Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
Businesses Google The Almighty Buck

Alphabet Heads For a $500 Billion Drop In Market Value (yahoo.com) 98

Yesterday, Google reported its Q3 results that showed searches made through its AI Mode generate less revenue than traditional search, even as overall search revenue grew 12% year over year to $63.25 billion. The news sent Alphabet shares plunging, with Bespoke Investment Group reporting that the stock is on track for its steepest post-earnings decline since the company went public in 2004. Yahoo Finance reports: At its low, Alphabet had lost $524 billion in stock market value, the second-biggest one-day loss ever for a US-listed company. Only Nvidia has lost more, about $593 billion on Jan. 27, 2025, the day China's DeepSeek rattled AI investors. Alphabet would need to close at about $274.75, down roughly 15%, to take Nvidia's record, by Yahoo Finance calculations. It has already blown past the $400 billion SpaceX lost on June 22, the previous No. 2.

In dollars, it's Alphabet's worst day by far. Its previous worst was about $275 billion on July 23. It's also on track for the stock's steepest drop after an earnings report since the company went public, according to Bespoke Investment Group. The previous low was a slide of nearly 10% in July 2008.

[...] US-listed stocks have shed $200 billion or more in a single session 18 times this year through Wednesday. That's up from 13 in all of 2025 and none before 2022, according to Yahoo Finance calculations from Bloomberg data. Alphabet alone has lost about $1.4 trillion since its record in May.

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

Alphabet Heads For a $500 Billion Drop In Market Value

Comments Filter:
  • Maybe (Score:4, Insightful)

    by Luthair ( 847766 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @02:08PM (#66400000)
    Maybe we can finally be rid of Sundar Pichai and end his reign of enshitification at Google. Usually though this end in layoffs for workers and bonuses for executives.
    • Re:Maybe (Score:4, Insightful)

      by Quakeulf ( 2650167 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @02:21PM (#66400028)

      The founders cashed out a long time ago. It's only going to get worse.

      • Sergei goes to work every day to make AGI happen. Larry is on a beach somewhere but that's where I'd be, too.
        • by drnb ( 2434720 )

          Sergei goes to work every day to make AGI happen.
          Larry is on a beach somewhere but that's where I'd be, too.

          On a beach near where his bunker is under construction in anticipation of the AGI.

        • He cannot possibly create anything of value. All he has done is shift money around and taken credit.

    • No. The fundamentals haven't changed. Same with the Nvidia and SpaceX mentions. The stocks recovered in both cases. Usually the action here is to buy the dip and sell when it gets back to about where it was, but I'm not a finance guy and this is not financial advice.

      The legitimate concern here is that this could (and IMO will) result in a long-term write down on assets long before they normally depreciate. And it probably will because these guys have been putting 5 year depreciation schedules on GPUs where

      • by dgatwood ( 11270 )

        No. The fundamentals haven't changed. Same with the Nvidia and SpaceX mentions. The stocks recovered in both cases. Usually the action here is to buy the dip and sell when it gets back to about where it was, but I'm not a finance guy and this is not financial advice.

        The legitimate concern here is that this could (and IMO will) result in a long-term write down on assets long before they normally depreciate. And it probably will because these guys have been putting 5 year depreciation schedules on GPUs where it's normally 3 years.

        Not a financial person either, but wouldn't writing it down mean that a company no longer considers it to have value? Is there something unique to the hardware they use for search-specific AI that prevents it from being leased out as part of Google Cloud or being used to run other teams' models?

        • Re: Maybe (Score:4, Interesting)

          by ArmoredDragon ( 3450605 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @04:00PM (#66400262)

          That's accounting rather than finance, and I'm not an accountant either. Writedown is when an asset already on the ledger is worth less or has a lower recoverable value than what is currently recorded. The difference in value gets recorded as an expense. What you're thinking of is a write-off, i.e. zero value, not a write down.

          While this wouldn't be an actual write down because it's not an asset on the books, my non-accountant mind treats it as a related concept. Basically, they're predicting future revenues may be lower than they had previously targeted. This is a forward looking statement, and generally where the finance side comes in. This is like when Facebook was predicting higher future revenue based on predicted mobile app usage growth, but then later announced that they hadn't quite figured out yet how to monetize advertising on the mobile app, but they were working on solving that problem. They eventually did and later realized those previously predicted targets. Meanwhile the stock took a pretty big hit.

          At least, that's my interpretation.

        • by ceoyoyo ( 59147 )

          It means it has less value than the purchase price indicates.

          Accounting practice usually includes some incremental depreciation on things that lose value over time. For tax purposes that rate is often specified but you can also use different rates. The idea is for the books to better indicate the actual asset value rather than freezing it at the purchase price until it's sold or disposed of.

      • Re: (Score:2, Insightful)

        by Luckyo ( 1726890 )

        Google's fundamentals are web ads on its search.

        AI search is more relevant and popular than ever, whereas web search results are less and less so. And AI search is proving to be less monetizable than web search.

        Ergo, fundamentals have changed. More monetizable search is slowly getting deprecated, whereas less monetizable one is replacing it everywhere.

        • by Gilmoure ( 18428 )

          Why doesn't Googly just buy up the dastardly AI company that's undercutting Googly's traditional high-value search engine business and shut down the AI motherfuckers?

          • > Why doesn't Googly just buy up the dastardly AI company that's undercutting Googly's traditional high-value search engine business and shut down the AI motherfuckers?

            Er... they already own it - they created it, it's called Gemini.

            That said, they *may* be getting less visitors in total as people use (say) chatgpt to do what they previously would have done with search. That's not really what they've said here though - they're saying their AI doesn't monetise as well as search does.

            Personally for search I

    • That's optimistic.

      The way I see it they have two options:

      1) throttle back on AI search and hope they don't lose share to OpenAI

      2) enshitify AI search to get more money from it.

      2 seems way more likely

      • by AmiMoJo ( 196126 )

        They have already put far too much emphasis on AI with their phones. When Pixel phones started they had A+ cameras, the absolute best you could get on a phone, at least for still photos. Video was always a bit weak, but for photos there was nothing else close.

        A few years ago they stopped really pushing the camera technology and went all in on AI instead. Their CPUs have mediocre performance, but always tout big AI chops, which rarely amount to anything. The supposedly exclusive features that they unlock alw

    • Re:Maybe (Score:5, Insightful)

      by OrangeTide ( 124937 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @03:25PM (#66400174) Homepage Journal

      The sort of people who could turn Google into a profitable innovation powerhouse no longer work at Google. Google lives and dies on how tightly they can hold onto their existing advertising empire. That's all they've got now and it is all they will ever be.

      • Oh they still work there, the problem is their products get killed just after release.

        • Google sucks a lot of the oxygen out of the room when it comes to people inventing the Next Big Thing. The projects that someone might have spent 5 years of their life trying to make into a startup, are now 20% projects at Google that sometimes see the light of day only to be walked back suddenly.

          Nothing can be made at Google that will do better then their ad search business. It's a reality that I faced when I was there, and the vast majority of management were delusional to think otherwise. Search pays for

    • Maybe we can finally be rid of Sundar Pichai and end his reign of enshitification at Google. Usually though this end in layoffs for workers and bonuses for executives.

      Yes and let's optimize revenue on the search screen by sorting worst to best, maybe make a few of the ads confusingly look like plausible search results while putting other ads in almost clearly marked boxes throughout the results to lower the user's guard. Probably a banner at top and bottom and both sides that stays in place as the user scrolls, charge a premium for that space, cause you have to have tiers. Could make clicking on a search result pop up a little movie trailer or interactive game ad that yo

      • What they put at the top is worthless garbage that is always wrong if I am looking for any information more sizable than what I would normally see in search result summaries. I run a Firefox addon to suppress the AI results because they are distracting dogshit.

    • Google is stealing traffic and IP from web pages it crawls. It is ironic that it isn't paying off for Google in the same way it is stealing money from content makers.

      I use a bunch of Firefox add-ons to remove AI from the web. At a point though when all of the results are AI generated slop not even that will help.

      The house is coming down folks. The only way to know you're interacting with people is too move your social behavior back to something local.

    • Maybe we can finally be rid of Sundar Pichai and end his reign of enshitification at Google.

      All late stage product development leads to enshitification. Getting rid of Sundar Pichai is cutting the head of a hydra. Enshittification didn't start with him, and it certainly won't end with him.

  • by Local ID10T ( 790134 ) <ID10T.L.USER@gmail.com> on Thursday October 29, 2026 @02:09PM (#66400004) Homepage

    This is just the leading edge of a bubble popping. Nothing to see here, move along.

    What? The recession has been here all along, but was being masked by the bubble-powered gains in the stock market? oh dear.

    • The recession has been here all along, but was being masked by the bubble-powered gains in the stock market? oh dear.

      Literally not how recessions work, but sure let's roll with it.

  • When you get your complete answer in one click, you won't be clicking past piles of additional unnecessary advertisements researching what you are looking for - you take what you need and go!

    • This is a good point and pretty logical so why does market panic on this? Unfortunately, what will happen is Google finding ways to pile ads into the AI search model.
      • Maybe an advertising agency should not be managing search engines, its a conflict of interest, people use search engines to search and reSearch specific things of interest and when that objective is derailed by advertising then the user becomes frustrated and will consider alternatives like ddg or others. Googles enshitified search engine needs to be managed by outside sources like scientists and wikipedia and directory assistance companies like yellowbook
    • Because it only works like that for the simplest questions.

      Ask Google any slightly complicated question through the search interface, where the question domain is complicated and not necessarily even the question itself, and the answer will be shit. The answers will be wrong and the alleged citations will not only not support all of their respective claims, some of them will not even speak to the specific issue they are supposed to be citations for AT ALL. It will also claim crazy shit like that it is givi

      • The spurious "I'm" in there is from Google's allegedly AI-powered autocorrect in Android, which is obviously also shit. It's really amazing how incompetent they are today.

    • When you get your complete answer in one click, you won't be clicking past piles of additional unnecessary advertisements researching what you are looking for - you take what you need and go!

      Man it's very weird knowing Google's whole story and seeing people in 2026 act surprised that search engines make more money the longer it takes people to find what they came for. Like that's how they killed their competition back in the day, by actually getting what you're looking for on the top of the first page. They made their fortune selling ads on OTHER sites. Selling ads on their own search page eventually happened as their competitors dried up.

      This news is as dumb as suddenly realizing that the Feel

    • Maybe that's the problem: it doesn't suck enough?
  • Search (Score:5, Informative)

    by sit1963nz ( 934837 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @02:27PM (#66400046)
    Search has become so bad its hardly worth using.
    I DONT want your AI BS search
    I want your search to go back to how it was 10 years ago where it was fast, accurate, helpful. Not this enshitified thing you have now.
    • This is only in the context of programming/computer related queries, but honestly, the AI search results from Google are better than their non-AI results. It's probably better than (or at least on par with) their non-AI results from a decade ago as well. That's mostly because their regular results degraded so badly, but they're probably never going to fix that. The citations for the AI answer to most technical questions are the page I was looking for. They probably don't make money from those searches thoug
      • I don't search google for programming advice anymore. I've downloaded all the docs for all the major dependencies of my project and go straight for the source, to the API docs. I haven't got the time to spend 10-20 minutes reading about random adventures of inexperienced knight errands on the Internet every time I'd like to check the API.

        • I don't do either one. I just ask Clade Code to write the API code for me. It gets it right the first time, most of the time. You can have your documentation!

    • Search has become so bad its hardly worth using.

      I DONT want your AI BS search

      I want your search to go back to how it was 10 years ago where it was fast, accurate, helpful. Not this enshitified thing you have now.

      You all keep blaming AI, but 10 years ago the internet was already full of regular content mill garbage, SEO spam and ads. Half your results might be some mailing list server scraped and replicated to unauthorized web forum looking things to sell ads. You have to go back 15 years minimum, and rewind the entire internet with it. Some might argue the internet was already beyond fucked even then. Good luck, time traveler.

      • I go back to dial up BBS, my first modem was a 1200/300
        Getting a 2400 for access to works "main framework" was amazing.
      • by dgatwood ( 11270 )

        I remember the Internet before Eternal September [wikipedia.org]. You need to go back at least that far.

        • Ah the days (circa 1974) of using a dial-up TIP connection to explore various ARPANET nodes and being personally kicked off an MIT machine by J.C.R. Licklider. This was in the NCP era, before IP/TCP.
    • by gweihir ( 88907 )

      Google search was already really bad 5 years ago. That is about when I stopped using it.

    • This is what I did years ago to my default searches, and I don't touch google's AI unless its on accident.
      https://tenbluelinks.org/ [tenbluelinks.org]
      https://udm14.com/ [udm14.com]
      It's saved my sanity, I'm sure of it.

  • because, well, there's nothing new here.

  • by Sloppy ( 14984 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @02:30PM (#66400060) Homepage Journal

    searches made through its AI Mode generate less revenue than traditional search

    Have you thought about disabling AI Mode and returning customers to traditional search? It'll not only make you more money, but result in happier users too. Everyone-except-Nvidia wins.

    • DuckDuckGo allows you to do this. On their homepage you can choose between a regular search or an AI search. I have my default page set to no AI.

      • I don't get "why." The search results are the same regurgitated crap on multiple sites, obfuscated with redundant paragraphs and word padding.

    • They could, but then people would just use ChatGPT instead.

  • How else can they get out of this but more debt to build more data centers to make them less money? Maybe their AI will get so good it'll tell people how crappy Google Books and Chrome Books and Pixel Phones and etc. are and they'll lose even more money!
  • by MobyDisk ( 75490 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @02:54PM (#66400114) Homepage

    I'm sure I'll get torn apart for this, but there are many cases where the AI mode does a significantly better job of searching, and is much more capable. Recent example:

    Every week my son's school sends an email with a list of colleges visiting along with dates and times. My son wants to find schools with a degree in XYZ, which is a bit specialized. I type "Which of these schools have a degree in XYZ?" then hit paste. The AI parses the email (which is formatted for a human and includes irrelevant information about the visit), then produces a bulleted list, with links to the page for that specific degree. That would have taken me 10+ searches. And since each school calls the degree something slightly different, it would take even more.

    • I mean, this is an llmâ(TM)s great gift: salient summaries of huge swaths of text. Same as mlâ(TM)s digestion of humongus data sets.

    • AI search basically gives you one or two of the top results merged together. Google for example often has almost word for word an AI summary, then the actual results below that are almost word for word - often from Reddit and such places.

      I'm not saying the results are always wrong just that if it picks wrong be prepared for that. Be skeptical and the AI search can be fruitful. Or poison. either way.
      • AI search goes WAY beyond the first two results. And it doesn't just default to whatever it finds on Reddit. I've found that it often scours dozens of search results to put results together. It's way faster than clicking through all those pages of search results, and better yet, AI automatically throws out the unrelated search results that always sneak in there.

    • I asked Gemini for a list of the mascots of schools in my county. This should be easy, right? LLMs are good at summarizing, right?

      Nope. Gemini told me no such thing existed.

      There was such a thing right below the AI response, in the traditional search results.

      Google's AI search is complete shit, and anyone who thinks it's good is proving they are shit at searching.

  • It's a disco inferno!

  • ...goes the bubble. If this is what happens to Google, investors WILL panic.

  • by edi_guy ( 2225738 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @03:49PM (#66400242)

    What I cannot wrap my head around is that trillion dollar Google, trillion dollar Facebook, etc are all still just advertising firms.

    There was a certain amount of money in advertising in the 20th century for print, radio, TV, etc. In the 21st century Google, Facebook, and some others captured all of that. But how was that bucket of advertising dollars enough to make these mega-corporations? Not like Time-Warner, or New York Times group was worth a trillion (adjusted) dollars back in the day.

    • by ceoyoyo ( 59147 )

      What I cannot wrap my head around is that trillion dollar Google, trillion dollar Facebook, etc are all still just advertising firms.

      That was a while ago. Google is 3.5 Trillion. Meta is 1.6. They're both much better at advertising than the NY Times and their cost to show ads is much lower.

    • But how was that bucket of advertising dollars enough to make these mega-corporations?

      You were under the assumption that this bucket was finite. The bucket depends on what companies think they can get out of advertising.

      While it's easy to write off the trillion dollar valuation of a company as just a fantasy, the reality is collectively the world sent Facebook $64billion in the last 3 months alone.

      Back in the day when you chose advertisement you had to create an advert for TV, or select a newspaper with your target audience. Today you can literally click a button on your phone. It's not even

  • by Beeftopia ( 1846720 ) on Thursday October 29, 2026 @08:42PM (#66400638)

    From Motley Fool [fool.com]:

    Class A shares (GOOGL): One vote per share
    Class B shares (held by insiders): 10 votes per share
    Class C shares (GOOG): No voting power

    GOOG and GOOGL have 5.6 billion and 5.9 billion shares in existence. Neither pay dividends.

    The voting power of the Class A is ceremonial; the class B's actually control the company and are only held by insiders.

    • by shess ( 31691 )

      GOOG and GOOGL have 5.6 billion and 5.9 billion shares in existence. Neither pay dividends.

      Both GOOG and GOOGL pay dividends, the most recent being $0.22/share. I'd be surprised if class B doesn't also pay that dividend.

  • Everyone talk about what a bad day the billionaires are having. The usual excuse is, pensioners put their money in the stock market so the pain is shared. No, the point of high-frequency trading is, liquidity is kept high and the serious stock market players desert 'ship' first and never lose. That means pension funds and hedge funds. Sure, the small and self-managed are vulnerable but the automated trading system was never for their benefit.
  • Google seems to be actively trying to destroy the browser-based web, I guess hoping it will be replaced with Android-based craplets.

    It killed its traditional business of placing ads on websites by persuading all readers to install ad blockers by pushing malvertising, and also making it an economically pointless for content providers, so now it's core business is just con-artist "content farmers" screwing anybody stupid enough to pay Google to place ads with bot readers.

    I just hope something better grows fro

  • "We lose money on every sale, but we make up for it in VOLUME!"
  • A trillion here a trillion there ... pretty soon it amounts to real money; as Sen Dirkson would agree a long overdue correction. American tek.service stocks have been highly over-valued since the JapeChat / AI obscurity went public. They have another 25% loss to absorb before price and long-term profit come into balance. Or possibly much worse, if AI.tek becomes habitual among guild/craft/small-manufacturing concerns. Imagine ... every lathe/ion-beam/router/CNC/3-D printer owne
  • If you can't handle a less than 15% change in one stock for one day you have no business looking at individual stocks.

  • Where will the money come from ?

    I don't mean the money investors put in, but the money that will fund the businesses they are hoping will return their investments.

    Has anyone tried to calculate how many companies and people will be spending money on (frontier, not cheap, local) AI in the near future ?
    And whether that will amount to the ... pinkie to mouth ... multiple trillion dollars needed for them to be profitable ?
  • How about a joke on google as the secondary target? Just collateral damage while the real plan is for Xi to buy control of TSMC as the AI bubble implodes?

To be is to program.

Working...