Google's Epic Response: Android 12 Will Make It Easier To Install App Stores (venturebeat.com) 44
Google today announced it will make it easier to install and use third-party app stores with the release of Android 12 next year. From a report: Google also reiterated its existing Payments Policy for in-app purchases of digital goods: Android developers who want to distribute apps and games on Google Play, must use Play's billing system. Google is offering a 1-year grace period for developers who aren't complying with this policy: The deadline is September 30, 2021. Today's announcements today are a direct response to Epic's war with Apple and Google over the 30% cut they take of every purchase on the iOS App Store and the Google Play store, respectively. On August 13, Epic updated Fornite for Android and iOS to use its own billing service, resulting in Apple and Google deleting Fortnite from their app stores. Epic then turned around and sued both tech giants. The lawsuits could define how all developers, from individuals to massive corporations, distribute apps on the world's duopoly of mobile operating systems.
Can Fdroid now manage updates properly? (Score:2)
If F-droid [f-droid.org] becomes able to properly update apps on a stock Android install then this is a big thing. If not, then Google is just cheating to avoid liability. Let's wait and see.
Subjects are stupid (Score:1)
If app stores are like steering wheels in your car analogy, do we count them as interchangeable? Do all steering wheels have a good quality airbag? Similarly, should all app stores be required to meet certain regulated standards? Does that mean that your app store availability will be based on your geographic location? Region of purchase?
This will be interesting to watch in the coming years. I normally only see talk of F-Droid from people who like to tinker with their phones. I'm not sure whether the idea o
Re: (Score:3)
Why would you compare app stores to steering wheels? Just compare them to stores. What 'regulated standards' do you think stores must meet? If you don't like what a store is offering, or you don't think they are secure enough or whatever, shop somewhere else.
Re: (Score:1)
Why would you compare app stores to steering wheels? Just compare them to stores. What 'regulated standards' do you think stores must meet?
LOL at your thinking retail stores don't have scores of regulated standards they have to follow.
Re: (Score:2)
They soon get things called "reputations".
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Of course it does. Do you think either would still offer that price if the other one wasn't there?
Re: Subjects are stupid (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Google will keep providing anti malware anyway, so if one does go rogue they can just delete it from your device and clean up the mess.
Re: Subjects are stupid (Score:3)
car analogy is apple wants dealer only for all (Score:2)
car analogy is apple wants dealer only for all
Repair
Upgrades / options
Add ons (even XM subs must be billed with apple)
In car data must buy with apple.
etc
Re: (Score:1)
The intent is to provide players with a sense of pride and accomplishment for unlocking different ~~heroes~~ apps.
~~-EA~~
-Apple
Sideloading (Score:5, Funny)
Re: (Score:1)
What on earth does that have to do with this? Sideloading doesn't mean root. Literally the only difference in loading an application from outside the play store is that the app signature hasn't been verified by Google. It's literally no different from installing a .deb or .rpm manually, since you're installing an apk.
I don't think you know anything about Android.
Re: (Score:1)
Pedant.
Re: (Score:2)
So you wandered off topic and I'm a pedant because I noticed? Ok there sport
Re: (Score:3)
Huh? The aren't 'suing about payments', they are suing about anti-competiive behavior.. And as soon as Apple kicked them out for daring to compete they had standing.
Re: (Score:1)
Huh, I thought Apple kicked Epic out for violating their contract. Which Epic did violate.
Re: (Score:3)
The two aren't mutually exclusive.
Re: (Score:2)
And how, exactly, did they 'violate the contract'? By competing. Competing is what got them kicked out. The 'contract violation' was just the vehicle used.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
> And Apple is free to do business with whoever they want to do business with.
Apple the Company under common law, sure.
Apple the Corporation under statute law - no, that's what "public accommodation" laws are about.
I wouldn't mind one bit if they reorganized as a Partnership with liability for the [actual person] Partners, but they probably prefer corporate protections. No doubt that they want to have it both ways.
Re: (Score:2)
And Apple is free to do business with whoever they want to do business with.
I think part of Epic's argument is that they don't want to business with Apple; they want to do business directly with Epic's users.
Start acting like a store instead of a marketplace (Score:2)
The only way I can see this working out properly is if Google and Apple change their app stores to be an actual "store" rather than a marketplace. Nobody would give Best Buy a hard time about making a profit on items they sell in their store. The issue is that they aren't set up like a flea market. Now, perhaps Google and Apple could get by with some sort of flea market style fee structure to their app stores, but only if there is an alternative.
As for things like Nintendo or Playstation online stores, I
Re: (Score:3)
Honestly, I don't see what Epic's problem is with Android. They can make a competing "game store" like they did on PC when they weren't happy with Steam. It's not as good as Steam and no one wants to use it, but that's a free market choice by consumers. Some people are willing to install their store to get the games they want
Re: Start acting like a store instead of a marketp (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:1)
"To get certification as "Apple-safe" or "Google-safe" you would need to pay a fee when you submit your app. To me, that would cover all their bases."
Google still cannot guarantee that the developer isn't some malicious person selling my CC info. The certificate would be meaningless. Forcing apps to go through the Google Play payment system would eliminate that risk. I will have to consciously install the app outside of Google's secure marketplace if I wanted to use those apps (which google is also making i
What about call recording. (Score:2)
I didn't upgrade my photo this year because google block call recording in Android 10.
Is this feature back ?
My Samsung note 8 have this by default.
Re: (Score:3)
Google never did any significant work to prevent third party app stores to begin with. What they're doing here is making it even easier for users to exercise choice. If they wanted to be Apple, they would have locked users into a walled garden and made most of their decisions for them already.
Re: You mean Google's Human Response. (Score:3)
Re: (Score:1)
Just like Linux, Windows, and Mac OS. Just look at how those are all falling apart machines because the makers screwed up and gave their users the ability to install apps and app stores beyond their central app store.....
Yes, they did. For years and years as users held local admin rights on every machine to install whatever they wanted to. Or more to the point, so malware could install itself whenever it wanted to. And it did.
How capable, do you think the average smartphone user, really is today? Should we look at their ability to merely patch first on a device designed for children?
Bottom line is this change is being done to meet the needs of Demand. And Demand, doesn't always know what its doing.
Re: (Score:3)
Those stupid security experts again with their never-happen-to-me cybercrime facts, pointless app gateways, and integrity checks. Why would anyone assume consumers want that annoying shit...
We have literally all of this in Android. We simply have the option to bypass it when we choose to. When we do, applications are still limited by the operating system in all of the usual ways, including the permissions system, and the capabilities-based security system. Even if we root, we can choose which applications can get root.
Lack of backwards compatibility (like a performant X server) aside, Android is in many ways the Linux system I've always wanted. It has the full power of Linux beneath it, and us
Re: (Score:2)
Those stupid security experts again with their never-happen-to-me cybercrime facts, pointless app gateways, and integrity checks. Why would anyone assume consumers want that annoying shit...
We have literally all of this in Android. We simply have the option to bypass it when we choose to. When we do, applications are still limited by the operating system in all of the usual ways, including the permissions system, and the capabilities-based security system. Even if we root, we can choose which applications can get root.
And when you speak of "we", are we talking about the 9-year old who just got a new birthday present, as well as Grandmas new smartphone?
The you out there, are obviously not the primary concern here.
...But I want to be able to run sideloaded software, root, and generally abuse my system if I want to.
Yes. So does malware against the average user's ability to detect it.
No big deal, because with a full-featured recovery system I can backup and restore the system so that I can return to any prior point
Yeah. No big deal. For the 5% of you out there.
Re: (Score:2)
And when you speak of "we", are we talking about the 9-year old who just got a new birthday present, as well as Grandmas new smartphone?
Yes, obviously. If they don't sideload, then they have all the same protections they get if they buy a device that doesn't offer them choice. Don't be daft.
Enough rope to hang themselves (Score:2)
Because it was so damn hard? (Score:2)
I mean sure I had to click a link, then click install AND acknowledge a siderloader warning. Oh the humanity. On some devices I even had to turn on the sideload functionality something which the OS took me to automatically. 3 clicks instead of 1, I only just got through it alive. Honestly F-Droid could have given me RSI with all those clicks.
Thanks Google for considering my health.
Also Epic are useless morons. No doubt their answer will be to introduce the Epic store to Android, it'll be buggy as crap, offe
Re: (Score:1)