Want to read Slashdot from your mobile device? Point it at m.slashdot.org and keep reading!

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Transportation

Waymo Will Start Operating In NYC (engadget.com) 18

Waymo will start driving its autonomous Chrysler Pacifica vans in New York City on November 4th. Engadget reports: This and a later wave of Jaguar I-Pace EVs will rely on human drivers to map streets and learn from the environment, and there aren't any immediate plans to offer driverless rides to passengers. However, Waymo clearly hopes to use this knowledge for its long-term autonomy goals in various cities. The rollout will focus on Manhattan below Central Park (aka midtown and lower Manhattan), including the financial district and a portion of New Jersey through the Lincoln Tunnel. All tests will operate during daylight.

The dry run will help Waymo's Driver AI cope with New York City's notoriously heavy traffic, of course, but the company is particularly interested in weather testing. Like many northern cities, NYC has its fair share of ice and snow, both of which remain huge challenges for driverless cars. This test will give Waymo further opportunities to test its navigation in winter conditions, not to mention the heavy rainfall more common in the region.

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Waymo Will Start Operating In NYC

Comments Filter:
  • Every time I see the name Waymo, my brain converts it to Wham-O.

    And I wonder what the hell they think they are doing.

    THEN I remember it isn't 70s anymore.

    • I just remind myself that it's going to cost way mo' money for the company to operate.
    • by PolygamousRanchKid ( 1290638 ) on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @06:04PM (#61955653)

      Every time I see the name Waymo, my brain converts it to Wham-O.

      Well the other name that they were considering was Ronco Ride-O-Matic.

    • by ls671 ( 1122017 )

      Agreed. the whole strategy of trying to remember every street corner by uploading its data to the cloud is silly.

      What if the data that was uploaded to the cloud suddenly changes like it often occurs?

      All of that is based on the fact that real AI that can really at least mimic a human brain still doesn't exist. The hype mandates to pretend it does although.

  • Die, die, everybody die!
    • by zeeky boogy doog ( 8381659 ) on Wednesday November 03, 2021 @09:00PM (#61956007)
      Mow down walkers and bikers? Au contraire... There's a hilarious story of a waymo car that "stalled" versus a biker at a crossing, because the biker... stopped and stayed upright by rocking forward and backward. And the car interpreted every forward oscillation as him about to enter the walkway and panic stopped.

      Forget weather and heavy traffic testing experience, I'm looking forward to finding out how vehicles programmed to be super-conservative pansy-ass drivers deal with New York drivers. Or rather, how they get chewed up, spit out and ground into the gutters.
      • I'm looking forward to finding out how vehicles programmed to be super-conservative pansy-ass drivers deal with New York drivers. Or rather, how they get chewed up, spit out and ground into the gutters.

        Does New York not have elderly people driving? I'm willing to believe that a large number of New York drivers are aggressive assholes, but surely there already are plenty of human 'pansy-ass drivers' on the streets of New York. Or are these people also 'chewed up, spit out and ground into the gutters'? What does that even mean anyway?

        • Been there?

          Not a lot of timid drivers in Manhattan; such as do exist, tend to cause wrecks.

          The de facto rules of the road in NYC are different than most of the rest of the US, and vary slightly even between boroughs, but in Manhattan, what would pass for aggression in less urbanized locales is simply how things work. It's expected, and deviating from it is more dangerous than not.

          True story: exiting one of the tunnels from Jersey one day, maybe 30 years ago. Forgot which one. Older lady walks right in fr

          • Been there?

            Yes. Traffic seemed pretty tame to me.
            Almost all the streets are at simple right angles to each other, so there are very few confusing or tricky situations.
            Admittedly, I did not drive there myself, but from what I could see from Ubers and taxis it did not seem challenging at all.

            Try Rome, Paris or worse: Hanoi, HCMC, or Bangkok.

            Not a lot of timid drivers in Manhattan; such as do exist, tend to cause wrecks.

            A quick Google search shows me that New York isn't even in the top 20 of US cities with the highest number of road fatalities or accidents. The whole 'New York traffic is crazy' meme

        • Elderly drivers? In NYC? If you have lived long enough to be considered elderly, you should have the intelligence and sense of self-preservation to not drive in NYC. There's probably a few out there, but they would certainly not be counted as the "pansy-ass drivers". You can be sure that if you get in the way of 80-year old Ethel Goldstein's Lincoln, you will receive a mix of horn blaring, F-bombs and middle fingers. The "pansy-ass drivers" are the tourists who were dumb enough to drive into the city and no
    • I figure that a multi-billion dollar, single product company will of course have an occasional problem... and people will very likely die... but, unlike human drivers where nothing is learned, every mistake and anomaly encountered by a Waymo will be addressed and their entire fleet will become better. As more cars are deployed, more anomalies will be encountered and addressed. I shouldn't take long before Waymo vehicles are greatly superior to human drivers.
    • by tlhIngan ( 30335 )

      Die, die, everybody die!

      These aren't Teslas you know. Waymo's safety record is much better than Tesla in that regard (granted, practically every self-driving system out there is better than Tesla's).

      That, and I doubt Waymo cars have a habit of driving into emergency vehicles as normal operation.

  • Imagine letting 10 of the loose on the streets of Manhattan without a driver.

    Have you looked at waymoâ(TM)s website? Itâ(TM)s pathetic. Lots of 20 something marketing types with way too much time on their hands.

    All the aspirational special interest stories about changing peopleâ(TM)s lives if only the product could.

  • Driving in central and south Manhattan requires a lot of anticipation, aggression, and interpretation of the unwritten road rules.
    Heavy traffic, double parked trucks, busses, bikes, scooters, jaywalkers, crowds, cabs abruptly changing lanes and stopping to pick up and drop off people.

    It will be interesting to see how the AI handles it without just freezing up

    • Soon will also require something like a $50 "congestion charge." Feels to me like a huge, regressive tax on lower-income commuters from Jersey or the boroughs. I would favor exempting those folks somehow. If you have to charge it at all, charge the rich f*cks driving to Wall Street from the UWS instead of taking the subway. They can more than afford it, and the subway is likely faster anyway.

      I'm a better driver than most of the robots I know, and I don't mind driving in most of NYC, but even I'm not cra

      • Soon will also require something like a $50 "congestion charge." Feels to me like a huge, regressive tax on lower-income commuters from Jersey or the boroughs. I would favor exempting those folks somehow. If you have to charge it at all, charge the rich f*cks driving to Wall Street from the UWS instead of taking the subway. They can more than afford it, and the subway is likely faster anyway.

        I'm a better driver than most of the robots I know, and I don't mind driving in most of NYC, but even I'm not crazy enough to drive in midtown or lower Manhattan. There are subways and cabs, which a person can take (well, at least the subways) without inordinately risking their lives.

        I agree, I detest these types of taxes that limit use of something by pricing out average people.

  • It does not sound as if they are going to run their taxi service in NYC, nor does it even seem like they are running their driving AI. What it sounds like is because of all the tall buildings in NYC there is a huge multi-path problem (anyone who has ever used Uber or Lyft there knows it will often locate you on the wrong street because of a bounce off a building). What I believe they are doing is mapping to compensate for this problem. If you read Waymo blog entries this is what it sounds like they are doi
  • What interests me the most is the question of when will the 3rd commercial city operations start.
    1. Phoenix, Arizona 2018-12,
    2. San Francisco - 2021-08
    3. NYC - ?

    From this we could see if the spreading speed is increasing or not and by how much. From this we can start to estimate how fast it will spread.

If all the world's economists were laid end to end, we wouldn't reach a conclusion. -- William Baumol

Working...