Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Software Government Politics

Texas Legislature Considers Open Document Formats 149

An anonymous reader notes that a legislator in Texas has introduced a bill to require open document formats in all state government business. The bill is carefully worded such that only ODF could pass its test as "open." The story is covered by the Fort Worth Star Telegram, which is careful to be even-handed, giving Microsoft's spokesman equal time. A ZDNet blogger notes that the bill, introduced by a Democrat in a state whose politics is dominated by Republicans, faces chances that "...fall somewhere east of slim and west of none."
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Texas Legislature Considers Open Document Formats

Comments Filter:
  • whilst it's always good to see genuinely open formats in use, isn't there already an ISO standard document format? If there is, is it better to use the ISO standard or an open standard?
    • Re: (Score:3, Informative)

      by iYk6 ( 1425255 )

      whilst it's always good to see genuinely open formats in use, isn't there already an ISO standard document format? If there is, is it better to use the ISO standard or an open standard?

      There are 2 ISO standard document formats (not including ASCII et al). Only one of them is open, and that is the format that this bill recommends, ODF. A "non-open standard" is sort of useless as a standard, and is more trouble than it is worth. The non-open ISO document format standard, MOO-XML, should be avoided.

      • There are 2 ISO standard document formats (not including ASCII et al). Only one of them is open, and that is the format that this bill recommends, ODF. A "non-open standard" is sort of useless as a standard, and is more trouble than it is worth. The non-open ISO document format standard, MOO-XML, should be avoided.

        How is one more open than the other? (If you are going to say patents--don't bother. Both are patented, and both are available under nearly identical patent convenants).

    • Re: (Score:3, Informative)

      Yes, and ODF is one of those ISO standards.

    • whilst it's always good to see genuinely open formats in use, isn't there already an ISO standard document format? If there is, is it better to use the ISO standard or an open standard?

      ODF is an ISO [desktoplinux.com] standard, as is Microsoft's OOXML [wired.com] format. However ODF is an open standard whereas OOXML is proprietary. As the Star-Telegram [star-telegram.com] article says "If the Constitution was in WordPerfect 5.1 format, it would probably be difficult to read right now", substitute any of MS's formats and it would still be true.

      Falcon

      • falconwolf wrote:

        whilst it's always good to see genuinely open formats in use, isn't there already an ISO standard document format? If there is, is it better to use the ISO standard or an open standard?

        ODF is an ISO standard, as is Microsoft's OOXML format. However ODF is an open standard whereas OOXML is proprietary. As the Star-Telegram article says "If the Constitution was in WordPerfect 5.1 format, it would probably be difficult to read right now", substitute any of MS's formats and it would still b

        • I'm not sure if it would be that difficult to read a document in the WordPerfect 5.1 format right now since the current version of WordPerfect and both OpenOffice.org and StarOffice will open the file.

          It depends on whether the file format was proprietary, and MS's OOXML is proprietary. OO.org can open some MS file formats but it does not display them all correctly.

          Falcon

  • by Nimey ( 114278 ) on Friday March 20, 2009 @11:16AM (#27269585) Homepage Journal

    And semi-dirty to dirty politicking if that doesn't convince them. Remember Massachusetts.

    • Re: (Score:2, Troll)

      by tjstork ( 137384 )

      And semi-dirty to dirty politicking if that doesn't convince them. Remember Massachusetts.

      Hey, Massachusetts has to pay for that health care bill somehow!

      • by Firehed ( 942385 )

        The one where they legally require you to buy your own private insurance and then call it universal healthcare? Yeah, I'm sure that one is costing the state billions.

        • IT is... (Score:2, Troll)

          by tjstork ( 137384 )

          The one where they legally require you to buy your own private insurance and then call it universal healthcare? Yeah, I'm sure that one is costing the state billions.

          It is, because if you cannot afford health insurance, the state picks up the tab. that's the whole key. Massachussetts has the lowest uninsured percentage in the country, by far, but it is expensive to do.

          • The one where they legally require you to buy your own private insurance and then call it universal healthcare? Yeah, I'm sure that one is costing the state billions.

            It is, because if you cannot afford health insurance, the state picks up the tab. that's the whole key.

            Except the state doesn't pick up the tab for everyone who can not afford health insurance. A few months ago CNN had special report on health care and part of it was about the Massachusetts system. One person in the report was a DJ for a radi

  • Make some calls (Score:5, Informative)

    by geekoid ( 135745 ) <dadinportland@y[ ]o.com ['aho' in gap]> on Friday March 20, 2009 @11:22AM (#27269671) Homepage Journal

    If you live in Texas, get involved with your reps to see that this gets passed.

    open documents means the government stays accessible to all. There is no reason not to want that in a republic.

    • New punctuation update "~" at the end of a line to indicate sarcasm. http://harns.blogspot.com/ [blogspot.com]

      I guess all those times I thought emacs was backing up my documents and source code files, it was actually just mocking what I had written in an ironic tone.

      • That's how I always took it. Good to see corroboration. (Might have felt a bit paranoid without it.)

        Anyway, parent thinks he's invented something new?

        There's precedent for sarcasm marks (sarcasm points), irony marks (irony points), doubt points, certitude points, acclamation points, authority points, indignation points, love points, and percontation points (rhetorical punctation).

        I recommend for him a bit of research before he thinks he's invented something and certainly before he commends others to actio

    • I contacted Representative Branch's office, and I sent to Senator West's office too asking that he introduce a companion bill there, or support it in any other ways he can.
  • It's called a PDF...

  • by CannonballHead ( 842625 ) on Friday March 20, 2009 @11:25AM (#27269701)

    Hm. It's the fault of the republicans I guess. Evil conservative types, wanting lock-ins. Definitely a republican problem. If we had more democrats in Texas, we would have more open standards! Just look at California, New York, Washington... look at all those open standards being used by those states! And democrat-liking Hollywood! Hollywood is a huge "open source," open document, non-DRM fan. What we need to do is legislate open formats, that way private companies can't be standards incompliant! That will fix the free market, private enterprise will flourish, etc.

    [/sarcasm]

    • by geekoid ( 135745 )

      I'm sorry, but the governor of California is a republican.
      Don't pollute the issue at hand with your dumb ass rant.

      • An extremely moderate Republican. Sacramento is primarily democrat, and California hasn't been "republican" for a while. The only reason Governor S. became governor of California is former Gov. Gray Davis's impeachment and a disillusionment with the democratic party because of it. CA Congress has 24 democrats and 15 republicans and a moderate to liberal "republican" governor that almost no republican is happy with. I'm more interested in positions, beliefs, stances, agendas, etc, than what party affilia

      • Re: (Score:3, Interesting)

        by jimwelch ( 309748 )

        As others have said, Arnold is a RINO to most Republicans. (Republican in Name Only)

        However, A quick true story will help understand the grayness of Liberal vs Conservative.
        A colleague of mine moved from CA. to OK. In CA, he thought he was a conservative. In OK, he discovered he was a liberal who was a little to the right towards being a moderate.

        In other words, Conservative/Liberal is in the eyes of the beholder!

        OK has a limited legislative session also.

        As a Staunch Republican, I use Linux, ODF, release pg

  • Don't let this thread turn into "Lets bash Texas!" please. I just see it coming, so I write this in hopes to get people thinking.

    I recently moved from Washington State to Houston, TX. Things are different here, that's no joke. Some people honestly think of this state as a sovereign country sometimes (and they were for a time... unfortunately). But people are people anywhere you go, and for the most part just want to be left alone down here, free from a government bothering them. This is fairly ing
    • by j1mmy ( 43634 )

      As an Illinois resident, I would be supremely happy if my legislature spent less time in session. The growing state debt and budget deficit has been caused by politicians unwilling to make the tough decisions necessary to turn things around.

    • What this boils down to, is a State Legislature that is inherently designed to be weak and making change difficult, especially at a state level. In every two year period they are allowed to meet for 140 days (barring a special session being called). Can you imagine your state legislature only meeting for 70 days a year?

      Yea, I've posted before about how I wish the US congress was the same and only worked about 120 days. What you left out though was that at first those elected to office had to work for a liv

  • by b4dc0d3r ( 1268512 ) on Friday March 20, 2009 @11:47AM (#27270007)

    The main argument, advanced by a Microsoft lobbyist, is that the bill is anti-competitive, and would be "like choosing Betamax over VHS."

    Wasn't Betamax the better of the two, and VHS only won because of porn? How does that analogy make any sense?

    • Re: (Score:2, Funny)

      The main argument, advanced by a Microsoft lobbyist, is that the bill is anti-competitive, and would be "like choosing Betamax over VHS."

      Wasn't Betamax the better of the two, and VHS only won because of porn? How does that analogy make any sense?

      Allow me. You see, most of the free online video players are available for MS Windows. What's the reason for online video? Porn. That's the only reason why folks use Windows is for porn. Therefore, all of us Windows users are degenerate porno viewers.

    • by geekoid ( 135745 )

      No, betamax is better, but to use the tapes you were charged a licensing fee. Add to that VHS came out with a longer tape shortly before Betamax did.

      But yes, that argument makes no sense.

    • Wasn't Betamax the better of the two

      So what was wrong with the analogy again? ;)

    • Wasn't Betamax the better of the two, and VHS only won because of porn?

      Betamax's [wikipedia.org] big brother, Betacam [wikipedia.org] was used extensively in professional television production until it was recently supplanted by hard disks.

    • "And therefor, you must acquit!"

  • by E. Edward Grey ( 815075 ) on Friday March 20, 2009 @12:12PM (#27270431)

    Go right ahead, Ballmer. You can bribe those oily Europeans until they're shining your car, but I dare you to budge the courageous and independent public officials of Texas! They cannot be bought and will stand tall against oh my god who am I kidding here open document formats are doomed.

    • The nice thing is these days you have myriads of these initiatives and all you can achieve with a lot of lobbying is to kill them. Poor old monopolist.

      So why not start another one as to watch the chairs flying around...

      You after all don't get bribed for playing nice.

  • http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123698935539126273.html [wsj.com]

    ----
    Among the reasons for Nebraska's economic strength is a long history of strong executive leadership and an independent legislature. But mainly these factors exist because we have an inquiring public that demands to know how tax dollars are spent. That's called accountability, and it was the inspiration behind my effort to create NebraskaSpending.com, a searchable, public database that discloses every aspect of state government spending. By allowing

  • They only way for ODF to fail is if big-business buys the result. I'm sure America has learnt over the past few months not to let big business dictate the politics.

    Ha ha ha ha.

  • Ok, I can understand ODF for collaboration, but is that the best format for publication? Why not PDF or XPS?
  • Aside from my quibbles that multiple implementations or "uses XML" should not really be part of the definition of an open format, there is not a clear way to interpret the bill as excluding OOXML, the format MS rammed through as an ISO standard to compete with ODF. So if the intent is to support ODF and disallow OOXML, I don't see that this will do it. (The bill as written requires documents to be an open document format, which the bill defines as one that is XML, open, interoperable across platforms and

To the landlord belongs the doorknobs.

Working...