Catch up on stories from the past week (and beyond) at the Slashdot story archive

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
Twitter Social Networks

Twitter Detects Riots Faster Than Police, Study Says (cnet.com) 49

A new study by Cardiff University has determined that Twitter can be used to identify dangerous situations up to an hour faster than police reports. From a report: Researchers at Cardiff analyzed 1.6 million tweets relevant to the 2011 London riots. In the town of Enfield, police received reports of disorder an hour and 23 minutes after computer systems could have picked up the same information from Twitter, according to the study. "In this research, we show that online social media are becoming the go-to place to report observations of everyday occurrences -- including social disorder and terrestrial criminal activity," said co-author of the study Pete Burnap.
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Twitter Detects Riots Faster Than Police, Study Says

Comments Filter:
  • Or 999 if you are in the UK. Just crowd source solutions to your problems.
  • by Anonymous Coward

    . . . idiots tweet and post selfies when they should call the police instead.

  • How hard is it to detect a riot? Hey look, there's a guy throwing a trashcan through a window surrounded by dozens of other people. Doesn't seem like rocket science.
    • Yes, really...

      By using experts in analysis from a university, and analysing the data for months after the event, Twitter will be able to detect riots before the police can.

      As long as you ignore the months in between.

      Am I being too sarcastic for slashdot?

  • by Anonymous Coward

    But totally useless for orbital or extraterrestrial criminal activity.

  • by Notabadguy ( 961343 ) on Thursday June 29, 2017 @02:19PM (#54714579)

    Yet again our Slashdot overlords subject us to clickbait and misleading titles.

    This should read, "Twitter Theoretically Could Detect Riots Faster Than Police."

    In other news, Jennifer Lawrence Could Theoretically Show Up At My Door And Demand Sex.

  • by Anonymous Coward

    Get rid of white privilege and a lot of riots will go away. I'll get lots of negative replies because Slashdot readers tend to be bigots in denial. However, it's true that a lot of the civil unrest is due to racism that still exists. Slashdot readers tend to actively deny this because this site is basically the new Stormfront and the readers are threatened by minorities that might diversify technology. Racism and sexism still exist and, in my experience, most of you are racists and sexists. Get rid of the i

    • Let's pretend you are right and white privileged does exist and all that hubub you spew isn't benevolent racism or a giant scapegoat to excuse personal responsibility... How is that going to help a black man get a job? Or graduate college? Or learn a strong work ethic? How is that going to help any black person with any struggle in their life besides being an excuse to hold them back? How are any of those struggles unique to black people when those struggles correlate to socioeconomic status?

    • The system is failing more and more people each passing year. Racism is still a thing, but it won't do to focus just on that and not the bigger picture. If you look at, for example, the Black Lives Matter protests - obviously, race can play a factor in police misconduct. But the police state problem extends way beyond that. Fixating on the racial aspect of it makes police accountability a more divisive issue than it needs to be. It gives certain white people license to disregard the problem of police brutal
    • I have to agree with you on Slashdot- it's been declining steadily for years. In the late 90s the discussions here were dominated by technically and scientifically literate people who actually had interesting things to say; now it's a political site crammed with trolls who attack scientists with arguments you'd expect to hear from middle schoolers.
  • Last night I finished reading "Hatching Twitter: A True Story of Money, Power, Friendship, and Betrayal" [amzn.to] by Nick Bilton. There's a quote by Mark Zuckerburg [huffingtonpost.com] that the Twitter founders "drove a clown car that feel into a gold mine." They played musical chairs for the CEO for first few years and the current CEO is a Steve Jobs wannabe. Unbelievable.
  • by bobbied ( 2522392 ) on Thursday June 29, 2017 @02:29PM (#54714657)

    Monitor Twitter and find the riot faster...

    It will be all fun and games until somebody figures out how to spoof a riot by spamming Twitter... The police show up and volia! A new way to "SWAT" someone...

    BTW.... For most riots... Who doesn't know in ADVANCE where they are going to be? We act like they are just events that happen at random times and places. You may not know the exact block the violence will break out, but it's usually pretty obvious when the risk of such behavior is high and where it's likely to happen based on the current events driving the whole thing.

    Riots, like fire, have some pretty easily identified prerequisites.... 1. Groups of people gathering for some reason... 2. Strong emotions around the reason... 3. Strong rhetoric associated with the reason, encouraging people to feel hopeless about affecting some kind of change 4. A faction of people involved who don't mind violence.

  • Okay, they said the London riots were predictable from Twitter. Did they get additional positive correlation from other twitter --> actual riots? Did they attempt this and find that they couldn't get the correlation? Did they predict other riots that simply didn't materialize? I'd like to believe there's more to the study than is found in the story, but frankly there just isn't enough there to indicate a xx% rate. A data point of 1 is not a recipe for actionable data.
  • Until it's used to actually report the riot before the authorities I'm skeptical. It's easy to look back and see that there were clues that a riot was going on, but it's another thing to look at the present and say a riot IS going on. You also could get plenty of false posities. Not to mention the moment you use it to predict ONE riot the Trolls will figure out how to trip your detector.
  • by sound+vision ( 884283 ) on Thursday June 29, 2017 @02:42PM (#54714731) Journal
    If law enforcement doesn't already have back-end access to this data, they will soon. I imagine the information gets even more detailed and accurate once you aggregate data from all the tracking companies (Apple, Facebook, Google) together. Not to mention the NSA's own databases.

    You could easily imagine a system being developed to track not just currently-happening riots, but the likelihood a riot will happen in the near future. Which area it's likely to happen in. Who is likely to participate.

    Of course, charging people in open court with pre-crime probably won't fly. And a predictive system like this is always going to be a game of probabilities, it might not have the "resolution" to predict individual actions. What you can do is systematically target groups of people for surveillance or manipulation. Not that we aren't already doing that, but now it's more effective. And who the data tells us to watch might end up being somebody different than they watch today.
  • by Anonymous Coward

    The ability to tweet and have it automatically picked up by the nearest emergency response org. seems like a needed feature.

  • and terrestrial criminal activity

    I couldn't help but wonder if it could also find extraterrestrial activity.

  • I was working in the bubs of Seattle during the WTO fun and games and I saw the substantial lag between events and police response. On local live TV I saw the black-block breaking windows and instigating the looting of Starbucks, etc. I also saw on live TV the protesters try and stop the damage/looting while the black-block made themselves scarce. A only after the fact were their police press conferences and riot squad response that only thumped on sweet young hippies in turtle costumes singing save the ear
  • Not that impressive. The Kaiser Chiefs, on the other hand, know before it even starts by using such techniques as measuring people's lairiness.

  • could it also be used to predict impeachment ?
  • All very well to turn up the sensitivity to max and predict something. Not so easy to continue to predict things with the sensitivity turned down to the point where false positives don't flood the system.

"More software projects have gone awry for lack of calendar time than for all other causes combined." -- Fred Brooks, Jr., _The Mythical Man Month_

Working...