Data Center Developer Offers $10,000 Checks To Nearby Households (tomshardware.com) 125
An anonymous reader quotes a report from Tom's Hardware: NorthPoint Development wants to build a data center on 1,300 acres in the Pocono foothills, near Hazle Township, Pennsylvania. As well as seeking to charm the local government with various funding packages, it has proposed paying checks of $10,000 per household. Despite the Pennsylvania town's median income of $60,000, the offer isn't being warmly welcomed by locals, reports the Wall Street Journal. Those interviewed were widely against the data center development plans and cited several reasons for being averse to accepting the payout. The major concerns regarded potential impacts on property values, the specter of noise pollution, and a distrust of both the AI moguls and local government representatives.
Offer letters began to be received by Hazle Township back in June. The WSJ recently talked to several residents about NorthPoint's $10,000 offer. While some say the $10,000 would be handy, it couldn't find many residents who were "eager to welcome the data center for the payout," in the journal's words. [...] Traditionally, developers have offered towns and cities packages worth tens of millions, including funding for local services. But direct cash payments to residents represent a new phase of their charm offensive, the WSJ indicates. Perhaps the idea for the direct payments to residents came after "a raucous public meeting last year, where angry locals asked what they had to gain by supporting the data center," ponders the source.
The locals won't just get the direct payout, though. Other funds up to $120 million over the next 15 years have been dangled like a carrot for community and local services investments -- improved schools, emergency services, and so on. Meanwhile, Hazle Township's government already rejected the data center project on zoning grounds last year, and it has enacted a temporary moratorium on data center construction. Finally, the $10,000 offer to households is simply not enough in many interviewed folks' opinions. Residents could feel insulted by it, regarding the offer as a bribe, concludes the WSJ report.
Offer letters began to be received by Hazle Township back in June. The WSJ recently talked to several residents about NorthPoint's $10,000 offer. While some say the $10,000 would be handy, it couldn't find many residents who were "eager to welcome the data center for the payout," in the journal's words. [...] Traditionally, developers have offered towns and cities packages worth tens of millions, including funding for local services. But direct cash payments to residents represent a new phase of their charm offensive, the WSJ indicates. Perhaps the idea for the direct payments to residents came after "a raucous public meeting last year, where angry locals asked what they had to gain by supporting the data center," ponders the source.
The locals won't just get the direct payout, though. Other funds up to $120 million over the next 15 years have been dangled like a carrot for community and local services investments -- improved schools, emergency services, and so on. Meanwhile, Hazle Township's government already rejected the data center project on zoning grounds last year, and it has enacted a temporary moratorium on data center construction. Finally, the $10,000 offer to households is simply not enough in many interviewed folks' opinions. Residents could feel insulted by it, regarding the offer as a bribe, concludes the WSJ report.
Underestimated The Cost of A Life (Score:5, Insightful)
$10k is a little low. Pop a few more zeroes on the end of that and you may actually end up with some takers. Come on, everything's for sale. You just gotta stop lowballing us plebes.
Re: (Score:2)
One time $10K is low. How about $10K per day? I will take that!
Re: (Score:3)
If they're freely offering $10k, then it's likely they've calculated the true cost to be much higher than that. You don't open a price negotiation by overpaying.
Re: (Score:2)
If they're freely offering $10k, then it's likely they've calculated the true cost to be much higher than that. You don't open a price negotiation by overpaying.
Yup. That's negotiation 101 right there. They can afford to *start* the bidding at 10k.
Re: Underestimated The Cost of A Life (Score:3)
Irrelevant
Re: Underestimated The Cost of A Life (Score:5, Funny)
Re: (Score:1)
Re: Underestimated The Cost of A Life (Score:1)
Also irrelevant to the argument at hand
Learn to stay on topic
Re: (Score:2, Interesting)
"I roleplay a viking on the internet but i'm going to shame people for eating meat for daring to question the environmental purity of data centers" sure is an interesting play
Re: Underestimated The Cost of A Life (Score:3)
Let's put a small break on datacenter building. The stampede needs to be slowed down.
Re: (Score:2)
Water consumption is why you choose a place like this. They get a lot of rain.
Geographic distribution is helpful for uptime, but we just need to stop building so many datacenters in deserts and california.
Re: (Score:3)
A: Don't worry, they will tell you.
Re:Underestimated The Cost of A Life (Score:5, Informative)
I don't think you quite understand the scale of the new AI data center build-outs. The new builds are requesting new total power plants/production of more than the current total installed base of power plants (in TX they have 3x the current installed base as new power) so basically they are going to double(or more) the current fuel consumption for power production of the entire US.
Because of the power consumption needs the new data centers are bringing their own baseload generators (gas turbines/diesel gens) and running them almost 100% of the time with the associated noise they produce.
Re: (Score:3)
And local air pollution.
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
Meat does something useful.
Re: (Score:2)
Don't worry... the DCs and their _Green_ power systems and the warehouse-sized UPSes will take up the farmland that would've grown your veggies, contributes to the noise that drives away all the wildlife that helps the plants grow, makes the area around the DC warmer.
I know, cow farts in Montana are so much more damaging than a 3GW datacenter (question: is the 3GW rating for the whole year or just daily?) that runs on NatGas and nuclear.
And, nuclear is better than NatGas (neither one is rapidly dispatchable
It seems like a lot until you think about it (Score:5, Insightful)
Re: (Score:2)
A quick look at a map shows me that there is a lot of land near Hazle that isn't near any homes.
Re: (Score:3)
Re: It seems like a lot until you think about it (Score:2)
Also as long as they are close enough for you to experience noise pollution, which is the case for some of these AI DCs already
Re: (Score:2)
You could dangle a mic out your window and have your computer do Noise Cancellation in real-time, and play that through speakers throughout your home.
Re: (Score:1)
As long as it is using your utilities and roads it is in the neighborhood. They would not be offering anything, if they did not think that it would help their case. Unfortunately for them, people do not want them, do not think that they are useful, and most people seem to hate AI, even when they use it.
A data center is like a flat windowless office building without people in it, and more computers. ...roads? These are immobile computers. They're offering money because people are showing up to city meetings and crying about them a lot because of stupid shit they read online about not even data centers, something something AI. Nobody is browsing realtor.com looking for data centers in the town. If your house is right up against an industrial/commercial zone, that's the best neighbor you could get among the
Re: (Score:3)
$10k isn't even enough to go solar+batteries for your home to help insult yourself from the increased electricity prices. Depending on zoning, you should also get your own well and osmosis system in place as well. $100k might cover all that. If there is any kind of noise from this (idk, just saying IF), you'll want to better insulate your home, so all new double pane windows and possibly adding insulation into the walls as well. So really, gonna need at least another 50k, so 150k minimum.
Personally, I'd tak
Re: (Score:3)
https://www.google.com/maps/pl... [google.com]
https://www.wndu.com/2026/04/2... [wndu.com]
Re: (Score:2)
Some places they do end up in neighborhoods like this one:
https://www.google.com/maps/@4... [google.com]
Re: It seems like a lot until you think about it (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
That means you'd have to install all the hardware to carry the steam or heated water from their DC to your house.
Not to mention the big question... is their system setup to allow that, or do they have to upgrade the hell out of their water-cooling system to allow for that sorta thing... and, then there's the question of what happens to that waste heat during the warm months.
There used to be steam pipes running to houses from a central place for heating, but those systems have been torn out (even in the real
Puerto Rico (Score:5, Funny)
I say we repurpose Puerto Rico and make it the State of Data Center and put all of the datacenters there. It'll be like practice for putting them in orbit.
Re: (Score:3)
Re: (Score:1, Offtopic)
Decide what you want...data centers or Somalis?
Re: (Score:3, Insightful)
Decide what you want...data centers or Somalis?
Fuck off, bigot.
We have more than sufficient poor people (Score:2)
While the poster was crude, importing the impoverished makes no sense in the US where bottom-feeder jobs are now the best many can do to keep food on the table.
If you want open borders then say so.
Re: (Score:2)
I do have to wonder how much money a DC brings into the state that it's built in... most likely, they have some workaround to not pay taxes or pay really low taxes.
Re: (Score:2)
not because they are easy, but because they are ha (Score:2)
That's why it's good practice. Plus hurricanes and storm surge too.
Also, terraforming a few square kilometers of Saharah is something we should do before we talk about a human visit to Mars.
Re: Puerto Rico (Score:2)
Too hot, too humid, too hilly and junglely. I'd look at Minnesota or the Dakotas.
Greenland!!!!! Trump figured it out long before us. Genius!!! (no I am not serious)
Re:Puerto Rico (Score:5, Funny)
Re: (Score:2)
Near one of Trumps golf courses.
And call it "One Beautiful Data Center"
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
"One Big Beautiful Data Center"
There, fixed that for you.
More Gaslighting (Score:5, Informative)
"Residents could feel insulted by it, regarding the offer as a bribe"
That's because it IS a bribe! Bribe:(noun) A valuable item or cash given to influence a person's actions or decisions.
Sorry, but I see no other way to interpret NorthPoint's "offer". Any other attempt to describe it is pure gaslighting.
Re: (Score:2)
>"That's because it IS a bribe!"
I came to post the exact same thing. It *is* a bribe. And it is insulting.
Now, if they had air-tight assurances it would cause no noise, ever, and not affect energy pricing ever, and wouldn't be visible from any residential locations, then maybe it is something I would consider supporting if I were there (with or without the "bribe"). The jobs thing is a joke- sick of hearing about that lie. But it could very much mean more tax revenue, which would be good for many yea
Re: (Score:3)
The problem isn't that it is a bribe. The problem is that is an insulting amount to try and bribe them with. $150k minimum so you could do all the necessary home upgrades to minimize the negative affects of the data center and it's hunger for resources.
Re: (Score:2)
Well then, the best answer would be for them to offer to pay directly for upgrades to homes that would help mitigate the effects. Acoustic treatments for instance. And if those complaining were honest, they'd shake hands and get it done.
But most wouldn't use the payout for that. The assumption is that they can be bribed. Which is fine. Absent any legal issues, there's nothing inherently wrong with a bribe. The question then becomes what the cost is to buy off the complainer, not what it costs to enhance the
Re: (Score:2)
Technically it's compensation for a loss. But it's such a small amount while having an immediate impact it works more like a bribe. But since they could actually lose money long-term by taking it, it's only a bribe because people are shortsighted and see it that way.
Required (Score:2, Offtopic)
They should be required to install solar for residents where appropriate.
Better... (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
This is probably less than 1 year of whatever tax incentive they already got offered.
This seems sad, but familiar. (Score:5, Funny)
Data Center Developer Offers $10,000 Checks To Nearby Households
Seems like some businesses and politicians can only offer "bribes" instead of things people actually want/need.
But hey, these homeowners can add this to their $5,000 DOGE and $2,000 tariff refunds -- oh, wait ...
Re: This seems sad, but familiar. (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
Unlike your other listed disbursements, they're likely to actually get this. Unlike politicians, companies generally make good on their offers. That already makes this far more legitimate.
Not for AI (Score:5, Interesting)
These data centers are not being built solely for AI. The real push behind them is to store every damn thing about you. Think Flock on steroids. These leech tech companies need to be put to heel now both through legislation and the public outright rejecting them. The cloud is your enemy people.
Re: (Score:2)
That's going to be the big use case for AI very soon if it isn't already. Companies have been gathering massive amounts of information on people for decades to package and resell. But AI actually makes it easier to sift through that massive amount of data and make use of it.
Re: (Score:2)
So you think that needs a data center in your neighborhood? Flock and other surveillance including most internet tracking are all running their stuff in data centers and not at the CEOs home computer. Most is probably distributed between AWS and Azure. If you want to limit data centers to limit how much data can be stored on the cloud, you probably end up with Flock & co. outbidding small business owners when they are competing for now limited cloud offers. You don't think these companies say "Oh, no st
Good! (Score:4, Insightful)
Those interviewed were widely against the data center development plans and cited several reasons for being averse to accepting the payout.
I'm glad that people are paying attention and pushing back. From what I've heard so far, the misery that big data centres inflict on local residents would be worth payments at least a couple of orders higher than what's being offered here.
As for paying per household, fuck that noise - double entendre intended. Every resident, regardless of age, should receive a big payment.
Oh, what's that you say? That would make the data centre too expensive to build? Too bad, so sad, oh well...
Re: (Score:2)
I'd say every house, condo and apartment building (regardless of who owns them) should be provided double pane windows and sliding glass doors. This should help with the noise factor quite a bit. If electricity is going to become a major issue, each home, condo, etc, needs to be provided enough solar and batteries to more or less cover their current needs.
If the water is getting contaminated, they should provide every residence a reverse osmosis system that works at the the entry to the home and not just fo
Re: Good! (Score:2)
RO wastes water. A really efficient rig only wastes about (side note, why the fuck does Google always think I'm trying to write "Scott" for "about"? Talk about a failure of statistical analysis) 8 gallons for every gallon produced... Not a big deal for most households for drinking water, and it can still go to the garden, but a big problem for a whole house system.
The answer is simple. (Score:2, Insightful)
What are the $10K conditions? (Score:2)
Smart residents know it's not worth it ! (Score:2)
Unstated DataCenter Benefits (Score:1)
World War III (Score:2)
Albert Einstein is often quoted as saying, "I do not know with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones."
I think it has become more clear by now to the world powers that their militaries need to run on AI or be left in the ensuing dust. Same goes for economic activity during peacetime, of course.
Which leads to the realization that this will make data centers a prime target for bombing.
Yet more reason to not want to live close to one. Yeah, 10K USD
Re:I'll take $10K (Score:5, Informative)
Noise, higher electricity and power bills.
Re: (Score:1, Funny)
I'd take that deal.
Re:I'll take $10K (Score:5, Insightful)
And its clear you have no idea the harm being done to locals.
Wonder why they havent put a data center next to you yet.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:3)
hey found some one that took the 10k
Re: (Score:2)
Nobody offered me.
Re: (Score:2)
And, during warmer months when lots are running A/C (and, thus... increasing power draw), the data center gets its power as a priority over the little people, and they'll pay way less for power by buying it at lower bulk prices.
And, what about the tens of thousands of gallons of water that they add ten different flavors of corrosion-inhibitors to?
Nott to mention all the high-security fences and lights and cameras, probable guard(s) all that jazz.
The cooling system to exchange heat isn't just going to be sim
Re: (Score:2, Interesting)
There is a lot to unpack in your post. Let's do the water part, because that one often has a lot of FUD.
First, check the actual numbers. Most are blown up or not put into proportion (i.e. absolute numbers instead of water per query). The google study on the median gemini query uses a few milliliters. Second, you seem to fear the water to be contaminated. But there are two types of water cycles: The closed one with corrosion inhibitors. That one is, as the name says, closed. Nothing to fear, that water basi
Re: I'll take $10K (Score:2)
I've been wondering about this. Why not use an artificial lake for the second cycle? It helps with regulating floods and droughts. Psychologically it gets the farmers on board, as well as the evironmentalists.
Re: (Score:2)
The main problem with an open cycle is, that you may take fresh water from locals, evaporate it (cleanly) but the resulting cloud doesn't rain down over the local town but somewhere else. That may or may not be a real problem, as far as I see there were places were it was a problem and then there is a lot of hysteria of people who actually have other motives and take every straw that helps to justify "data center bad" even when they mean "AI may become my competitor".
But people talk like it would be fresh w
Re: (Score:2)
So, they never, ever, change out the water, throughout the lifetime of the facility? Cool!
A warehouse-sized DC isn't using milliliters (your computer with its water-cooling system uses more than that)... sure, the water that is in the CPU block might be milliliters at one single moment, but when you have a thousand CPUs and a thousand NPUs, that number climbs (and, it depends on what else in each machine you want cooled)... and you're gonna have about twice that just in the heat exchanger (depending on how
Re: (Score:2)
Do you REALLY think this is a problem? Do you really think nobody thought about this ever before even though there are thousands of data centers being used since decades? Either you're falling for the current propaganda, or you're spreading it.
If you care about chemical pollution, you better not look at real industries. There you have way more and way more toxic waste. So please don't contribute to the "data center bad!" FUD.
Re: (Score:2)
Yes, it is.
_Exactly_ what chemicals is the DC next to your house using?
Hate to break your bubble, what chemical pollution happens to make your Chinese solar panels and wind turbines and the big battery pack that they charge (and deliver them, and ?
Do you need heat in winter? Bet NatGas has something to do with that... even if it's a heatpump, bet the truck that drilled that wasn't running on solar.
And, I'm sure people thought of that... but, the $$$$ dollar over-rules what they were thinking.
I worked at El
Re: (Score:2)
Let's say that probably all of us can agree that industries should have proper waste management and there should be tight control, which should be the tighter the more toxic the waste is. Maybe this wasn't clear, but any chemical used in DC's should OF COURSE be disposed in a correct way. The important point was, that a closed loop cooling system with anti corroding chemicals is not the worst offender in industry. That doesn't mean you should just dispose it into the next river. And I guess the US doesn't h
Re: (Score:2)
You're assuming alot about those who might have an opinion.
Any chemicals used for any purpose are disposed the cheapest way... whether it's the rust inhibitors or radioactive s**t... some guy can haul that barrel someplace.
Big question: do you have any verified owner or anything for that barrel?
Doing the disposal crap _the right way_ costs more than tossing it into a pond... hint: it's not just the US... it's all the rest of the world.
Re: (Score:2)
EU has pretty strict regulations. In particular US people make fun of it and talk about how companies can compete less, but in the end it means that the citizens can assume that nobody is dumping radioactive waste in their local lake and that the USB charger they bought won't burn their house down because a missing extra capacitor would make the production 5 cent more expensive.
Re: (Score:2)
The EU's reach isn't global, or even extending to a lot of the continent.
Maybe, just a suggestion, someone could throw money towards fusion (maybe someone could rework the design so it can use the nuclear waste as fuel).
Re: (Score:2)
But I think it is a good example for regulations. I see a problem with some attempts for more surveillance currently, but all the regulation of products and privacy laws are something valuable.
Re: (Score:2)
What privacy?
Now that phone calls and texts and emails and everything else happens online totally, all of it can be listened to, and has been since the 'net became a thing. Not to mention, it's easy to track your location now that everybody has cellphones.
Re: (Score:2)
(what is FUD?)
I know... the 12 years we lived next to Electrolux, we never heard the massive 2 story tall A/C units fans (/sarcasm). (the apartment was over 400 feet from the plant, across the tracks)
A big place like that pays for their power in bulk, at a far lower price than we ever know of, and the power company increases 'the little peoples' rates to cover the cost of upgrading the system feeding the DC.
Re: (Score:2)
FUD means fear, uncertainty, doubt. When Microsoft told people that Linux may have a license problem and that the viral GPL is cancer, that was FUD. They wanted people to hesitate to switch to Linux, not because they knew it would be a problem, but because they didn't want to risk the possibility of it being or becoming a problem for them.
Currently people are spreading rumors how bad data centers were, who never have seen one from close. In particular Youtubers seem to be happy to explain people they were e
Re: (Score:2)
Do you only have old adages or also real facts?
Re: (Score:2)
Do you own research is an argument of people talking about the government spraying chemtrails. Either you have some hard facts or you don't.
Re: I'll take $10K (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Come back when you have real arguments. And sources. Not just thinly veilled insults, or calling people trolls.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
First "Do your own research" now "Ask an AI" ... Do you know how to deal with damn sources, or are your really just arguing "Pick the first Google/AI result and you'll see"? At the moment you called me an idiot the discussion ended. Go discuss with your AI, if you think that's better than having actual sources. Bye.
Re: I'll take $10K (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Go look up Dunning-Kruger before you call others idiot. And try to understand what "bye" means.
Re: I'll take $10K (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
That depends on whether it is enough to get a new home where you want(#1) to live.
Or maybe you wanted to move somewhere else anyway, then by all means, take it.
#1: Which means: Is it near where I/my wife work? Is it near where my kids go to school? Does it offer the required facilities?
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
$10K isn't anything... now, if they offered that per month or something if you stayed (and kept issuing those payments for the next thousand years, payable to my decendents), now you're talking.
If I had a proper house and they offered that monthly, I'd take it... for the noise, I'd dangle a mic on the side of the house facing the DC and have my computer calculate the Active Noise Blocking (phase cancellation) in real time and broadcast it through the house just loud enough (per room) to hide the DC.
Or... th
Re: (Score:2)
Got it - so now I have to leave the neighborhood I bought a house to *live* in, NOT AS A FUCKING "INVESTMENT", and find somewhere else.
Re: (Score:2)
Also water bills, and noise if you happen to live close by. As a matter of interest, 1,300 acres equates to 5.26 square kilometers or just over 2 square miles.
Re:I'll take $10K (Score:5, Informative)
If you look at the data centre they are planning to build near me, it will use more electricity than the whole of the rest of the town of 250,000 people.
Obviously there is absolutely no way the electricity grid could support that, so they are planning to power it with gas generators, so it is basically a gas power station they are building in our back yard with all the associated pollution, except that an actual power station would likely do a better job of managing the pollution than a data centre would.
Re: (Score:2)
its ok the 10k can pay for 6 months of your insurance premium, then you are on your own.
Data Center Noise Google search (Score:2)
https://www.google.com/search?q=data+center+noise [google.com]
The noise is a HUGE problem!