabled watch. From the article, this sounds like a regular Timex watch with an RFID chip in it. According to a radio news story, you can not only use the watch to buy gas, but at some locations in Chicago you can also use it at McDonald's. The watch is available from Timex. This was first mentioned on Slashdot in March last year."
News? (Score:5, Informative)
Re:News? (Score:2)
Then, there's plenty of quite fine domestic coffee here (OK, the raw materials come from the Americas, but you see what I mean), and finally I'm a fat penniless bastard, and I can still find cheap ski resorts with this system enabled, to which I can lug my Toyota at 130km/h not 130.1 otherwise the Prunomatic radars a
Re:News? (Score:3, Funny)
Hi ... (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Hi ... (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Hi ... (Score:5, Funny)
Get a life. No privacy issue here. (Score:5, Insightful)
Pull up to the pump. Exit car. Wave Speedpass over receiver. While it is authorizing, take off your gas cap, lift the nozzle, and select your fuel type. By then, the authorization's gone through and you're already pumping. When full, replace nozzle. By the time you screw the gas cap back on, the receipt is ready. Get back in car and drive off. And if you don't want to wait for your receipt, no worries, it doesn't have your credit card number on it anyway.
Debit might sound like not much more hassle, but remember: I'm in Canada. It gets damn cold up here in the winter. I can pay with Speedpass and pump my gas without ever having to remove my gloves or mitts. Not so with debit. Try taking out your wallet, removing and swiping your card, then punching a bunch of buttons with mitts on in -35 degree weather. Aside from being slower, it's just plain not possible.
People who shriek about "privacy" regarding these types of benign things have either never used them, or are just whoring for karma. There is no privacy issue. They're basically just a credit card you don't have to sign for.
If you lose the tag, cancel the credit card. Same as if you'd lost the card itself. Since the Speedpass tags are almost always with your car keys anyway, if you lost your tag, then you probably lost your car keys too, and you've got more things to worry about than privacy. Like, say for example, canceling that credit card and finding your car!
Re:Get a life. No privacy issue here. (Score:5, Insightful)
I'm surprised how many people have said, "just cancel the card" here. Its not THAT tightly bound to the card. I had mine bound to a check card a year before they approved it. Also, they call you when they detect unusual activity. I had to fill up every 2 days for 2 weeks, so they called to see if everything was ok.
Re:Get a life. No privacy issue here. (Score:3, Informative)
Not sure how it works in Canada, but here in the Chicago Area, the Speedpass has a unique number that is tied to a credit card. Lose the Speedpass, you just cancel the pass and not the card itself.
As for the privacy aspect, I've had one of these for about three years and it sure comes in handy. It gets cold here in Chicago as well so the less time standing by the pump, the better. We can also use them at McDonald's. I don't have to juggle the kids, keys, and ca
You don't have to sign for a credit card (Score:4, Insightful)
Not to mention the fact that you don't technically have to sign for a credit card either. Do you sign anything when you pay at the pump with your credit card?
(sound of crickets)
Yeah, that's what I thought. Even on purchases, you don't always have to sign. What do you sign when you make an internet transaction? If you go to a store, they technically don't have to make you sign something if it is under a certain dollar amount (can't remember offhand what it is).
Personally, I don't use a Speedpass because I don't always go to Mobil. If I had one, I would probably always go to them, and I refuse to be controlled by their clever, evil marketing ideas. :-)
Re:Get a life. No privacy issue here. (Score:3, Informative)
Hello...Earth to Clown Planet :) (Score:3, Interesting)
Where that approach hasn't quite reached c'cards just yet.
Take a pill, jill :)
Re:Hi ... (Score:2)
Re:Hi ... (Score:2)
Re:Hi ... (Score:2)
Re:Hi ... (Score:2)
If you want to get ultra-paranoid about that, they use this information to figure out the exact time and place to send the aliens in to abduct you!
Gas + Food (Score:5, Funny)
Hello, I'll take premium fuel for my car and sub-standard fuel for my body.
And Super Size it.
Re:Gas + Food (Score:2)
Re:Gas + Food (Score:2)
-B
Y'know, I don't think... (Score:4, Insightful)
A month later, all of them has taken down the receivers and nary a word was said. I think the central problem in this one example is that nobody wants to hand 10 bucks to a holding company to buy burgers on 49-cent Wednesday.
We want to use our debit cards like we do almost everywhere else.
GTRacer
- 1077, same as a cheese pizza and a soda...
Re:Y'know, I don't think... (Score:3)
IMO the problem is only the lack of support, so to speak. If you can only use it at one or two places, the effort to setup an account and get the equipment isn't really worth the time.
Re:Y'know, I don't think... (Score:3, Insightful)
And as far as support goes, debit card acceptance has really taken off. There are few places I go now that I have to pay with anything other than debit (or the debit card acting in check card mode).
One piece of plastic that I was already carrying, made more useful with the PIN Pad explosion. I don't have to remember fobs, dongles, or buttons.
I'd be curious to see how man
Re:Y'know, I don't think... (Score:3, Interesting)
When my local Mobil was having trouble authenticating their Speedpasses to hq, they kept calling the cops with license plates of "non-payers". I found this out b/c my wife said it took a couple tries for the light to stay on the very first time she used it, but she showed me the receipt she ended up getting anyway. The next day, a cop was at the door and explained the situation. I told h
Re:Y'know, I don't think... (Score:3, Insightful)
I'm not sure if we're talking about the same thing here - I don't want to use RFID + debit. I meant that I can already use ordinary pin-based debit at 97% of the places I spend money, so what does an RFID fob and a holding account get me?
I know I'm not a typical consumer, but I can debit my gas, most food purchases, movie tickets, groceries, Home Depot, Wal-Mart and Target. Games, video rentals, most mall s
I need an RFID transceiver (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:I need an RFID transceiver (Score:2)
If that is saying much...=)
How is this "security through obscurity"? You swipe your card/speedpass, it calls Visa, and says yes or no...it's not too difficult, most 16 year olds do this working at the mall...
Re:I need an RFID transceiver (Score:3, Informative)
Re:I need an RFID transceiver (Score:3, Informative)
Unless there are some very sensative RFID antennas out there, I wouldn't feel weird at all about carrying it around.
Re:I need an RFID transceiver (Score:4, Insightful)
of course people have no qualms with handing their credit card to any kid in a smock, and swiping a credit card number from their machines is no-tech/no-cost/no-brained compared to an RFID receiver.
then there's the lack of an increase in car-theft that followed the proliferation of rf key fobs to lock/unlock car doors.
perhaps the hard cap of people willing to commit meat-space crimes has already been reached - regardless of the level of technology? particularly when they can still easily perform the same type of theft without even knowing what rfid is?
aside from all that, credit card theft leaves the burden of proof on the bank - not me. it's their money that's in limbo while the issue is up in the air. with debit, theft can result in the money being gone from my account until they can resolve the issue. a much more worrying situation. particularly considering the average speed of bank investigations when it's your money on the line.
so while i would be extremely hesitant to tie an rf payment fob to a debit card, i'm open to the idea of tying it to a credit card probably even without strong encryption.
of course i'm already hesitant to use debit cards for the same reason. particularly since i've yet to find a vendor who actually requires the pin to be entered. though admittedly i don't use it much.
Re:I need an RFID transceiver (Score:3, Interesting)
Nope. Just a unique serial number is transmitted. RFID was not invented for security reasons, but for inventory.
Re:I need an RFID transceiver (Score:3, Informative)
With RFID, this poster is speculating that the RFID reader not be visible, or even super-close to the RFID chip. With a credit card, you know every time the number is pulled from the card, because you swipe it.
With RFID, you might not even know your number was swiped, because of the radio nature of these devices.
While I'm not saying it would be easy, I think it would be significantly easier to
Re:I need an RFID transceiver (Score:3, Informative)
You don't eat out much, do you?
It's way harder to steal somebodies CC number. You have to own (or have good access to) the magnetic card reader.
Cell phone w/digital camera or a James Bond [prezzybox.com] cig lighter...
Very fast and relatively cheap way for a dishonest waiter or waitress to quickly snag hundred
Great... (Score:2, Insightful)
Lost the time?
Which do you value more? I hope the watch band is sturdy.
Excellent, (Score:3, Funny)
In related news ... (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:In related news ... (Score:2)
The UN may be many things, but the single world government it isn't. Imagine more a commitee of people that really loath each other...
Best way to get consumers to accept RFIDs? (Score:2)
Well, there's only one logical solution. Implanted microchip in the index finger.
And if you bitch about your "privacy," the terrorists win. Remember that.
Re:Best way to get consumers to accept RFIDs? (Score:3, Informative)
What if someone steals my credit card? Come on, its the same threat you can make about anything (what if someone steals my wallet?).
Re:Best way to get consumers to accept RFIDs? (Score:3, Insightful)
Sign the back. I don't see anywhere to sign the back of my watch.
what if someone steals my wallet?
So I don't carry cash. But I'll be damned if I'll go from a more secure to less secure method of transaction. I also imagine there's no credit protection for this speedpass system, as there is for all credit cards. No go.
Re:Best way to get consumers to accept RFIDs? (Score:2)
1.) How many people really check the signature.
2.) How many ways can you use it without a signature (like a gas station, etc...)?
Re:Best way to get consumers to accept RFIDs? (Score:2, Redundant)
Right, but again, *I'm* not responsible if they don't, my credit card covers me completely. If Speedpass guarantees against theft, it's a different story, I thought they didn't.
And believe it or not, more places check than you'd think.
Re:Best way to get consumers to accept RFIDs? (Score:3, Insightful)
My experience (and I'm sure other people will chime in) says the complete opposite. I've used my parents credit cards to buy many things. I'm not talking about going and buying a pack of gum. I'm talking about TVs, air conditioners, stereo systems. Thousands of dollars. I was almost never questioned, even though I was signing a different name than was on the credit card (some times I just signed anything, who can read the scribble that is some peop
Re:Best way to get consumers to accept RFIDs? (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Best way to get consumers to accept RFIDs? (Score:3, Informative)
"Credit cards MUST be signed. The words "Ask for ID" are not acceptable."
Re:Best way to get consumers to accept RFIDs? (Score:2)
The rf only works for a distance of a couple inches for the keychain fob and wristwatch. No pringles can from across the parking lot, nor the ability to reproduce a keyfob with your RFID in it. Also, it only acts as a conduit to the frontend charge system for your Visa card. It is not ano
Re:Best way to get consumers to accept RFIDs? (Score:2)
No doubt many people would get the chip planted in their middle finger.
Keeps a lickin' (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Keeps a lickin' (Score:2)
Ever owned one of their watches? Doesn't apply to them either.
RF snooping (Score:2, Interesting)
Or is thinking of this a violation of the DMCA.
Re:RF snooping (Score:2)
http://www.ti.com/tiris/docs/news/news_
Time and money. (Score:4, Interesting)
It's kind of cool (not really) how when we were little we saw visions of distopia and laughed. Now we see the building blocks being built before our eyes.
I sure hope they build tinfoil hats with "speedpasses" so I don't have to take mine off to get a cheeseburger.
Re:Time and money. (Score:2)
Please go on further about how a system which makes transferring money easier is a 'building block' to a world where one is classified by how much money spent per unit time. My hope is that you'll realize how stupid your statement was.
Re:Time and money. (Score:2)
Now reread 'Ubik' by Phillip K Dick
I've had mine for almost a year... (Score:5, Informative)
The RF chip is in the band, not the watch.
I swapped the Timex watch body for a decent Casio
The watch works much better at the POS terminals inside the stations/stores, where the key tags have always had mediocre luck.
They both work well on the pumps.
Re:I've had mine for almost a year... (Score:2)
I wonder if it uses the same module as the speedpass, just repackaged in the band? My speedpass had a glass oil-filled capsule inside it (so it's hermetically sealed), cradled in some rubber to insulate it from shocks. I put the thing in my pen and I have AFAIK the world's only speedpass pen. The glass module might not be a good idea for a b
Re:I've had mine for almost a year... (Score:4, Interesting)
But, boy is it nice when it's about 3 below, and the pump is ready to go by the time you get out of your car. Privacy, shimvacy, its effin' freezing out! I only wish they, and more, places would take EZ Pass.. especially parking garages. Sometimes I just want to drive without stopping or rolling my windows down, is that too much to ask?
Ohhhhh, shiney! (Score:2, Insightful)
Come on people, form an orderly line! There's enough for everybody to have one!
Get your own mark of the beast right here!
You idiot geeks and your gadget fetish. You'd scream bloody murder if GW Bush forced you to wear one of these. But since it's a neat gadget and a convienence, you'll don your shackles eagerly. ex - see CELL PHONES
Re:Ohhhhh, shiney! (Score:2)
By the way, I can't see myself messing with one of these RFID things for the near-term, but I've gotta say, better to wear it AROUND your wrist than INSIDE it.
Won't Work (Score:2)
First of all, its a luxury, which is good during great economy times (which hasn't happened in over a year, now).
Second, it will only be effective if speedpass is common in a populous area (and does the seconds faster it takes than a credit card really make it that much better?).
Third, people freak out when they see RFID even though it gives out as much info as using the credit cards everyone uses.
User verification... (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:User verification... (Score:2)
I don't know about the watches, but I have a speedpass, and there's no security. Just swipe and go. I got it when they first came out, long before the whole RFID craze, and I admit, I didn't really think about the privacy implications. (OTOH, it can be used while wearing gloves, and getting a card out of you
Great Geek Watches? (Score:4, Interesting)
There are: watches with simple computer functions, watches with atomic clock radio recievers, watches with digital cameras, watches with IR remotes, watches with calculator/basic PIM functions, watches that run on Mars time and pager watches.
Any others? What is your fav?
Re:Great Geek Watches? (Score:2)
Re:Great Geek Watches? (Score:2)
Mine tells time. It has a big hand, a little hand, and a big but thin hand that moves frequently.
Re:Great Geek Watches? (Score:3, Interesting)
Of these, only the IR Remote and Camera watches have become part of the permanent product line. Casio still produces calculator watches, but without scientific functions.
It's nice, but (Score:4, Funny)
Lovely (Score:2, Redundant)
Hacking for fun and profit? (Score:5, Interesting)
Really, how is the security / authentication implemented here?
Re:Hacking for fun and profit? (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Hacking for fun and profit? (Score:3, Insightful)
Besides, the actual credit card number isn't on the tag, simply a tag ID value that converts back to a credit card on file at SpeedPass headquarters. This creates an extra layer of transaction approval, as Mobil can quic
The RFID is in the band -- not the watch (Score:2)
This means the watch band could possibly be attached to different watches. It also means you better be careful with that old, broken watch band!
Think this could be a good deal for the people at Target who get stuck replacing watch bands for people?
(Imaginary conversation)
Clerk: Here you go. I just put the new band on your watch to replace your broken one. Do you want me to throw away
stop and shop (Score:2)
I got mine for free. (Score:2, Informative)
The grocery chain is running a pilot program in my area-- as soon as we found out about it, we went up to the customer service desk, hooked our speedpass into their accounting system and a month later had a new watch!
Five finger pass (Score:3, Interesting)
Do PROM-style RFIDs exist? Could you overhear the challenge-response interaction at the pump and make your own copy?
Enquiring thieves want to know.
PROBLEM (Score:3, Insightful)
however, ALL gadget watches (with the sole exception of the Breitling with the emergency beacon in it) look like cack on your wrist and mark you out as a sad sack.
USB watch storage? Ugh. Microsoft Spot? Ack. That Fossil Palm-on-your-wrist? Please.
Real men buy Omega Seamasters and leave the gadgets in their pockets.
How exactly is this invasion of privacy? (Score:2)
Also, the RFID-enabled watch is not mandatory for purchases. Want anonymity? Pay cash.
Also, no personal data is stored on the watch, according to the manufacturer. All it does is link back to a Speedpass account number.
Per
groceries (stop and shop) too, in a few places (Score:2)
pretty convenient, to have ability to pay for gas and food even if you lose your wallet.
I'm a privacy bigot, but to me this is acceptable.
I KNOW they're tracking these purchases (they have to for it to work) and their ppolicy is fine.
Do you still need an SSN? (Score:5, Interesting)
Needless to say, I never heard back, and I don't intend to ever get one if the SSN is required. Or maybe I'll just make one up and see what happens.
For those who don't know - it is not a credit device, it is a billing device. It links to an existing credit card. They may have expanded to granting credit, but it was not part of the deal when I tried to sign up.
Better solutions? (Score:2)
I don't have a complete alternative, but I'm thinking of something like "digital money" i.e. you purchase tokens (digital coins, generated with a public
Sad. (Score:2)
Its no wonder that judges and congress see no problem in re-interpreting our basic foundation on a whim. People don't seem to care about their rights and freedoms, so why should they be protected?
What if I want to pay cash? (Score:2)
I think the RFID system would be better if I had to press a button on the watch to register my acceptance of their payment request.
Chip H.
My timex watch says... (Score:2)
Using a Speedpass to buy McDonalds... (Score:3, Insightful)
Great. (Score:2, Funny)
Invasion of privacy? How about credit card fraud? (Score:3, Insightful)
Wireless internet connection + speedpass reader + batterys or whatever power source...
I don't know about you, but I'd rather not have my pocket picked electronically...
RFID's a security risk? Come on.... (Score:3, Insightful)
http://www.ti.com/tiris/docs/news/news_releases/ 90 s/rel04-05-99.shtml
"RFID systems feature a digital signature encryption protocol that has a challenge/response authentication to ensure complete consumer protection.
This technique makes it extremely difficult, if not impossible to duplicate the transponder (tag), or the secret encryption key. And, even if the key were duplicated, it would only be valid for one tank of gas, making it a very expensive tank of gasoline for a would-be criminal. "
My ta
Is it more secure? (Score:3, Interesting)
Though you may have a point there. I guess I don't see RFID being any less secure, than, say, the internet. And I'm sure as hell not going to stop using Amazon.
I-PASS watch? (Score:4, Funny)
Compared to credit cards -- (Score:5, Insightful)
Consider, for example, the following:
1. We give our credit cards to a less-than minimum wage employee each time we pay for a meal at a restaraunt. The credit card leaves our sight for several minutes.
2. We give our credit card with no signature over the phone and internet all the time.
3. Does anyone match the signature on the credit card with the signature you provide anyway? I've seen it done in some cities, but here in the West people normally give you the card back before you even sign.
4. This could go on, but the point is made.
Credit cards work because the companies cover the losses (for the most part). It's cheaper to cover losses than to prevent them. These watches and whatever else comes in the future will probably work the same.
Nothing's changed here, people. Move along...
Universal ID (Score:4, Interesting)
Yeah, yeah. No doubt several of you will post something about tin foil hats and all, but then you obviously do not read your history.
First they came for the jew, but I did nothing....
More and more... (Score:4, Insightful)
So when can I... (Score:3, Interesting)
Get a calendar printed on paper currency?
Get a sundial added to Sacagawea dollars?
I can go on....
make your own. (Score:3, Interesting)
I simply ground down my speedpass dongle until I got to the thickness I desired and then ground down the sides for length. Then after I broke that one, I did it to the second one knowing what to expect and called in the first one as lost.
I then superglued it inside the leather band of my watch.
really simple and sounds like the exact same thing they did.
NOTE: record your speedpass numbers and keep them in a safe place when you need to report it lost/stolen.
Re:bad idea (Score:4, Insightful)
So? Don't lose it. How hard is that? (Score:2)
Simple solution? Don't lose the watch. Don't let your watch get stolen. It's the exact same solution we prescribe for credit cards - what makes it so unreasonable for your watch? If someone's going to break into your gym locket to steal your "Speedpass" watch, why wouldn't they also grab your wallet, car keys, and anything else valuable?
Re:Make sure it has a good band! (Score:2)
Re:Make sure it has a good band! (Score:2)
Its not as if its magically passing money around - its just passing an account number, that (in this case) is even more obscured since its linked to a (changable at will) credit card number.
Re:This is great news. (Score:4, Insightful)
Now, if we imbed the RFID chip in their skull, then it might work... With enough science, technology, and BigBrother (TM) we can get kids to go to school.
Or we could just pay attention to our kids, and make our schools interesting enough that kids want to go, and get parents to stop ignoring their kids as soon as they can use the bathroom on their own....
Hmm, looks like science and technology will win this one, eh?
Re:This is great news. (Score:2)
Dunno about you, but the kids I went to school with would have it out of their skull in ten minutes. Or, at least, would have it out of other kids' skulls.
Vendor lock-in attempt (Score:2)
I normally go to the most inexpensive gas station I can find on the right side of the street I'm currently travelling on. I don't want to have to choose Exxon because of a silly speedpass thing. Besides most stations take credit cards at the pump these days.
Except Shell, which one out of three times asks you to go see the attendant when you try to use a CC. I just drive off and find another station; I'm not giving them my business if they