2014 Geek Gift Guide 113
Most annual gift guides would only list new items. It would be considered a mortal sin of click-baiting to tell the reader, "Well, the coolest stuff we could tell you about, was stuff that we mentioned this time last year, so first and foremost we're just going to direct you to that."
Well, my job in writing a gift guide is not to dazzle people with "all new hottest gift item" recommendations, my job is to recommend the things that I think you would most enjoy giving and the recipient would most enjoy receiving, and the fact of the matter is that most of the gifts I would most highly recommend, were listed in different previously written articles. I'll provide that list in a second (with links back to the older articles describing them in more detail), but first some criteria for how I make the recommendations.
First, I'm assuming you want to go inexpensive. If you have unlimited cash, you don't need my help finding cool presents -- although for the record, the online store of New York's Museum of Modern Art has the best collection of things that incorporate "visual puns" that I really like, but which are usually overpriced for what the item does. (Check out this image of a set of nesting tables, for example -- which isn't even that much of a "neat idea", by their standards -- and try to guess how much they cost, before looking at the answer on the product page.) If you don't mind spending the money, they also sell a dandelion encased in acrylic ($375), a lamp in the shape of an open book ($190), a necklace of small rectangular mirrors creating an interesting 3D effect ($190), a porcelain vase that kind of looks like a crinkled paper bag ($120), a pair of candleholders that interlock without touching ($170), a serving tray that looks like the splash from a drop of water ($130), a clock that evokes an M.C. Escher "infinite staircase" optical illusion ($80), and a vase that exists in the shape of an outline ($65, which at this point sounds cheap). At the end of this gift guide I list some MoMA items that are somewhat more reasonably priced.
Second, I'm assuming you don't need help finding branded merchandise. I'm sure literally every combination of [Star Wars / LOTR / Game of Thrones / Star Trek / Hunger Games] and [coffee mug / beach towel / earrings / Christmas tree ornaments / shot glass / cufflinks] is available somewhere. It's not that these are bad gifts for the hardcore fan, it's that all you need to find them is to Google "Game of Thrones Christmas tree ornaments" and you'll find something. And occasionally you'll will find something in this "branded" category that jumps out as a pretty cool idea, like the TARDIS Tea Infuser or the Game of Thrones Dragonclaw Goblet or the light-up lightsaber chopsticks.
Third, I look mostly for novelty or decorative items that confound your senses or demonstrate some interesting scientific principle (or both), but that can still fit in to a semi-elegant environment without garishly calling attention to themselves. These color changing beads are kind of neat, but it would look weird having them lying around on top of a living room dresser along with a UV flashlight to demonstrate what they do. On the other hand, a Galileo thermometer can blend in pretty well the decorations on a mantlepiece.
The following are my current most-recommended gift ideas:
Custom Photomosaic
In this December 2013 post I described how to create a photomosaic (a patchwork of smaller pictures that, when viewed from a distance, take on the appearance of a larger picture) using two free (donation-supported) programs, one to download and save pictures en masse from a friend's Facebook profile, and the other to create the photomosaic using those photos. I still think they make amazing gifts, and the only cost is the cost of printing and framing it. You can even give the digital-only version as a gift that costs nothing at all, making a photomosaic from a friend's photos and sending it to them on the other side of the world, where they can print it themselves or use it as a desktop background. Everyone that I've given one of these to, has loved it.
Strandbeest kit
With this $35 kit, which I recommended as a Christmas gift last year, you can assemble a tabletop version of the legendary full-size Strandbeests, the eerily lifelike creatures created by Dutch artist Theo Jansen which walk across the beaches of Holland powered only by the wind. Assembly of the creature takes about 90 minutes, less if you make a family activity out of it and share the labor.
In the last year, a second model has been released, dubbed the "Rhinoceros Mini-Beest (technically, it was available a year ago, but the assembly instructions were only printed in Japanese; now it's available with English directions). I haven't assembled one of these myself yet, but it looks fine in the video.
There is also now a pre-assembled, motorized, remote-control version of the Strandbeest, although honestly, where's the fun in that? Part of the effect of the Strandbeest assembly kit is the feeling that you've breathed life into an inanimate object by putting it together from static parts. A remote-control toy that moves forwards and backwards on the ground is a little underwhelming when you can get an RC helicopter for the same price.
Levitron Revolution and Levitron Cherrywood
The Levitron Revolution ($70) consists of a circular magnetic disc that levitates about half an inch above an electrically powered square base, and can support up to a pound of weight on top of it while maintaining levitation. The Levitron Cherrywood ($35) consists of a top that has to be spun by hand, which levitates almost a full two inches above the cherrywood base containing an embedded magnet. As described in the first gift guide, the Levitron Cherrywood is more visually impressive because of the extra height of levitation, but the top almost always falls if you touch the top or move the base while the top is spinning. The Levitron Revolution only levitates the disc by half an inch, but you can embellish the appearance by placing other objects on top of it, like the pyrite crystal levitating in this video. (Also, the Levitron Revolution will continue levitating as long as power is supplied to it, making it a good decorative item; the Levitron Cherrywood has to be spun by hand and levitates for only about two minutes before air friction slows it down, so it works better as a toy or party activity.) Both of them take some practice to operate (the Levitron Cherrywood takes considerably more), but they're worth it.
Spare batteries for your friend's phone
I mentioned this in January 2013 as a life hack for smartphones and got pilloried for promoting what people called an "obvious" idea. But two years later, almost nobody that I know is carrying around fully charged extra batteries for their phones. It's easy, it works, and the spare batteries in my jacket pockets have gotten me out of a jam multiple times. If you know what type of phone your gift recipient uses, get them some extra batteries. (T-Mobile sent me extra batteries for my LG Optimus for free.)
The iPhone is the only phone I'm aware of that does not support this, because the battery is not meant to be removed or replaced by the user.
And yes, I know about the portable external battery products that can be used to charge a phone. These aren't as big or expensive as they used to be, but you still have to leave them plugged in to your phone while they're charging it, which is awkward if you're using your phone or carrying it in your pocket (compared to the 10 seconds it takes to swap out the battery).
Heat Wave car heater
This $40 device from Canadian company "Heat & Clean" sits on your dashboard and turns itself on at a pre-determined time, blowing hot air into the interior of the car for 20 minutes, all without starting the car. If all goes well, this means your car will be warm (or at least not as cold as it would have been) when you first get into it in the morning, and you don't have to wait several minutes for the air ventilation system to heat up. The Heat Wave is powered by the car's 12V charger, although Heat & Clean states that "has built-in circuitry to ensure that the health of the vehicle's battery is never compromised."
I can't vouch for the device's respect for your battery (the device unfortunately isn't sold on Amazon, which is usually where I go to find out if something does what it's supposed to), but I ordered one and verified that it works, then gave it to my aunt for her birthday. (If it kills her car, I will promptly make it up to her by taking it out of the gift guide.) Even though I tested the functionality, I didn't get the chance to see if the device actually helps much, because it's not cold enough yet here in Seattle to really feel the bite of the cold when you get into your car in the morning. (The other reason I personally won't get much benefit from this, is that I work from home and leave the house at a different time every day, so I never know in advance what time I'll be getting into my car the next morning.)
Most cars can be modified so they can be started remotely, so that they're warmed up by the time you go outside and get into them, but that modification usually costs a few hundred dollars. You might as well try the Heat Wave first to see if it does the job almost as well.
(To me, the obvious question is: Why not make a version of the Heat Wave that can be turned remotely, as well? For people like me who usually don't know the night before what time they'll be getting into their car the next day, but who often do know at least 20 minutes in advance, so they can turn it on remotely and start heating the car. The company does make a very different-looking product called the Heat Stick which can be activated remotely -- but at $300, that's more than it costs to add remote start to the actual car.)
It's Nuts 3D puzzle
Distributed by Grand Illusions in the UK, the It's Nuts 3D puzzle consists of a bolt and a pair of nuts threaded onto the bolt. As you can see in the video, when you rotate one nut, it moves in the direction that you'd expect, following the threading on the bolt -- but when you rotate the other nut the same way, it moves in the opposite direction. There are no hidden moving parts to make the illusion work, and you can unscrew both nuts right off of the bolt and examine them.
Having acquired one, I can say that the secret is a little bit easier to figure out when you're holding it in your hand and looking at it closely, than when you're watching the video. But it still makes a nice novelty conversation piece.
As a brain-tickler, this feels a bit overpriced at $40 - costing more than the aforementioned Levitron Cherrywood, which actually levitates. I bought It's Nuts mainly to fill out my collection off oddities since I already owned most of the other items in this list. Of course, unlike the Levitron, this takes no skill to operate (only a little bit of smarts to figure out the secret). I wouldn't foist the Levitron on my grandfather, but he would probably enjoy this one.
(Note that if you buy from the Grand Illusions website to ship to the United States, you'll pay the non-VAT rate -- but then you'll have to add about $14 in air mail shipping to the U.S. So you might want to combine this order with some other items from Grand Illusions -- search this article for "Grand Illusions" for the other recommended items, or browse their site and pick your own.)
Inverter Magnet
The Inverter Magnet, from Grand Illusions (also available from Amazon at a slightly higher price), consists of one disc magnet encased in rubber, which holds a second disc magnet in a permanent "force field" a few millimeters away when the two are slid across a table.
At $40, this might be more of a "collection filler-outer", since especially as a magnetic toy it compares unfavorably with the Levitron Cherrywood, which, to repeat, can actually fly. But again, the Inverter Magnet also takes no skill to operate.
Magna Nails
This nail polish (about $7 used on Amazon) forms a stripe pattern when you hold a magnet near your fingernail while the polish is trying. (There are many similar products on the market, searchable under "magnetic nail polish.") The appeal to young science geeks is that the iron filings in the nail polish align themselves along magnetic field lines in the vicinity of the magnet, forming the stripes.
I don't wear glittery nail polish (at least not as "Bennett Haselton"...), but I took one for the team to see if this works. It does. That's my thumb. (Apparently it looks better if you apply a "top coat" after the nail polish dries, but I didn't have any.) If you plan on testing it out before giving it as a gift, remember to pick up some nail polish remover to get it off.
A few things from MoMA that we can actually afford
- An appetizer serving dish complete with toothpick holder that looks like a porcupine ($28). This item probably has the highest price-to-cool-factor ratio of anything on this list, just barely within the limit of what I'd recommend, but it's elegant in addition to being funny, and the recipient would probably use it.
- A faux-wood cube clock ($38). This is interesting mostly for looking like a visual impossibility -- how can the digital numbers appear on the side of a block of wood, even fake wood? Unfortunately I think the photo is doctored, because this youtube video shows an undoctored shot of the cube clock, and you can easily see the un-illuminated LEDs on the side, which don't quite blend in with the wood. But it still makes for an elegant optical illusion.
Miscellaneous "Visual Puns"
- The ambiguous vase ($33) from Grand Illusions -- a real-life version of the Rubin vase optical illusion, where a vase suddenly takes on the appearance of two faces in profile.
- The glass water faucet ($50)
- The sliced grandfather clock ($36)
- Ulexite "television stones" ($10) - a rock that, when placed on a flat surface, will cause the markings on that surface to re-appear on the top face of the rock, due to the naturally occurring fiber optics in ulexite.
Of course, if you're now craving one of these items for yourself, order one and try it out before re-gifting, or set up an Amazon wish list in the last two weeks before Christmas. And remember to be good!
The best gift? (Score:5, Insightful)
No more Bennett Haselton submissions. That's all I want for Christmas!
Re: (Score:1, Redundant)
I don't understand the hate for this guy.
The above post seems like just a long but reasonable commentary on some recent products. So what?
Is Bennet Haselton hate the new hipster-hate? Are people jumping on the Haselton-hate bandwagon because it's the latest trendy thing to do on ./? I'm not really sure, but it is pretty stupid.
Re: The best gift? (Score:5, Insightful)
No hate. Just want him to go post somewhere else.
Re: (Score:2)
Why?
Re: The best gift? (Score:5, Insightful)
because a good deal of what he writes is flawed, compositionally and methodologically, uninteresting, and lacks a certain element of news.
Someone has the temerity to assume that we would care what this man has to say about things he has no actual insight into.
Re: The best gift? (Score:5, Insightful)
Re: (Score:2)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B... [wikipedia.org]
Re: (Score:3)
I don't hate him. But that doesn't mean I want him yammering on. Post a short summary, like almost every slashdot article, then include a link to the longer blog post. It's not hard. I'd rather have the click bait.
Re:The best gift? (Score:4, Insightful)
I've never taken him seriously because the first time I ever heard of him was when he was running his web site with instructions on how to bypass parental filtering software. Mind you, nothing wrong with that, but he whined like a little girl when that web site got blocked by the very software he was trying to help people defeat.
Like a little girl.
Re: (Score:2)
So you have an issue with how he handles criticism...but not with his posting content? Seriously, what's wrong with his long post? I don't get it.
Re: (Score:1)
Um, it's too long and it's difficult to read. Forgive me, but the comments are entertaining.
Re:The best gift? (Score:5, Informative)
I don't even know who this guy is, but this article is horrible. It's unnecessarily long, it's factually misleading due to his ignorance (iPhone is the only phone with batteries not user-replaceable? Really?), and terribly edited (they still haven't corrected his typo about fingernail polish DRYING, even after someone pointed it out and the author responded with sarcasm).
I'm not sure I'd blame the author. It seems the people who edit Slashdot are incompetent and/or are not getting enough quality submissions from the community. Perhaps Slashdot is dying?
Re: (Score:2)
netcraft confirms it
Re:The best gift? (Score:4, Interesting)
He's a blowhard who takes himself far, far more seriously than anyone else does. And has no off switch.
He desperately wants to matter. And doesn't.
Re: The best gift? (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
I usually hate Bennet's long-winded posts, mainly because he thinks he knows what he's talking about, but manages to be rather wrong most of the time.
This post is more like a "Here's some cool stuff!" - and he's right, a lot of it is pretty cool. If you don't really read the words and just skim the links, it's a pretty good article.
Re:The best gift? (Score:4, Insightful)
The problem is it he might as well have posted previous guides all over again. Mostly repeats. This guy loves levitation and puzzles.
http://entertainment.slashdot.... [slashdot.org]
See if you can count how many rehashed items from the 2012 list are in this one...
Re: (Score:2)
Huh, good point. I might actually try that nail polish, though, so it was a little useful for me. :)
Re: (Score:2)
Sometimes even a geek needs to feel pretty, no matter what gender.
Re: (Score:1)
It might be useful nail polish to use to tack down a trimpot. It seems like it has some metal content so might not be usable in a pinch for coil dope.
Re: (Score:1)
Hey, this is slashdot. Dupes are good, and dupes about tripe are even better!
Re:The best gift? (Score:5, Insightful)
Looks like link referral spam to me. If you like bennet, follow him on tumblr.
This shit is not news, nothing he submits is, and further degrades what was once a decent source of tech info and discussion on the webs.
Re: (Score:2)
I hovered over a few links (including some at Amazon) and there's no referrer ID. Since he doesn't send you to his personal blog either (remember Ronald Piquepaille?), it's not even clickbait.
I agree that most of his content is too fluffy, and I usually stop reading way before the middle.
Re: The best gift? (Score:2)
most of the "hate" posts are his sockpuppet accounts, trying to raise his profile and name recognition. Clever marketing - go follow his amazon referral links now.
Re: (Score:2)
His links (Amazon or otherwise) don't seem to have referral IDs. Just saying, criticize him over the right things (like verbosity and being wrong).
Re:The best gift? (Score:5, Insightful)
Agreed. I thought maybe this piece would be interesting because it would feature interesting gear rather than poorly thought out opinions and commentary. But apparently he can't even choose interesting gifts let alone solve mildly difficult real-world problems.
I'd use slashdot beta if it offered Haselton free reading.
The missing gift (Score:4, Funny)
I was hoping that somewhere on Bennett's list I would find a "Terse Text for Dummies" but alas....
Re:The best gift? (Score:4, Informative)
No more Bennett Haselton submissions. That's all I want for Christmas!
Merry Christmas to us all! [github.com] (or, if you prefer to read the line of code first, you can do that - click Raw to install [github.com])
Re:The best gift? (Score:5, Informative)
Personally, I miss the ohnoitsbennett tag that used to get applied to all his submissions. I still tag his walls-of-text with it, but I think it's been blacklisted along with most of the other fun tags.
Re: (Score:1)
No, in those days we had to make do with crap by Michael Shims and Roland Pisspole.
Re: (Score:2)
I thought this article might be somewhat useful, since I've never heard of Haselton and my daughter and I are both geeks, but... I have to admit that is a lot of text to wade through. I think much of the hostility is still overreaction, but... yeah, poorly written and (as others have noted) poorly researched.
And even if the article were reasonable and well formatted and provided useful information... who on the planet is waiting until the last minute to get their Christmas shopping done? I could have used
Re: (Score:2)
Trying to what? (Score:2)
Trying to what? Dry, I hope.
Re: (Score:1)
Who the fuck buys used nail polish?
Re:Trying to what? (Score:5, Interesting)
Re: (Score:2)
Hey, Bennett. Have you asked the /. editors if you can be made an editor so those of us who want to block your stories can? It would improve the S/N ratio on the comments for your stories.
Re: (Score:1)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?... [youtube.com]
The best gift I could ask for (Score:5, Insightful)
The best gift I could ask for would be Slashdot no longer posting Bennett's long-winded drivel.
FFS! (Score:3)
Oh FFS. Was a google search too hard?
Great news everyone. The iPhone is now the only phone with a non user-serviceable battery.
Re: (Score:2)
I replaced the battery on my Android, but I had to put it back together with duct tape which makes the touch screen hard to use.
Re: (Score:1)
Every once in awhile when I drop my Samsung Galaxy Victory the back cover pops off and sometimes the battery even slides out. It's easily put back together, though.
littlebits (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
I realize this isn't ad space, but I thought this analog synthesizer kit was interesting. http://littlebits.cc/kits/synt... [littlebits.cc]
Of course, couldn't I accomplish the same purchasing my own parts for a kit? Oh, and unleash your inner rock star.
That's pretty clever. I'd get one for my kid... but then again... no thanks...
Re: (Score:1)
They should have printed the schematics. It looks like a good junkbox project.
serious question (Score:5, Insightful)
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Quick Slashdot game of the day: "Bennett Haselton" is obviously an anagram of something. What is it?
Re:serious question (Score:5, Insightful)
is bennett haselton a real person? and if so, any idea what abnormal psychological diagnoses he might fit?
Narcissistic Marketing Disorder: the belief that whatever you have to say, no matter now banal, stupid, confused, idiotic, boring, passe', imbecilic or wrong, it is interesting and important because it's you saying it.
Slashdot Breaking FTC Rules? (Score:4, Interesting)
Wow. There's a lot of links to product pages in Bennett Haselton's post. Considering that Haselton is probably paying to post here, I hope Slashdot is in compliance with FTC regulations [ftc.gov] concerning spondored content.
I'm not seeing any notices in the story unless "Bennet Haselton" is Slashdot's code for "Sponsored Content". Either way, we'd all prefer to see less of these geek-monetisation stories and more news for nerds.
Holy fuck, really? (Score:5, Insightful)
Now we have Bennett Fucking Haselton's fucking gift guide?
Tell you what, Bennett ... give us all a gift, and stop posting this shit.
So far timothy, soulskill, and samsenpuss all post this crap from Bennett. Is it official dice policy to promote the shit this guy writes? Or is he just sucking your dick?
Mod parent up. (Score:5, Insightful)
Seconded! Is he paying for this placement? Is he someone's friend? WHY is he getting this space on /.?
His posts always follow the same pattern. ... something. /. about how he solved it.
1. He becomes aware of
2. His massive intellect solves it.
3. He posts 1,000+ words to
4. His solutions fail to address anything other than the most superficial aspects of whatever it is that he just became aware of.
That's not "News for Nerds". There's no in depth analysis.
So WHY does he keep getting space on /.?
Re: (Score:2)
Affirmative action to get more posts by people with learning difficulties and/or severe brain damage on Slashdot.
Ads (Score:5, Insightful)
Not again! (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Not again! (Score:5, Funny)
This year's April Fool's will be nothing by BH posts. Calling it now.
Re: (Score:2)
Times like these we could really use a +1 Horrifying moderation.
Re: (Score:3)
Except that Rick Astley was slightly interesting, and promises never to run around or let us down.
Can't even copy and paste (Score:2)
The link for the appetizer serving dish complete with toothpick holder that looks like a porcupine explicitly states that it is actually a different animal that it looks likes. Now that's some lazy reporting.
What's the old saying? (Score:1)
Re: (Score:1)
I thought it was "bare in gifs".
Re: (Score:1)
Wood LED clock doesn't look Photoshopped to me (Score:2)
A faux-wood cube clock ($38). This is interesting mostly for looking like a visual impossibility -- how can the digital numbers appear on the side of a block of wood, even fake wood?
Because it's a fairly thin veneer and the LEDs beneath are extremely bright. Same way my PVR makes text appear on what otherwise looks like an opaque brushed metal surface (though why they have to be brighter than my TV is beyond me - I ended taking the thing apart and putting some ND filter in it).
Unfortunately I think the photo is doctored, because this youtube video shows an undoctored shot of the cube clock, and you can easily see the un-illuminated LEDs on the side, which don't quite blend in with the wood.
I can barely see anything in that 360p overly compressed YouTube video.
How about an S&M Ball Gag? (Score:5, Funny)
Or would that just be considered a gag gift?
For shame. (Score:3)
All I want for Christmas is Bennet roasting on an open fire.
Oh Bennett, I don't need any gifts (Score:1)
For the XKCD fan (Score:4, Insightful)
...if nothing at the XKCD store [xkcd.com] appeals to you, that is...
Stick one of these [stuffedsafari.com] in a box. Label the box "Office chair". [xkcd.com] Stand back and watch the fun.
And for those less familiar with XKCD, print out a card with that comic to go with the box. It might still work.
Not Referrer Links (Score:1)
At least most of those links don't have referral ids attached to them.
The real geek gift guide (Score:1)
For most people, gift buying breaks down into three categories:
1. People you're willing to splurge for. Close family, offspring, significant other, etc. Since these are the people you interact with the most, not being clued in to what they wanted for a gift is an epic fail. No gift guide is going to help you here.
2. Good friends, extended family. These people are the reason gift cards were invented. Sure, some people may argue that it's not personal enough, but screw that. Everybody loves a free mea
Re: (Score:1)
most restaurants are shit; i can cook much better. there are usually good restaurants, but geeks are notoriously awful (and diverse!) in taste. app downloads? eh, maybe, but you know what's even better? CASH. just get some crisp fresh bills from the bank, maybe a stack of $2s, if you don't give a shit anyway. most people have been conditioned implicitly to get a dopamine rush from counting/sorting money, so that actually makes a better gift than a piece of plastic linked to a rapidly depreciating account. [
ein klein (Score:2)
Bennett Haselton's Revised Gift Guide (Score:1)
* A phone with a slideout keyboard, no matter how shitty the phone is otherwise, because the primary use of a phone is typing huge amounts of text into it and it's impossible to find external keyboards for touchscreen phones.
* Donation in recipient's name to the "Association of Tyrants, Prosecutors, and Torturers for Liberty", a non-profit organization dedicated to repealing the Fifth Amendment.
* A cooler full of ice for next year's BURNING MAN ! ZOMG so excited!
hacer (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
That was much less annoying than TFA.